Collective beliefs versus individual inflexibility: The unavoidable biases of a public debate
Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its ApplicationsPublished 19 April 2011
Serge Galam
Citations39
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.67
SNIP1.08
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
The combined effects of collective beliefs and individual inflexibility in the dynamics of a public debate are investigated using the Galam sequential probabilistic model of opinion dynamics. The study is focused on pair interactions for which the bias produced by collective beliefs is the decisive factor to win the debate. The current value of that bias is a fixed external parameter. It is a constant of the problem not given to change. In contrast, inflexibility is an individual property. It results from external ingredients, which are susceptible to be modified during the debate. More precisely, giving some beliefs we determine the required inflexibility to oppose its associated bias in the debate outcome. The results shed a new and counter intuitive light on paradoxical outcomes of sensitive issues, which are discussed in the public. The cases of global warming issue and debate over evolution are discussed.
Keywords
Social SciencesPhysics and Astronomy
Reviews of Modern PhysicsStatistical physics of social dynamics
4,025 Citations2009Claudio Castellano, Santo Fortunato +1 more
International Journal of Modern Physics CSOCIOPHYSICS: A REVIEW OF GALAM MODELS
481 Citations2008SERGE GALAM
Using a series of models of sociophysics introduced by Galam and Galam et al. several major real political events were successfully predicted including the victory of the French extreme right party in the 2000 first round of French presidential elections, the voting at fifty–fifty in several democratic countries, and the defeat of the "no" to the 2005 French referendum on the European constitution.
European Journal of Social PsychologyTowards a theory of collective phenomena: Consensus and attitude changes in groups
399 Citations1991Serge Galam, Serge Moscovici
Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its ApplicationsThe role of inflexible minorities in the breaking of democratic opinion dynamics
312 Citations2007Serge Galam, Frans J. Jacobs
Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its ApplicationsContrarian deterministic effects on opinion dynamics: “the hung elections scenario”
309 Citations2003Serge Galam
Journal of Mathematical PsychologyMajority rule, hierarchical structures, and democratic totalitarianism: A statistical approach
236 Citations1986Serge Galam
It is shown how such self-oriented hierarchies are always H -oriented provided they have a minimal number of levels which is determined by the value of p 0 and their stability is studied against increases in p 0 .
Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its ApplicationsRational group decision making: A random field Ising model at T = 0
229 Citations1997Serge Galam
RePEc: Research Papers in EconomicsRational group decision making: A random field Ising model at T = 0
208 CitationsSerge Galam
Physical Review EHeterogeneous beliefs, segregation, and extremism in the making of public opinions
159 Citations2005Serge Galam
Segregation among subclasses may produce a coexistence of opinions at the class level, thus averting global extremism, and insight into the existence of contradictory public opinions in similar social-cultural neighborhoods is given.
Europhysics Letters (EPL)Local dynamics <i>vs.</i> social mechanisms: A unifying frame
153 Citations2005S. Galam
A general sequential probabilistic frame, which extends a series of earlier opinion dynamics models and orders and classifies all of the existing two-state spin systems, concluding that one should not judge from the above model results the validity of their respective psycho-social assumptions.
International Journal of Modern Physics COPINION FORMATION ON A DETERMINISTIC PSEUDO-FRACTAL NETWORK
121 Citations2004Marta C. González, A. O. Sousa +1 more
A model for elections based on the Sznajd model is studied and the exponent obtained for the distribution of votes during the transient agrees with those obtained for real elections in Brazil and India.
Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topicsMajority versus minority dynamics: Phase transition in an interacting two-state spin system
118 Citations2003Mauro Mobilia, S. Redner
In one dimension and within a Kirkwood decoupling scheme, the final magnetization in a finite-length system has a nontrivial dependence on the initial magnetization for all p not equal p(c), in agreement with numerical results.
Monograph series on nonlinear science and complexityBiology, Sociology, Geology by Computational Physicists
116 Citations2006
Physical Review EMobility and social network effects on extremist opinions
88 Citations2008André C. R. Martins
This paper shows extreme opinions to arise in a ubiquitous manner in the CODA model for a multitude of social network structures and suggests that depending on network details reducing extremism seems to be possible.
Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its ApplicationsAn opinion dynamics model for the diffusion of innovations
87 Citations2009André C. R. Martins, Carlos de B. Pereira +1 more
The model predicts a fat tailed distribution for late adopters which is verified by empirical data and compares the cases where initial adopters are clustered to the case where they are randomly scattered around the social network and investigates small world effects on the final proportion of adopters.
The European Physical Journal BNeighborhood models of minority opinion spreading
78 Citations2004C. J. Tessone, R. Toral +3 more
International Journal of Modern Physics CON SPATIAL CONSENSUS FORMATION: IS THE SZNAJD MODEL DIFFERENT FROM A VOTER MODEL?
72 Citations2003Laxmidhar Behera, Frank Schweitzer
It is shown that the SM can be completely reformulated in terms of a linear voter model (VM), where the transition rates towards a given opinion are directly proportional to frequency of the respective opinion of the second-nearest neighbors (no matter what the nearest neighbors are).
Quality & QuantityModeling society with statistical mechanics: an application to cultural contact and immigration
70 Citations2007Pierluigi Contucci, Stefano Ghirlanda
The approach building a model of cultural contact between two cultures is demonstrated, showing that it is possible to make predictions about how contact changes the two cultures.
International Journal of Modern Physics CTHE INFLUENCE OF CONTRARIANS AND OPPORTUNISTS ON THE STABILITY OF A DEMOCRACY IN THE SZNAJD MODEL
53 Citations2004Johannes Schneider
Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its ApplicationsPublic debates driven by incomplete scientific data: The cases of evolution theory, global warming and H1N1 pandemic influenza
49 Citations2010Serge Galam
The underlying key mechanisms of these puzzling and unfortunate conclusions are identified using the Galam sequential probabilistic model of opinion dynamics, which reveals that the existence of inflexible agents and their respective proportions are the instrumental parameters to determine the faith of incomplete scientific data in public debates.
Europhysics Letters (EPL)Some new results on one-dimensional outflow dynamics
45 Citations2008F. Slanina, K. Sznajd-Weron +1 more
International Journal of Modern Physics CTHE IMPACT OF ELECTION RESULTS ON THE MEMBER NUMBERS OF THE LARGE PARTIES IN BAVARIA AND GERMANY
37 Citations2005Johannes Schneider, Christian Hirtreiter
International Journal of Modern Physics BFALSIFICATION OF THE ATMOSPHERIC<font>CO</font><sub>2</sub>GREENHOUSE EFFECTS WITHIN THE FRAME OF PHYSICS
33 Citations2009GERHARD GERLICH, RALF D. TSCHEUSCHNER
Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its ApplicationsOutward-inward information flux in an opinion formation model on different topologies
16 Citations2005A. O. Sousa, J. R. Sánchez
A transition from consensus in one opinion to the other is found at the same percentage of initial distribution no matter which type of network is used or which opinion formation rule is used.
International Journal of Modern Physics CTHE GALAM MODEL OF MINORITY OPINION SPREADING AND THE MARRIAGE GAP
15 Citations2008K. Kułakowski, Maria Nawojczyk
SignificanceHotter or Not? Should we Believe Model Predictions of Future Climate Change?
11 Citations2008Reto Knutti