The discovery of processing stages: Extensions of Donders' method
Acta PsychologicaPublished 1 January 1969
Saul Sternberg
Citations3,144
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.85
SNIP1.04
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is demonstrated that stage-durations may be additive without being stochastically independent, a result that is relevant to the formulation of mathematical models of RT.
Abstract
A new method is proposed for using reaction-time (RT) measurements to study stages of information processing. It overcomes limitations of Donders' and more recent methods, and permits the discovery of stages, assessment of their properties, and separate testing of the additivity and stochastic independence of stage durations. The main feature of the additive-factor method is the search for non-interacting effects of experimental factors on mean RT. The method is applied to several binary-classification experiments, where it leads to a four-stage model, and to an identification experiment, where it distinguishes two stages. The sets of stages inferred from both these and other data are shown to carry substantive implications. It is demonstrated that stage-durations may be additive without being stochastically independent, a result that is relevant to the formulation of mathematical models of RT.
Keywords
Computer ScienceNeuroscience
ScienceHigh-Speed Scanning in Human Memory
3,631 Citations1966Saul Sternberg
When subjects judge whether a test symbol is contained in a short memorized sequence of symbols, their mean reaction-time increases linearly with the length of the sequence, implying the existence of an internal serial-comparison process.
Quarterly Journal of Experimental PsychologyOn the Rate of Gain of Information
2,243 Citations1952W. E. Hick
Planning of experiments.
993 Citations1958David Cox
Subjects include the justification and practical difficulties of randomization, various factors occurring in factorial experiments, selecting the size of an experiments, different purposes for which observations may be made and much more.
Psychological ReviewChronometric analysis of classification.
800 Citations1967Michael I. Posner, Ronald F. Mitchell
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series B (Statistical Methodology)Analysis of Factorial Experiments by Estimating Monotone Transformations of the Data
510 Citations1965Joseph B. Kruskal
Acta PsychologicaWhere is capacity limited? A survey and a model
434 Citations1967Neville Moray
A model is presented for the limitations of processing information by the human operator which proposes that he acts not as a limited capacity channel with fixed capacity, but as aLimited capacity processor where the total capacity is not exceeded, and where there is high compatibility.
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal BehaviorGrammatical transformations and speed of understanding
418 Citations1965Philip B. Gough
The true-false variable was found to interact with the affirmative-negative, indicating that the latter difference is not simply syntactical, and transformational complexity was confounded with frequency and length.
Perception & PsychophysicsTwo operations in character recognition: Some evidence from reaction-time measurements
406 Citations1967Saul Sternberg
ErgonomicsTHE MEASUREMENT OF SENSORY-MOTOR PERFORMANCE : SURVEY AND REAPPRAISAL OF TWELVE YEARS' PROGRESS
386 Citations1960A. T. Welford
This paper sketches the historical development of the work in this area and attempts a reappraisal under five main heads: there appears to be in the central mechanisms a ‘ single channel ’ which deals with signals or groups of signals one at a time so that signals coming in rapid succession may have to ‘ queue ’ before they are dealt with.
Psychological BulletinChoice reaction time: An analysis of the major theoretical positions.
370 Citations1968Edward E. Smith
Choice reaction time to visual stimuli - analysis of major theoretical positions to perceptual recognition theories and its applications to choice reaction time-based recognition theories.
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal BehaviorThe verification of sentences: The effects of delay of evidence and sentence length
280 Citations1966Philip B. Gough
Journal of Mathematical PsychologyThe general-gamma distribution and reaction times
152 Citations1965W. J. McGill, John Gibbon
Acta PsychologicaQuantification of shared capacity processing in auditory and visual discrimination
145 Citations1967M. Morgan Taylor, Peter H. Lindsay +1 more
Journal of Mathematical PsychologyStochastic models for choice reaction time with applications to experimental results
134 Citations1965Jean‐Claude Falmagne
Choice reaction times are analyzed on the basis of a simple model in which RT's are drawn at random from one of two ideal distributions, and a sampling scheme that generates the RT distributions from the preparatory states.
Journal of Experimental PsychologySome Experiments on Simple and Choice Reaction Time.
99 Citations1967Joan Gay Snodgrass, R. Duncan Luce +1 more
The suthors examine the role of time estimation in the manipulation of responses in simple reaction time experiments by means of payoffs and information feedback and investigates the relation between RT and signal presentation probability in choice situations.
Bulletin of Mathematical BiologyDecision structure and time relations in simple choice behavior
93 Citations1956Lee S. Christie, R. Duncan Luce
British Journal of PsychologyON THE INTERACTION OF S‐R COMPATIBILITY WITH OTHER VARIABLES AFFECTING REACTION TIME
93 Citations1965D. Ε. Broadbent, Margaret Gregory
Choice reactions to tactual stimulation were studied, and it was found that decrease in compatibility increased the effect of number of alternative reactions, of uncertainty about the time of arrival of a stimulus, of a simultaneous distracting task, and of an unequal frequency of departure of different signals.
Perception & PsychophysicsDetection of auditory signals presented at random times: III
72 Citations1971David M. Green, R. Duncan Luce
It was concluded that the assumed decision process was in error and the dependence of mean reaction time on signal waits was shown to depend largely on the average wait, not the actual one, and that this relationship betweenmean reaction time and average stimulus wait increased for strong signals and decreased for weak ones.
Advances in child development and behaviorComponent Process Latencies in Reaction Times of Children and Adults
45 Citations1967Raymond H. Hohle
This chapter reviews a number of reaction time (RT) studies using child Ss and suggests that development of the reactive process might be better understood if more information were available on the underlying processes producing variations in RT.
Journal of Experimental PsychologyInteraction of time-uncertainty and relative signal frequency in determining choice reaction time.
34 Citations1965Paul Bertelson, Jacques Barzeele
This result shows that "preparation," a hypothetical state which has often been postulated to account for time-uncertainty effects, is at least in part specific to 1 particular signal-response pair, or that the well-known effect of signal relative frequency is affected by very short-term fluctuations.
British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical PsychologyREACTION‐TIME STUDIES: THE ANTICIPATION AND INTERACTION OF RESPONSES
34 Citations1967E. A. C. Thomas
It is argued that temporal uncertainty alone is insufficient to account for the increase in reaction time to the second of two closely spaced signals, both of which require a response, and a model for the interaction of two responses is stated in which refractoriness in the central processes is not inevitable.
Psychonomic ScienceStimulus- response compatibility and the rate of gain of information
27 Citations1964Earl A. Alluisi, G. S. Strain +1 more
Perception & PsychophysicsVerbal reaction times to hues vs hue names and forms vs form names
25 Citations1968Barry Gholson, Raymond H. Hohle
Psychonomic ScienceSignal discriminability, S-R compatibility and choice reaction time
22 Citations1967Patrick Rabbitt
With a very simple display, signal discriminability and S-R compatibility interact in their effects on choice RT.
British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical PsychologyA NEW INTERPRETATION OF THE RELATION BETWEEN CHOICE‐REACTION TIME AND THE NUMBER OF EQUIPROBABLE ALTERNATIVES
21 Citations1966Donald Laming
This paper presents an alternative interpretation of the original results in terms of n parallel decision processes, the reaction time being determined by whichever of these n decisions takes the longest.
Perception & PsychophysicsDetection of auditory signals presented at random times, II
15 Citations1970R. Duncan Luce, David M. Green
Perception & PsychophysicsEffects of time and event uncertainty upon sequential information processing
9 Citations1968Ira H. Bernstein, Randolph Blake +1 more
NatureInformation Load and Discriminability
5 Citations1963Patrick Rabbitt
The two experiments summarized here show interactions between size of stimuli, illumination-level, and the number of items between which discriminations are made, and how long it takes subjects to differentiate between two stimuli.
ScienceHuman Choice Reaction Time within and among Sense Modalities
4 Citations1962William C. Howell, Jack E. Donaldson
Human choice reaction time was studied as a function of sense modality and inter- versus intrasensory coding at three levels of stimulus strength: stimulus strength was equated across sense modalities and classical findings were supported for strength and modality.
NatureTwo Dimensions for Reaction Time Distributions
3 Citations1965D. H. Taylor
Experiments in which the total time for execution of a repetitive self-paced task (such as card-sorting) is the only measure taken have become a popular, even a standard, method of investigation in this field.