Embodying information systems: the contribution of phenomenology
Information and OrganizationPublished 1 April 2001
John Mingers
Citations141
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.80
SNIP1.83
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
A philosophical and biological framework for embodied cognition is identified; the main arguments in favor of the approach; and the implications for information systems and artificial intelligence.
Abstract
This paper presents a case for embodying information systems. That is, for recognizing the fundamental importance of the body in human cognition and social action, and exploring the consequences for information systems and artificial intelligence. Current work within philosophy, biology, cognitive science, and social theory demonstrates that the Cartesian dualism of mind and body is no longer tenable, and points to the embodied and enactive nature of thought and language. Three different approaches to cognition are identified and their underlying philosophies are exemplified by Husserl, Heidegger, and Merleau-Ponty respectively. Sections of the paper cover: a philosophical and biological framework for embodied cognition; the main arguments in favor of the approach; and the implications for information systems and artificial intelligence.
Keywords
Social SciencesNeuroscienceArts and Humanities
American Sociological ReviewThe Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.
26,149 Citations1956Kaspar D. Naegele, Erving Goffman
Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972-1977
22,396 Citations1980Michel Foucault, Colin Gordon
Research PolicyThe Knowledge-creating company: How Japanese companies create the dynamics of innovation
13,271 Citations1997H. Takeuchi
Medical Entomology and ZoologyBeing and Time
12,229 Citations1927Ronald W. Hepburn, Martín Heidegger +2 more
Phenomenology of Perception
9,858 Citations1982Maurice Merleau-Ponty
Truth and Method
7,580 Citations1960Hans Georg Gadamer, Joel Weinsheimer +1 more
The Journal of Higher EducationWomen, Fire, and Dangerous Things: What Categories Reveal about the Mind
7,437 Citations1988Terence Odlin, George Lakoff
The MIT Press eBooksCognition in the Wild
6,871 Citations1995Edwin Hutchins
Welcome aboard navigation as computation the implementation of contemporary pilotage the organization of team performances communication navigation as a context for learning learning in context organizational learning cultural cognition.
Outline of a Theory of Practice
5,570 Citations2007Pierre Bourdıeu
How We Became Posthuman
4,857 Citations1999N. Katherine Hayles
Autopoiesis and Cognition: The Realization of the Living
4,733 Citations1980Humberto R. Maturana, Francisco J. Varela +1 more
The aim of this book is to provide a Discussion of the Foundations of Cognitive Function and its Applications in Autopoiesis, and to clarify the role of language in the development of cognition.
Artificial IntelligenceIntelligence without representation
4,625 Citations1991Rodney A. Brooks
The fundamental decomposition of the intelligent system is not into independent information processing units which must interface with each other via representations, but into independent and parallel activity producers which all interface directly to the world through perception and action.
Strategic Management JournalMaking knowledge the basis of a dynamic theory of the firm
4,282 Citations1996J.‐C. Spender
A multitype epistemology is begun which admits both the pre- and subconscious modes of human knowing and, reframing the concept of the cognizing individual, the collective knowledge of social groups, to help managers discover their place in the firm as a dynamic knowledge-based activity system.
Knowledge and Human Interests
4,058 Citations1968Jürgen Habermas
A Realist Theory of Science
4,008 Citations2013Roy Bhaskar
The Philosophical ReviewKnowledge and the Flow of Information.
3,336 Citations1983William P. Alston, Fred Dretske
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsIn The Age of the Smart Machine: The Future of Work and Power.
3,302 Citations1989Carmen Sirianni, Shoshana Zuboff
The Philosophical QuarterlyPhenomenology of Perception.
3,177 Citations1964Mary Warnock, M. Merleau-Ponty +1 more
Understanding Computers and Cognition: A New Foundation for Design
3,163 Citations1987Terry Winograd, Fernando Flores
The theory of communicative action
2,296 Citations2005Andrew Edgar
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsCommunication and the Evolution of Society.
2,208 Citations1981Dieter Misgeld, Jurgen Habermas +1 more
The American Journal of PsychologyWomen, Fire, and Dangerous Things: What Categories Reveal about the Mind
1,886 Citations1989Raymond W. Gibbs, George Lakoff
The Body and Social Theory
1,695 Citations2003Chris Shilling
LeonardoWhat Computers Still Can't Do: A Critique of Artificial Reason
1,644 Citations1994Simon Penny, H. L. Dreyfus
For this edition of What Computers Can't Do, Hubert Dreyfus has added a lengthy new introduction outlining changes and assessing the paradigms of connectionism and neural networks that have transformed the field.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyBeing-in-the-World: A Commentary on Heidegger's Being in Time, Division I.
1,124 Citations1990Hubert L. Dreyfus
The Body: Social Process and Cultural Theory
1,050 Citations1991Mike Featherstone, Mike Hepworth +1 more
The Possibility of Naturalism
998 Citations2013Roy Bhaskar
Beacon Press eBooksReason and the rationalization of society
816 Citations1984Jürgen Habermas, Thomas McCarthy
ScienceNew Approaches to Robotics
751 Citations1991Rodney A. Brooks
The relationship to traditional academic robotics and traditional artificial intelligence is examined and the use of representations, expectations, plans, goals, and learning is demonstrated, but without resorting to the traditional uses of central, abstractly manipulable or symbolic representations.
Regulating Bodies: Essays in Medical Sociology
589 Citations1992Bryan S. Turner
The author's preface and conclusion: Theory and Epistemology of the Body: Interview with Richard Fardon.
Beacon Press eBooksLifeworld and system : a critique of functionalist reason
542 Citations1987Jürgen Habermas, Thomas McCarthy
ACM Transactions on Information SystemsComputer systems and the design of organizational interaction
485 Citations1988Fernando Flores, Michael Graves +2 more
A theory of language as social action, which differs from the generally taken-for-granted understandings of what goes on in an organization is proposed and illustrated.
Fat Is a Feminist Issue
481 Citations1978Susie Orbach
Human-Computer InteractionA Language/Action Perspective on the Design of Cooperative Work
472 Citations1987Terry Winograd
Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW)Do categories have politics?
393 Citations1993Lucy Suchman
It is proposed that the adoption of speech act theory as a foundation for system design carries with it an agenda of discipline and control over organization members' actions.
Cartesian Meditations
368 Citations1977Edmund Husserl
The MIT Press eBooksDesigning Information Technology in the Postmodern Age
222 Citations1995Richard Coyne
Richard Coyne puts the theoretical discussion of computer systems and information technology on a new footing, shifting the discourse from its usual rationalistic framework, and draws extensively from the writing of Martin Heidegger.
Do Categories Have Politics? The language/action perspective reconsidered
219 Citations1993Lucy Suchman
It is proposed that the adoption of speech act theory as a foundation for system design carries with it an agenda of discipline and control over organization members actions, and the implications for the politics of CSCW systems design.
Management, Information and Power
188 Citations1997Lucas D. Introna
Journal of the Operational Research SocietySelf-Producing Systems—Implications and Applications of Autopoiesis
183 Citations1997John Mingers
This book discusses autopoiesis in the Physical Domain, applications of Autopoietic Organizations and Social Systems, and the implications for information systems, Cognitive Science, and Artificial Intelligence.
Information Systems JournalInformation and meaning: foundations for an intersubjective account
180 Citations1995John Mingers
A coherent and consistent analysis of data, information, meaning and their interrelations is provided, particularly concerned with the semantic and pragmatic dimensions of information, and integrates the work of Maturana and Habermas into a framework provided by Dretske's theory of semantic information.
A game controller based on multiple sensors
166 Citations2009Dapeng Zhang, Zhongjie Cai +2 more
The statistics gathered from the experiments show that even though the quality of control on the chosen fighting game is not as high as with a normal joystick, the developed controller is still preferred by most of the participants.
Robotics and Autonomous SystemsFrom earwigs to humans
155 Citations1997Rodney A. Brooks
Attempts to emulate insect-level locomotion and navigation with very little work on behavior-based non-trivial manipulation of the world are reported on.
Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW)Categories, disciplines, and social coordination
127 Citations1993Terry Winograd
This paper clarifies the difference between formal comprehensive models of behavior and formalstructures used in communication and recording.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyInformation Systems an Emerging Discipline
119 Citations2004Frank Stowell, John Mingers
The future of IS is discussed, issues and implications organizational semiotics factors influencing success of strategic information systems critical systems thinking and information systems development.
Whence Perceptual Meaning? A Cartography of Current Ideas
111 Citations1992Francisco J. Varela
Information SystemsAction based model of information system
89 Citations1986Erkki Lehtinen, Kalle Lyytinen
Some weaknesses in recently suggested models for information system specification are discussed, focusing on the technical specification but on the formal structure of social interaction through an information system.
Making a Mind Versus Modelling the Brain: Artificial Intelligence Back at the Branchpoint
81 Citations1991Hubert L. Dreyfus, Stuart E. Dreyfus
Systems Thinking in Europe
77 Citations1991Michael C. Jackson, Gilbert Mansell +2 more
PubMedWhat is it to see?
72 Citations1983Humberto R. Maturana
The contention is that by answering the question what is it to see, one can show that this assumption cannot be sustained because the phenomenon of perception cannot consist in a process of grasping the features of an independent world of objects and that by reflecting upon the nature of a scientific explanation, this assumption is unnecessary.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A Physical and Engineering SciencesThe practical requirements for making a conscious robot
61 Citations1994Daniel C. Dennett
The aim of the project is to make a conscious robot that can interact with human beings in a robust and versatile manner in real time, take care of itself, and tell its designers things about itself that would otherwise be extremely difficult if not impossible to determine by examination.
Systemic Practice and Action ResearchAn evaluation of theories of information with regard to the semantic and pragmatic aspects of information systems
47 Citations1996John Mingers
It is concluded that Dretske's analysis of knowledge and information provides the most suitable basis for further development.
Understanding origins : contemporary views on the origin of life, mind, and society
39 Citations1994Francisco J. Varela, Jean‐Pierre Dupuy +1 more
Information Systems JournalThe effectiveness of office information systems: a social action perspective
37 Citations1991Kalle Lyytinen, Heinz K. Klein +1 more
It is proposed that office information systems should be analysed as social action systems the behaviour of which is strongly affected by socially determined forces and constraints such as the behaviour‐channelling influences of authority, norms, customs, habits and precedence.
Unitn Eprints Research (Università Degli Studi di Trento)Computer Mediated Communication and the Emergence of "Electronic Opportunism"
36 Citations1996Elena Rocco, Massimo Warglien
Medical Entomology and ZoologySystems Science: Addressing Global Issues
33 Citations2012Frank Stowell, David W. West +1 more
AI MagazineOn Babies and Bathwater: A Cautionary Tale
29 Citations1994Patrick J. Hayes, Kenneth M. Ford +1 more
It is suggested that popular recent positions in AI thinking have done just this by rejecting the useful idea of mental representations in their overenthusiastic zeal to correct some simplifications and naiveties in the way traditional AI ideas have sometimes been understood.
The Philosophical QuarterlyUnderstanding Phenomenology.
26 Citations1992Paul Gorner, Michael Hammond +4 more
Phenomenology in Perspective
24 Citations1970
World Views and the Problem of Synthesis
20 Citations1999Diederik Aerts, Hubert Van Belle +1 more
AI MagazineThe computational metaphor and artificial intelligence: a reflective examination of a theoretical falsework
20 Citations1991David West, Larry Travis
This work addresses three issues: the role of metaphor in science and AI, an examination of the computational metaphor, and an introduction to the possibility and potential value of using alternative metaphors as a foundation for AI theory.
Kent Academic Repository (University of Kent)Information, Meaning and Communication: An Autopoietic Approach to Linking the Social and Individual
17 Citations1999John Mingers
The contribution made in this paper is to link analyses at the level of the individual up to the social system of communication (based on Luhmann's work) utilising structuration theory.
Synthesising Constructivism and Critical Realism: Towards Critical Pluralism
15 Citations1999John Mingers
The discipline within which I work aims to assist the management of organisations using a broadly-defined scientific approach and my work is generally informed by a systems approach.
Minds and MachinesComputationalism
13 Citations1995Stuart C. Shapiro
This paper gives some refutations to some well-known alleged refutations of computationalism, and sketches the design and abilities of a possible embodied computer system.
Systemic Practice and Action ResearchEnabling Network System (ENS)
10 Citations1991Roger Harnden, Geoff Mullery
The design of a novel implementation of the ENS is outlined and the sort of consensual coordinations of actions that this system enables are described and an unusual explanation of how conceptual processes relate to the consensual domain is described.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A Physical and Engineering SciencesNew breakthroughs or dead-ends?
9 Citations1994Margaret A. Boden
The papers presented at this Royal Society/British Academy meeting explore the issues of consciousness and functionalist interpretations of AI, arguing that intentionality cannot be grounded in syntactic and/ or simulated and/or non-evolved systems.
OR InsightWhere are the “real” expert systems?
9 Citations1989John Mingers, Jane Adlam
There are few reports of systems genuinely at work, although this does not mean that such systems do not exist, and those that have been found suggest that success depends more on good software practice than on the expert systems technology used.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A Physical and Engineering SciencesNon-symbolic approaches to artificial intelligence and the mind
8 Citations1994David Willshaw
This work describes recent work due to Foster, who proposes that it is valid to view a system at many different levels of description and that, whereas any theory may have many different implementations, in general sub-symbolic theories may not be implementations of symbolic ones.
AI MagazineFrom society to landscape: alternative metaphors for artificial intelligence
8 Citations1991David West, Larry Travis
This article picks up the call for a reflective examination of the prevailing computational metaphor of AI by sketching alternatives that might serve as seeds for discussion-specifically, the seven alternatives introduced in the previous article.
Cybernetics & SystemsTHESEUS—THE EVOLUTION OF A HYPERMEDIUM
7 Citations1993Roger Harnden, Roy Stringer
The Theseus system is prototypical of such convergence, demonstrating how the idealist models of knowledge transfer and expertise that have dominated computer design and information systems may be replaced by an embodied model of knowledge and understanding as effective action.
Being and Subjectivity: Heidegger and Husserl
7 Citations1970F. Joseph Smith
Information Systems as Linguistic Systems: A Constructivist Perspective
6 Citations1991Robert Stephens, J. R. G. Wood
By treating information systems as fundamentally linguistic systems involving signals that are used by people in relationships, this work will share Checkland and Scholes (1990, p55) concern for the attribution of meaning by the individual and the purposeful action which the information system serves.
NASA Technical Reports Server (NASA)Is thinking computable?
5 CitationsPeter J. Denning
The recent book by Roger Penrose offers a sharp challenge, arguing that the laws of quantum physics may govern mental processes and that these laws may not be computable, that mental processes are inherently more powerful than computational processes.
Minds and MachinesIncarnate mind
2 Citations1995Mark L. Johnson
An account of how the authors ought to understand ourselves as incarnates is given, and how this would change their view of meaning, knowledge, reason, and subjectivity.
…