Patients comment on video-recorded consultations — the “good” GP and the “bad”

Scandinavian Journal of Social MedicinePublished 1 December 1992

Elisabeth Arborelius, Toomas Timpka, James M. Nyce

DOI10.1177/140349489202000405

Citations33

TL;DR

To describe and understand patients' positive and negative experiences of General Practitioners (GPs), consultations were videotaped in four primary health care centres in Sweden and an image of the ”good” GP emerged that had two major characteristics: that of being a caring human; an individual who listens, understands, and is concerned.

Abstract

The aim of this study was to describe and understand patients' positive and negative experiences of General Practitioners (GPs). Forty-six consultations were videotaped in four primary health care centres in Sweden. Afterwards the patients commented on the recorded consultations. The comments were categorized and analyzed using an exploratory qualitative approach. An image of the "good" GP emerged that had two major characteristics: that of being a caring human; an individual who listens, understands, and is concerned. At the same time, the good GP acts like an ordinary person and treats the patient as an equal. The personal relationship with the GP also influenced the choice and course of medical interventions. For the patient, the manner in which an intervention is seen is linked to whether the GPs treats the patient with respect or not. A typical experience of a "bad" GP was that the GP appeared unreachable as a person. An example is when the patient feels that the GP was not taking his or her symptoms seriously. Another characteristic of the bad GP is failure to communicate to the patient his or her standpoint on issues raised during consultations.

Keywords

MedicineHealth ProfessionsArts and Humanities

The Discovery of Grounded Theory

23,416 Citations2017Barney G. Glaser, Anselm L. Strauss

Medical CareScale for the Measurement of Attitudes toward Physicians and Primary Medical Care

240 Citations1970Barbara S. Hulka, Stephen J. Zyzanski +2 more

Patients' attitudes toward physicians and medical care, as well as the providers, should be consulted as to their attitudes, concerns, and satisfactions with the medical care they receive.

Social Science & MedicineHow perceptions of a simulated physician-patient interaction influence intended satisfaction and compliance

160 Citations1982Pamela Willson, J. Regis McNamara

Univariate ANOVAs indicated that the courtesy manipulation influenced the perception of courtesy and general medical satisfaction, while the competence manipulation influenced not only perceived competence but perceived courtesy, generalmedical satisfaction, and compliance as well.

Medical TeacherIn what way may videotapes be used to get significant information about the patient-physician relationship ?

80 Citations1990Elisabeth Arborelius, Toomas Timpka

The conclusion is, that by this modified video-method the ability to obtain knowledge to help to understand/interpret the patient-physician relationship was increased.

PubMedAssessing residents' behavioral science skills: patients' views of physician-patient interaction.

44 Citations1983Falvo Dr, Smith Jk

This study was conducted to identify physician behaviors that patients themselves consider to be important in the physician-patient interaction and then to develop a reliable, valid scale to evaluate residents' ability to perform these skills.

Family PracticeGeneral Practitioners' Comments on Video Recorded Consultations as an Aid to Understanding the Doctor–Patient Relationship

36 Citations1990Elisabeth Arborelius, Toomas Timpka

It is concluded that a key factor in communication is the difficulty which the physician has in understanding what the patient in fact wants-the failure to be on the same wavelength so that the message from the patient can be received.

Psychotherapy and PsychosomaticsDifferent Models in the Approach to the Doctor-Patient Relationship

19 Citations2010Roland A. Pierloot

In the last years the doctor-patient relationship has been the subject of many studies, however, the framework in which this relationship is approached is not always specified and different models, formulated in the approach to interpersonal relationships in general, can also be applied to this relationship.