The concept of ‘Organismic Asymmetry’ in sport science
Journal of science and medicine in sportPublished 3 July 2010
Keith Davids, Duarte Araújo
Citations160
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.32
SNIP1.41
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The philosophical roots of the bias are elucidated, implications of organismic asymmetry for sport science and performance analysis are discussed and examples in psychology, sports medicine and biomechanics are highlighted.
Abstract
The concept of organismic asymmetry refers to an inherent bias for seeking explanations of human performance and behaviour based on internal mechanisms and referents. A weakness in this tendency is a failure to consider the performer-environment relationship as the relevant scale of analysis. In this paper we elucidate the philosophical roots of the bias and discuss implications of organismic asymmetry for sport science and performance analysis, highlighting examples in psychology, sports medicine and biomechanics.
Keywords
PsychologyMedicineBiochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology
The Quarterly Journal of EconomicsA BEHAVIORAL MODEL OF RATIONAL CHOICE
15,263 Citations1955Herbert A. Simon
Psychological ReviewThe role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance.
8,820 Citations1993K. Anders Ericsson, Ralf Krampe +1 more
A theoretical framework is proposed that explains expert performance in terms of acquired characteristics resulting from extended deliberate practice and that limits the role of innate (inherited) characteristics to general levels of activity and emotionality.
Computers & Mathematics with ApplicationsDynamic patterns: The self-organization of brain and behavior
2,861 Citations1997
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesDegeneracy and complexity in biological systems
1,524 Citations2001Gerald M. Edelman, Joseph A. Gally
It is argued that degeneracy is a ubiquitous biological property and it is a feature of complexity at genetic, cellular, system, and population levels.
Handbook of Sport Psychology
1,242 Citations2020Robert N. Singer, Heather A. Hausenblas
Annual Review of Ecology and SystematicsOptimization Theory in Evolution
1,132 Citations1978John Maynard Smith
The basic structure of optimization arguments is outlined, and the possibility that some variation may be selectively neutral, and some structures maladaptive is discussed, as well as comment on criticisms made by Lewontin.
The American Journal of Human GeneticsACTN3 Genotype Is Associated with Human Elite Athletic Performance
917 Citations2003Nan Yang, Daniel G. MacArthur +5 more
Associations between ACTN3 genotype and athletic performance suggest that the presence of alpha-actinin-3 has a beneficial effect on the function of skeletal muscle in generating forceful contractions at high velocity, and provides an evolutionary advantage because of increased sprint performance.
Psychology of sport and exerciseThe ecological dynamics of decision making in sport
826 Citations2006Duarte Araújo, Keith Davids +1 more
Psychological ReviewThe dynamics of perception and action.
809 Citations2006William H. Warren
A theoretical framework called behavioral dynamics is developed that integrates an information-based approach to perception with a dynamical systems approach to action for a given task, which is used to develop theories of several tasks in which a human agent interacts with the physical environment.
NatureGenetics of body-weight regulation
784 Citations2000Gregory S. Barsh, I. Sadaf Farooqi +1 more
The role of genetics in obesity is twofold: Studying rare mutations in humans and model organisms provides fundamental insight into a complex physiological process, and complements population-based studies that seek to reveal primary causes.
Journal of Experimental Psychology GeneralSelf-organization of cognitive performance.
718 Citations2003Guy C. Van Orden, John G. Holden +1 more
Two experiments demonstrate 1/f scaling (pink noise) in simple reaction times and speeded word naming times, which round out a catalog of laboratory task demonstrations that background noise is pink noise.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyDynamics of Skill Acquisition: A Constraints-Led Approach
660 Citations2007Simon Jenkins
Nature reviews. NeuroscienceInside the brain of an elite athlete: the neural processes that support high achievement in sports
620 Citations2009Kielan Yarrow, Peter Brown +1 more
This work attempts to link neural and cognitive processes that have been found to be important for elite performance with computational and physiological theories inspired by much simpler laboratory tasks to inspire neuroscientists to consider how their basic research might help to explain sporting skill at the highest levels of performance.
NatureHuman gene for physical performance
615 Citations1998Hugh Montgomery, Ruth Marshall +17 more
It is shown that a polymorphism in the gene encoding angiotensin-converting enzyme is associated with elite endurance performance among high-altitude mountaineers and after physical training, repetitive weight-lifting is improved eleven-fold in individuals homozygous for the ‘insertion’ allele.
Oxford University Press eBooksEncountering the WorldToward an Ecological Psychology
531 Citations1997Edward S. Reed
International journal of sport psychologyInformation, affordances, and the control of action in sport.
490 Citations2009Brett R. Fajen, Michael A. Riley +1 more
The MIT Press eBooksThe Complementary Nature
434 Citations2006J. A. Scott Kelso, David A. Engstrøm
The Complementary Nature argues that ubiquitous contraries are complementary and proposes a comprehensive, empirically based scientific theory of how the polarized world and the world in between can be reconciled, and nominates the tilde, or squiggle, as the symbolic punctuation for reconciled complementary pairs.
Skill Acquisition in Sport
392 Citations2012
This chapter discusses the roles and uses of augmented feedback in motor skill acquisition, and how to schedule observational practice in the context of a busy professional schedule.
Organizational Behavior and Human Decision ProcessesTake The First: Option-generation and resulting choices
367 Citations2003Joseph G. Johnson, Markus Raab
Choice Reviews OnlineContemporary debates in cognitive science
366 Citations2007
This book argues that cognitive science has shown that human beings are cognitively bounded, or irrational, and that mental states, knowledge in particular, be into a narrow component and a broad component.
Choice Reviews OnlineThe code of codes: scientific and social issues in the human genome project
297 Citations1993Lesley A. Hall
The code of codes is a collection of fourteen essays on the Human Genome Project that lies in the way in which social, legal, scientific, and ethical issues share the same space (although no space is given to a critical appraisal of the HGP on any of these grounds).
Mathematical BiosciencesThe complete optimization of a human motion
231 Citations1976H. Hatze
It is believed that this is the first time that an optimization of this kind has been performed successfully, and the trajectories and control functions of near-optimal motions as measured on the living system were found to be very close to the theoretical optimal process thus confirming the optimality of the model solution.
Understanding complex systemsCoordination Dynamics: Issues and Trends
160 Citations2004Viktor Jirsa, J. A. Scott Kelso
Emergence of sport skills under constraints
157 Citations2004Duarte Araújo, Keith Davids +3 more
Studies of nonlinear phenomena in life scienceWhere Medicine Went Wrong - Rediscovering the Path to Complexity
151 Citations2006Bruce J. West
Sports MedicineConstraints on the Complete Optimization of Human Motion
129 Citations2008Paul S. Glazier, Keith Davids
It is suggested that it is currently not possible to identify the complete optimal solution for a given motor activity.
Human Movement ScienceInformation–movement coupling in developing cricketers under changing ecological practice constraints
109 Citations2009Ross A. Pinder, Ian Renshaw +1 more
Results confirmed the need to ensure representative batting task constraints in practice, cautioning against an over-reliance on ball projection machines in cricket development programmes.
Beyond Rationality: The Search for Wisdom in a Troubled Time
106 Citations2007Kenneth R. Hammond
Psychology of sport and exerciseAn ecological approach to expertise effects in decision-making in a simulated sailing regatta
105 Citations2005Duarte Araújo, Keith Davids +1 more
Advances in experimental medicine and biologyNature of Motor Control: Perspectives and Issues
83 Citations2008M. T. Turvey, Sérgio T. Fonseca
Twelve major issues that commonly constrain the understanding of the control and coordination of movement are identified and evaluated within the framework of the four perspectives of motor control.
Ecological PsychologyThe Agent-Environment Interface: Simon's Indirect or Gibson's Direct Coupling?
74 Citations2003Robert E. Shaw
It is given that the computational approach provides an inadequate account of situated adaptive actions and founders on the symbol grounding problem, whereas the ecological approach does a better job on both.
Journal of Motor BehaviorShould Common Optimal Movement Patterns be Identified as the Criterion to be Achieved?
61 Citations1996Therese A. Brisson, Claude Alain
During training, subjects who used their personal template had a lower incidence of zero scores and were more consistent than those who used the template of the best subject, providing a second line of evidence against the assumption that a common optimal movement pattern exists for this type of task.
Theory & PsychologySpecial Section: The Skillful Body as a Concernful System of Possible Actions
61 Citations2008Erik Rietveld
Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical PsychologyThe neglect of the environment by cognitive psychology.
58 Citations2006Philip T. Dunwoody
Fitness Information Technology eBooksSport psychology : linking theory and practice
53 Citations1999Ronnie Lidor, Michael Bar‐Eli
Molecular TherapyGene Transfer and Athletics— An Impending Problem
23 Citations2001Theodore Friedmann, Johann Olav Koss
Journal of BiomechanicsThe problem of measurement indeterminacy in complex neurobiological movement systems
20 Citations2009Paul S. Glazier, Keith Davids
A further benefit of establishing more of the unknowns is that human movement scientists will be able to gain greater insight into ubiquitous processes of physical self-organising that underpin the formation of coordinative structures and the confluence of organismic, environmental and task constraints that determine the exact morphology of these special-purpose devices.
SHURA (Sheffield Hallam University Research Archive) (Sheffield Hallam University)Power law distributions in pattern dynamics of attacker-defender dyads in the team sport of Rugby Union : phenomena in a region of self-organized criticality?
17 Citations2009Pedro Passos, Duarte Araújo +3 more
Theory & PsychologySpecial Section: Is Cognitive Science Changing its Mind?
12 Citations2008Tjeerd van de Laar, Herman de Regt
QUT ePrints (Queensland University of Technology)Power law distributions in pattern dynamics of attacker-defender dyads in the team sport of Rugby Union: Phenomena in a region of self-organised criticality?
1 Citations2009Passos, Pedro, Araujo, Duarte +3 more