The user–developer communication process: a critical case study
Information Systems JournalPublished 18 December 2002Open access
Michael J. Gallivan, Mark Keil
Citations202
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score3.60
SNIP3.12
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
A process model is proposed that delineates four stages of communication between users and software developers, and it is argued that these stages must occur for user participation to lead to effective outcomes.
Abstract
Abstract. Although user participation in systems development is widely believed to have positive impacts on user acceptance, it does not guarantee success and there is still much that we do not know about how and why user participation sometimes delivers positive benefits, but not always. Much of the prior research on user participation assumes that user–developer communication will ensure that the resulting system will be designed to meet users’ needs and will be accepted by them. The nature and quality of the communication between users and developers, however, remains an understudied aspect of user participation. In this paper, we focus on the user–developer communication process. We propose a process model that delineates four stages of communication between users and software developers, and we argue that these stages must occur for user participation to lead to effective outcomes. To illustrate our model, we apply it to analyse a ‘critical case study’ of a software project that failed despite high levels of user involvement. We show that when ‘communication lapses’ occurred in several of the user–developer communication stages, developers failed to be informed regarding the underlying reasons that users avoided the system. Based on the insights from this case study, we advise researchers and practitioners how to leverage the potential benefits of user participation, rather than take them for granted.
Keywords
Computer Science
Evaluation & Research in EducationCase study research: design and methods
21,946 Citations2011Simon Phelan
Throughout this text, the authors have successfully provided many practical, relevant recommendations that would benefit researchers currently developing a literature review.
Management ScienceOrganizational Information Requirements, Media Richness and Structural Design
9,556 Citations1986Richard L. Daft, Robert H. Lengel
Models are proposed that show how organizations can be designed to meet the information needs of technology, interdepartmental relations, and the environment to both reduce uncertainty and resolve equivocality.
MIS QuarterlyMessage Equivocality, Media Selection, and Manager Performance: Implications for Information Systems
2,335 Citations1987Richard L. Daft, Robert H. Lengel +1 more
The findings indicate that media vary in their capacity to convey information cues and that high performing managers are more sensitive to the relationship between message ambiguity and media richness than low performing managers.
Management ScienceInformation Technology and Organizational Change: Causal Structure in Theory and Research
2,110 Citations1988M. Lynne Markus, Daniel Robey
This article concerns theories about why and how information technology affects organizational life and examines theories in terms of their structures-theorists' assumptions about the nature and direction of causal influence.
Organization SciencePerspective Making and Perspective Taking in Communities of Knowing
2,106 Citations1995Richard J. Boland, Ramkrishnan V. Tenkasi
It is argued that producing knowledge to create innovative products and processes in knowledge-intensive firms requires the ability to make strong perspectives within a community, as well as the ability to take the perspective of another into account.
Management ScienceCoordinating Expertise in Software Development Teams
1,692 Citations2000Samer Faraj, Lee Sproull
This study investigates the importance of expertise coordination through a cross-sectional investigation of 69 software development teams and reveals that expertise coordination shows a strong relationship with team performance that remains significant over and above team input characteristics, presence of expertise, and administrative coordination.
Management ScienceExplaining the Role of User Participation in Information System Use
1,534 Citations1994Jon Hartwick, Henri Barki
Embedding the constructs of participation and involvement into the theoretical framework of Fishbein and Ajzen, a model is developed and tested in a field study of information system projects and several key findings emerge.
MIS QuarterlyCASE Tools as Organizational Change: Investigating Incremental and Radical Changes in Systems Development
1,512 Citations1993Wanda J. Orlikowski
The framework and findings suggest that in order to account for the experiences and outcomes associated with CASE tools, researchers should consider the social context of systems development, the intentions and actions of key players, and the implementation process followed by the organization.
TechnometricsMaking Hard Decisions, an Introduction to Decision Analysis
1,468 Citations1992Shin Ta Liu, Robert T. Clemen
This text involves readers in real-world decisions from personal, federal, corporate and environmental areas and readers should learn how to use the tools of decision analysis including decision tree diagrammes, influence diagrammes and probabilistic models for insight into decision-making situations.
Journal of American HistoryVictims of Groupthink: A Psychological Study of Foreign-policy Decisions and Fiascoes
1,464 Citations1973Bruce Kuklick, Irving L. Janis
Psychological ReviewDifferential contributions of majority and minority influence.
1,217 Citations1986Charlan Nemeth
Management ScienceUnderstanding User Evaluations of Information Systems
1,216 Citations1995Dale L. Goodhue
TTF focuses on the degree to which systems characteristics match user task needs, and proposes task-technology fit (TTF), a user evaluation construct defined within a theoretical perspective that can usefully link underlying systems to their relevant impacts.
Communications of the ACMCoordination in software development
1,087 Citations1995Robert E. Kraut, Lynn A. Streeter
Since its inception, the software industry has been in crisis and problems with software systems are common and highly-publicized occurrences.
Research PolicyImplementation as mutual adaptation of technology and organization
931 Citations1988Dorothy Leonard‐Barton
Communications of the ACMInformation systems and organizational change
908 Citations1981Peter G. W. Keen
The causes of social Inertia, resistance and counterimplementatlon are reviewed, which stresses the pluralistic nature of organizations.
WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooksSpark Innovation through Empathic Design
793 Citations2011Dorothy A. Leonard, Jeffrey F. Rayport
The five-step process Dorothy Leonard and Jeffrey Rayport describe in detail is a relatively low-cost, low-risk way to identify customer needs, and it has the potential to redirect a company's existing technological capabilities toward entirely new businesses.
How IT Creates Business Value: A Process Theory Synthesis.
631 Citations1995Christina Soh, M. Lynne Markus
This paper attempts its own process theory synthesis of these models, resolving some of their apparent contradictions, to serve as a platform for future research and one important implication of the process model is to highlight IT use and knowhow as intermediate outcomes requiring much further research.
MIS QuarterlyRethinking the Concept of User Involvement
621 Citations1989Henri Barki, Jon Hartwick
This article argues for a separation of the constructs of user participation (a set of behaviors or activities performed by users in the system development process) and user involvement (a subjective psychological state reflecting the importance and personal relevance of a system to the user).
MIS QuarterlyPulling the Plug: Software Project Management and the Problem of Project Escalation1
605 Citations1995Mark Keil
A model of escalation based on the literature suggests that escalation is promoted by a combination of project, psychological, social, and organizational factors, and the managerial implications are discussed along with prescriptions for how to avoid the problem of escalation.
MIS QuarterlyA Social Process Model of User-Analyst Relationships
542 Citations1992Michael Newman, Daniel Robey
A process model of useranalyst relationships is presented to guide research into the social dynamics of system development and may be used to diagnose problems and to enact critical encounters that move a project in a different direction.
MIS QuarterlyThe Relationship Between User Participation and User Satisfaction: An Investigation of Four Contingency Factors
470 Citations1994James D. McKeen, Tor Guimãrães +1 more
Analysis of 151 independent system development projects in eight different organizations indicated that user participation has a direct relationship with user satisfaction, and the four contingency factors found to play key roles on this relationship.
Decision Support SystemsUsefulness and ease of use: field study evidence regarding task considerations
422 Citations1995Mark Keil, Peggy M. Beranek +1 more
The results of a field study illustrating the hazards of focusing on EOU and overlooking usefulness are presented and it is suggested that perceived EOU may be a function of task/tool fit.
Management ScienceUser Involvement in Information System Development: A Conflict Model and Empirical Test
340 Citations1982Daniel Robey, Dana L. Farrow
Results show that influence does result from user participation, and that influence leads to both conflict and resolution, but participation without influence does not lead to success in any of the three development stages.
European Journal of Social PsychologyCreative problem solving as a result of majority vs minority influence
326 Citations1983Charlan Nemeth, Joel Wachtler
ComputerInteractive systems: bridging the gaps between developers and users
315 Citations1991Jonathan Grudin
Three development contexts are examined to provide a framework for understanding interactive software development projects and strategies to cope with the gaps between developers and prospective users are explored at the general level of the three development paradigms.
Communications of the ACMCustomer-developer links in software development
295 Citations1995Mark Keil, Erran Carmel
MIS QuarterlyDeterminants of Commitment to Information Systems Development: A Longitudinal Investigation
293 Citations1996Michael Newman, Rajiv Sabherwal
Initial insights into the determinants of commitment are provided based on a longitudinal study of an IS project that was stopped and then restarted on several occasions over a 17-year period (1975-1992).
Management ScienceGroup Process and Conflict in System Development
270 Citations1989Daniel Robey, Dana L. Farrow +1 more
Assessment of group process during the development of an information system in an insurance company using questionnaires, recorded transcripts of group meetings, interviews, and archival data shows that in every time period participation positively affected influence and that influence positively affected both conflict and conflict resolution.
Sloan management reviewThe Magic Bullet Theory in IT-Enabled Transformation
263 Citations1997M. Lynne Markus, Robert I. Benjamin
According to the authors, there are effective change advocates anywhere in an organization; they are not necessarily top managers but may be line managers or IT specialists, and other organizational members must all practice the change agent role.
Information Systems ResearchThe Contradictory Structure of Systems Development Methodologies: Deconstructing the IS-User Relationship in Information Engineering
258 Citations1994Cynthia Mathis Beath, Wanda J. Orlikowski
It is shown that systems development methodologies may contain incompatible assumptions about the role of users and information systems IS personnel during systems development, and that such prescriptions make the relationship between users and IS personnel problematic.
MIS QuarterlyDe-escalating Information Technology Projects: Lessons from the Denver International Airport1
256 Citations2000Ramiro Montealegre, Mark Keil
The model reveals de-escalation as a four-phase process: (1) problem recognition, (2) re-examination of prior course of action, (3) search for alternative course ofaction, and (4) implementing an exit strategy.
Information & ManagementThe effect of user engagement on system success: A meta-analytical integration of research findings
252 Citations1999Mark I. Hwang, Ron G. Thorn
Overall, these findings indicate that both user involvement and user participation are beneficial, but the magnitude of these benefits much depends on how involvement and its effect are defined.
MIS QuarterlyEffects of User Participation in Systems Development: A Longitudinal Field Experiment1
228 Citations1997James E. Hunton, Jesse D. Beeler
Research findings indicate that user participation can be effective, particularly when users perceive a noticeable degree of instrumental control over the decision outcome.
Information Systems ResearchUser Involvement as an Interaction Process: A Case Study
194 Citations1990Michael Newman, Faith Noble
A two-stage model of user involvement based on Robey and Farrow's work (1982) is proposed which distinguishes conflict development from conflict resolution.
Communications of the ACMApprenticing with the customer
194 Citations1995Hugh Beyer, Karen Holtzblatt
It is the relationship between designers and customers that determines how well the design team understands the customer problem, and designers need better approaches to gathering customer requirements.
Information & ManagementSuccessful application of communication techniques to improve the systems development process
187 Citations1989Robert P. Bostrom
The findings indicate that the new meeting format improved the communication between users and developers and enhanced their ability to develop shared, accurate and complete system requirements.
Management ScienceSuccessful Information System Development in Relation to Situational Factors Which Affect Effective Communication Between MIS-Users and EDP-Specialists
179 Citations1984B. De Brabander, Geert F. Thiers
The paper describes the results of an experimental test of a theoretical model which explains under what circumstances the interaction between MIS-users and EDP-specialists during the design of an EDP system is explained.
Human RelationsUser Influence and the Success of MIS Projects: A Contingency Approach
171 Citations1977Anders Edström
Alternative specifications of the relation-ship between user influence and the success of the management information system (MIS) project are investigated and Tentative causal models are proposed to relate the important variables.
Information Systems ResearchUser Participation, Conflict, and Conflict Resolution: The Mediating Roles of Influence
164 Citations1994Henri Barki, Jon Hartwick
Results obtained in a field study of 74 IS projects suggest the relationship between user participation and conflict is more complex than previously believed and influence has a dual role in the emergence of conflict.
Journal of Management Information SystemsIdentifying Sources of Reengineering Failures: A Study of the Behavioral Factors Contributing to Reengineering Risks
161 Citations1995Eric K. Clemons, Matt E. Thatcher +1 more
This research suggests that the two principal reasons for failure are functionality risk and political risk: respectively, the organization’s inability to understand its uncertain future strategic needs, and its inability to make painful and difficult changes in response to these future strategicneeds.
Journal of Management Information SystemsAn Empirical Test of the Contingency Approach to User Participation in Information Systems Development
113 Citations1996Naveed Saleem
The data suggest that users who perceive themselves as functional experts, relative to others, are unlikely to accept a system unless they exerted a substantive influence on its design, and the appropriate extent of a participant user's influence on system design.
IEEE Transactions on Engineering ManagementOccupational cultures as a challenge to technological innovation
105 Citations1999Alexandra von Meier
IEEE Transactions on Professional CommunicationCommunication as a dimension of user participation
104 Citations2001Jon Hartwick, Henri Barki
This paper replicates and extends past research by proposing the addition of a fourth dimension: communication activity to the three dimensions of user participation: responsibility, the user-IS relationship and hands-on activity.
Management ScienceSuccessful Information System Development Projects
103 Citations1977Bert Debrabander, Anders Edström
A formal theory for predicting the success of information system development projects is developed and one important managerial tool to establish effective user-specialist communication is suggested.
Technical Communication QuarterlyThe social perspective and pedagogy in technical communication
66 Citations1993Charlotte Thralls, Nancy Roundy Blyler
Medical Entomology and ZoologyXSEL's Progress: The Continuing Journey of an Expert System
51 Citations1989Enid Mumford, W. Bruce MacDonald
Part 1 Design, participation and culture: designing systems - retrospect and reality participation and systems design innovation and the digital culture and the technical development of XSEL and lessons from the journey.
Information Systems ResearchResearch Report—Modeling Interpersonal Processes During System Development: Further Thoughts and Suggestions
35 Citations1994Daniel Robey
Commentary on the paper by Barki and Hartwick 1994, to replicate and extend the model of conflict during systems development reported in previous research, suggesting a more careful distinction between hypothesis testing and data exploration is suggested.
Journal of Business CommunicationFrom Text to Context: An Open Systems Approach to Research in Written Business Communication
35 Citations1998J. Suchan, Ronald E. Dulek
Human RelationsA Methodological Inquiry of Organizational Noise in Sociotechnical Systems
21 Citations1984Claudio Ciborra, Piero Migliarese +1 more
Accounting Management and Information TechnologiesCan executive information systems reinforce biases?
12 Citations1994Arun Rai, Charles I. Stubbart +1 more
The interaction between key characteristics of executive systems and fundamental features of human thinking drawn from the field of Behavioral Decision Theory are examined to examine the possibility that the operation of these systems may reinforce or intensify certain biases in human information processing.
Reducing work related uncertainty: the role of communication and control in software development
9 Citations2002Patricia J. Guinan, Samer Faraj
This finding goes beyond previous studies by showing the mediating impact of role and task ambiguity on the relationship between team performance on the one hand, and team communication and control strategies on the other.