Signs and Maps: Cognitive Economy in the Use of External Aids for Indoor Navigation

eScholarship (California Digital Library)Published 1 January 2007Open access

Christoph Hölscher, Simon J. Büchner, Martin Brösamle, T Meilinger, Gerhard Strube

Citations34

TL;DR

The experiment investigates the relative effectiveness and efficiency of external aids for navigation in a complex multi-level, multi-building ensemble and suggests that showing a floor map to participants immediately prior to testing reduced the effects of familiarity with the building and improved wayfinding performance.

Abstract

Wayfinding in public buildings often proves to be a challenge especially for first time visitors. The experiment investigates the relative effectiveness and efficiency of external aids for navigation in a complex multi-level, multi-building ensemble. A previous experiment provided the performance baseline for the re-design and prototype evaluation of the information system. Navigation aids were tested in three conditions: maps, signs, and the combination of both. With respect of usage a preference for signs over maps was identified. Also, signage had the largest impact on wayfinding performance, while maps alone showed the smallest level of support and the combination provided yet further improvement. Analysis of individual tasks identifies limitations of each type of external aid. A comparative task analyses reveals higher cognitive costs of maps relative to signs. The results are discussed in a framework of cognitive economics and agent nationality, explaining both usage preference performance differences.

Keywords

Social SciencesEngineering

Medical Entomology and ZoologyRules of the Mind

1,899 Citations1993John R. Anderson

Cognitive PsychologyDifferences in spatial knowledge acquired from maps and navigation

1,154 Citations1982Perry W. Thorndyke, Barbara Hayes‐Roth

Models of the spatial knowledge people acquire from maps and navigation and the procedures required for spatial judgments using this knowledge are proposed and results are consonant with the proposed mechanisms.

International Journal of Human-Computer StudiesExternal cognition: how do graphical representations work?

1,048 Citations1996Mike Scaife, Yvonne Rogers

This analysis reveals a fragmented and poorly understood account of how graphical representations work, exposing a number of assumptions and fallacies, and proposes a new agenda for graphical representation research.

View PDF

Choice Reviews OnlineWayfinding: people, signs, and architecture

524 Citations1992

This book brings together expertise on three of the elements that comprise wayfinding within the context of the built environment: architecture; graphics; and verbal human interaction to gain a better understanding of the wayfinding difficulties people have and why they have them.

Environment and BehaviorEvaluating Architectural Legibility

457 Citations1981Jerry Weisman

The legibility of a sample of ten university buildings was evaluated: self-report data indicated way-finding to be a problem for a substantial minority, and two aspects of the floor plan configurations of these settings, as judged from highly significant relationships to frequency of disorientation.

Psychological ReviewThe soft constraints hypothesis: A rational analysis approach to resource allocation for interactive behavior.

363 Citations2006Wayne D. Gray, Chris R. Sims +2 more

Model and data support the SCH view of resource allocation; at the under 1000-ms level of analysis, mixtures of cognitive and perceptual-motor resources are adjusted based on their cost-benefit tradeoffs for interactive behavior.

Environment and BehaviorEffects of Signage and Floor Plan Configuration on Wayfinding Accuracy

303 Citations1991Michael J. O'Neill

Human Factors The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics SocietyWayfinding by Newcomers in a Complex Building

83 Citations1993Darrell L. Butler, April L. Acquino +2 more

Lecture notes in computer scienceMap Use and Wayfinding Strategies in a Multi-building Ensemble

29 Citations2007Christoph Hölscher, Simon J. Büchner +2 more

Overall, the strategy of moving horizontally into the target section of the building prior to vertical travel was shown to be more effective in this multi-building setting.

Lecture notes in computer scienceSpatial Cognition and the Processing of Verticality in Underground Environments

21 Citations2001Sylvie Fontaine

The axonometric representation was found to be the easiest to learn and enabled individuals to perform well on the different tasks by allowing them to elaborate a correct mental representation of the vertical relations between the levels of the station, and between the underground and the outside.