Qualitative research and content validity: developing best practices based on science and experience
Quality of Life ResearchPublished 26 September 2009
Meryl Brod, Laura E. Tesler, Torsten L. Christensen
Citations957
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.44
SNIP1.64
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This paper provides an overview of the current state of knowledge regarding qualitative research to establish content validity based on the scientific methodological literature and authors’ experience and suggests best practices for establishing content validity.
Abstract
It is hoped this paper will stimulate further discussion regarding best practices for establishing content validity so that, as the PRO field moves forward, qualitative research can be evaluated for quality and acceptability according to scientifically established principles.
Keywords
Social SciencesDecision SciencesHealth Professions
The Discovery of Grounded Theory
23,416 Citations2017Barney G. Glaser, Anselm L. Strauss
Field MethodsHow Many Interviews Are Enough?
19,442 Citations2005Greg Guest, Arwen Bunce +1 more
The authors operationalize saturation and make evidence-based recommendations regarding nonprobabilistic sample sizes for interviews and found that saturation occurred within the first twelve interviews, although basic elements for metathemes were present as early as six interviews.
Qualitative SociologyGrounded theory research: Procedures, canons, and evaluative criteria
10,900 Citations1990Juliet Corbin, Anselm Strauss
Choice Reviews OnlineQualitative research practice: a guide for social science students and researchers
10,663 Citations2003Jane Ritchie
Basics of qualitative research
10,029 Citations1990Anselm L. Strauss
Focus Groups as Qualitative Research
8,719 Citations1997David Morgan
Foundations of Qualitative Research: Interpretive and Critical Approaches
2,577 Citations2007Jerry Willis
Cognitive Interviewing: A Tool for Improving Questionnaire Design
1,949 Citations2004Gordon Willis
Public Opinion QuarterlyResearch Synthesis: The Practice of Cognitive Interviewing
1,613 Citations2007Paul Beatty, G. B. Willis
Methods for Testing and Evaluating Survey Questionnaires
849 Citations2004
Field MethodsReliability in Coding Open-Ended Data: Lessons Learned from HIV Behavioral Research
824 Citations2004Daniel J. Hruschka, Deborah A. Schwartz +4 more
The text coding process applied to three HIV-related studies conducted with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention considering populations in the United States and Zimbabwe concludes that a team of coders will initially produce very different codings, but it is possible, through a process of codebook revision and recoding, to establish strong levels of intercoder reliability.
BMJHow to read a paper: Papers that go beyond numbers (qualitative research)
750 Citations1997Trisha Greenhalgh, Rod S Taylor
Qualitative methods aim to make sense of phenomena in terms of the meanings people bring to them and use “a holistic perspective which preserves the complexities of human behaviour.”
Value in HealthPatient-Reported Outcomes to Support Medical Product Labeling Claims: FDA Perspective
719 Citations2007Donald L. Patrick, Laurie B. Burke +6 more
Developing and use of patient-reported outcomes in clinical trials to evaluate medical products and major challenges from Food and Drug Administration's perspective in using PRO instruments, measures, and end points to support treatment benefit claims in product labeling are reviewed.
Inside Interviewing: New Lenses, New Concerns
660 Citations2003James A. Holstein
Journal of Advanced NursingMethodological issues in grounded theory
634 Citations2000John R. Cutcliffe
This paper identifies and attempts to address four key issues, namely, sampling, creativity and reflexivity, the use of literature, and precision within grounded theory.
Journal of Contemporary EthnographyThe Social Contexts of Focus Groups
585 Citations2004Jocelyn A. Hollander
Value in HealthWhat Is Sufficient Evidence for the Reliability and Validity of Patient-Reported Outcome Measures?
569 Citations2007Marlene H. Frost, Bryce B. Reeve +3 more
This article focuses on the necessary psychometric properties of a patient-reported outcomes (PROs) measure and the kinds of evidence needed to indicate that a PRO has a sufficient level of reliability and validity.
Journal of Advanced NursingGrounded theory research: literature reviewing and reflexivity
372 Citations2007Gerry McGhee, Glenn Marland +1 more
Use of literature or any other preknowledge should not prevent a grounded theory arising from the inductive-deductive interplay which is at the heart of this method.
Moderating Focus Groups: A Practical Guide for Group Facilitation
327 Citations2000Thomas L.Greenbaum
BMJRandom allocation or allocation at random? Patients' perspectives of participation in a randomised controlled trial
232 Citations1998Katie Featherstone, J L Donovan
The provision of clear and accurate patient information is important, but this alone will not ensure consistent interpretation of concepts such as randomisation, so patients may need to discuss the purposes of randomisation in order to understand them fully enough to give truly informed consent.
Value in HealthPatient-Reported Outcomes: Conceptual Issues
221 Citations2007Margaret Rothman, Philippe Beltran +3 more
This work addresses the challenges in constructing the conceptual foundations for PRO assessment to support drug product labeling claims submitted to regulatory agencies worldwide and examines the consequences of choosing PRO instruments without reference to a well-established conceptual framework for measurement.
Journal of Nursing ScholarshipThe Pros and Cons of Data Analysis Software for Qualitative Research
205 Citations2000Winsome St John, Patricia Johnson
Researchers should be as critical of the methodological approaches to using qualitative data analysis software as they are about the fit between research question, methods, and research design.
PharmacoEconomicsPerspectives on Patient-Reported Outcomes
204 Citations2008Nancy Kline Leidy, Margaret Vernon
Focus groups, cognitive debriefing, user acceptance testing and translation methodologies are discussed as ways to address and document the content validity of PRO instruments and ensure the empirical data representing the voice of the patient is sound.
Value in HealthPatient-Reported Outcomes: Instrument Development and Selection Issues
163 Citations2007Ralph R. Turner, Alexandra L. Quittner +3 more
This work recognizes that PRO assessment stands at a technological crossroads with the increasingly frequent application of "modern" psychometric methods and discusses how innovations such as item banks and computer-adaptive testing will influence PRO instrument development.
Journal of Advanced NursingThe role of computer software in the analysis of qualitative data: efficient clerk, research assistant or Trojan horse?
129 Citations1998Moya Morison, James L. Moir
This paper illustrates the way in which a package called NUD facilitated analysis where grounded theory methods of data analysis were also extensively used, and illustrates the limitations of such programs.
Child Care Health and DevelopmentDevelopment of a condition‐specific measure of quality of life for children with cerebral palsy: empirical thematic data reported by parents and children
127 Citations2005E. Waters, Elise Maher +3 more
Research with parents and children with cerebral palsy reinforced and expanded on the traditional themes that have underpinned QOL measurement development, which has implications not only for the development of a new QOL scale for children with cortex palsy, but also for clinical interventions and community care management.
Cognitive Interviewing Revisited: A Useful Technique, in Theory?
101 Citations2004Gordon Willis
The Dynamics of Cognitive Interviewing
90 Citations2004Paul Beatty
Contemporary Clinical TrialsAfrican Americans and participation in clinical trials: Differences in beliefs and attitudes by gender
81 Citations2006Rhonda BeLue, Kelly D. Taylor-Richardson +3 more
Focus group results indicate that African American men and women present different preferences, beliefs and barriers to participation, and integrating gender preferences into researcher-participant interactions, advertisement, informed consent delivery and advertisement of research studies may lead to increased participation rates.
Journal of Medical EthicsAttitudes towards clinical research among cancer trial participants and non-participants: an interview study using a Grounded Theory approach: Table 1
72 Citations2007Søren Madsen, Søren Holm +1 more
Although most patients originally trusted that doctors primarily pursued the interest of patients, they did not trust the adequacy of doctors or industry in maintaining self-regulation, and public control measures were judged to be essential.
Quality of Life ResearchDocumenting the rationale and psychometric characteristics of patient reported outcomes for labeling and promotional claims: the PRO Evidence Dossier
66 Citations2007Dennis A. Revicki, Ari Gnanasakthy +1 more
The purpose and content of a PRO Evidence Dossier, which consists of important information supporting PRO claims, is described, which should be completed by pharmaceutical industry or other researchers to document the planning of the PRO assessment strategy, psychometric evidence, desired target labeling statements, and the clinical trial evidence of PRO benefits.
Quality of Life ResearchContent validity for dementia of three generic preference based health related quality of life instruments
61 Citations2002Michel Silberfeld, Sergio Rueda +2 more
A semi-structured interview was conducted with dementia patients and their caregivers in order to explore which aspects of quality of life were perceived as relevant and important and these aspects were compared with the content of three generic utility-basedquality of life instruments.
Health ExpectationsPatient and clinician collaboration in the design of a national randomized breast cancer trial
58 Citations2004Jo Marsden, Jane Bradburn
To show breast cancer patient involvement in the design of a national randomized trial of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) in symptomatic patients will increase accrual is presented.
PubMedParticipating in the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS): a qualitative study of patients' experiences.
49 Citations2003Julia Lawton, Anna Fox +2 more
Patients' motivations for joining the UKPDS and for remaining in the trial are explored, and the implications of findings for good practice before, during, and after clinical trials are examined.
Evaluation ReviewThe Formalization of Qualitative Research
46 Citations1983William A. Firestone, Robert E. Herriott
JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency SyndromesHIV Medication Adherence
40 Citations2006Gerald Friedland
Relations and differences in training and expertise, perceived mission, orientation, culture, and personal and professional skills can thwart meaningful collaboration or be used synergistically to move understanding and improvement of HIV medication adherence forward.
CancerAsian Americans and cancer clinical trials
39 Citations2005Debora A. Paterniti, Moon S. Chen +10 more
Multiple strategies will be necessary to enhance awareness of and experience with accrual to cancer clinical trials for Asians, including richer understanding and increased involvement of Asians in cancerclinical trials and greater attention to the location and diversity of the Asian population in structuring study centers and evaluating trial results.
Qualitative Health ResearchThe Use of Focus Groups with the Disabled Elderly
37 Citations1995Susan Quine, Ian D. Cameron
Using the guidelines outlined, focus groups could be used more widely with disabled elderly people.
Social Science & MedicineThe research, policy and practice interface: Reflections on using applied social research to promote equity in health in Malawi
28 Citations2008Sally Theobald, Bertha Nhlema-Simwaka
A critical reflection on the strategic frameworks applied social researchers have used in the Malawian context to try and bring the voices of poor women and men to policy makers and practitioners and hence intensify the research to policy and practice interface is reflected.
Psychiatric Rehabilitation JournalConducting focus groups with women with severe psychiatric disabilities: A methodological overview.
22 Citations2001Nancy F. Koppelman, Joretha N. Bourjolly
The purpose of the focus groups was to understand the experiences of low-income women with severe psychiatric disabilities in accessing and using primary health care services.
International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health CareCONNECTING PRE-MARKETING CLINICAL RESEARCH AND MEDICAL PRACTICE
9 Citations2003Nicolien F. Wieringa, Jules Peschar +3 more