Surgery on trial: an account of clinical trials evaluating operations.
PubMedPublished 1 July 1998
J C Hall, Cameron Platell, Jane L. Hall
Citations19
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The objective of this study was to review published clinical trials to determine the level of compliance with issues relevant to operations. METHODS: We evaluated 10 methodologic criteria in 186 trials that were published in 10 prestigious journals between January 1986 and December 1995. RESULTS: One quarter of the trials failed to provide a clear account of the operative technique, 34% of the trials did not adequately detail the adverse events that occurred after operation, and 40% of the trials neglected to declare the nature and success of the follow-up of patients after the operation. Only 35% of the trials indicated that there was an attempt to standardize either the surgical procedure or perioperative care. In addition, less than 20% of the trials declared a method for assessing compliance with the surgical protocol or commented on the use of resources during the perioperative period. CONCLUSIONS: Greater attention needs to be paid to the specific issues that arise when operations are evaluated in clinical trials.
Keywords
Decision SciencesMedicine
JAMAImproving the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials. The CONSORT statement
3,343 Citations1996Colin B. Begg
Annals of Internal MedicineSurrogate End Points in Clinical Trials: Are We Being Misled?
1,609 Citations1996Thomas R. Fleming, David L. DeMets
Surrogate end points are rarely, if ever, adequate substitutes for the definitive clinical outcome in phase 3 trials and proper justification for such replacement requires that the effect of the intervention on the surrogate end point predicts the effect on the clinical outcome.
Controlled Clinical TrialsA method for assessing the quality of a randomized control trial
1,370 Citations1981Thomas C. Chalmers, Harry Smith +5 more
A reasonable standard design and conduct of trials will facilitate the interpretation of those with conflicting results and help in making valid combinations of undersized trials.
The LancetRandomised comparison of morbidity after D1 and D2 dissection for gastric cancer in 996 Dutch patients
1,033 Citations1995Johannes J. Bonenkamp, Ilfet Songun +14 more
Morbidity and mortality differences persisted in almost all subgroup analyses, and D2 dissection should not be used as standard treatment for western patients.
BMJThe scandal of poor medical research
872 Citations1994D G Altman
The authors need less research, better research, and research done for the right reasons, and researchers who use the wrong techniques, use the right techniques wrongly, misinterpret their results, report their results selectively, cite the literature selectively, and draw unjustified conclusions.
New England Journal of MedicineA Randomized Study of Coronary Angioplasty Compared with Bypass Surgery in Patients with Symptomatic Multivessel Coronary Disease
542 Citations1994Christian W. Hamm, Jacobus Reimers +4 more
In selected patients with multivessel coronary disease, PTCA and CABG as initial treatments resulted in equivalent improvement in angina after one year, however, in order to achieve similar clinical outcomes, the patients treated with P TCA were more likely to require further interventions and antianginal drugs, whereas the patients treating with CABGs were morelikely to sustain an acute myocardial infarction at the time of the procedure.
Annals of SurgeryGastric Surgery for Morbid Obesity
313 Citations1990John C. Hall, J. McK. Watts +5 more
The Roux-en-Y gastric bypass is the preferred procedure for the surgical treatment of morbid obesity in a prospective randomized study of 310 morbidly obese subjects.
ScienceStatistics and Ethics in Surgery and Anesthesia
153 Citations1977John Gilbert, Bucknam McPeek +1 more
Questions are investigated about how potential new therapies are evaluated and what the findings are, and how much better or worse is a new therapy likely to be than the standard treatment when they are tested.
BMJUnderstanding clinical trials
97 Citations1994David L. Sackett, Richard J. Cook
The randomised clinical trial has revolutionised the way that the authors decide whether a treatment or intervention does more good than harm, providing the qualitative answer that antihypertensive drugs are better than no treatment for patients with moderate to severe hypertension.
SurgeryMethodologic standards in surgical trials
86 Citations1996John C. Hall, Briony Mills +2 more
This study reviews the nature and methodologic standards of surgical trails published in 10 prestigious journals between January 1988 and December 1994 and concludes readers should be cautious when interpreting the results of surgical trials.
British journal of surgeryEvaluating surgical risk: The importance of technical factors in determining outcome
63 Citations1987Ross A. Pettigrew, H.J.G. Burns +1 more
It is concluded that operative performance is the main factor in the development of postoperative complications and should be assessed in future studies of outcome.
Annals of SurgeryThe Impact of Surgical Quality Control in Multi-Institutional Group Trials Involving Adjuvant Cancer Treatments
50 Citations1983Charles M. Balch, John Durant +1 more
Quality control involving surgical treatment in multi-institutional cancer trials is important because the results of postoperative adjuvant therapy might be obscured by inadequate surgery or pathologic examination of the specimen.
British journal of surgeryAnalysis of randomized controlled trials in laparoscopic surgery
49 Citations1997K. Slim, Jean Bousquet +3 more
This study presents a meta-analysis of eight randomized controlled studies of surgical procedures conducted at four hospitals in the Netherlands over a 12-month period and found that three of the studies met or exceeded acceptable standards.
BMJRemoving bias in surgical trials
38 Citations1997A G Johnson, J. Michael Dixon
The safety and efficacy register of new interventional procedures (SERNIP), recently set up by Britain's Academy of Royal Medical Colleges, provides a framework that should go some way to remedying the defect, but it is still voluntary rather than compulsory.
The American Journal of SurgeryTen rules for reading clinical research reports
31 Citations1990John M. Yancey
The overall quality of data analysis in these papers was found to be above average for the medical literature; and yet, I found many instances of errors so serious as to render invalid the conclusions of the authors.
Archives of SurgerySome Problems With Clinical Trials
27 Citations1991Walter Lawrence
This society, devoted to oncology, was founded in 1940 as the James Ewing Society both to "further the authors' knowledge of cancer" and to honor this great man.
BMJGrowing pains of meta-analysis
24 Citations1996Ida Sim, Mark A. Hlatky
Advances in methodology will not remove the need for well designed trials Meta-analysis is a statistical technique for pooling clinical trials of similar design that achieves higher statistical power for detecting differences between treatments and obtaining more precise estimates of outcome.