Quality of life measures in health care. I: Applications and issues in assessment.
BMJPublished 31 October 1992Open access
Ray Fitzpatrick, Astrid Fletcher, S M Gore, David R. Jones, D. J. Spiegelhalter, Dennis Cox
Citations699
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The instruments available and their application in screening programmes, audit, health care research, and clinical trials are reviewed; using the appropriate instrument is essential if outcome measures are to be valid and clinically meaningful.
Abstract
Many clinicians remain unsure of the relevance of measuring quality of life to their clinical practice. In health economics quality of life measures have become the standard means of assessing the results of health care interventions and, more controversially, the means of prioritising funding; but they have many other applications. This article--the first of three on measuring quality of life--reviews the instruments available and their application in screening programmes, audit, health care research, and clinical trials. Using the appropriate instrument is essential if outcome measures are to be valid and clinically meaningful.
Keywords
Economics, Econometrics and FinanceHealth Professions
Medical CareThe Sickness Impact Profile: Development and Final Revision of a Health Status Measure
4,655 Citations1981Marilyn Bergner, Ruth A. Bobbitt +2 more
The final development of the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP), a behaviorally based measure of health status, is presented and a technique for describing and assessing similarities and differences among groups was developed using profile and pattern analysis.
SpineA Study of the Natural History of Back Pain
3,380 Citations1983Martín Roland, Richard Morris
The development and validation of a questionnaire designed to measure selfrated disability due to back pain is described, which is short, simple, sensitive, and reliable.
JAMATHERAPEUTIC CRITERIA IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
2,883 Citations1949Otto Steinbrocker
This report summarizes recommendations for uniform therapeutic criteria in rheumatoid arthritis and highlights the varied language used in the body and conclusions of articles on therapy which did not lend themselves to any accurate appraisal.
Journal of Chronic DiseasesMeasuring change over time: Assessing the usefulness of evaluative instruments
1,895 Citations1987Gordon Guyatt, Stephen D. Walter +1 more
Responsiveness should join reliability and validity as necessary requirements for instruments designed primarily to measure change over time in psychometric measures.
JAMAFunctional status and well-being of patients with chronic conditions. Results from the Medical Outcomes Study
1,874 Citations1989Anita L. Stewart
Medical CareGeneric and Disease-Specific Measures in Assessing Health Status and Quality of Life
1,788 Citations1989Donald L. Patrick, Richard A. Deyo
Comparison studies are needed of the validity, reliability, and responsiveness of generic and disease-specific measures in the same population and in minority and age-specific groups.
ThoraxA measure of quality of life for clinical trials in chronic lung disease.
1,745 Citations1987Gordon Guyatt, L Berman +3 more
It has been shown that the questionnaire is precise, valid, and responsive and can therefore serve as a useful disease specific measure of quality of life for clinical trials.
JAMAFunctional Status and Well-being of Patients With Chronic Conditions
1,736 Citations1989Anita L. Stewart
For eight of nine common chronic medical conditions, patients with the condition showed markedly worse physical, role, and social functioning; mental health; health perceptions; and/or bodily pain compared with patients with no chronic conditions.
Journal of Chronic DiseasesMeasuring the quality of life of cancer patients
1,536 Citations1981Walter O. Spitzer, Annette J. Dobson +6 more
The aim has been to provide a new measure that can help physicians assess the relative benefits and risks of various treatments for serious illness and of supportive programs such as palliative care or hospice service.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Effects of Antihypertensive Therapy on the Quality of Life
1,343 Citations1986Sydney H. Croog, Sol Levine +6 more
It is shown that antihypertensive agents have different effects on the quality of life and that these can be meaningfully assessed with available psychosocial measures.
British Journal of CancerWho should measure quality of life, the doctor or the patient?
913 Citations1988ML Slevin, Hilary Plant +3 more
It is concluded that if a reliable and consistent method of measuring quality of life in cancer patients is required, it must come from the patients themselves and not from their doctors and nurses.
PubMedMeasuring health status: a new tool for clinicians and epidemiologists.
872 Citations1985Soiya M. Hunt, J McEwen +1 more
The Nottingham Health Profile is intended as a standardized tool for the survey of health problems in a population, but is equally valid and useful as a means of evaluating the outcome of medical and/or social interventions and as an adjunct to the clinical interview.
PubMedFunctional status and well-being of patients with chronic conditions. Results from the Medical Outcomes Study.
678 Citations1989Anita L. Stewart, Sheldon Greenfield +6 more
Recent results in cancer research/Recent Results in Cancer ResearchA Modular Approach to Quality-of-Life Assessment in Cancer Clinical Trials
417 Citations1988Neil K. Aaronson, Monika Bullinger +1 more
Following the lead of the WHO in defining health as complete physical, mental and social well-being, the scope of investigation has been extended to include assessment of a range of psychosocial variables that can be subsumed under the heading “quality of life.”
Arthritis & RheumatismThe arthritis impact measurement scales. further investigations of a health status measure
390 Citations1982Robert F. Meenan, Paul M. Gertman +2 more
The results confirmed the reliability and validity of the AIMS instrument and suggested that the instrument will prove useful as a tool to assess arthritis outcome in a wide variety of clinical settings.
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series A (Statistics in Society)Quality-of-Life Assessment: Can We Keep It Simple?
355 Citations1992D. R. Cox, Ray Fitzpatrick +4 more
The importance of general statistical principles of study design and analysis to quality-of-life assessment in clinical trials is emphasized and the use of simple weighting schemes supplemented by sensitivity analysis is suggested.
Measures of Need and Outcome for Primary Health Care
291 Citations1992David Wilkin, L Hallam +1 more
This work defines need and outcome, methods of measurement, and measures of functioning for mental illness and mental health, and multi-dimensional measures for disease - specific measures and social support are presented.
The LancetCOMPARISON OF HEALTH OUTCOMES AT A HEALTH MAINTENANCE ORGANISATION WITH THOSE OF FEE-FOR-SERVICE CARE
289 Citations1986JohnE. Ware, WilliamH. Rogers +7 more
To determine whether health outcomes in a health maintenance organisation (HMO) differed from those in the fee-for-service (FFS) system, 1673 individuals were randomly assigned to one HMO or to an FFS insurance plan in Seattle, Washington for 3 or 5 years.
PubMedThe functional status of patients. How can it be measured in physicians' offices?
271 Citations1990Eugene C. Nelson, Jeanne M. Landgraf +3 more
Journal of GerontologyQuality of Life in Chronic Diseases: Perceptions of Elderly Patients
244 Citations1988Robert A. Pearlman, Richard F. Uhlmann
It is suggested that quality of life in elderly outpatients with chronic disease is a multidimensional construct involving health, as well as social and other factors.
PubMedThe assessment and prediction of functional disability in rheumatoid arthritis.
234 Citations1991Frederick Wolfe, M A Cathey
Assessment of functional disability with the Stanford Health Assessment Questionnaire Functional Disability Index in 1,274 patients with rheumatoid arthritis followed longitudinally for up to 12 years found the rate of functional loss increased sharply after the first clinic visit.
Medical CareThe Functional Status of Patients
217 Citations1990Eugene C. Nelson, Jeanne M. Landgraf +3 more
It is concluded that the COOP Charts are practical, reliable, valid, sensitive to the effects of disease and useful for quickly measuring patient function.
PubMedToward clinical applications of health status measures: sensitivity of scales to clinically important changes.
202 Citations1984Richard A. Deyo, Thomas S. Inui
This feature of the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) in a group of patients with rheumatoid arthritis is studied, comparing it with more traditional measures of functional status (the American Rheumatism Association (ARA) functional classification and a patient self-rating scale).
Annals of Internal MedicineImproving Patient Function: A Randomized Trial of Functional Disability Screening
186 Citations1989Lisa V. Rubenstein, David R. Calkins +8 more
A more powerful intervention than a 2-hour educational session and the regular provision of functional status information is needed to help office-based internists improve patient outcomes.
Medical CareThe Measurement of Health Status in Clinical Practice
179 Citations1989Eugene C. Nelson, Donald M. Berwick
The authors analyze both the potential and the barriers to use of health assessment tools in practice and note the need for better scientific evidence of their clinical utility, as opposed to their information content.
Controlled Clinical TrialsQuality of life assessment in clinical trials: Methodologic issues
170 Citations1989Neil K. Aaronson
This article reviews a number of the central methodologic issues surrounding the development or selection of quality of life measures appropriate for use in clinical trials and focuses on research design and implementation issues in clinical trial-based quality oflife studies.
Medical CareMeasuring Health Changes Among Severely III Patients
164 Citations1990Andrew B. Bindman, Dennis Keane +1 more
Many patients who reported their health had become worse also recorded the lowest possible score on the MOS-20 at baseline, creating an instrument bias against documenting a decline in health among severely ill patients, the group in which it may be most important to detect such a change.
Statistics in MedicineAssessment of quality of life in clinical trials
162 Citations1991Martin Schumacher, Manfred Olschewski +1 more
An overview of developments in the assessment of quality of life (QOL) in clinical trials over the last decade from the viewpoint of clinical biostatistics is intended, with critical conclusions outlined and suggestions for further research given.
Archives of Internal MedicineMethotrexate in rheumatoid arthritis. Impact on quality of life assessed by traditional standard-item and individualized patient preference health status questionnaires
127 Citations1990Peter Tugwell
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyHealth status reports in the care of patients with rheumatoid arthritis
119 Citations1990Lewis E. Kazis, Leigh F. Callahan +2 more
The failure to demonstrate objective benefits of health status reports in this study may be due to physician unfamiliarity with health status scores, failure to link the report with an office visit, the relative stability of clinical status in the subjects over 1 year and the relatively short time-frame of the study.
PubMedMortality predictors among 263 patients with rheumatoid arthritis.
108 Citations1991Leigh Jp, Fries Jf
The results confirm studies suggesting that the HAQ disability index is a useful prognosticator of length of survival, and use univariate correlation coefficients, stepwise regression, and survival functions to identify a number of covariates that appear useful for predicting survival.
Medical CareUsing Health Status Measures in the Hospital Setting
106 Citations1992David Lansky, Juliet Butler +1 more
BMJ Quality & SafetyImportance of sensitivity to change as a criterion for selecting health status measures.
106 Citations1992Ray Fitzpatrick, Sue Ziébland +3 more
Selection of health status instruments for audit or evaluation may have a considerable impact on the pattern of results obtained, and the "responsiveness" of such scales should be as carefully examined as their reliability and acceptability when selecting outcome measures.
PubMedBenefits and obstacles of health status assessment in ambulatory settings. The clinician's point of view. The Dartmouth Primary Care COOP Project.
104 Citations1992John H. Wasson, Adam Keller +4 more
By following the steps outlined in this paper, the clinician should be able to overcome many obstacles for functional health status assessment in busy ambulatory settings.
Medical CareApplications of Health Status Assessment Measures in Clinical Practice
92 Citations1992Kathleen N Lohr
Medical CarePatient Versus Clinician Item Generation for Quality-of-Life Measures
69 Citations1987Jonathan Lomas, Laura Pickard +1 more
The study demonstrates that language-disabled adults can generate items for a quality-of-life measure (hence, this should be possible in almost any other disease group), and that clinician-generated items are not fully representative of patient values.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyRatings of the importance of quality of life variables: Therapeutic implications for patients with metastatic breast cancer
65 Citations1990Heather J. Sutherland, Gina Lockwood +1 more
The results emphasize the importance of including in clinical trials of therapy that are palliative in intent, endpoints that include those aspects of quality of life that are of greatest importance to patients.
Medical CareCase-Mix Groups for VA Hospital-Based Home Care
60 Citations1992Mary E. Smith, Carolyn Baker +10 more
The purpose of this study is to group hospital-based home care patients homogeneously by their characteristics with respect to cost of care to develop alternative case mix methods for management and reimbursement (allocation) purposes.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyAnalysis of quality of life data from a randomized, placebo-controlled heart-failure trial
57 Citations1989P.K. Tandon, Herb Stander +1 more
In a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, 3-months trial involving 111 congestive heart failure patients, one non-validated and three validated Quality of Life (QL) instruments were administered.
International Disability StudiesProblems in the assessment of outcome in a back pain clinic
50 Citations1987Ray M. Fitzpatrick, M. R. Bury +2 more
Patients' reports, both with regard to expectations and satisfaction, particularly emphasized the importance of communication in patients' evaluations of the rheumatological back pain clinic.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthThe epidemiology of indications.
44 Citations1991Stephen Frankel
As the dust clouds from the NHS reforms begin to clear, a large hole is becoming discernible where the epidemiology of indications might be, and the suggestion that patterns of provision should be guided by health needs assessments may have seemed an innocuous statement at the time of the introduction of the reforms.
Lara D. VeekenA COMPARISON OF MEASURES OF HEALTH STATUS IN RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
39 Citations1989Ray Fitzpatrick, Stanton Newman +2 more
Cross-sectional correlations were strongest between the health status measures (HAQ and FLP) and grip strength and the Ritchie articular index and overall the HAQ andFLP achieved similarly modest levels of sensitivity and specificity.
Lara D. VeekenA GENERIC HEALTH STATUS INSTRUMENT IN THE ASSESSMENT OF RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
31 Citations1992Ray Fitzpatrick, Sue Ziébland +3 more
Energy, pain, mobility and emotions scales of the NHP correlate significantly with other measures such as clinical assessments, matching scales ofThe AIMS and the Beck Depression Inventory, indicating satisfactory validity for the instrument with RA.
Family PracticeMeasurement of Health Status in Patients with Chronic Illness: Comparison of the Nottingham Health Profile and the General Health Questionnaire
28 Citations1990Crispin Jenkinson, RAY FTTZPATRICK
Evidence is provided that the NHP and GHQ may be used to assess the impact of illness upon sufferers' lives, not only in severely disabling disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, but in health problems such as migraine which have often been considered as relatively minor ailments.
BMJ Quality & SafetyPractical experiences in auditing patient outcomes.
21 Citations1992Martin Bardsley, J Coles
The progress made in this difficult area of outcome monitoring is described and issues of general interest concerning outcome monitoring are identified.
International Disability StudiesThe social dimension of health status measures in rheumatoid arthritis
18 Citations1991Ray Fitzpatrick, Sue Ziébland +3 more
It is argued that the generic NHP may be a valid instrument as an outcome measure in RA but the NHP and AIMS assess different aspects of social interaction, and care is needed in the selection of outcome measures to evaluate interventions.
Journal of Adolescent Health CareContraceptive use in the chronically Ill adolescent female. Part II
14 Citations1986Lawrence S. Neinstein, Barbara F. Katz
Contraceptive services for mentally ill women to be provided by specially trained individuals who are able to obtain informed consent, while taking into account the specific needs of the psychiatrically impaired individual is helpful.