Residential treatment and its alternatives: A review of the literature
Child & Youth Care ForumPublished 1 February 1997
Brady C. Bates, Dallas R. English, Sophia Kouidou-Giles
Citations125
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.86
SNIP0.88
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This review summarizes the literature for residential treatment, family preservation services, treatment foster care, and individualized services and evaluates characteristics of each model, methodological limitations of outcome studies, and treatment effectiveness with children.
Abstract
This review summarizes the literature for residential treatment, family preservation services, treatment foster care, and individualized services and evaluates characteristics of each model, methodological limitations of outcome studies, and treatment effectiveness with children. Although residential care is often viewed negatively, empirical evidence does not suggest differential levels of effectiveness compared to nonresidential alternatives. The results of some nonresidential outcome studies are promising, but efficacy claims should be viewed critically due to the absence of methodologically rigorous evaluations for both residential and nonresidential approaches. Future research should focus on establishing empirically grounded placement criteria, identifying what presenting problems are most amenable to each form of treatment, and maximizing the maintenance of treatment gains in the postdischarge environment.
Keywords
PsychologySocial Sciences
Autism and child psychopathology seriesHandbook of Clinical Child Psychology
402 Citations2023Johnny L. Matson
Partial table of contents: Child development, psychological assessments of children, and intervention strategies.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyThe Child Welfare Challenge: Policy, Practice, And Research
341 Citations2000James K. Whittaker
International Journal of the AddictionsEvaluation of the Effectiveness of Adolescent Drug Abuse Treatment, Assessment of Risks for Relapse, and Promising Approaches for Relapse Prevention
250 Citations1991Richard F. Catalano, J. David Hawkins +3 more
A review of controlled evaluations of adolescent and other drug abuse treatment programs concludes that some treatment is better than no treatment, but few comparisons of treatment method have consistently demonstrated the superiority of one method over another, and posttreatment relapse rates are high.
PubMedEnhanced services and stipends for foster parents: effects on retention rates and outcomes for children.
241 Citations1992Patricia Chamberlain, S Moreland +1 more
This study demonstrates the significant benefits to both foster parents and the children in their care of providing enhanced services and stipends to foster parents.
Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent PsychiatryInpatient Psychiatric Treatment of Children and Adolescents: A Review of Outcome Studies
221 Citations1990Steven I. Pfeiffer, STEPHEN C. STRZELECKI
All outcome studies of child and adolescent residential treatment and inpatient psychiatric hospitalization reported in the literature from 1975 to the present were examined and recommendations to guide future researchers are offered that will provide new insights into better understanding in patient psychiatric treatment.
American PsychologistMental health services for children: The state of the art.
215 Citations1989June M. Tuma
The development of a continuum of care that is coordinated across the mental health and non-mental-health systems that naturally occur in all children's lives has the potential to vastly improve mental health services to children, youth, and families.
Journal of Community PsychologyUsing a specialized foster care community treatment model for children and adolescents leaving the state mental hospital
172 Citations1991Patricia Chamberlain, John B. Reid
Results showed that the SFC model is a viable treatment option for severely emotionally disturbed children and adolescents, and that once placed outside of the hospital, SFC cases were slightly more successful at maintaining in their communities than were control cases.
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryOutcome research on residential treatment: Implications and suggested directions.
158 Citations1991John F. Curry
More powerful comparative research designs between, within, and across programs are examined, and recommendations are made for their use in future outcome studies in this area.
Keeping Families Together: The Homebuilders Model
116 Citations1991Jill Kinney, David Haapala +1 more
The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & ResearchThe role of individualized care in a service delivery system for children and adolescents with severely maladjusted behavior
115 Citations1990John D. Burchard, Richard T. Clarke
The principles of individualized care are described and the ecological, multilevel assessment process that coincides with the delivery of services are described, including the need for evaluation data with some suggested strategies for documenting effectiveness.
Children and Youth Services ReviewAssessing family preservation programs
114 Citations1992Peter H. Rossi
The evaluations reviewed do not provide definitive findings concerning effectiveness of family preservation strategies and neither support nor contradict the effectiveness offamily preservation strategies.
From Child Abuse to Permanency Planning
113 Citations2017Richard P. Barth, M. Karner Courtney +2 more
Social WorkAn Evaluation of Family Preservation Services: Fitting Agency Services to Family Needs
105 Citations1992Marianne Berry
Journal of Emotional and Behavioral DisordersImproving Adjustment Outcomes For Foster Children With Emotional And Behavioral Disorders
101 Citations1994Hewitt B. Clark, Mark E. Prange +4 more
PubMedTreatment foster care services: a research agenda for child welfare.
93 Citations1994Pamela Meadowcroft, Barbara Thomlison +1 more
Results from program evaluations and experimental research suggest that treatment foster care is an effective alternative to residential treatment for seriously troubled and troubling children.
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryPlacement of emotionally disturbed children in residential treatment: A review of placement criteria.
79 Citations1991Kathleen Wells
It is revealed that criteria for placement are inadequate and information on outcomes insufficient for guidance on the placement problem, and implications and recommendations for practice and research are delineated.
Social Service ReviewFamily-Centered, Home-Based Services in Child Protection: A Review of the Research
75 Citations1988Harvy Frankel
Journal of Child and Family StudiesWrapping community-based mental health services around children with a severe behavioral disorder: An evaluation of project wraparound
74 Citations1992Richard T. Clarke, Mark Schaefer +2 more
A longitudinal analysis of client and family adjustment data from Project Wraparound indicates that substantial change occurred on measures of the home environment and client adjustment in the home with no significant change in adjustment inThe school.
Social Service ReviewChild and Family Functioning after Intensive Family Preservation Services
62 Citations1993Kathleen Wells, Dale Whittington
Univariate and multivariate analyses revealed that at follow-up children and their families were functioning at a lower level than nonclinical samples, but their functioning improved between admission and discharge and did not decline between discharge and follow- up.
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryCritical issues for practice in residential treatment: The view from within.
60 Citations1991Richard W. Small, Kevin Kennedy +1 more
Child Abuse & NeglectIntensive family preservation services with abused and neglected children: An examination of group differences
58 Citations1993Howard Bath, David Haapala
Assessment of maltreatment group differences in a relatively large sample of families referred by Child Protective Service agencies found that children from neglectful families were almost twice as likely to be placed than children from abusive ones, with those from multiple maltreatment families being at highest risk.
Children and Youth Services ReviewParental involvement in children's residential treatment: From preplacement to aftercare
58 Citations1987Jeffrey M. Jenson, James K. Whittaker
Policy reforms and empirical evidence supporting family focused care for children have increased parental involvement in children's residential treatment and factors that inhibit parents from participating in children’s residential care are outlined.
Children and Youth Services ReviewSpecialized foster care and group home care: Similarities and differences in the characteristics of children in care
55 Citations1993Jill Duerr Berrick, Mark E. Courtney +1 more
A cross-sectional mailed survey was distributed to all group care and specialized foster care agencies in a large state to address topics related to children's characteristics, pointing to two groups of very difficult children, with unique mental health and health needs.
Journal of Emotional and Behavioral DisordersDevelopment And Evaluation Of Treatment Foster Care And Family-Centered Intensive Case Management In New York
55 Citations1994Mary E. Evans, Norín Dollard +4 more
The present article compares and contrasts the program elements of FCICM and the treatment foster care models, provides an overview of the research design and methods, describes the children and families served, and examines program implementation issues.
Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services ResearchIntegration of individualized mental health services into the system of care for children and adolescents
53 Citations1993John VanDenBerg
A viable option is “wrap-around” or “individualized” services which, when integrated into system of care services, can be more effective and less expensive.
Children and Youth Services ReviewThe assessment of imminence of risk of placement: Lessons from a family preservation program
49 Citations1991Marianne Berry
An analysis of the determination of imminent risk within one family preservation program finds that the conventional and accepted risk factors to be used in making a risk determination at intake are more accurate at predicting placement after leaving the program than in predicting who is judged to be at imminent risk at intake.
Children and Youth Services ReviewCharacteristics of youths referred to residential treatment: Implications for program design
48 Citations1993Kathleen Wells, Dale Whittington
Journal of Emotional and Behavioral DisordersThe Alternatives to Residential Treatment Study: Initial Findings
48 Citations1993Albert J. Duchnowski, Michael K. Johnson +3 more
Social Service ReviewResidential Treatment of Emotionally Disturbed Children: A Review of the Literature
47 Citations1972Anthony N. Maluccio, Wilma D. Marlow
Journal of Child and Family StudiesSatisfaction, involvement, and unconditional care: The perceptions of children and adolescents receiving wraparound services
47 Citations1994Lee Rosen, Timothy G. Heckman +2 more
It was found that both youths' sense of involvement and their perceptions that their care was unconditional were strongly associated with satisfaction with services, but neither satisfaction nor involvement were correlated with the severity of subjects' acting-out behaviors.
Children and Youth Services ReviewAre services to prevent foster care effective?
45 Citations1981Stephen Magura
Data from a new demonstration project in New Jersey illustrate various problems in providing and evaluating preventive services to families referred to protective service agencies, and a new direction focused on truly early intervention with children and families is proposed.
Journal of Clinical Child PsychologyFoster Family-based Treatment
45 Citations1985Robert P. Hawkins, Pamela Meadowcroft +2 more
Pressley Ridge Youth Development Extension (PRYDE) is a foster family-based treatment program for troubled and troubling children and adolescents that represents a movement away from treating youths in groups within institutions to treating them individually within the context of a normal family.
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryThe parent-therapist program: Alternate care for emotionally disturbed children.
43 Citations1978Julian S. Rubenstein, James A. Armentrout +2 more
Evaluation of the program indicates that outcome does not differ significantly from that of residential treatment, but that costs are markedly lower.
Journal of Clinical Child PsychologySpecial foster care: A history and rationale
42 Citations1981Brad Bryant
Social Work Research and AbstractsIntensive family preservation services research: Current status and future agenda
41 Citations1992Kathleen Wells, David E. Biegel
Children and Youth Services ReviewFactors associated with adaptation of youths discharged from residential treatment
39 Citations1991Kathleen Wells, Elizabeth Wyatt +1 more
Behavioral DisordersEcological Factors in Successful Residential Treatment
38 Citations1982W. W. Lewis
PubMedResearch priorities for residential group child care.
38 Citations1994James K. Whittaker, S I Pfeiffer
This brief paper selectively reviews the growing body of research on developmental psychopathology and its implications for both the development of group care programming and evaluation; summarizes the existing corpus of outcome research on residential group care; and details a number of suggestions for group child care research that have implications for the individual practitioner, the individual residential agency, and policy and service organizations.
Children and Youth Services ReviewChild age and outcome correlates in intensive family preservation services
36 Citations1992Howard Bath, Cheryl A. Richey +1 more
An examination of client variables associated with outcome revealed that child age was an important predictor of placement outcomes, with infants and older children being significantly more likely to be placed after treatment than 3 to 9 year-old children.
The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol AbuseEffects of Community-Based Group-Home Treatment Programs on Male Juvenile Offenders′ Use and Abuse of Drugs and Alcohol
31 Citations1985Curtis J. Braukmann, Martha M. Bedlington +5 more
Examination of the comparative effects of community-based, group-home, delinquency-treatment programs in Kansas on participants' self-report measures of drug and alcohol use and abuse, and of some prosocial behaviors indicated that youths participating in group homes using the broadly disseminated Teaching-Family approach had better during-treatment outcomes.
PubMedNotes on the history of adolescent inpatient and residential treatment.
29 Citations1990Zimmerman Dp
Journal of Abnormal Child PsychologyPrevention and treatment of juvenile problem behavior: A proposal for a socio-ecological approach
28 Citations1992Evert Scholte
A socio-ecological model representing the relation between emotional and behavioral problems of children and risk factors in the family, at school and in the peer group is proposed to provide possibilities for prevention and intervention.
Families in Society The Journal of Contemporary Social ServicesNew Directions for Mental Health Services for Families and Children
28 Citations1991Ira S. Lourie, Judith Katz‐Leavy
Inherent in these changes are expansion of the continuum of care to include new forms of intervention, the creation of new funding strategies, and a new role for parents.
Children and Youth Services ReviewImplementation issues
28 Citations1992John R. Schuerman, Tina L. Rzepnicki +2 more
Journal of Clinical Child PsychologySpecialized Foster Care as an Alternative Therapeutic Out-of-Home Placement Model
27 Citations1988Dianne B. Webb
American Journal of OrthopsychiatryMultiple indicators of success in residential youth care and treatment.
26 Citations1988James K. Whittaker, Edward J. Overstreet +3 more
This paper focuses on multiple indicators of success measured at multiple points of time in the treatment process, and considers factors associated with the successful community adjustment of troubled adolescents leaving residential treatment.
Residential Treatment for Children & YouthSubstance Abuse and Psychiatric Disorders
23 Citations1991Danilo E. Ponce, Helene S. Jo
The paper describes a barely perceptible, but nonetheless quite ominous trend in Residential Treatment Centers: The increasing incidence of patients with so-called "dual diagnosis" (i.e., those who have drug and substance abuse problems in addition to or concomitantly with customary psychiatric disorders).
Children and Youth Services ReviewSocial support in aftercare services for troubled youth
21 Citations1986Jeffrey M. Jenson, J. David Hawkins +1 more
The evidence shows that the development of supportive relationships and prosocial networks in a youth's community, school, and workplace and among parents and family members is important to success in community reentry.
Journal of Emotional and Behavioral DisordersTreatment Foster Care
20 Citations1994Kevin J. Moore, Patricia Chamberlain
Children and Youth Services ReviewPrior services used by youths referred to mental health facilities: A closer look
19 Citations1990Kathleen Wells, Dale Whittington
Journal of Emotional and Behavioral DisordersThe Use of Flexible Service Dollars in Rural Community-based Programs for Children with Serious Emotional Disturbance and Their Families
17 Citations1994Norín Dollard, Mary E. Evans +2 more
Child & Youth Care ForumAftercare service development for children in residential treatment
16 Citations1989Neil B. Guterman, Vanessa G. Hodges +2 more
This paper describes an empirically-based, concrete aftercare program that addresses concerns about effective aftercare services for children returning home from residential treatment.
Residential Treatment for Children & YouthAssessing the Post-Residential Functioning of Latency-Aged Conduct Disordered Children
11 Citations1994David M. Day, Anita Pal +1 more
Child & Youth ServicesChapter 3: Treating Emotionally Disturbed Children and Adolescents in Foster Homes
11 Citations1989Pamela Meadowcroft
Treatment foster care is a relatively new form of service to emotionally disturbed children and adolescents treating only one or two children within the homes of carefully selected substitute families with low caseloads.
Children and Youth Services ReviewThe little turtle's progress: A reconsideration of the short versus long-term residential treatment controversy
9 Citations1993D. Patrick Zimmerman
Social CaseworkIntensive Aftercare Services for Children
8 Citations1989Vanessa G. Hodges, Neil B. Guterman +2 more
The authors describe an intensive aftercare program for children in residential treatment that includes parent training, social support linkages, and school placement.
Behavioral DisordersProject Aftercare: Followup to Residential Treatment
7 Citations1978Elaine H. Harding, James Bellew +1 more
Issues in Residential and Inpatient Treatment
4 Citations1989Robert D. Lyman, Steven Prentice‐Dunn +2 more
Because of the disruptive effects of removing children from their homes for treatment and the dangers of institutionalization and stigmatization that follow, it is important that mental health practitioners consider all aspects of the clinical situation before making such a treatment decision.
Child & Youth ServicesChapter 5: Family Preservation in Foster Care:
3 Citations1989Peter W. Forsythe
Treatment foster care is described in repect to the permanency continuum, particularly the importance of family connectedness for children placed out of home.
Child & Youth ServicesChapter 12: Doing It in Public:
2 Citations1989Brad Bryant, Fred Simmens +1 more
Child & Youth ServicesChapter 17: The Community as an Advocate for Youth:
1 Citations1989Peter Kelley, James B. Carruth
Child & Youth ServicesChapter 19: The New Brunswick Therapeutic Home Program
1 Citations1989Reuben Orenstein
A Canadian province-wide specialist fostering scheme is described in terms of the children served, homes licensed, program services provided, and implementation difficulties.
Child & Youth ServicesChapter 18: Providing Competence Building and Normalizing Environments:
1 Citations1989Joe Hudson, Burt Galaway +1 more
Key elements of the HSA service program include contracting, networking, mobilization of community resources, foster parent support systems, and respite care.