Randomized controlled trial of education and feedback for implementation of guidelines for acute low back pain
Journal of General Internal MedicinePublished 1 October 2003Open access
Joel M. Schectman, W. Scott Schroth, Dante Verme, John D. Voss
Citations138
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.99
SNIP1.71
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Implementation of an education and feedback-supported acute low back pain care guideline for primary care clinicians was associated with an increase in guideline-consistent behavior and Implementation barriers could limit the utility of this approach in usual care settings.
Abstract
Implementation of an education and feedback-supported acute low back pain care guideline for primary care clinicians was associated with an increase in guideline-consistent behavior. Patient education materials did not enhance guideline effectiveness. Implementation barriers could limit the utility of this approach in usual care settings.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
SpineA Study of the Natural History of Back Pain
3,380 Citations1983Martín Roland, Richard Morris
The development and validation of a questionnaire designed to measure selfrated disability due to back pain is described, which is short, simple, sensitive, and reliable.
New England Journal of MedicineDo Practice Guidelines Guide Practice?
1,245 Citations1989Jonathan Lomas, Geoffrey M. Anderson +4 more
It is concluded that guidelines for practice may predispose physicians to consider changing their behavior, but that unless there are other incentives or the removal of disincentives, guidelines may be unlikely to effect rapid change in actual practice.
PubMedTranslating guidelines into practice. A systematic review of theoretic concepts, practical experience and research evidence in the adoption of clinical practice guidelines.
1,227 Citations1997Dave A. Davis, Anne Taylor‐Vaisey
The evidence shows serious deficiencies in the adoption of CPGs in practice and future implementation strategies must overcome this failure through an understanding of the forces and variables influencing practice and through the use of methods that are practice- and community-based rather than didactic.
JAMAPrinciples of Educational Outreach ('Academic Detailing') to Improve Clinical Decision Making
1,041 Citations1990Stephen B. Soumerai
Using the theory and practice of methods to improve physicians' clinical decision making to enhance the quality and cost-effectiveness of care and to reduce inappropriate prescribing as well as unnecessary health care expenditures are shown.
Orthopedic Clinics of North AmericaAn Overview of the Incidences and Costs of Low Back Pain
919 Citations1991John W. Frymoyer, William L. Cats‐Baril
The future challenge, if costs are to be controlled, appears to lie squarely with prevention and optimum management of disability, rather than perpetrating a myth that low back pain is a serious health disorder.
SpinePhysician Office Visits for Low Back Pain
889 Citations1995L G Hart, Richard A. Deyo +1 more
The frequency of office visits for low back pain, the content of ambulatory care, and how these vary by physician specialty are characterized and visit, referral, and management patterns among specialties providing the most care are described.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Treatment of Acute Low Back Pain — Bed Rest, Exercises, or Ordinary Activity?
617 Citations1995Antti Malmivaara, Unto Häkkinen +9 more
Among patients with acute low back pain, continuing ordinary activities within the limits permitted by the pain leads to more rapid recovery than either bed rest or back-mobilizing exercises.
New England Journal of MedicineA Comparison of Physical Therapy, Chiropractic Manipulation, and Provision of an Educational Booklet for the Treatment of Patients with Low Back Pain
616 Citations1998Daniel C. Cherkin, Richard A. Deyo +3 more
For patients with low back pain, the McKenzie method of physical therapy and chiropractic manipulation had similar effects and costs, and patients receiving these treatments had only marginally better outcomes than those receiving the minimal intervention of an educational booklet.
JAMAOpinion leaders vs audit and feedback to implement practice guidelines. Delivery after previous cesarean section
580 Citations1991J Lomas
New England Journal of MedicineThe Outcomes and Costs of Care for Acute Low Back Pain among Patients Seen by Primary Care Practitioners, Chiropractors, and Orthopedic Surgeons
567 Citations1995Timothy S. Carey, Joanne M. Garrett +4 more
The times to functional recovery, return to work, and complete recovery from low back pain were similar among patients seen by all six groups of practitioners, but there were marked differences in the use of health care services.
SpinePhysician Views About Treating Low Back Pain
515 Citations1995Daniel C. Cherkin, Richard A. Deyo +2 more
A lack of consensus among physicians about treatment efficacy for patients with low back pain could be attributable to the absence of clear evidencebsed clinical guidelines, ignorance or rejection of existing scientific evidence, excessive commitment to a particular mode of therapy, or a tendency to discount the efficacy of competing treatments.
JAMAEffect of Local Medical Opinion Leaders on Quality of Care for Acute Myocardial Infarction
480 Citations1998Stephen B. Soumerai, Thomas J. McLaughlin +10 more
Working with opinion leaders and providing performance feedback can accelerate adoption of some beneficial AMI therapies (eg, aspirin, beta-blockers), andSecular changes in knowledge and hospital protocols may extinguish outdated practices.
JAMAOpinion Leaders vs Audit and Feedback to Implement Practice Guidelines
466 Citations1991Jonathan Lomas
After 24 months the trial of labor and vaginal birth rates in the audit and feedback group were no different from those in the control group, but rates were 46% and 85% higher, respectively, among physicians educated by an opinion leader.
Annals of Internal MedicineInternists' Attitudes about Clinical Practice Guidelines
445 Citations1994Sean Tunis, Robert S. A. Hayward +5 more
A national survey of a random sample of American College of Physicians (ACP) members to assess ACP members' familiarity with, confidence in, and attitudes about guidelines issued by ACP and other organizations and members' perceptions of the effect of ACp and other guidelines on their practices.
JAMAEffects of the National Institutes of Health Consensus Development Program on Physician Practice
410 Citations1987Jacqueline Kosecoff
It was concluded that the consensus development conference is an important educational tool whose effects might be enhanced by focusing on areas of practice that need improvement and by encouraging follow-up programs at the state and local level.
Journal of the American Medical Informatics AssociationComputer-based Guideline Implementation Systems: A Systematic Review of Functionality and Effectiveness
336 Citations1999Richard N. Shiffman, Yischon Liaw +2 more
The functionality provided by recent computer-based guideline implementation systems and their effectiveness are analyzed to characterize the effectiveness of the systems.
PubMedPhysician utilization. The state of research about physicians' practice patterns.
301 Citations1985John M. Eisenberg
PainBack pain in primary care: predictors of high health-care costs
296 Citations1996Charles C. Engel, Michael Von Korff +1 more
Factors predicting subsequent high costs suggest behavioral interventions targeting dysfunction, pain persistence, and depression may reduce health‐care utilization and prevent accumulation of high health-care costs among primary‐care back pain patients.
American Journal of Public HealthCharacteristics of physician visits for back symptoms: a national perspective.
294 Citations1983Beulah K. Cypress
Data from the National Ambulatory Medical Care Surveys of 1977 and 1978 were examined using the sex of the patient and the physician's degree (MD or DO) as control variables, and typical encounter characteristics as dependent variables to provide insight into the scope of the problem.
Annals of Internal MedicineHerniated Lumbar Intervertebral Disk
293 Citations1990Richard A. Deyo, John D. Loeser +1 more
Except for patients with the cauda equina syndrome, surgery is generally appropriate only when there is a combination of definite disk herniation shown by imaging, a corresponding syndrome of sciatic pain, a corresponds neurologic deficit, and a failure to respond to 6 weeks of conservative therapy.
JAMAConservative Therapy for Low Back Pain
278 Citations1983Richard A. Deyo
Conservative therapies for low back pain entail expense, work loss, and risk of side effects, so valid trials supporting use of corsets, bed rest, transcutaneous nerve stimulation, and conventional traction were not found.
SpineComparative Validity of the Sickness Impact Profile and Shorter Scales for Functional Assessment in Low-Back Pain
236 Citations1986Richard A. Deyo
The modified Roland Scale appeared to have reliability, validity, and sensitivity that were at least as good as the overall SIP or its major subscales, although the Roland Scale did not measure psychosocial function well.
PubMedOpinion leaders vs audit and feedback to implement practice guidelines. Delivery after previous cesarean section.
226 Citations1991J Lomas, M Enkin +4 more
JAMAUse of Laboratory Tests and Pharmaceuticals
192 Citations1973Steven A. Schroeder
Variation in costs of laboratory and drug use was audited among 33 faculty internists caring for a homogeneous population at a university clinic and Laboratory and drug costs per physician were significantly correlated.
SpineAcute Low-Back Pain
188 Citations1980Sam W. Wiesel, John M. Cuckler +4 more
The results showed that bedrest, as compared with ambulation, will decrease the amount of time lost from work by 50% and analgesic medication, when added to bedrest in the treatment of lumbago, does not provide an advantage over bedrest alone.
SpineSafety, Efficacy, and Cost Effectiveness of Evidence-Based Guidelines for the Management of Acute Low Back Pain in Primary Care
186 Citations2001Brian McGuirk, Wade King +3 more
The Joint Commission Journal on Quality ImprovementA Randomized Controlled Trial of CQI Teams and Academic Detailing: Can They Alter Compliance with Guidelines?
183 Citations1998Harold I. Goldberg, Edward H. Wagner +7 more
The AD techniques and the CQI teams evaluated were generally ineffective in improving guideline compliance and clinical outcomes regarding the primary care of hypertension and depression.
Annals of Internal MedicinePractice Guidelines and Reminders to Reduce Duration of Hospital Stay for Patients with Chest Pain: An Interventional Trial
177 Citations1994Scott Weingarten, Mary S. Riedinger +5 more
The benefits, risks, and costs of implementing a practice guideline promoting a 2-day hospital stay for patients with chest pain who were considered to be at low risk for complications and in whom the diagnosis of acute myocardial infarction was dismissed are examined.
Arthritis & RheumatismPhysician Variation in Diagnostic Testing for Low Back Pain. Who You See Is What You Get
172 Citations1994Daniel C. Cherkin, Richard A. Deyo +2 more
There is little consensus, either within or among specialties, on the use of diagnostic tests for patients with back pain, and the diagnostic evaluation depends heavily on the individual physician and his or her specialty, and not just the patient's symptoms and findings.
Journal of Bone and Joint SurgeryThe impact of musculoskeletal disorders on the population of the United States.
156 Citations1979Jennifer L. Kelsey, AR White +2 more
The pertinent data is collected to determine the incidence, effect on the quality of life, and associated costs ofculoskeletal disorders in the United States.
SpineEducational and Behavioral Interventions for Back Pain in Primary Care
138 Citations1996Judith A. Turner
It may be useful to incorporate cognitive‐behavioral interventions in primary care settings, but additional research is needed to evaluate their efficacy in improving specific outcomes.
Annals of Internal MedicineStepped Care for Back Pain: Activating Approaches for Primary Care
137 Citations2001Michael Von Korff, James C. Moore
A stepped-care approach to the activation of patients with back pain who are seen in primary care settings is intended to complement medical management and is concluded that when physicians avoid prescribing bed rest and advise patients to stay active and to continue normal activities, patients return to work faster and have reduced disability.
SpinePitfalls of Patient Education
136 Citations1996Daniel C. Cherkin, Richard A. Deyo +3 more
These findings challenge the value of purely educational approaches in reducing functional impact or health care use related to back pain and also challenge thevalue of fitness exercise in the most acute phase of back pain.
Annals of Internal MedicineEffects of Practice Style in Managing Back Pain
130 Citations1994Michael Von Korff, William Barlow +2 more
An approach to back pain management that places greater emphasis on self-care than on medical cure may encourage patients to experiment with various approaches to managing back pain on their own, and increase the likelihood that patients learn to manage back pain without ongoing or recurrent medical attention.
Annals of Internal MedicineFailure of Information as an Intervention to Modify Clinical Management: A Time-Series Trial in Patients with Acute Chest Pain
124 Citations1995Thomas H. Lee, Steven D. Pearson +6 more
This intervention provided information and recommendations to clinicians in the emergency department and hospital without person-to-person contact to improve the efficiency of care for patients with acute chest pain.
Journal of General Internal MedicineLumbar spine films in primary care
122 Citations1986Richard A. Deyo, Andrew K. Diehl
Archives of Internal MedicineReducing Roentgenography Use
118 Citations1987Richard A. Deyo
Eliminating or delaying spine films need not cause anxiety, dissatisfaction, or dysfunction, and this strategy may modify future expectations of roentgenography use and reduce health care costs.
SpineEvaluation of a Physician Education Intervention to Improve Primary Care for Low-Back Pain II
114 Citations1991Dan Cherkin, Richard A. Deyo +1 more
Despite its apparent benefit to physicians, the intervention did not result in significant improvements in any patient outcomes, even for the subset of patients whose physicians had perceived the greatest benefit.
Annals of Internal MedicinePatterns of Ordering Diagnostic Tests for Patients with Acute Low Back Pain
107 Citations1996Timothy S. Carey, Joanne Garrett +1 more
The North Carolina Back Pain Project examined specialty-specific differences in treatment patterns and outcomes among the main types of practitioners who care for acute back pain: primary care physicians, chiropractors, orthopedic surgeons, and practitioners in group-model health maintenance organizations.
JAMAFeedback Reduces Test Use in a Health Maintenance Organization
106 Citations1986Donald M. Berwick
Overall use fell by 14.2% in a 16-week period during which physicians received confidential feedback on their individual rates of use compared with peers (cost feedback), and similar feedback on rates of abnormal test results (yield feedback) and a program of test-specific education failed to show a consistent effect.
Journal of General Internal MedicineReasons for repeated medical visits among patients with chronic back pain
105 Citations1998Carol McPhillips-Tangum, Daniel C. Cherkin +2 more
Patients with chronic back pain report many unmet needs and expectations and overall satisfaction might be improved if clinicians elicit patients’ views of underlying causes and their expectations from office visits.
JAMAUse of Lumbar Radiographs for the Early Diagnosis of Low Back Pain
105 Citations1997María E. Suarez‐Almazor
The implementation of the AHCPR guidelines for the initial use of radiographs in patients with low back pain may increase utilization and economic costs and a more restricted and cost-efficient set of guidelines should be proposed.
Archives of Internal MedicineRoentgenograms in Primary Care Patients With Acute Low Back Pain
104 Citations1982Matthew H. Liang
The risks and costs of obtaining lumbar roentgenograms at the initial visit in patients with acute low back pain do not seem to justify the relatively small associated benefit.
Journal of General Internal MedicinePrimary care physicians’ use of lumbar spine imaging tests
86 Citations1997Donald K. Freeborn, Diana Shye +3 more
Clinical practice guidelines and practice pattern feedback fall to achieve their goals when features of the practice setting and patient expetations and behavior are not identified and addressed.
BMJGeneral practitioners' management of acute back pain: a survey of reported practice compared with clinical guidelines
85 Citations1996Paul Little, Lisa Smith +4 more
The study shows that management of back pain by general practitioners does not match the guidelines, in that most do not routinely perform some recommended examinations and several do not give advice about exercise or everyday activities.
Archives of Internal MedicinePatients' Role in the Use of Radiology Testing for Common Office Practice Complaints
79 Citations2001Ira B. Wilson, Kim Dukes +3 more
Patients' perceived need for radiological studies was significantly associated with use of those services for outpatients with respiratory problems and low back pain, and the findings suggest that patients communicate their wishes to physicians, either directly or indirectly, regarding services they think are necessary.
Archives of Internal MedicineEnhancing Physician Adoption of Practice Guidelines
77 Citations1995Jurgis Karuza
A case is made for the small-group consensus process as an effective utilization-focused dissemination method based on group dynamics and sensitive to local practice contexts in facilitating adoption of guidelines by physicians in group practices.
SpineNo Clinical Effect of Back Schools in an HMO A Randomized Prospective Trial
74 Citations1989Donald M. Berwick, Simon H. Budman +1 more
Back school instructions given in a single 4-hour session had no measurable impact on the comfort or functional status of the majority of patients with new onset back pain in this HMO.
Journal of General Internal MedicineUtilization of medical services for the treatment of acute low back pain
68 Citations1992W. Scott Schroth, Joel M. Schectman +2 more
It is necessary to determine whether underutilization of plain lumbar radiography adversely affects diagnostic accuracy and whether over utilization of other services improves important clinical outcomes, given the generally benign natural history of this condition.
SpinePatients’ Views on Importance and Usefulness of Plain Radiography for Low Back Pain
64 Citations2001Ansgar Espeland, Anders Bærheim +3 more
The finding that inappropriately referred patients tended to rate their radiography referral as more important than appropriately referred patients indicates that the patient’s view may be a substantial barrier to appropriate use of radiography.
Human Rights Documents onlinePutting prevention into practice
62 Citations2018R.W. Elford, P. A. Jennett +3 more
A practical example of helping family practitioners develop a "sustaining office system in prevention" that minimizes barriers, focuses energy and integrates clinical prevention into office routines is reported on.
International Journal for Quality in Health CareUnderstanding physicians' imaging test use in low back pain care: the role of focus groups
57 Citations1998Diana Shye, Donald K. Freeborn +2 more
The findings suggest that gaining information from focus groups prior to designing physician behavior change interventions may aid the design of more effective interventions.
Journal of Clinical OncologyEffects of patient management guidelines on physician practice patterns: the Community Hospital Oncology Program experience.
53 Citations1987Leslie G. Ford, Carrie P. Hunter +3 more
The Community Hospital Oncology Program (CHOP), funded under contracts by the National Cancer Institute from 1981 to 1984, was designed to be a model for delivery of the most up-to-date cancer care in the community setting and there was the potential for PMGs to have a strong effect on physician practice patterns.
The Joint Commission Journal on Quality ImprovementA Model for Practice Guideline Adaptation and Implementation: Empowerment of the Physician
47 Citations1995Christopher G. Wise, John E. Billi
The Medical Center model of practice guideline adaptation and implementation uses local clinical leaders to evaluate nationally endorsed guidelines, adapt those guidelines for use in the local setting, work with support staff to develop and apply methods for guideline implementation, and assist the evaluation of clinical practice and outcomes data.
International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health CareStrategies for Reducing Medical Costs by Changing Physicians' Behavior: <i>Efficacy and Impact on Quality of Care</i>
47 Citations1987Steven A. Schroeder
The role of physicians in generating medical costs and ways of changing physicians' behavior so as to reduce those costs and how cost reductions affect the quality of care are studied.
Academic MedicineEffect of medical record audit and feedback on residentsʼ compliance with preventive health care guidelines
46 Citations1998Eric S. Holmboe, Richard E. Scranton +2 more
An intensive medical record audit with individualized feedback can produce exceptionally high levels of compliance with preventive care practices among internal medicine residents, and the improved compliance is generalizable to other health care measures not directly targeted for audit.
SpineEvaluation of a Physician Education Intervention to Improve Primary Care for Low-Back Pain I
42 Citations1991Dan Cherkin, Richard A. Deyo +3 more
The intervention had a similar impact on health maintenance organization and fee-for-service physicians and had little impact on the prevalence of negative feelings about patients with back pain or frustration with patients who wanted their doctor to “fix” their problem.
Journal of Management in MedicineBeyond guidelines: promoting clinical change in the real world
36 Citations1996Rosalind Eve, Ian Golton +3 more
Argues that guidelines, and other forms of intervention to change clinical practice in an evidence-based direction, will succeed only to the extent that they engage actively with the real world of clinical decision making.
Annals of Emergency MedicineFailure of a Chest Pain Clinical Policy to Modify Physician Evaluation and Management
34 Citations1995Lawrence M. Lewis, Laura Lasater +1 more
It is concluded that the dissemination of the ACEP chest pain clinical policy has not significantly modified the behavior of metropolitan area emergency physicians regarding the evaluation and management of patients who present to the ED with a chief complaint of nontraumatic chest pain.
PainPrediction of physician visits and prescription medicine use for back pain
25 Citations1999Kathleen Saunders, Michael Von Korff +2 more
Findings that a subset of items predicted physician visits and prescriptions medication fills, and was sensitive to change following a self-care intervention, suggest avenues for improving measurement of self-Care orientation.
Southern Medical JournalLow Back Pain and X-ray Films of the Lumbar Spine
21 Citations1986Daniel M. Kaplan, Mark Knapp +3 more
Patients with x-ray evidence of DJD were three times more likely than those with normal films to receive nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs other than aspirin, and patients given a “diagnostic label” ofDJD were more likely to express satisfaction with medical care and less likely to seek care elsewhere.
PubMedTrends in diagnostic testing following a national guideline for evaluation of dyspepsia.
17 Citations1996Lisa M. Schwartz, Steven Woloshin +1 more
American Journal of Medical QualityThe Impact of Climcal Guidelines On Practice Patterns: Doing More versus Doing Less
14 Citations1998Caryl E. Carpenter, Nelda E. Johnson +1 more
The findings suggest that older patients may be treated less aggressively than others and that physicians who are the most knowledgeable about guidelines may feel the most qualified to override the guidelines when they believe they do not apply.
Archives of Internal MedicineTrends in Diagnostic Testing Following a National Guideline for Evaluation of Dyspepsia
12 Citations1996Lisa M. Schwartz
The slow decline in UGI utilization suggests that, at best, the guideline had limited impact on clinical practice, and alternative approaches to change clinical practice will need to be found.
European Journal of RadiologyGeneral practitioners’ willingness to request plain lumbar spine radiographic examinations
9 Citations2001Olli‐Pekka Ryynänen, Jukka Lehtovirta +2 more
General practitioners commonly use plain lumbar spine radiographic examinations, despite its limited value in the diagnosis of low back pain, and further consensus and medical education is needed to clarify the indications for plainLumbar radiographic examination.