Importance of experimenter-blind procedure in neurotoxicology
Neurotoxicology and TeratologyPublished 1 January 1993
Vernon A. Benignus
Citations24
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.68
SNIP0.70
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The importance of having the investigator blind to the experimental condition of a human subject was demonstrated using meta analysis of 43 reports of the effects of carbon monoxide (CO) on behavior, which showed that 75% of single-blind studies found significant CO effects.
Abstract
The importance of having the investigator blind to the experimental condition of a human subject was demonstrated using meta analysis of 43 reports of the effects of carbon monoxide (CO) on behavior. It was shown that 75% of single-blind studies found significant CO effects as opposed to only 26% of double-blind studies (difference was significant, p < 0.005). It was also not possible to show that the difference could have been due to different CO exposure levels, different statistical practices, or different study group sizes. The failure to follow double-blind procedure has been partly responsible for disagreement about the effects of CO reported in the literature. Investigator blinding is also important in laboratory animal research.
Keywords
Immunology and MicrobiologyMedicine
Archives of Internal MedicineExperimenter Effects in Behavioral Research.
1,207 Citations1967James L. Titchener
"Clever Hans," the mathematical horse owned by an apparently ingenuous German schoolmaster in the early 1900's, could add, subtract, multiply, divide, read, spell, and solve problems of musical harmony, communicating his answers by tapping his foot.
Electroencephalography and Clinical NeurophysiologyMultidisciplinary perspectives in event-related brain potential research
524 Citations1980John R. Hughes
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalExperimental Human Exposure to Carbon Monoxide
170 Citations1970Richard D. Stewart, Jack E. Peterson +4 more
American Journal of Public Health and the Nations HealthBehavioral impairment associated with small doses of carbon monoxide.
168 Citations1967Rodney R. Beard, George A. Wertheim
18 young men were subjected to tone-length discrimination tests while in a room where CO was or was not present and rats were exposed to CO and studied with operant behavior schedules of reinforcement.
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalEffects of Mild Carbon Monoxide Intoxication
145 Citations1963John H. Schulte
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalCarbon Monoxide and Human Vigilance
62 Citations1971Steven M. Horvath, Thomas E. Dahms +1 more
Results showed that vigilance was impaired by breathing 111 ppm CO which raised the average COHb level to 6.6.% and heart rates and minute ventilatory volumes were not affected.
PubMedRecommendations for appropriate statistical practice in toxicologic experiments.
62 Citations1984Muller Ke, Barton Cn +1 more
The problem centers on the antagonistic needs to discover toxic effects and avoid false indictments of harmless compounds andropriate statistical practice in toxicologic research is reviewed.
PubMedA comparative study of the effects of carbon monoxide and methylene chloride on human performance.
59 Citations1980Vernon Putz, BL Johnson +1 more
The conclusion was that carbon monoxide, the main metabolite of methylene chloride, was responsible for the observed performance decrements.
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalCarbon Monoxide and Driving Skills
53 Citations1973G. R. Wright, Philip Randell +1 more
There is a need to revise the permitted eight-hour industrial CO exposure level of 50 ppm because the CO-exposed group showed a highly significant deficit in “careful driving” skills and a statistically insignificant facilitation of emergency-type movements.
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalLow Level Exposure to Carbon Monoxide and Driving Performance
46 Citations1973Ross A. McFarland
The overall pattern of results indicates that a 6%COHb level had no effect on driving ability, and that COHb levels of 11 % and 17% did not appear to seriously affect the ability to drive motor vehicles, as measured by the tests administered in this study.
American Journal of Public HealthClinical Implications of Air Pollution Research
46 Citations1976Emanuel Landau
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalEffect of Carbon Monoxide on Time Perception
41 Citations1973Richard D. Stewart, Paul E. Newton +2 more
Exposure to carbon monoxide at concentrations of < 2, 50, 100, 200, and, 500 ppm for periods up to five hours produced no impairment in the ability of the subjects to perform the Beard-Wertheim time discrimination test, to estimate 10- or 30-second intervals, or to performs the Marquette time estimation test.
PubMedInteractive effects of physical work and carbon monoxide on cognitive task performance.
36 Citations1988Bunnell De, Horvath Sm
Performance on the second of two sequentially presented Stroop interference tasks (using identical stimuli but with instructions reversed) was impaired with increasing HbCO level, suggesting a reduced ability to adapt to a new response set.
Neurotoxicology and TeratologyEffect of low level carbon monoxide on compensatory tracking and event monitoring
26 Citations1987Vernon A. Benignus
Experiments by Putz et al. concerning the effect of carbon monoxide (CO) exposure on compensatory tracking and monitoring in healthy young men were replicated and no statistically significant effect of COHb in monitoring behavior was found.
Neurotoxicology and TeratologyCarbon monoxide exposure and human visual detection thresholds
25 Citations1989H. Kenneth Hudnell, Vernon A. Benignus
The results indicated that visual function in healthy, young-adult males was not affected by a COHb level of about 17% which was maintained for over 2 hours, and sensitivity was monitored throughout the course of dark adaptation by measuring luminance thresholds.
Toxicology and Applied PharmacologyLow level carbon monoxide exposure and human psychomotor performance
24 Citations1971Robert D. O’Donnell, Peter J. Mikulka +2 more
The present data do not support the hypothesis that low level carbon monoxide exposure of humans results in performance decrement, and additional investigation is required to define the lower limit and extent of such exposure and to resolve conflicting views on this issue.
Neurotoxicology and TeratologyThe effects of low-level carbon monoxide exposure upon evoked cortical potentials in young and elderly men
19 Citations1988Thomas J. Harbin, Vernon A. Benignus +2 more
Results indicated that acute, low-level CO exposure is probably not neurotoxic, in normal, healthy men, and greater absorption of CO by young than by elderly men.
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalBrake Reaction Time — Effects of Age, Sex, and Carbon Monoxide
19 Citations1978G. R. Wright, Roy J. Shephard
Simulated braking responses have been tested in relation to blood carboxyhemoglobin (HbCO) levels and average response times and the rate of aging of the braking response were very similar in smokers and in nonsmokers.
PubMedDark adaptation of the eye during carbon monoxide exposure in smokers and nonsmokers.
18 Citations1988W. Von Restorff, S Hebisch
Dark adaptation time was longer and light sensitivity of the dark adapted eye was reduced in smokers as compared to nonsmokers at comparable levels of both inspired CO and HbCO, indicating chronic poisoning with CO, stemming from cigarette smoking.
Clinical ScienceCarbon Monoxide, Tissue Hypoxia, and Sensory Psychomotor Response in Hypoxaemic Subjects
18 Citations1972Janine M. Ramsey
It is concluded that COHb concentrations of 5% may adversely affect reaction time to visual stimuli and that patients with emphysema are less susceptible to accumulation ofCOHb and decrease in venous oxygen content than normal subjects or patients with anaemia.
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalEffects of Low Levels of Carbon Monoxide on Visions of Smokers and Nonsmokers
18 Citations1979S. M. Luria, Christine L. McKay
The scotopic sensitivity, reaction time, eye movements, and visually evoked cortical potentials of 12 nonsmokers and 6 smokers were measured during the course of 3 hr of exposure both to air and to 200 ppm CO in air.
American Industrial Hygiene Association JournalEffects of Single Exposures of Carbon Monoxide on Sensory and Psychomotor Response
18 Citations1973James M. Ramsey
Twenty young, healthy male subjects exposed to a single exposure of 650 ppm carbon monoxide for 45 minutes increased their mean carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) by 7.61%.
PubMedModerate carbon monoxide exposure during sleep: neuro- and psychophysiological effects in young and elderly people.
16 Citations1983E. Groll-Knapp, M. Haider +4 more
The general hypothesis of more pronounced CO-susceptibility of elderly people was not supported in this study and some CO-related AEP-changes within different sleep-stages, namely shorter latencies in elderly Ss and higher amplitudes in young Ss, approached significance.
Neurotoxicology and TeratologyCompensatory tracking in humans with elevated carboxyhemoglobin
15 Citations1990Vernon A. Benignus, Keith E. Muller +3 more
Even at the highest dose, the increase in tracking error was small and the increased mean error score due to rapid formation was virtually the same as that due to slow formation.
Journal of Experimental PsychologyThe effects of carbon monoxide on three types of performance at simulated altitudes of 10,000 and 15,000 feet.
14 Citations1946E Vollmer, Barry G. King +2 more
PubMedEffect of gradually increasing carboxyhaemoglobin saturation on visual perception and psychomotor performance of smoking and nonsmoking subjects.
14 Citations1977A Seppänen, Häkkinen +1 more
The effect of gradually increasing COHb saturation on human visuoperceptual and psychomotor performance was studied in nonsmokers and smokers and visual perception measured with critical flicker frequency was sensitive to CO.
PubMedCarbon monoxide and human time discrimination: failure to replicate Beard-Wertheim experiments.
11 Citations1979Otto Da, Benigus Va +1 more
The bulk of evidence does not indicate any adverse effect of low level CO exposure on time perception in healthy young adults.
Proceedings of the Royal Society of MedicineThe Significance of Exposure to Small Concentrations of Carbon Monoxide
11 Citations1964Marie-Louise von Post-Lingen
Journal of Safety ResearchTHE EFFECT OF CARBON MONOXIDE ON SEVERAL MEASURES OF VIGILANCE IN A SIMULATED DRIVING TASK
11 Citations1974Nicholas J. Rummo, K Sarlanis
Seven volunteer subjects were exposed to low blood levels of CO during a two hour vigilance task in a driving simulator subjects under CO were significantly slower in responding to lead car speed changes and nonsmokers made significantly fewer steering wheel corrections.
PubMedCarbon monoxide and human performance in a single and dual task methodology.
10 Citations1983Gliner Ja, Horvath Sm +1 more
Results suggested that exposure to CO decreased arousal and interacted with fatigue to produce decreases in performance, and was suggested to limit man's ability to time share two concurrent tasks.
Perceptual and Motor SkillsLack of Effects of Carbon Monoxide on Human Vigilance
9 Citations1977Vernon A. Benignus, David A. Otto +2 more
ErgonomicsCarbon Monoxide and Phenobarbitone: A Comparison of Effects on Auditory Flutter Fusion Threshold and Critical Flicker Fusion Threshold
8 Citations1970A. D. L. GUEST, CATHERINE DUNCAN +1 more
In a small series of experiments, eight healthy subjects breathed either air alone or a mixture of air and carbon monoxide designed to raise carboxyhaemoglobin saturations to approximately 10 per cent, and the effects of the exposures on auditory flutter fusion thresholds and critical flicker fusion thresholds was assessed.
International Archives of Occupational and Environmental HealthCarbon monoxide exposure and information processing during perceptual-motor performance
8 Citations1983Patricia M. Mihevic, Jeffrey A. Gliner +1 more
It was concluded that motor performance was not influenced by exposure to CO leading to COHb concentrations of 5%.
Human Factors The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics SocietySustained Visual Attention and Carbon Monoxide: Elimination of Adaptation Effects
8 Citations1981S W Roche, Steven M. Horvath +3 more
The subjective questionnaire indicated that CO significantly decreased the subjects' confidence concerning their performance on the vigilance task, as well as causing significant irritation of the eyes and throat.
The Effect of Carbon Monoxide on Time Perception, Manual Coordination, Inspection, and Arithmetic
6 Citations1975Richard D. Stewart, Paul E. Newton +3 more
Alarmingly, these decrements in time perception are reported to be produced by exposures to CO at concentrations as low as 50 parts per million (ppm) for 90 min, exposures which are currently acceptable in American industry, commonly encountered by urban populations, and much lower than those experienced by the average adult smoking one pack of cigarettes per day.