On the Principle of Privacy by Design and its Limits: Technology, Ethics and the Rule of Law
Published 1 January 2012
Ugo Pagallo
Citations31
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The idea should be to decrease the entropy of the system via ‘digital air-bags’ and to strengthen people’s rights by widening the range of their choices, rather than preventing harm generating behaviour from occurring through the use of self-enforcement technologies.
Abstract
Over the last years lawmakers, privacy commissioners and scholars have discussed the idea of embedding data protection safeguards in ICT and other types of technology, by means of value-sensitive design, AI and legal ontologies, PeCAM platforms, and more. Whereas this kind of effort is offering fruitful solutions for operating systems, health care technologies, social networks and smart environments, the paper stresses some critical aspects of the principle by examining technological limits, ethical constraints and legal conditions of privacy by design, so as to prevent some misapprehensions of the current debate. The idea should be to decrease the entropy of the system via 'digital air-bags' and to strengthen people's rights by widening the range of their choices, rather than preventing harm generating behaviour from occurring through the use of self-enforcement technologies.
Keywords
Social SciencesNeuroscience
Medical Entomology and ZoologyCode and Other Laws of Cyberspace
3,176 Citations1999Lawrence Lessig
Harvard Professor Lawrence Lessig shows how code can make a domain, site, or network free or restrictive; how technological architectures influence people's behavior and the values they adopt; and how changes in code can have damaging consequences for individual freedoms.
Value Sensitive Design and Information Systems
1,140 Citations2008Batya Friedman, Peter H. Kahn +1 more
SciencereCAPTCHA: Human-Based Character Recognition via Web Security Measures
1,126 Citations2008Luis von Ahn, Benjamin Maurer +3 more
This research explored whether human effort can be channeled into a useful purpose: helping to digitize old printed material by asking users to decipher scanned words from books that computerized optical character recognition failed to recognize.
interactionsValue-sensitive design
891 Citations1996Batya Friedman
Value Sensitive Design particularly emphasizes values with moral import, including privacy, trust, human dignity, respect for person, physical and psychological well-being, informed consent, intellectual property, access, universal usability, freedom from bias, moral responsibility, and moral accountability.
IEEE Intelligent SystemsThe Nature, Importance, and Difficulty of Machine Ethics
663 Citations2006James H. Moor
The question of whether machine ethics exists or might exist in the future is difficult to answer if the authors can't agree on what counts as machine ethics, and a discussion of the issue could rapidly propel us into deep and unsettled philosophical issues.
The Human-Computer Interaction Handbook
660 Citations2007
Free Culture: The Nature and Future of Creativity
584 Citations2008Lawrence Lessig
To lose the authors' long tradition of free culture, Lawrence Lessig shows, is to lose their freedom to create, the freedom to build, and, ultimately, their freedom to imagine.
Communications of the ACMUniversal usability
576 Citations2000Ben Shneiderman
The goal of universal access to information and communications services is compelling, although critics see unreasonable zeal for technology, pursuit of high profit margins, and regulatory excesses or omissions.
Identity in the Information SocietyPrivacy by Design
376 Citations2010Peter Schaar
It makes all the more sense to identify and examine possible data protection problems when designing new technology and to incorporate privacy protection into the overall design, instead of having to come up with laborious and time-consuming “patches” later on.
Technology and Privacy: The New Landscape
357 Citations1998Philip E. Agre, Marc Rotenberg
Cambridge University Press eBooksEmbodying Values in Technology: Theory and Practice
316 Citations2008Mary Flanagan, Daniel C. Howe +1 more
A pragmatic turn from this largely descriptive posture sets forth values as a design aspiration, exhorting designers and producers to include values, purposively, in the set of criteria by which the excellence of technologies is judged.
MetaphilosophyPHILOSOPHICAL THEORIES OF PRIVACY: IMPLICATIONS FOR AN ADEQUATE ONLINE PRIVACY POLICY
274 Citations2007Herman T. Tavani
It is shown how RALC can help to frame an online privacy policy that is sufficiently comprehensive in scope to address a wide range of privacy concerns that arise in connection with computers and information technology.
Human Values, Ethics, and Design
270 Citations2002Batya Friedman
Cambridge University Press eBooksInformation Technology and Moral Philosophy
220 Citations2008Jeroen van den Hoven, Jeroen van den Hoven +19 more
ACM Transactions on the WebMethods for extracting place semantics from Flickr tags
210 Citations2009Tye Rattenbury, Mor Naaman
An approach for extracting semantics for tags, unstructured text-labels assigned to resources on the Web, based on each tag's usage patterns, and two novel methods, TagMaps and scale-structure identification are described.
Protecting Privacy in an Information Age: The Problem of Privacy in Public
185 Citations2017Helen Nissenbaum
Ethics and Information TechnologyFour challenges for a theory of informational privacy
161 Citations2006Luciano Floridi
It is argued that the ontological theory of informational privacy can cope with challenges fairly successfully and some of the work that lies ahead is discussed.
Handbook of Peer-to-Peer Networking
156 Citations2010Xuemin Shen, Mursalin Akon +2 more
This handbook addresses current issues as well as emerging concepts and applications, including P2P architectures, search and queries, incentive mechanism, multimedia streaming, service- oriented architectures, collaboration to share non-storage resources, mobile P1P, theory and analysis, and P2p databases.
Hart Publishing eBooksRegulating Technologies : Legal Futures, Regulatory Frames and Technological Fixes
153 Citations2008
Informed consent in the Mozilla browser: implementing value-sensitive design
137 Citations2003Batya Friedman, Daniel C. Howe +1 more
This work describes the VSD methodology, explicate criteria for informed consent in online interactions and summarize how current browsers fall short with respect to those criteria.
Identity in the Information SocietyPrivacy by design: the definitive workshop. A foreword by Ann Cavoukian, Ph.D
134 Citations2010Ann Cavoukian
In November, 2009, a prominent group of privacy professionals, business leaders, information technology specialists, and academics gathered in Madrid to discuss how the next set of threats to privacy could best be addressed.
ACM SIGCAS Computers and SocietyInformation ethics, its nature and scope
121 Citations2005Luciano Floridi
The world of the future will be an ever more demanding struggle against the limitations of their intelligence, not a comfortable hammock in which the authors can lie down to be waited upon by their robot slaves.
The Hastings Center ReportEthics as Design: Doing Justice to Moral Problems
115 Citations1996Caroline Whitbeck
The question is not simply how I should evaluate proposed courses of action, but how I go about devising such courses ofaction, a subject on which ethics has had little to say.
ACM SIGCAS Computers and SocietyInformation ethics, its nature and scope
113 Citations2006Luciano Floridi
The world of the future will be an ever more demanding struggle against the limitations of their intelligence, not a comfortable hammock in which the authors can lie down to be waited upon by their robot slaves.
Legal StudiesCode, control, and choice: why East is East and West is West
106 Citations2005Roger Brownsword
IEEE Intelligent SystemsComputational Models of Ethical Reasoning: Challenges, Initial Steps, and Future Directions
98 Citations2006Bruce M. McLaren
The author briefly describes a few of the programs and discusses in detail two programs, both of which employ techniques from the area of AI known as case-based reasoning and implement aspects of the ethical approach known as casuistry.
Ethics and Information TechnologyFuture Technologies, Dystopic Futures and the Precautionary Principle
73 Citations2005Steve Clarke
It is argued, along with Sunstein and Manson, that variants of the precautionary principle that appear strong enough to support significant restrictions on future technologies actually lead to contradictory policy recommendations.
O'Reilly & Associates, Inc. eBooksWeb security & commerce
65 Citations1997Simson Garfinkel, Eugene H. Spafford
Electronic Commerce Research and ApplicationsP3P deployment on websites
64 Citations2008Lorrie Faith Cranor, Serge Egelman +3 more
The deployment of computer-readable privacy policies encoded using the standard W3C platform for privacy preferences (P3P) format is studied to inform questions about P3P's usefulness to end users and researchers and it is found that P 3P adoption is increasing overall and that P2P adoption rates greatly vary across industries.
The Yale Law JournalDigital Architecture as Crime Control
63 Citations2003Neal Kumar Katyal
An understanding of architecture and target prevention will illuminate why firewalls at end points will more effectively guarantee security than will attempts to bundle security into the architecture of the Net.
ACM Transactions on the WebProtecting browsers from DNS rebinding attacks
56 Citations2009Collin Jackson, Adam Barth +3 more
Defenses to DNS rebinding attacks are analyzed, including improvements to the classic “DNS pinning,” and changes to browser plug-ins, firewalls, and Web servers are recommended.
Computer NetworksA middleware architecture for privacy protection
51 Citations2007Georgios V. Lioudakis, E. Koutsoloukas +6 more
The architecture mediates between the users, the service providers and the law, constituting a middleware shield for individuals' personal data, in order to limit the disclosure and avoid the misuse of personal data.
European Data Privacy Law and Online Business
34 Citations2003Christopher Kuner
This book focuses on how to determine whether EU law applies to particular electronic commerce and online activities, and how to transfer personal data outside Europe so as to comply with EU law.
ACM Transactions on the WebA large-scale empirical study of P3P privacy policies
34 Citations2009Ian Reay, Scott Dick +1 more
It is shown that Web sites generally do not follow all the privacy-protection mandates in their legal jurisdiction, and this general statement appears to be true for every jurisdiction with privacy laws and any significant number of P3P policies, including European Union nations, Canada, Australia, and Web sites in the USA Safe Harbor program.
Ethics and Information TechnologyThe future of intellectual property
33 Citations2003Richard A. Spinello
Information SystemsPeCAN: An architecture for users’ privacy-aware electronic commerce contexts on the semantic web
31 Citations2005Dawn Jutla, Peter Bodorik +1 more
This work presents the Personal Context Agent Networking (PeCAN) knowledge architecture consisting of client-side and web-side architectural data components and services which inform the user of online privacy and trust within e-commerce tasks and describes a data belief ontology and illustrates PeCAN's compliance to the P3P privacy data schema.
Participatory Design ConferenceDesigning for Human Values in a Urban Simulation System: Value Sensitive Design and Participatory design
26 Citations2004Alan Borning, Batya Friedman +1 more
The UrbanSim work is used as an example to bring out key commonalities and differences between value Sensitive Design and Participatory Design, and to motivate some preliminary ideas about ways in which each methodology could evolve based on techniques and concepts from the other.
Frontiers in MicrobiologyBuilding Privacy into the Semantic Web: An Ontology Needed Now
22 Citations2002Anya Kim, Lance J. Hoffman
It is determined that the bacterial communities of native biocrusts are distinct from those in their underlying soil, where dominant bacterial taxa differed according to crust morphologies, demonstrating that biocrUST communities are seemingly islands of biological activity in an arid landscape, uniquely different from their surrounding and underlying soil.
InformationDesigning Data Protection Safeguards Ethically
20 Citations2011Ugo Pagallo
In order to address some of the most relevant issues of data protection today, the paper suggests a stricter, yet more effective version of “privacy by design,” which should be to reinforce people’s pre-existing autonomy, rather than having to build it from scratch.
Hague Journal on the Rule of LawThe Future of Rule of Law: Challenges and Prospects for the Field
19 Citations2009Randy Peerenboom
Interações (Campo Grande)Inovar para desenvolver: o conceito de gestão de trajectórias territoriais de inovação
18 Citations2016João Ferrão Ferrão
AIS Electronic Library (AISeL) (Association for Information Systems)Privacy Agents and Ontology for the Semantic Web
16 Citations2004Dawn Jutla, Liming Xu
It is proposed that existing and to-be-designed XML-based P3P tags be incorporated in any regulatory privacy ontology to enable future P2P agents to automatically match not only the business’ privacy policy with the user preference rules, but also to match the business privacy laws with the privacy laws applicable to the stated legal jurisdiction in which the business operates.
Lecture notes in computer scienceA Legal Ontology to Support Privacy Preservation in Location-Based Services
14 Citations2006Hugo Mitre‐Hernandez, Ana I. González–Tablas +2 more
An ontology of the main Spanish privacy norm is presented as well as the method used to construct it and the ontology is specifically aimed and applied to the preservation of privacy in LBS.
The Social Impact of P2P Systems
13 Citations2009Andrea Glorioso, Ugo Pagallo +1 more
The aim is to deepen legal issues, sociological trends, economical aspects, and political dimensions of P2P technology, along with some of its next possible outputs, in order to assess one of the most compelling alternatives to the traditional frame of highly centralized human interaction.
Lecture notes in computer scienceAn Ontology-Based Approach for Managing and Maintaining Privacy in Information Systems
10 Citations2006Dhiah el Diehn I. Abou-Tair, Stefan Berlik
The usage of ontologies in the approach differs from the conventional form in focusing on generating access control policies which are adapted from the software framework to provide fine granular access on the diverse data sources.
Maturing e-Privacy with P3P and Context Agents
7 Citations2005Dawn Jutla, Yongwang Zhang
This work proposes a collaboration, between a context agent and a P3P agent, which results in the application of context-specific privacy rules during a user's electronic commerce transaction with an organization's Web site or Web service.
Identity in the Information SocietyLayering privacy on operating systems, social networks, and other platforms by design
7 Citations2010Dawn Jutla
An online privacy lifecycle from the user perspective that drives and categorizes the development of services, a layered platform design solution for online privacy, the evolution of the PeCAN architecture to a platform for pervasively providing multiple contexts for user privacy preferences and online informational privacy services, and use of platform network effects for increasing wide-scale user adoption of privacy services.
ACM SIGCAS Computers and SocietyOnline file sharing
6 Citations2008Frances S. Grodzinsky, Herman T. Tavani
This essay expands upon an earlier work in which it analyzed the implications of the Verizon v RIAA case for P2P Networks vis-à-vis concerns affecting personal privacy and intellectual property by analyzing the intellectual property and privacy issues that emerged in the MGM Studios v Grokster case.
Digital Rights ManagementThe Trouble with Digital Copies
1 Citations2012Ugo Pagallo
This chapter analyzes some of the most relevant ethical issues and social dilemmas in knowledge management and organizational innovation, by focusing on a paramount feature of digital technology, which is “copying,” and suggests new ways for balancing property rights and the right to freely participate in the cultural life of the community.