Trophic cascades promote threshold-like shifts in pelagic marine ecosystems
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesPublished 24 December 2008Open access
Michele Casini, Joakim Hjelm, Juan‐Carlos Molinero, Johan Lövgren, Massimiliano Cardinale, Valerio Bartolino
Citations400
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
An ecological threshold is identified, corresponding to a planktivore abundance of ≈17 × 1010 individuals, that separates 2 ecosystem configurations in which zooplankton dynamics are driven by either hydroclimatic forces or predation pressure, and the current strong regulation by sprat of the feeding resources for larval cod may hinder cod recovery and the return of the ecosystem to a prior state.
Abstract
Fisheries can have a large impact on marine ecosystems, because the effects of removing large predatory fish may cascade down the food web. The implications of these cascading processes on system functioning and resilience remain a source of intense scientific debate. By using field data covering a 30-year period, we show for the Baltic Sea that the underlying mechanisms of trophic cascades produced a shift in ecosystem functioning after the collapse of the top predator cod. We identified an ecological threshold, corresponding to a planktivore abundance of approximately 17 x 10(10) individuals, that separates 2 ecosystem configurations in which zooplankton dynamics are driven by either hydroclimatic forces or predation pressure. Abundances of the planktivore sprat above the threshold decouple zooplankton dynamics from hydrological circumstances. The current strong regulation by sprat of the feeding resources for larval cod may hinder cod recovery and the return of the ecosystem to a prior state. This calls for the inclusion of a food web perspective in management decisions.
Keywords
Environmental Science
Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and SystematicsRegime Shifts, Resilience, and Biodiversity in Ecosystem Management
3,765 Citations2004Carl Folke, Steve Carpenter +5 more
Active adaptive management and governance of resilience will be required to sustain desired ecosystem states and transform degraded ecosystems.
Wiley StatsRef: Statistics Reference OnlineGeneralized Additive Models
3,175 Citations2014Trevor Hastie, Robert Tibshirani
Trends in Ecology & EvolutionCatastrophic regime shifts in ecosystems: linking theory to observation
2,733 Citations2003Marten Scheffer, Stephen R. Carpenter
NatureImpact of climate change on marine pelagic phenology and trophic mismatch
2,123 Citations2004Martin Edwards, Anthony J. Richardson
It is shown that not only is the marine pelagic community responding to climate changes, but also that the level of response differs throughout the community and the seasonal cycle, leading to a mismatch between trophic levels and functional groups.
Trends in Ecology & EvolutionTrophic cascades revealed in diverse ecosystems
1,457 Citations1999Michael L. Pace, Michael L. Pace +6 more
Analyses of the extirpation of large animals reveal loss of cascades, and the potential of conservation to restore not only predator populations but also the ecosystem-level effects that ramify from their presence is revealed.
Trends in Ecology & EvolutionPredicting ecological consequences of marine top predator declines
1,317 Citations2008Michael R. Heithaus, Alejandro Frid +2 more
The consequences of marine predator declines are outlined and an integrated predictive framework that includes risk effects is proposed, which appear to be strongest for long-lived prey species and when resources are abundant.
ScienceTrophic Cascades in a Formerly Cod-Dominated Ecosystem
1,180 Citations2005Kenneth T. Frank, Brian Petrie +2 more
Using data spanning many decades from a once cod-dominated northwest Atlantic ecosystem, a trophic cascade is demonstrated in a large marine ecosystem, suggesting the existence of trophIC cascades in these systems.
Ecology LettersA cross‐ecosystem comparison of the strength of trophic cascades
966 Citations2002Jonathan B. Shurin, Elizabeth T. Borer +6 more
Predator effects on herbivores were generally larger and more variable than on plants, suggesting that cascades often become attenuated at the plant‐ herbivore interface.
EcologyPIECEWISE REGRESSION: A TOOL FOR IDENTIFYING ECOLOGICAL THRESHOLDS
964 Citations2003Judith D. Toms, Mary Lesperance
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesGlobal fish production and climate change
939 Citations2007Keith Brander
Reducing fishing mortality in the majority of fisheries, which are currently fully exploited or overexploited, is the principal feasible means of reducing the impacts of climate change.
Trophic cascade in lakes
856 Citations1993Stephen R. Carpenter, James F. Kitchell
EcologyCLIMATE CHANGE UNCOUPLES TROPHIC INTERACTIONS IN AN AQUATIC ECOSYSTEM
844 Citations2004Monika Winder, Daniel E. Schindler
A long-term decline in Daphnia populations, the keystone herbivore, is associated with an expanding temporal mismatch with the spring diatom bloom and may have severe consequences for resource flow to upper trophic levels.
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic SciencesComparison of methods to account for autocorrelation in correlation analyses of fish data
796 Citations1998Brian J. Pyper, Randall M. Peterman
This work compared several adjustment methods via Monte Carlo simulation and found that a modified version of these methods kept Type I error rates near and methods that remove autocorrelation control Type Ierror rates well but may in some circumstances increase Type II error rates and hence reduce statistical power.
ScienceBottom-Up Ecosystem Trophic Dynamics Determine Fish Production in the Northeast Pacific
669 Citations2005D. M. Ware, Richard E. Thomson
Zooplankton data for coastal British Columbia confirm strong bottom-up trophic linkages between phytoplankon, zooplANKton, and resident fish, extending to regional areas as small as 10,000 square kilometers.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesInteraction strength combinations and the overfishing of a marine food web
639 Citations2005Jordi Bascompte, Carlos J. Melián +1 more
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesTrophic cascades triggered by overfishing reveal possible mechanisms of ecosystem regime shifts
627 Citations2007Georgi Daskalov, А. Н. Гришин +2 more
Two major shifts were detected, the first related to a depletion of marine predators and the second to an outburst of the alien comb jelly Mnemiopsis leidyi; both shifts were triggered by intense fishing resulting in system-wide trophic cascades.
Journal of Animal EcologyFrom plankton to top predators: bottom‐up control of a marine food web across four trophic levels
583 Citations2006Morten Frederiksen, Martin Edwards +3 more
These links are consistent with bottom-up ecosystem regulation and indicate how climate-driven changes in plankton communities can affect top predators and potentially human fisheries through the dynamics of key mid-trophic fish.
Deep Sea Research Part II Topical Studies in OceanographyClimate change and control of the southeastern Bering Sea pelagic ecosystem
573 Citations2002George L. Hunt, Phyllis J. Stabeno +5 more
It is predicted that pelagic ecosystem function in the southeastern Bering Sea will alternate between primarily bottom-up control in cold regimes and primarily top-down control in warm regimes, and the ability of large predatory fish populations to sustain fishing pressure will vary between warm and cold regimes.
Cambridge University Press eBooksThe Trophic Cascade in Lakes
501 Citations1993Stephen R. Carpenter, Stephen R. Carpenter +18 more
A simulation models of the trophic cascade: predictions and evaluations of the fish behavioral and community responses to manipulation and the annual fossil record of food-web manipulation are presented.
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic SciencesCultivation/depensation effects on juvenile survival and recruitment: implications for the theory of fishing
481 Citations2001Carl J. Walters, James F. Kitchell
Risk of depensatory effects should be a major target of recruitment research, and management policies should aim for considerably higher spawning abundances than has previously been assumed necessary based on recruitment data collected during adult stock declines associated with fishery development.
Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesMulti-level trophic cascades in a heavily exploited open marine ecosystem
347 Citations2008Michele Casini, Johan Lövgren +4 more
This work shows for the first time a four-level community-wide trophic cascade in the open Baltic Sea, and suggests that in order to dampen the occasionally harmful algal blooms of the Baltic, effort should be addressed not only to control anthropogenic nutrient inputs but also to preserve structure and functioning of higher Trophic levels.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesBenthic–pelagic links and rocky intertidal communities: Bottom-up effects on top-down control?
347 Citations1997Bruce A. Menge, Bryon A. Daley +4 more
Shore-based sampling revealed that between-site differences were associated with nearshore oceanographic conditions, including phytoplankton concentration and productivity, particulates, and water temperature during upwelling, and offshore chlorophyll-a samples are consistent with the postulated mechanism.
ICES Journal of Marine ScienceEffects of climate and overfishing on zooplankton dynamics and ecosystem structure: regime shifts, trophic cascade, and feedback loops in a simple ecosystem
271 Citations2008Christian Möllmann, Bärbel Müller‐Karulis +2 more
EcologyFISH PRODUCTION AND CLIMATE: SPRAT IN THE BALTIC SEA
190 Citations2004Brian R. MacKenzie, Fritz Köster
It is demonstrated using 45 years of data that recruitment depends on temperature conditions during the months when sprat gonads, eggs, and larvae are developing and can be predicted before adults spawn by using linkages between recruitment, large-scale climate variability, Baltic Sea ice coverage, and water temperature.
Marine Ecology Progress SeriesFood consumption of larval, young and adult herring and sprat in the Baltic Sea
179 Citations1993F Arrhenius, Sture Hansson
The estimate for annual consumption of zooplankton by clupeids in the Baltic sea is 4 times higher than previous estimates, and simulations also show that a diet shift, from a mix of zoopsids, mysids and amphipods to only zoopLankton, could have a significant effect on fish growth rate.
Marine Ecology Progress SeriesQuantifying environmental heterogeneity:habitat size necessary for successful development of cod Gadus morhua eggs in the Baltic Sea
162 Citations2000Brian R. MacKenzie, H.-H. Hinrichsen +3 more
The results of 2 independent volume-estimation methods are comparable, indicating that highly significant differences exist among the sites, and that the westernmost spawning ground, Bornholm Basin, has on average the highest reproductive volume and the lowest variability among the 4 sites.
Ecology LettersPredator disease out‐break modulates top‐down, bottom‐up and climatic effects on herbivore population dynamics
161 Citations2006Christopher C. Wilmers, Eric Post +2 more
It is suggested that predators in this system may play an important role in dampening the effects of climate change on the dynamics of their prey.
Progress In OceanographyInterplay between top-down, bottom-up, and wasp-waist control in marine ecosystems
160 Citations2006George L. Hunt, Skip McKinnell
OikosInter‐annual variation in herring, <i>Clupea harengus</i> , and sprat, <i>Sprattus sprattus</i> , condition in the central Baltic Sea: what gives the tune?
125 Citations2006Michele Casini, Massimiliano Cardinale +1 more
The results are not in agreement with most of the current literature that has suggested that clupeid growth is regulated by environmentally mediated bottom-up processes acting on the abundance of copepods, and provide the first evidence of food resources mediated density-dependent fish growth in a large marine ecosystem.
Global Change BiologyClimate control on the long‐term anomalous changes of zooplankton communities in the Northwestern Mediterranean
119 Citations2007Juan Carlos Molinero, Frédéric Ibañez +4 more
A chain of mechanisms is suggested, whereby climate variation has modified the long-term dynamics of pelagic copepods, chaetognaths and jellyfish in the Ligurian Sea, suggesting a shift in the functioning of the pelagic ecosystem.
Ecology LettersOscillating trophic control induces community reorganization in a marine ecosystem
112 Citations2007Michael A. Litzow, Lorenzo Ciannelli
It is shown that the nature of trophic control in a North Pacific ecosystem depends on climate state, and top-down control could not be detected in the final state without reference to the initial state and transition period.
Journal of Sea ResearchHow cod shapes its world
106 Citations2008Anieke van Leeuwen, André M. de Roos +1 more
Cod stocks in the North West Atlantic and the Baltic Sea have shown similar dynamics in recent decades with a rapid decline in abundance and a lack of stock recovery following a period of large bio ...
Fish and FisheriesAdverse feedback sequences in exploited marine systems: are deliberate interruptive actions warranted?
91 Citations2006Andrew Bakun, Scarla Weeks
This history can illustrate how multiple feedback loops might interact with one another in unanticipated and quite malignant ways, leading not only to collapse of customary resource stocks but also to degradation of the ecosystem to such an extent that disruption of customary goods and services may go beyond fisheries alone to adversely affect other major global ecosystem concerns.
Marine Ecology Progress SeriesZooplanktivory in the Baltic Sea: a comparison of prey selectivity by Clupea harengus and Mysis mixta, with reference to prey escape reactions
89 Citations2001Markku Viitasalo, Juha Flinkman +1 more
It is suggested that large-sized copepods are important food for both herring and mysids and that a hydrography-induced shift towards a cladoceran-dominated zooplankton community may decrease the food gain by Baltic herring.
Ecological MonographsTOP-DOWN HERBIVORY AND BOTTOM-UP EL NINO EFFECTS ON GALÁPAGOS ROCKY-SHORE COMMUNITIES
86 Citations2006Luis Vinueza, G. M. Branch +2 more
The effects of marine iguanas, sally lightfoot crabs, and fish on rocky-shore sessile organisms at two sites at Santa Cruz Island, Galapagos Islands, Ecuador, for 3–5 years during and after the 1997–1998 El Nino, using exclusion cages to separate the effects.
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic SciencesThe influence of stock structure and environmental conditions on the recruitment process of Baltic cod estimated using a generalized additive model
85 Citations2000Massimiliano Cardinale, F Arrhenius
The number of Baltic cod recruits is strictly dependent on the age structure of the population and interactions between biotic and abiotic factors are crucial in explaining recruitment variabil - ity, and generalized additive models (GAMs) are a powerful technique for defining and quantifying the intricate multidimensional relation- ship involved in recruitment processes.
ICES Journal of Marine ScienceFish and zooplankton interaction in the Central Baltic Sea
75 Citations2001Georgs Kornilovs
Research Portal (King's College London)Stock recruitment relationships for cod ( Gadus morhua L.) in the central Baltic Sea incorporating environmental variability
50 Citations2000Astrid Jarre, Kai Wieland +4 more
This work relates recruitment at age 2 to parent stock size using updated time series of these variables, comprising the period 1966 to 1994, and a modified Ricker model is outlined explicity accounting for environmentally-induced oscillations around the two observed levels of cod stock size.
EcosystemsAlternative Dynamic Regimes and Trophic Control of Plant Succession
46 Citations2006Oswald J. Schmitz, Elizabeth L. Kalies +1 more
It is concluded that a single ecosystem can display both top–down and bottom–up control in the rate of development of ecosystems consistent with a working hypothesis that succession proceeds via abrupt regime shifts.