Content and context effects in children's and adults' conditional reasoning
The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section APublished 28 July 2002
Pierre Barrouillet, Jean-François Lecas
Citations20
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
As predicted, BB conditionals elicited more biconditional response patterns than did NN conditionals in all age groups, and manipulating the context had the same effect in children but not in adults.
Abstract
We have recently shown that children interpret conditional sentences with binary terms (e.g., male/female) in both the antecedent and the consequent as biconditionals (Barrouillet & Lecas, 1998). We hypothesized that the same effect can be obtained with conditionals that do not contain binary terms provided that they are embedded in a context that restricts to only two the possible values on both the antecedent and the consequent. In the present experiment, we asked 12-year-old children, 15-year-old children, and adults to draw conclusions from conditional syllogisms that involved three types of conditional sentence: (1) conditionals with binary terms (BB), (2) conditionals with non-binary terms (NN), and (3) conditionals with non-binary terms embedded in a restrictive context (NNR). As we predicted, BB conditionals elicited more biconditional response patterns than did NN conditionals in all age groups. On the other hand, manipulating the context had the same effect in children but not in adults. Content and context constraints on conditional reasoning along with developmental issues are discussed within the framework of the mental models theory.
Keywords
PsychologyMathematics
Relevance: Communication and Cognition
6,077 Citations1986Dan Sperber, Deirdre Wilson
Choice Reviews OnlineHuman reasoning: the psychology of deduction
996 Citations1994
Conditional reasoning theories of propositional reasoning - rules versus models the Wason selection task disjunctive reasoning relational inferences syllogistic reasoning reasoning with quantifiers - beyond syllogisms.
Psychological ReviewConditionals: A theory of meaning, pragmatics, and inference.
811 Citations2002P. N. Johnson‐Laird, Ruth M. J. Byrne
The authors outline a theory of conditionals of the form If A then C and if A then possibly C, which predicts the major phenomena of understanding and reasoning with conditionals.
Psychological ReviewPropositional reasoning by model.
458 Citations1992P. N. Johnson‐Laird, Ruth M. J. Byrne +1 more
The theory proposes that reasoning is a semantic process based on mental models that assumes that people are able to maintain models of only a limited number of alternative states of affairs, and they accordingly use models representing as much information as possible in an implicit way.
Memory & CognitionConditional reasoning and causation
332 Citations1991Denise D. Cummins, Todd Lubart +2 more
Investigation of the relative contributions of syntactic form and content to conditional reasoning found conclusions of arguments based on conditionals with few alternative causes or disabling conditions were found to be more accept-able than conclusions based on those with many.
Psychological ReviewA theory of if: A lexical entry, reasoning program, and pragmatic principles.
324 Citations1991Martin D. S. Braine, David P. O'Brien
Memory & CognitionNaive theories and causal deduction
284 Citations1995Denise D. Cummins
A causal analysis is presented in which alternative causes and disabling conditions impact on judgments concerning causal necessity and sufficiency, which in turn determine deductive entailment relations.
Developmental ReviewThe Development of Conditional Reasoning: A Mental Model Account
178 Citations2002Henry Markovits, Pierre Barrouillet
A variant of mental model theory (Johnson-Laird, 1983) is proposed that suggests that the development of conditional reasoning can be explained, at least partly, by such factors as the capacity of working memory, the range of knowledge available to a reasoner and his/her ability to access this knowledge on-line.
CognitionConditional reasoning by mental models: chronometric and developmental evidence
162 Citations2000Pierre Barrouillet, Nelly Grosset +1 more
Two predictions resulting from the mental models theory of conditional reasoning are verified: the denial of antecedent (DA) and modus tollens (MT) inferences should take longer to verify than modus ponens (MP) and affirmation of consequent (AC) because the former require subjects to flesh out the initial model whereas the latter do not.
Thinking & ReasoningMental Models in Conditional Reasoning and Working Memory
160 Citations1999Pierre Barrouillet, Jean-François Lecas
CognitionThe mental model theory of conditional reasoning: critical appraisal and revision
157 Citations1993Jonathan St. B. T. Evans
The theory is critically examined with regard to its ability to account for psychological data, principally with respect to the rate at which people draw the four basic inferences of modus ponens, denial of the antecedent (DA), affirmation of the consequent (AC) and modus tollens (MT).
Memory & CognitionDeductive reasoning with factual, possible, and counterfactual conditionals
152 Citations1999Ruth M. J. Byrne, Alessandra Tasso
It is proposed that people construct a richer representation of conditionals that deal with possibilities rather than facts, and experiments show that reasoners make more inferences from conditionals based on possibilities rather on facts when the inferences depend on the presupposed case.
Developmental PsychologyThe development of reasoning with causal conditionals.
105 Citations1999Geneviève Janveau-Brennan, Henry Markovits
Journal of Memory and LanguageCounterexamples and the Suppression of Inferences
103 Citations1999Ruth M. J. Byrne, Orlando Espino +1 more
PubMedThe development of conditional reasoning and the structure of semantic memory.
101 Citations1998Henry Markovits, Marie-Léda Fleury +2 more
CognitionHow can mental models theory account for content effects in conditional reasoning? A developmental perspective
93 Citations1998Pierre Barrouillet
The model suggests that this interpretation of conditional statement of the form 'if ... then' is based on the construction of mental models supplied by establishing a correspondence between the semantic spaces associated with the antecedent and consequent of the statements.
CognitionConditional reasoning, causality, and the structure of semantic memory: strength of association as a predictive factor for content effects
90 Citations1998Stéphane Quinn
This study examines the effect of strength of association on performance on a conditional reasoning task using causal premises for which there exist one highly associated potential cause for the given consequent term and predicted that adults would produce a greater proportion of biconditional responses to invalid forms than weakly associated ones.
CognitionThe effect of premise order in conditional reasoning: a test of the mental model theory
89 Citations1997Vittorio Girotto, Alberto Mazzocco +1 more
It is predicted that conditions in which reasoners are forced to represent the not-q case should improve correct performance on modus tollens and that the presentation of the minor premise (not-q) as the initial premise should produce facilitation.
Child DevelopmentThe Development of Conditional Reasoning and the Structure of Semantic Memory
65 Citations1998Henry Markovits, Marie‐Léda Fleury +2 more
2 predictions concerning conditional reasoning in children derived from a revised version of Markovits's model of conditional reasoning are examined, interpreted as consistent with the idea that 1 major factor in the development of reasoning in this age level is theDevelopment of children's ability to explore their own knowledge base.
Psychological ReviewPropositional reasoning by mental models? Simple to refute in principle and in practice.
62 Citations1994David P. O'Brien, Martin D. S. Braine +1 more
It is argued that the mental-logic theory provides the more plausible description of the actual psychological processes in propositional reasoning.
Child DevelopmentReasoning in Young Children: Fantasy and Information Retrieval
58 Citations1996Henry Markovits, Michèle Venet +4 more
The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section AThe Role of Negation in Conditional Inference
58 Citations1999Jonathan St. B. T. Evans, Simon J. Handley
CognitionWhy should we abandon the mental logic hypothesis?
31 Citations1994Luca L. Bonatti
The arguments to reject the mental logic hypothesis are revised and claim that they are either not conclusive, or point at problems which are troublesome for the mental model hypothesis as well.
Thinking & ReasoningConditional reasoning with negations: Implicit and explicit affirmation or denial and the role of contrast classes
23 Citations2000Walter Schroyens, Niki Verschueren +2 more
Two studies on the effect of implicitly versus explicitly conveying affirmation and denial problems about conditionals confirm that binary sets, where the contrast class is a singleton, eliminate the differential effect of implicit affirmation and deny, and investigate the role of contrast classes.
British Journal of PsychologyThe effect of explicit negatives and of different contrast classes on conditional syllogisms
20 Citations2000Walter Schaeken, Walter Schroyens
An experiment tested the effects of systematically negating the constituents of four fundamental inferences based on conditionals of the form: Modus Ponens, Modus Tollens, Affirmation of the Consequent, and Denial of the Antecedent, and discussed the results in relation to a negative categorical premise bias, an affirmative premise biases, a negative conclusion bias and a double negation effect.
CognitionIllusory inferences from a disjunction of conditionals: a new mental models account
8 Citations2000Pierre Barrouillet, Jean-François Lecas
It is shown that the way individuals represent conditionals leads them to misinterpret the locus of the disjunction and prevents them from drawing conclusions from a false conditional, thus accounting for the compelling character of the illusory inference.