Misrepresentation of Randomized Controlled Trials in Press Releases and News Coverage: A Cohort Study
PLoS MedicinePublished 11 September 2012Open access
Amélie Yavchitz, Isabelle Boutron, Aïda Bafeta, Ibrahim Marroun, Pierre Charles, Jean Mantz
Citations266
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score4.28
SNIP3.21
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
A study examines the factors associated with “spin” (specific reporting strategies, intentional or unintentional, that emphasize the beneficial effect of treatments) in press releases of clinical trials.
Abstract
"Spin" was identified in about half of press releases and media coverage. In multivariable analysis, the main factor associated with "spin" in press releases was the presence of "spin" in the article abstract conclusion.
Keywords
Decision SciencesEconomics, Econometrics and FinancePharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmaceutics
BMJEvidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't
15,683 Citations1996David L. Sackett, William Rosenberg +3 more
As evidence based medicine continues to evolve and adapt, now is a useful time to refine the discussion of what it is andWhat it is not.
American Journal of EpidemiologyA Modified Poisson Regression Approach to Prospective Studies with Binary Data
9,099 Citations2004Guangyong Zou
Results from a limited simulation study indicate that this approach is very reliable even with total sample sizes as small as 100, and the method is illustrated with two data sets.
JAMAReporting and Interpretation of Randomized Controlled Trials With Statistically Nonsignificant Results for Primary Outcomes
776 Citations2010Isabelle Boutron
The reporting and interpretation of findings was frequently inconsistent with the results and the nature and frequency of distorted presentation or "spin" was identified in published reports of randomized controlled trials with statistically nonsignificant results for primary outcomes.
JAMAAssociation of Funding and Conclusions in Randomized Drug Trials
744 Citations2003Bodil Als‐Nielsen, Wendong Chen +2 more
Conclusions in trials funded by for-profit organizations may be more positive due to biased interpretation of trial results, and readers should carefully evaluate whether conclusions in randomized trials are supported by data.
PLoS MedicineCONSORT for Reporting Randomized Controlled Trials in Journal and Conference Abstracts: Explanation and Elaboration
659 Citations2008Sally Hopewell, Mike Clarke +6 more
A minimum list of essential items, which authors should consider when reporting the results of a RCT in any journal or conference abstract, is developed to improve reporting of abstracts of RCTs published in journal articles and conference proceedings.
The American StatisticianBootstrap Methods for Developing Predictive Models
620 Citations2004Peter C. Austin, Jack V. Tu
Using data on patients admitted to hospital with a heart attack, it is demonstrated that selecting those variables that were identified as independent predictors of mortality in at least 60%% of the bootstrap samples resulted in a parsimonious model with excellent predictive ability.
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsMass media interventions: effects on health services utilisation
541 Citations2002Roberto Grilli, Craig Ramsay +1 more
There is evidence that these channels of communication may have an important role in influencing the use of health care interventions and those engaged in promoting better uptake of research information in clinical practice should consider mass media as one of the tools that may encourage theUse of effective services and discourage those of unproven effectiveness.
New England Journal of MedicineCoverage by the News Media of the Benefits and Risks of Medications
506 Citations2000Ray Moynihan, Lisa Bero +6 more
News-media stories about medications may include inadequate or incomplete information about the benefits, risks, and costs of the drugs as well as the financial ties between study groups or experts and pharmaceutical manufacturers.
New England Journal of MedicineImportance of the Lay Press in the Transmission of Medical Knowledge to the Scientific Community
404 Citations1991David P. Phillips, Evan Kanter +2 more
Columns in the Times that were covered by the Times received a disproportionate number of scientific citations in each of the 10 years after the Journal articles appeared, and the effect was strongest in the first year after publication.
Annals of Internal MedicineMeasured Enthusiasm: Does the Method of Reporting Trial Results Alter Perceptions of Therapeutic Effectiveness?
375 Citations1992C. David Naylor, Erluo Chen +1 more
Clinicians' views of drug therapies are affected by the common use of relative risk reductions in both trial reports and advertisements, by end-point emphasis, and, above all, by underuse of summary measures that relate treatment burden to therapeutic yields in a clinically relevant manner.
Annals of Internal MedicineChanges in the Use of Postmenopausal Hormone Therapy after the Publication of Clinical Trial Results
315 Citations2004Jennifer S. Haas, Celia P. Kaplan +2 more
Whether the use of hormone therapy has changed among postmenopausal women as a result of the publication of the HERS and the WHI is examined, and whether patterns of use differ by patient characteristics is examined.
New England Journal of MedicineMisunderstandings about the Effects of Race and Sex on Physicians' Referrals for Cardiac Catheterization
194 Citations1999Lisa M. Schwartz, Steven Woloshin +1 more
In the February 25 issue of the Journal, Schulman et al. claimed that the race and sex of a patient independently influence how physicians manage chest pain.
JAMAPress Releases
187 Citations2002Steven Woloshin, Lisa M. Schwartz
Press releases do not routinely highlight study limitations or the role of industry funding, and data are often presented using formats that may exaggerate the perceived importance of findings.
BMJReporting research in medical journals and newspapers
165 Citations1995Vikki Entwistle
The Lancet and BMJ are both examined carefully by broadsheet journalists in Britain each week, and stories focused on serious diseases, topical health problems, and new treatments rather than social problems.
BMJInfluence of medical journal press releases on the quality of associated newspaper coverage: retrospective cohort study
134 Citations2012Lisa M. Schwartz, Steven Woloshin +2 more
High quality press releases issued by medical journals seem to make the quality of associated newspaper stories better, whereas low qualityPress releases might make them worse.
Annals of Internal MedicinePress Releases by Academic Medical Centers: Not So Academic?
107 Citations2009Steven Woloshin, Lisa M. Schwartz +3 more
Annals of Internal MedicineThe Media Matter: A Call for Straightforward Medical Reporting
106 Citations2004Lisa M. Schwartz, Steven Woloshin
The decline in hormone replacement therapy (HRT) use following the release of the main findings of the Women's Health Initiative (WHI), a randomized trial that examined the efficacy of HRT in the primary prevention of heart disease, is reported on.
JAMANews Media Coverage of Screening Mammography for Women in Their 40s and Tamoxifen for Primary Prevention of Breast Cancer
89 Citations2002Lisa M. Schwartz
Most news stories favored routine use of screening mammography and urged caution about using tamoxifen, and almost all noted the potential harms of each preventive strategy; however, the negative aspects of tamoxIFen received greater emphasis.
BMJBelievability of relative risks and odds ratios in abstracts: cross sectional study
84 Citations2006Peter C Gøtzsche
Significant results in abstracts are common but should generally be disbelieved, and P values were more extreme in observational studies and in cohort studies than in case-control studies.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineInfluence of the News Media on Diagnostic Testing in the Emergency Department
78 Citations2003Vidya Sharma, M. Denise Dowd +3 more
A surge in news stories regarding GAS disease was associated with an increase in testing for GAS in a pediatric emergency department (ED) and the peak in media events were concomitant.
JAMAThe Hidden Research Paper
75 Citations2002Richard Horton
It was found that discussion sections were haphazardly organized and did not deal systematically with important questions about the study, and there is now empirical support for the introduction of structured discussion sections in research papers.
Social Science & MedicineJournalists and their sources of ideas and information on medicines
66 Citations1994Anke M. van Trigt, Lolkje T.W. de Jong‐van den Berg +3 more
The pharmaceutical industry did not seem to play a role as source of ideas and information according to the journalists, but professional medical journals and information from universities and their hospitals are the third most frequently cited source of information in the newspaper articles.
New England Journal of MedicineDNA Vaccines — Designer Vaccines for the 21st Century
64 Citations1999R A Seder, Sanjay Gurunathan
The development and widespread use of vaccines against infectious agents has been one of the triumphs of medical science and one reason for the success of these vaccines is the easy availability of cheap and effective vaccine ingredients.
PLoS ONEQuality of Pharmaceutical Industry Press Releases Based on Original Research
31 Citations2008Bindee Kuriya, Elana C. Schneid +1 more
Pharmaceutical company press releases frequently report basic study details, but readers should be cautioned by the preliminary nature of the data and lack of identified limitations, which are desirable to prevent misleading media coverage.
JNCI Journal of the National Cancer InstitutePromoting Healthy Skepticism in the News: Helping Journalists Get It Right
30 Citations2009Steven Woloshin, Lisa M. Schwartz +1 more
Media coverage of a new cancer treatment and the effect of treatment was not quantified, so viewers had no way to know how well it worked and journalists should remind readers that confounding is always a threat to the validity of observational studies.
Tobacco ControlPress-released papers are more downloaded and cited: Table 1
25 Citations2007Simon Chapman, Thien Nga Nguyen +1 more
In March 2006, website data and citations shown on the Institute for Scientific Information’s Web of Science for all 553 original articles, reviews, editorials and special communications published in Tobacco Control and its peer-reviewed supplements were examined, comparing press-released and non-released articles.