Representation construction, externalised cognition and individual differences
Learning and InstructionPublished 1 August 1999
Richard Cox
Citations348
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.24
SNIP2.54
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
This article discusses the cognitive differences between reasoning with self-constructed external representations (ERs) and reasoning with presented representations (e.g. textbook diagrams). Examples of ERs produced by subjects solving reasoning problems are provided. It is argued that effective reasoning with ERs involves a three-way interaction between (a) the cognitive and semantic properties of the representation; (b) the match between the demands of the task and the type of information read-off afforded by the representation and (c) the effects of within-subject factors (e.g. prior knowledge, cognitive style). It is suggested that providing direct instruction in the use of ERs could usefully address each factor.
Keywords
Psychology
Mental Representations: A Dual Coding Approach
5,042 Citations1986Allan Paivio
This book discussesMeta-Theoretical Issues and Perspectives, a meta-theoreticalPrinciples of Representation, and its Applications, a Practical Guide to Bilingual Cognitive Representation.
Voices of the Mind: A Sociocultural Approach to Mediated Action
4,120 Citations1991James V. Wertsch
Cognitive ScienceWhy a Diagram is (Sometimes) Worth Ten Thousand Words
3,579 Citations1987Jill H. Larkin, Herbert A. Simon
Human memory : theory and practice
3,034 Citations1990Alan Baddeley
This book discusses memory, Emotion and Cognition, and the role of Memory in Cognition - Working Memory, as well as Implicit Memory and Recollection.
Cognitive ScienceSelf-explanations: How students study and use examples in learning to solve problems
2,300 Citations1989M Chi
Choice Reviews OnlineThe children's machine: rethinking school in the age of the computer
1,967 Citations1993
Cognitive ScienceSelf‐Explanations: How Students Study and Use Examples in Learning to Solve Problems
1,677 Citations1989Michelene T.H., Miriam Bassok +3 more
The present paper analyzes the self-generated explanations that “Good” and “Poor” students produce while studying worked-out exomples of mechanics problems, and their subsequent reliance on examples during problem solving and the adequacy of current Al models of explanation-based learning is discussed.
Design IssuesThings That Make Us Smart: Defending Human Attributes in the Age of the Machine
1,504 Citations1994Rick Robinson, Donald A. Norman
This book discusses a Human-Centered Technology, Experiencing the World, and the Power of Representation, as well as Distributed Cognition and Soft and Hard Technology.
Cognitive Psychology: A Student's Handbook
1,460 Citations1990Michael W. Eysenck, Marc P. Keane
Constructivism in Education
1,407 Citations2012
Image and Brain: The Resolution of the Imagery Debate
1,323 Citations1994Stephen M. Kosslyn
Cognitive ScienceRepresentations in Distributed Cognitive Tasks
1,129 Citations1994Jiaje Zhang, Donald A. Norman
The theoretical framework and methodology are used to analyze the hierarchical structure of the Tower of Hanoi problem and the nature of external representations is discussed.
Cognitive ScienceThe Nature of External Representations in Problem Solving
852 Citations1997Jiajie Zhang
Experimental results show that the behavior in the Tic-Tac-Toe is determined by the directly available information in external and internal representations in terms of perceptual and cognitive biases, regardless of whether the biases are consistent with, inconsistent with, or irrelevant to the task.
Cognitive ScienceA cognitive theory of graphical and linguistic reasoning: Logic and implementation
385 Citations1995Keith Stenning
The theory proposes that graphical representations limit abstraction and thereby aid processibility, and considers how the architecture of working memory explains why such specific representations are relatively easy to store.
Computers & Mathematics with ApplicationsDiagrammatic reasoning: Cognitive and computational perspectives
379 Citations1996
Diagrammatic Reasoning brings together recent investigations into the cognitive, the logical, and particularly the computational characteristics of diagrammatic representations and the reasoning that can be done with them.
Cognitive ScienceAbstract Planning and Perceptual Chunks: Elements of Expertise in Geometry
370 Citations1990Kenneth R. Koedinger, John R. Anderson
It is argued that the particular and efficient knowledge organization of DC challenges current theories of skill acquisition as it presents an end-state of learning that is difficult to explain within such theories.
Cognitive ScienceA Cognitive Theory of Graphical and Linguistic Reasoning: Logic and Implementation
315 Citations1995Keith Stenning, Jon Oberlander
It is proposed that graphical representations limit abstraction and thereby aid processibility and how the architecture of working memory explains why such speci c representations are relatively easy to store is considered.
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal BehaviorIndividual differences in the verification of sentence—picture relationships
282 Citations1978Colin M. MacLeod, Earl Hunt +1 more
British Journal of Educational PsychologyThe effect of cognitive style and mode of presentation on learning performance
207 Citations1993Richard Riding, Graeme Douglas
It was found that the Verbal-Imagery cognitive style and presentation condition interacted in their effect on overall learning performance (p < .05), and it was observed that Imagers used more diagrams to illustrate their answers than Verbalisers.
Cognitive ScienceSome demonstrations of the effects of structural descriptions in mental imagery
175 Citations1979Geoffrey E. Hinton
Memory & CognitionOn the coding of spatial information
168 Citations1977Jean M. Mandler, Dale Seegmiller +1 more
It was concluded that a great deal of location information is automatically coded into long-term memory storage in the sense that active processing is not required.
Cognitive ScienceSome Demonstrations of the Effects of Structural Descriptions in Mental Imagery*
152 Citations1979Geoffrey E. Hinton
The difficulty of certain mental imagery tasks is shown to depend on which of the alternative structural descriptions of an object is used, and this is interpreted as evidence that structural descriptions are an important component of mental images.
Supporting the use of external representation in problem solving: the need for flexible learning environments
150 Citations1995Richard Cox, Paul Brna
Subjects’ prior knowledge of ER formalisms was shown to be an important determiner of effective ER use and the importance of a number of issues relevant to support both for analytical reasoning and for problem solving in general are indicated.
CognitionTwo modes of mental representation and problem solution in syllogistic reasoning
134 Citations1995Marilyn Ford
The theory of syllogistic reasoning proposed by Johnson-Laird (1983, 1986) is shown to be inadequate and an alternative theory is put forward and Protocols of people attempting to solve syllogism problems and explaining to another person how they reached their conclusions were obtained.
Memory & CognitionVisual discovery in mind and on paper
82 Citations1993Rita E. Anderson, Tore Helstrup
Differences in performance in the visual synthesis task with and without external drawing support are interpreted in terms of limited cognitive resources.
Memory & CognitionComprehension as affected by structure of problem representation
82 Citations1976Richard E. Mayer
A problem-like branching system describing what prizes were awarded for particular outcomes of a tournament of games among three teams was presented to 200 subjects as either a verbal list with “go to” structure (Jump), a shortened verbal list (Short-Jump), nested verbal paragraphs with ‘if ... then..., else’ structure (Nest).
Journal of Memory and LanguageInterpretational errors in syllogistic reasoning
82 Citations1989Stephen E. Newstead
Memory & CognitionOn-line processing of textual illustrations in the visuospatial sketchpad: Evidence from dual-task studies
67 Citations1994Peter Kruley, Sonia C. Sciama +1 more
It is shown that the comprehension of illustrated texts does not differentially interfere with a verbal short-term memory task, consistent with the claim that illustrations accompanying a text encourage the formation of a spatial mental model with the use of the working memory's sketchpad.
The Psychology of learning and motivation/The psychology of learning and motivationAlternative Representations
66 Citations1988Ruth S. Day
Advances in psychologyCognitive Technology - In Search of a Humane Interface
62 Citations1996
Cognitive technology and differential topology: The importance of shape features (T.H. Kunii).
Learning Disability QuarterlyDiagramming a Logic Strategy: Effects on Difficult Problem Types and Transfer
54 Citations1990Bonnie Grossen, Doug Carnine
Computer-assisted instructional treatments in syllogistic reasoning were effective in producing better-than-chance scores, improving performance on difficult problem types, and teaching learning disabled students to perform complex logical-thinking tasks to a level equivalent to that of high-achieving populations.
Contemporary Educational PsychologySearching for Information in Knowledge Maps and Texts
48 Citations1993Angela M. O’Donnell
Instructional ScienceThe interrelations between diagrammatic representations and verbal explanations in learning from social science texts
36 Citations1988Sarah Guri‐Rozenblit
The Journal of PsychologySpatial Visualization in Solving Complex Verbal Problems
35 Citations1969Arden N. Frandsen, James R. Holder
Journal of Experimental Child PsychologyChildren's understanding of class inclusion hierarchies: The relationship between external representation and task performance
32 Citations1989Terry R. Greene
Children's responses to questions, as well as their external representations, suggested that children as young as second grade have substantial understanding of hierarchical relations, and a strong relationship between the quality of children's external representations and their performance on question tasks requiring both recognition and reasoning.
Edinburgh Research Archive (University of Edinburgh)Analytical reasoning with multiple external representations
31 Citations1996Richard Jeffrey Cox
British Journal of PsychologyThe sentence—picture verification task: Methodological and theoretical difficulties
13 Citations1994Maxwell J. Roberts, David Wood +1 more
Graphical effects in learning logic: reasoning, representation and individual differences
13 Citations2019Richard Cox, Keith Stenning +1 more
Comparing the effects of teaching undergraduate logic classes using Hyperproof and a control syntactic teaching method indicates that there is significant transfer from the logic courses to logical and analytical reasoning problems, and provides support for the important practical conclusion that individual differences in aptitude should be taken into account in choosing teaching.
Learning From Explanations: Diagrams can "Inhibit" the Self- Explanation Effect
11 Citations1997Bernadette Wilkin
The Journal of Cognitive ScienceThe effect of graphical and sentential logic teaching on spontaneous external representation
11 Citations1995Richard Cox, Keith Stenning +1 more
Resins comprising cross-linked copolymers of aromatic vinyl compounds having dithioic acid groups and the process for the preparation thereof are disclosed.
Nottingham ePrints (University of Nottingham)Designing and evaluating multi-representational learning environments for primary mathematics
5 Citations1997Shaaron Aınsworth
The design and evaluation of multi-representational learning environments that teach aspects of number sense and the effects of MERs are reported, finding that providing a tabular representation of solutions in addition to the familiar row and column representation improved learning.
Advances in psychologyChapter 15 Teaching syllogistic to the blind
3 Citations1996Laurence Goldstein
This chapter describes a device, in fact, two devices that were designed to help blind students learn a simple fragment of elementary logic—the theory of syllogisms which originated over two thousand years ago with the work of Aristotle.