Screening Women and Elderly Adults for Family and Intimate Partner Violence: A Review of the Evidence for the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force
Annals of Internal MedicinePublished 2 March 2004
Heidi D Nelson, Peggy Nygren, Yasmin McInerney, Jonathan D. Klein
Citations290
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score3.38
SNIP3.27
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This report is an update on the current literature on family and intimate partner violence and focuses on studies of the performance of screening instruments designed for the clinical setting and the effectiveness of clinical-based interventions for women and elderly adults.
Abstract
Although the literature on family and intimate partner violence is extensive, few studies provide data on detection and management to guide clinicians.
Keywords
Social Sciences
American Journal of Preventive MedicineRelationship of Childhood Abuse and Household Dysfunction to Many of the Leading Causes of Death in Adults
18,454 Citations1998Vincent J. Felitti, Robert F. Anda +6 more
A strong graded relationship was found between the breadth of exposure to abuse or household dysfunction during childhood and multiple risk factors for several of the leading causes of death in adults.
JAMAChildhood Abuse, Household Dysfunction, and the Risk of Attempted Suicide Throughout the Life Span
2,226 Citations2001Shanta R. Dube, Robert F. Anda +4 more
A powerful graded relationship exists between adverse childhood experiences and risk of attempted suicide throughout the life span, and alcoholism, depressed affect, and illicit drug use, which are strongly associated with such experiences, appear to partially mediate this relationship.
American Journal of Preventive MedicineCurrent methods of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force
1,734 Citations2001Russell Harris, Mark Helfand +5 more
This paper summarizes the current methods of the third USPSTF, supported by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and two of the AHRQ Evidence-based Practice Centers (EPCs), and examines a variety of methodologic issues and document work group progress in future communications.
American Journal of Public HealthRisk Factors for Femicide in Abusive Relationships: Results From a Multisite Case Control Study
1,533 Citations2003Jacquelyn C. Campbell, Daniel Webster +16 more
There are identifiable risk factors for intimate partner femicides and they include perpetrator's access to a gun and previous threat with a weapon, perpetrator's stepchild in the home, and estrangement, especially from a controlling partner.
JAMADating Violence Against Adolescent Girls and Associated Substance Use, Unhealthy Weight Control, Sexual Risk Behavior, Pregnancy, and Suicidality
1,232 Citations2001Jay G. Silverman
Data from both surveys indicate that physical and sexual dating violence against adolescent girls is associated with increased risk of substance use, unhealthy weight control, sexual risk behavior, pregnancy, and suicidality.
Archives of Family MedicinePhysical Health Consequences of Physical and Psychological Intimate Partner Violence
1,159 Citations2000Ann L. Coker
JAMAAssessing for Abuse During Pregnancy
1,012 Citations1992Judith McFarlane
A simple clinical assessment screen completed by the health care provider in a private setting and with the male partner absent is as effective as research instruments in identifying abused women.
PsycEXTRA DatasetPrevalence, Incidence, and Consequences of Violence Against Women: Findings From the National Violence Against Women Survey.
927 Citations1998Patricia Tjaden, Nancy Thoennes
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineA 12-Year Prospective Study of the Long-term Effects of Early Child Physical Maltreatment on Psychological, Behavioral, and Academic Problems in Adolescence
836 Citations2002Jennifer E. Lansford, Kenneth A. Dodge +4 more
Adolescents maltreated early in life were absent from school more than 1.5 as many days, were less likely to anticipate attending college compared with nonmaltreated adolescents, and had levels of aggression, anxiety/depression, dissociation, posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms, social problems, thought problems, and social withdrawal that were on average more than three quarters of an SD higher than those of their nonmALTreated counterparts.
Annals of Internal MedicineThe “Battering Syndrome”: Prevalence and Clinical Characteristics of Domestic Violence in Primary Care Internal Medicine Practices
745 Citations1995Jeanne McCauley, David E. Kern +7 more
The prevalence of domestic violence among female patients presenting to four community-based, primary care, adult medicine practices that serve patients of diverse socioeconomic background was determined and demographic and clinical differences between currently abused patients and patients not currently being abused were identified.
Journal of Women s Health & Gender-Based MedicineSocial Support Protects against the Negative Effects of Partner Violence on Mental Health
655 Citations2002Ann L. Coker, Paige Hall Smith +4 more
Ass associations between intimate partner violence (IPV) and mental health outcomes and the protective role of abuse disclosure and support on mental health among abused women are determined.
JAMADomestic violence against women. Incidence and prevalence in an emergency department population
604 Citations1995Jean Abbott
The incidence of acute DV is not as common among women visiting an ED as previously reported, although the cumulative prevalence of DV is strikingly high.
PubMedHITS: a short domestic violence screening tool for use in a family practice setting.
593 Citations1998K. Sherin, James Sinacore +3 more
The HITS scale showed good internal consistency and concurrent validity with the CTS verbal and physical aggression items, and showed good construct validity in its ability to differentiate family practice patients from abuse victims.
Psychiatric Clinics of North AmericaMENTAL AND PHYSICAL HEALTH EFFECTS OF INTIMATE PARTNER VIOLENCE ON WOMEN AND CHILDREN
589 Citations1997Jacquelyn C. Campbell, Linda Lewandowski
Current knowledge regarding the mental and physical health effects of intimate partner violence on women and their children is highlighted, and needed directions for screening, intervention, research, and changes in the health care system are discussed.
JAMAInterventions for Violence Against Women
514 Citations2003C. Nadine Wathen, Harriet L. MacMillan
Much has been learned in recent years about the epidemiology of violence against women, yet information about evidence-based approaches in the primary care setting for preventing intimate partner violence is seriously lacking.
BMJShould health professionals screen women for domestic violence? Systematic review
510 Citations2002Jean Ramsay, Jo Richardson +3 more
Although domestic violence is a common problem with major health consequences for women, implementation of screening programmes in healthcare settings cannot be justified and evidence of the benefit of specific interventions and lack of harm from screening is needed.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineThe Cycle of Violence
500 Citations1996Michael G. Maxfield
Assessment of the long-term effects of child abuse and neglect on delinquency, adult criminality, and violent criminal behavior in a metropolitan area in the Midwest found childhood victims of abuse or neglect were more likely than controls to have a juvenile or adult arrest for any nontraffic offense.
PsychiatryChronic Community Violence: What Is Happening to Our Children?
451 Citations1993Joy D. Osofsky, Sarah Wewers +2 more
Chronic violence is a growing problem in society today as evidenced by the ever-increasing murder rate in many of the authors' large urban centers in the United States, and the effects on the children who must grow up in environments where they are repeatedly being exposed to significant levels of violence are not addressed adequately.
JAMAAccuracy of 3 Brief Screening Questions for Detecting Partner Violence in the Emergency Department
412 Citations1997Kim M. Feldhaus
A partner violence screen (PVS), consisting of 3 questions about past physical violence and perceived personal safety, can detect a large number of women who have a history of partner violence.
International Journal of Trauma NursingAccuracy of 3 brief screening questions for detecting partner violence in the emergency department
397 Citations1997KM Feldhaus, Jane Koziol‐McLain +4 more
Three brief directed questions can detect a large number of women who have a history of partner violence, as well as partially validate this screen against established instruments.
BMJIdentifying domestic violence: cross sectional study in primary care
381 Citations2002Jane Richardson
With the high prevalence of domesticviolence, health professionals should maintain a high level of awareness of the possibility of domestic violence, especially affecting pregnant women, but the case for screening is not yet convincing.
American PsychologistWhat children can tell us about living in danger.
377 Citations1991James Garbarino, Kathleen Kostelny +1 more
On the basis of field work in 5 war zones, the article points to the importance of adult-led "processing" of the young child's experience to his or her psychological coping and moral development.
JAMAPrevalence of Intimate Partner Abuse in Women Treated at Community Hospital Emergency Departments
338 Citations1998Stephen R. Dearwater
If the prevalence of abuse in community hospitals throughout the United States is similar to the range of prevalence estimates found in this study, then heightened awareness of intimate partner abuse is warranted for patients presenting to the ED.
PubMedPrevalence of domestic violence in community practice and rate of physician inquiry.
300 Citations1992L. Kevin Hamberger, David G. Saunders +1 more
Although spouse abuse is common, physicians rarely ask about it and Physicians should be trained to detect and assess abuse among female patients.
PubMedCo-victimization of African-American children who witness violence: effects on cognitive, emotional, and behavioral development.
238 Citations1991Bambade Shakoor, David J. Chalmers
The prevalence of violence and co-victimization among African-American youth in Chicago is reported, with results indicating that 75% of the participating boys and 10% of participating girls had witnessed the shooting, stabbing, robbing, or killing of another person in their own lives.
Research in Nursing & HealthTesting an intervention to prevent further abuse to pregnant women
219 Citations1999Barbara Parker, Judith McFarlane +3 more
Using repeated measures MANCOVA with entry scores as a covariate, it is found significantly less violence reported by women in the intervention group than byWomen in the comparison group.
Archives of Family MedicineDiagnostic and treatment guidelines on elder abuse and neglect
213 Citations1993Sara C. Aravanis
Elder mistreatment may be physical, psychological, or financial, and it may be perpetrated by family members or by other informal or formal caregivers.
Obstetrics and GynecologyBattering in pregnancy: An assessment of two screening methods
212 Citations1995L NORTON, Jeffrey F. Peipert +3 more
Use of a structured screen improves detection rates of battering both before and during pregnancy, enabling clinicians to have a greater opportunity to intervene.
The GerontologistValidation of the Indicators of Abuse (IOA) Screen
210 Citations1998Marcelo Barcellos Reis, Daphné Nahmiash
The study supports the validity of the 29-item set of indicators of the IOA, which discriminates abuse cases from nonabuse cases and suggests three main types of abuse signals: caregiver personal problems/issues, care receiver social support shortages and past abuse.
PubMedApplication of the Woman Abuse Screening Tool (WAST) and WAST-short in the family practice setting.
192 Citations2000Judith Belle Brown, Barbara Lent +2 more
The WAST was found to be a reliable and valid measure of abuse in the family practice setting, with both patients and family physicians reporting comfort with it being part of the clinical encounter.
Annals of Emergency MedicineBattered Women: Injury Locations and Types
191 Citations1996Robert L. Muelleman, Patricia A. Lenaghan +1 more
Although battered women experience certain injury types more frequently than women injured by other mechanisms, the low positive predictive value of these injuries supports the use of universal screening for domestic violence in all injured women.
Public Health NursingAssessing for Abuse: Self‐Report Versus Nurse Interview
187 Citations1991Judith McFarlane, Karen Christoffel +3 more
Planned Parenthood of Houston and Southeast Texas added four self-reported abuse assessment questions to their standard intake form completed by all initial and annual-visit clients, and the prevalence of physical abuse after one month of self-report was 7.3%.
Maternal and Child Health JournalWomen's Lives After an HIV-Positive Diagnosis: Disclosure and Violence
176 Citations2000Andrea C. Gielen, Karen A. McDonnell +2 more
Identifying women at risk for abuse after an HIV-positive diagnosis is important for those who provide HIV testing and care and routine screening for interpersonal violence should be incorporated into HIV posttest counseling and continuing primary care services.
Public Health NursingAn Evaluation of Interventions to Decrease Intimate Partner Violence to Pregnant Women
176 Citations2000Judith McFarlane, Karen L. Soeken +1 more
A longitudinal study with repeated evaluation interviews at 2, 6, 12, and 18-months postdelivery showed that severity of abuse decreased significantly across time for all intervention groups and the use of lay outreach for abused pregnant women merits further research.
Journal of Applied GerontologyValidation of the Hwalek-Sengstock Elder Abuse Screening Test
163 Citations1991A. V. Neale, Melanie Hwalek +3 more
The data suggest that this short, easy-to-administer screening device can be useful to service providers interested in identifying people at high risk of the need for protective services.
PubMedThe factors associated with disclosure of intimate partner abuse to clinicians.
158 Citations2001Maria Alma Rodriguez, W.R. Sheldon +2 more
Clinician inquiry appears to be one of the strongest determinants of communication with patients about partner abuse and other factors that need to be addressed include patient perceptions regarding clinicians' time and interest in discussing abuse, fear of police or court involvement, and patient concerns about confidentiality.
Journal of Adolescent HealthExposure to violence and victimization and fighting behavior by urban black adolescents
152 Citations1994Robert H. DuRant, Robert A. Pendergrast +1 more
Data support the hypothesis that exposure to, and being a victim of, violence is associated with the frequency of fighting by adolescents, and adolescents who are future-oriented and goal-directed and from more secure families are hypothesized to report less fighting behavior.
Journal of Emergency NursingIntimate partner violence screening and intervention: Data from eleven Pennsylvania and California community hospital emergency departments
147 Citations2001Nancy Glass, Stephen Dearwater +1 more
Evidence is provided supporting standard protocols for routine screening for IPV among women who come to emergency departments and chart prompts for both screening and interventions and should be considered in systematic repeated training of health care professionals in emergency departments.
Canadian Journal on Aging / La Revue canadienne du vieillissementValidation of the Caregiver Abuse Screen (CASE)
145 Citations1995Myrna Reis, Daphné Nahmiash
Journal of General Internal MedicinePrevalence of domestic violence among patients in three ambulatory care internal medicine clinics
144 Citations1991Nancy Gin, Lloyd Rucker +3 more
Physicians should ask their patients routinely about domestic violence and, when domestic violence is present, should offer emotional support, information about social service agencies, and psychological care, the study found.
Obstetrics and GynecologyAdverse childhood experiences and risk of paternity in teen pregnancy,
138 Citations2002Robert F. Anda
Adverse childhood experiences have an important relationship to male involvement in teen pregnancy, and this relationship has persisted throughout four successive birth cohorts dating back to 1900–1929, suggesting that the effects of adverse childhood experiences transcend changing sexual mores and contraceptive methods.
PEDIATRICSBarriers to Domestic Violence Screening in the Pediatric Setting
138 Citations2001Mary J. Erickson, Teresa D. Hill +1 more
Great efforts are needed to educate pediatricians on DV for the AAP recommendations to be accepted, and those with DV training were 10.9 times (odds adjusted ratio) more likely to screen.
Clinical Psychology ReviewTreatment strategies for child physical abuse and neglect: a critical progress report
124 Citations1993David A. Wolfe, Christine Wekerle
Findings support the significance of parent-focused interventions that include well-specified training components aimed at improving child-rearing competence and stress management and show value in regaining some of the developmental milestones and peer competencies often lagging in maltreated children.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineEffect of Abuse on Health
120 Citations2002Ángela Díaz, Elisabeth Simantov +1 more
The magnitude of risk for adolescents reporting both types of abuse compared with no abuse is much greater than that for either abuse type alone.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineMothers' and Health Care Providers' Perspectives on Screening for Intimate Partner Violence in a Pediatric Emergency Department
105 Citations2002M. Denise Dowd, Christopher Kennedy +2 more
Intimate partner violence screening protocols in the pediatric emergency department should take into consideration the beliefs and attitudes of both those doing the screening and those being screened.
PubMedAssessment of clinical partner violence screening tools.
99 Citations2001Ann L. Coker, Brian Pope +3 more
Clinicians need validated screening tools to rapidly and reliably screen patients for IPV and the WEB was more strongly associated with self-perceived mental health, anxiety, depression, drug abuse, and low social support than the ISA-P.
MidwiferyWomen's attitudes to being asked about exposure to violence
92 Citations2001Kristina Stenson, Hilkka Saarinen +2 more
The findings suggest that most pregnant women are not averse to being asked, by their midwife, about exposure to violence, and as part of the identification of risk factors that is carried out in every pregnancy, the midwife should ask about Exposure to violence at the antenatal clinic.
JAMAIs Domestic Violence Screening Helpful?
86 Citations2000Thomas B. Cole
It is unlikely that screening had a major impact on rates of violence against women because few physicians routinely screen their patients for intimate partner abuse unless they have injuries, and it is not possible to make inferences about the effect of screening without data.
PubMedRates of domestic violence against adult women by men partners.
86 Citations1989G D Rath, L G Jarratt +1 more
Boyfriends not cohabitating were the least abusive, while couples together for 4 to 6 years had more domestic violence than other couples, and women whose partners had less formal education were at greater risk for verbal and physical abuse.
Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic & Neonatal NursingAttitudes and Practices of Registered Nurses Toward Women Who Have Experienced Abuse/Domestic Violence
81 Citations1998Mary Moore, Dan Zaccaro +1 more
Comparing the education, attitudes, and practices related to domestic violence of perinatal nurses from three types of practice sites found differences in the attitudes and beliefs of nurses from different practice sites, but more differences were found in their behaviors.
OJIN The Online Journal of Issues in NursingIntimate Partner Violence in African American Women
72 Citations2002Doris W. Campbell, Phyllis Sharps +3 more
Examining existing empirical studies of prevalence and health outcomes of intimate partner violence against women in general, plus what limited research there is about African American women, specifically, finds that there is a paucity of research and interventions specific and culturally relevant for these women.
MidwiferyWomen's responses to screening for domestic violence in a health-care setting
68 Citations2001Joan Webster, Susan Stratigos +1 more
Women in Queensland found screening for domestic violence acceptable and, where health providers are suitably educated, it should be included when taking a routine health history.
PubMedScreening for abuse in Spanish-speaking women.
68 Citations2002Colleen T. Fogarty, Judith Belle Brown
The Spanish version of the WAST successfully discriminated between Spanish-speaking nonabused and abused women, and a short form using the two most reliable questions was developed as a more rapid screening tool for office use.
Journal of Emergency MedicineImproving the Emergency Department detection rate of domestic violence using direct questioning
64 Citations2000Laurie J. Morrison, Rebecca Allan +1 more
It is indicated that the use of simple, direct questioning significantly improves the detection rate of DV in the ED and is significant at p < 0.001.
Women & HealthThe Impact of Perceived Barriers on Primary Care Physicians' Screening Practices for Female Partner Abuse
64 Citations2002Linda Chamberlain, Katherine A. Perham-Hester
Primary care physicians have not integrated screening for partner abuse into routine care and strategies to increase awareness of the high prevalence of abuse in the primary care setting and to educate providers on the negative health effects of victimization can help physicians to acknowledge their responsibility in addressing abuse and the importance of screening at routine visits.
PEDIATRICSParental Screening for Intimate Partner Violence by Pediatricians and Family Physicians
62 Citations2002Iris W. Borowsky, Marjorie Ireland
Few child and adolescent primary care physicians routinely screen parents for intimate partner violence and most need more information on this topic, but residency training and continuing medical education on violence prevention, including screening and intervention skills in intimate partnerviolence, and office protocols for managing cases of domestic violence could increase screening rates.
The Annals of Family MedicineScreening Children for Family Violence: A Review of the Evidence for the US Preventive Services Task Force
60 Citations2004Peggy Nygren
Clinician referrals to nurse home visitation during pregnancy and in early childhood may reduce abuse in selected populations and no trials of the effectiveness of screening in a health care setting have been published.
Annals of Emergency MedicineComparison of Domestic Violence Screening Methods: A Pilot Study
58 Citations1998Paul M. Furbee, Rosanna Sikora +2 more
The results indicate that the alternative method of employing a recorded questionnaire was no less effective than the best efforts of a designated and conscientious physician as a means of quickly assessing the prevalence of DV in an ED setting.
Maternal and Child Health JournalPhysicians' Screening Practices for Female Partner Abuse During Prenatal Visits
56 Citations2000Linda Chamberlain, Katherine A. Perham-Hester
Most Alaskan physicians do not routinely screen for abuse during prenatal visits and should increase physicians' index of suspicion for abuse, emphasize physicians' responsibility to address partner abuse, and reinforce the importance of routine screening throughout the pregnancy.
American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyDomestic abuse in pregnancy: A comparison of a self-completed domestic abuse questionnaire with a directed interview
52 Citations1999Joseph Canterino, Linda VanHorn +3 more
A standardized domestic abuse questionnaire is superior to a directed interview in identifying self-reported domestic abuse in pregnancy and Utilizing both methods in parallel further increases the number of patients identified.
PubMedEvaluating domestic partner abuse in a family practice clinic.
46 Citations1997Helen S. Pan, Miriam K. Ehrensaft +3 more
The Partner Abuse Interview is a simple and reliable instrument that could be adapted for use by medical personnel to assess incidents of abuse among patients.
Women & HealthA Population-Based Survey Assessing Support for Mandatory Domestic Violence Reporting by Health Care Personnel
40 Citations2002Carolyn J. Sachs, Jane Koziol‐McLain +3 more
Most women support mandatory reporting by health care personnel, however, abused women were significantly less supportive than those not abused, and reporting would increase the risk of perpetrator retaliation.
Journal of women's healthWife Abuse: Are We Detecting It?
35 Citations1992Rui Martins, Stephen Holzapfel +1 more
Wife abuse is reported in at least 8% of the authors' patients, and family physician documentation of wife abuse was poor, including homicide, suicide, and rape.
PubMedComparison of three instruments for assessing ongoing intimate partner violence.
31 Citations2002Amy A. Ernst, Steve J Weiss +2 more
The OAS (Ongoing Abuse Screen, OAS) was created by changing the AAS to specifically request information related to 'ongoing' IPV and resulted in rates different from that of the A AS and may be more specific to ongoing IPV than the Aas and more sensitive than a single question about DV.
Military MedicineEvaluation of Spouse Abuse Treatment: Description and Evaluation of the Air Force Family Advocacy Programs for Spouse Physical Abuse
25 Citations2002Albert L. Brewster, Joel S. Milner +3 more
After treatment compared with before treatment, professionals rated offenders as less at risk, and the offenders indicated general satisfaction with the Family Advocacy Program services, and objective measures indicated that offenders showed significant decreases in family conflict and child abuse risk and significant increases in family cohesion, family expression, and marital satisfaction.
Journal of Nursing MeasurementAssessing Abuse Among the Elderly Living in Public Housing
19 Citations2000Linda E. Moody, Audrey A. Voss +1 more
This study assessed the psychometric properties of an existing instrument, the Hwalek-Sengstock Elder Abuse Screening Test (HSEAST), which has been tested in only two studies and showed that 6 items were as effective as the 9-item model in classifying cases as abused.
AIDS and BehaviorPsychosocial Adjustment of Women to Living with HIV/AIDS
15 Citations1999Daniel Karus, Karolynn Siegel +1 more
It is suggested that, while all HIV-infected women may be at risk for problematic psychosocial adjustment to living with HIV/AIDS, Puerto RicanWomen may be especially vulnerable.
PubMedDomestic violence: recognition, intervention, and prevention.
14 Citations1995Marjorie Smith, Francisco Bocanegra Martín
Nursing professionals should play a major role in primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention interventions to reduce the incidence of domestic violence in the future.
…