Methodologies analysing individual practice in health care: a systematic review
Journal of Advanced NursingPublished 22 July 2001
Tessa Watts, Melanie Jones, Paul Wainwright, Anne Williams
Citations18
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.40
SNIP1.69
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The authors conclude that the assessment of health care roles and responsibilities would be well served by a more balanced approach that recognizes the strengths of both quantitative and qualitative work.
Abstract
AIM OF THE REVIEW: The aim of the systematic review was to identify, explore and evaluate the current level of knowledge of methodologies used in comparative analyses of the individual practice of doctors, nurses and midwives. RATIONALE: The question of how roles and responsibilities might be shared differently between professional groups in order to promote improved, cost-effective health care requires a systematic analysis of existing roles and practice. To do this effectively, knowledge of the methodologies available for such an analysis is essential. METHODS: A systematic review of the literature published since 1989 comparing the practice of doctors, nurses and midwives was undertaken. FINDINGS: The findings are presented in tabular format and include the following categories of published methodologies: experimental/quasi-experimental; descriptive/nonexperimental and qualitative studies. The discussion centres on a critique of quantitative methodologies used to analyse individual practice in relation to role substitution and diversification. The potential contribution of qualitative methodologies in the analysis of individual practice is discussed. CONCLUSIONS: The authors conclude that the current level of knowledge is biased towards quantitative research. It is argued that the assessment of health care roles and responsibilities would be well served by a more balanced approach that recognizes the strengths of both quantitative and qualitative work.
Keywords
Health ProfessionsNursing
Qualitative Health ResearchRationale and Standards for the Systematic Review of Qualitative Literature in Health Services Research
998 Citations1998Jennie Popay, Anne Rogers +1 more
It is argued that three interrelated criteria can be identified as the foundation of good qualitative health research: interpretation of subjective meaning, description of social context, and attention to lay knowledge.
European Journal of Public HealthEnsuring rigour in qualitative research
587 Citations1997C Seale
A general review is followed by a detailed illustration of selected techniques, including the use of counting in qualitative research, the development of systematic coding schemes with the aid of computer programmes, searching for deviant cases and the useof the transcription techniques of conversation analysis.
BMJRandomised controlled trial comparing cost effectiveness of general practitioners and nurse practitioners in primary care
494 Citations2000P. Venning
If nurse practitioners were able to maintain the benefits while reducing their return consultation rate or shortening consultation times, they could be more cost effective than general practitioners.
American Journal of Public HealthThe safety of home birth: the farm study.
454 Citations1992A. Mena Durán
Pregnancy outcomes of 1707 women, who enrolled for care with a home birth service run by lay midwives in rural Tennessee, were compared with outcomes from 14,033 physician-attended hospital deliveries derived from the 1980 US National Natality/National Fetal Mortality Survey to suggest that, under certain circumstances, home births can be accomplished as safely as, and with less intervention than, hospital deliveries.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Burlington Randomized Trial of the Nurse Practitioner
437 Citations1974Walter O. Spitzer, David L. Sackett +16 more
A randomized controlled trial was conducted to assess the effects of substituting nurse practitioners for physicians in primary-care practice, and the quality of care rendered seemed similar, as assessed by a quantitative "indicator-condition" approach.
BMJ Quality & SafetyQualitative methods for assessing health care.
303 Citations1994Ray Fitzpatrick, Mary Boulton
The evaluation of health care and efforts to maintain and improve quality in health care have very largely drawn on quantitative methods.
The LancetCare of minor injuries by emergency nurse practitioners or junior doctors: a randomised controlled trial
254 Citations1999M Sakr, Jan Angus +4 more
Properly trained accident and emergency nurse practitioners, who work within agreed guidelines can provide care for patients with minor injuries that is equal or in some ways better than that provided by junior doctors.
BMJHow to read a paper: Assessing the methodological quality of published papers
231 Citations1997Trisha Greenhalgh
It may be perfectly valid to do a study which is, on the face of it, "unoriginal," but the whole science of meta-analysis depends on the literature containing more than one study that has addressed a question in much the same way.
The LancetRandomised, controlled trial of efficacy of midwife-managed care
230 Citations1996Deborah Tumbull, Ann Holmes +10 more
It is concluded that midwife-managed care for healthy women, integrated within existing services, is clinically effective and enhances women's satisfaction with maternity care.
Annals of Internal MedicineThe Burlington Randomized Trial of the Nurse Practitioner: Health Outcomes of Patients
194 Citations1974David L. Sackett, WALTER O. SPITZER +11 more
In a randomized trial of nurse practitioners as providers of primary clinical services, attention was devoted to the "outcomes" of clinical effectiveness and safety.
BMJMidwife managed delivery unit: a randomised controlled comparison with consultant led care
186 Citations1994Vanora Hundley, F M Cruickshank +7 more
Midwife managed intrapartum care for low risk women results in more mobility and less intervention with no increase in neonatal morbidity, however, the high rate of transfer shows that antenatal criteria are unable to determine who will remain at low risk throughout pregnancy and labour.
New England Journal of MedicineNurse Clinics and Progressive Ambulatory Patient Care
179 Citations1967Charles E. Lewis, Barbara A. Resnik
JAMARoles of Nonphysician Clinicians as Autonomous Providers of Patient Care
166 Citations1998Richard A. Cooper
Assessment of practice prerogatives of nonphysician clinicians in 10 disciplines found that a health care workforce that includes a diversity of disciplines can be assured of providing a coherent set of patient care services in the future.
MidwiferyThe ‘Know Your Midwife’ scheme—a randomised trial of continuity of care by a team of midwives
163 Citations1989C Flint, Polly Poulengeris +1 more
A team of four midwives provided the majority of care during pregnancy, labour and the puerperium to 503 women at low obstetric risk, over a 2-year period, associated with greater continuity in all phases of maternity care.
Lara D. VeekenAN EVALUATION OF THE EFFECTIVENESS, SAFETY AND ACCEPTABILITY OF A NURSE PRACTITIONER IN A RHEUMATOLOGY OUTPATIENT CLINIC
159 Citations1994Jackie Hill, H. A. Bird +3 more
Between group comparisons also showed significant differences by the end of the study, and in patients managed by the RNP, pain, morning stiffness, psychological status, patient knowledge and satisfaction had all improved significantly.
BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics & GynaecologyA systematic review comparing continuity of midwifery care with standard maternity services
141 Citations1998Ulla Waldenström, Deborah Turnbull
This review of randomised controlled trials of alternative maternity services characterised by continuity of midwifery care in Northern Ireland found that these services should be considered as safe and effective for women in need of maternity care.
Journal of Advanced NursingEthical reasoning in nurses’ and physicians’ stories about care episodes
136 Citations1992Giggi Udén, Astrid Norberg +2 more
It turned out that nurses and physicians related different kinds of stories, and seemed to use different kind of ethical reasoning in these stories.
American Journal of Public HealthInterspecialty differences in the obstetric care of low-risk women.
123 Citations1997Roger A. Rosenblatt, S Dobie +7 more
The low-risk patients of certified nurse-midwives in Washington State received fewer obstetrical interventions than similar patients cared for by obstetrician-gynecologists or family physicians, with lower cesarean section rates and less resource use.
Journal of Health Services Research & PolicyCatching Goldfish: Quality in Qualitative Research
123 Citations1998Robert Dingwall, Elizabeth Murphy +3 more
This paper reviews the contribution of qualitative methods to health services research (HSR) and discusses some of the issues involved in recognizing quality in such work.
BirthA Randomized, Controlled Trial of Nurse‐Midwifery Care
111 Citations1996Sheila Harvey, John Jarrell +3 more
The results clearly support the effectiveness of the pilot nurse-midwifery program and suggest that more extensive participation of midwives in the Canadian health care system is an appropriate use of health care dollars.
BMJShould obstetricians see women with normal pregnancies? A multicentre randomised controlled trial of routine antenatal care by general practitioners and midwives compared with shared care led by obstetricians
109 Citations1996Janet Tucker, M H Hall +5 more
There was no net benefit from routine specialist antenatal visits for women initially at low risk of pregnancy complications, and care by general practitioners and midwives improved continuity of care and acceptability of allocated style of care.
Health PolicySkill mix changes: substitution or service development?
106 Citations1998Gerald Richardson, Alan Maynard +2 more
An extensive review of published studies where doctors were replaced by other health professions demonstrates considerable scope for alterations in skill mix, however, the studies reported are often dated and have design deficiencies.
New England Journal of MedicineActivities, Events and Outcomes in Ambulatory Patient Care
104 Citations1969Charles E. Lewis, Barbara A. Resnik +2 more
Most efforts to measure the quality of care have attempted to analyze either the process of giving care or the outcomes or results of care, but studies of both types have been limited by methodologic problems.
PubMedNurse practitioner role in a chronic congestive heart failure clinic: in-hospital time, costs, and patient satisfaction.
96 Citations1983G Cintrón, C Bigas +3 more
In-hospital time and yearly medical costs decreased markedly and patient satisfaction increased after institution of the NP chronic congestive heart failure clinic.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipContent and Process in Clinical Decision‐Making by Nurse Practitioners
88 Citations1992Joyce E. White, Donna G. Nativio +2 more
It is indicated that nurse practitioners use a process of clinical decision-making in which diagnostic hypotheses drive data acquisition and both experienced and inexperienced family nurse practitioners were more likely to acquire subjective and objective data that did not appear to be hypothesis driven.
BMJFeasibility and effects of nurse run clinics for patients with epilepsy in general practice: randomised controlled trial
87 Citations1997Leone Ridsdale, Diana L. Robins +2 more
This study shows that nurse run clinics set up to provide such information and monitoring in six general practices were well attended by patients with epilepsy and significantly improve the level of advice and drug management recorded.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineComparison of Neonatal Nurse Practitioners, Physician Assistants, and Residents in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
75 Citations1994Ronald P. Carzoli
Neonatal nurse practitioners and physician assistants are an effective alternative to residents for patient care in the neonatal intensive care unit and demonstrated no significant differences in management, outcome, or charge variables between patients cared for by the two teams.
RePEc: Research Papers in EconomicsFewer doctors? More nurses? A review of the knowledge base of doctor-nurse substitution
75 Citations1995Gerald Richardson, Alan Maynard
An estimate of the potential savings arising from altering the skill mix must at present remain speculative because the evidence base is very small, with most of the studies having significant defects in their design.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Child-Health Nurse (Pediatric Nurse Practitioner) in Private Practice
71 Citations1971Evan Charney, Harriet Kitzman +9 more
Journal of Nurse-MidwiferyCesarean section rates in low-risk private patients managed by certified nurse-midwives and obstetricians
69 Citations1994Lowell E. Davis, G Riedmann +3 more
Women cared for by nurse-midwife-managed patients had a lower cesarean section rate, fewer interventions, and equally good maternal and infant outcomes when compared with those care for by physicians.
Paediatric and Perinatal EpidemiologyWho should provide routine antenatal care for low‐risk women, and how often? A systematic review of randomised controlled trials
68 Citations1998Dina Khan-Neelofur, A. Metin Gülmezog̈lu +1 more
There is evidence that a midwife's clinic for provision of antenatal care for low-risk pregnancies is feasible and therapy reduction in costs achievable and that women's response regarding the continuity of care favoured midwife-led care.
Intracranial Pressure Monitor Placement by Midlevel Practitioners
64 Citations1998Krista L. Kaups, Steven N. Parks +1 more
Use of midlevel practitioners (MLPs) may aid neurosurgeons in providing prompt monitoring of patients with head injuries and ICP monitor placement by MLPs is safe.
PubMedA cost-effectiveness analysis of neonatal nurse practitioners.
62 Citations1997Robin L. Bissinger, Charlene A. Allred +2 more
In the 35 cases cared for by NNPs, in collaboration with neonatoologists, neonates received care equal in quality to the 35 matched cases care for by medical house staff at lower cost with greater continuity and consistency.
MidwiferySatisfaction with midwife-managed care in different time periods: A randomised controlled trial of 1299 women
60 Citations1998Noreen Shields, Deborah Turnbull +4 more
Midwife-managed care for healthy pregnant women which is integrated into existing services improves satisfaction with antenatal, intrapartum and postnatal care.
PubMedComparison of the work of a nurse practitioner with that of a general practitioner.
54 Citations1988Christopher J. Salisbury, Monica Tettersell
Nurse practitioners are a valuable extra resource for the development of new areas of care, rather than a cheaper substitute for a general practitioner, thus emphasizing the need for flexibility when defining the role.
American Journal of Obstetrics and GynecologyComparison of obstetric outcome of a primary-care access clinic staffed by certified nurse-midwives and a private practice group of obstetricians in the same community
53 Citations1995Howard Blanchette
Low-income, uninsured, and underinsured women who have access to excellent prenatal care with supervised certified nurse-midwives can have obstetric outcomes similar to women having prenatal carewith private obstetricians, according to a retrospective cohort study.
Preventive MedicineAttitudes and Practices for Smoking Cessation Counseling by Provider Type and Patient Age
52 Citations1995Frederick J. Kviz, Melissa A. Clark +5 more
There is a need for provider education, especially among registered/licensed practical nurses, about the benefits of smoking cessation for patients of all ages and the potential effectiveness of provider-based intervention strategies that are targeted toward specific age groups.
Social Science & MedicineMidwifery care and out-of-hospital birth settings: How do they reduce unnecessary cesarean section births?
51 Citations1993Carol Sakala
The present study--together with cohort studies documenting such a reduction, studies showing other benefits of such forms of care, and the increasing reluctance of physicians to provide obstetrical services--suggests that childbearing families would realize many benefits from greatly expanded use of midwives and out-of-hospital birth settings.
Family PracticeSignal versus noise in the evidence base for medicine: an alternative to hierarchies of evidence?
46 Citations1998Adrian Edwards, Ian Russell +1 more
This work proposes a classification of research which does not reject studies on the basis of design alone, but recognizes the importance of assessing the message or 'signal' within each piece of research, and explicitly introduces judgement into the appraisal and synthesis of evidence.
BirthLicensed Midwife‐Attended, Out‐of‐Hospital Births in Washington State: Are They Safe?
46 Citations1994Patricia A. Janssen, Victoria L. Holt +1 more
The results of this study indicate that in Washington state the practice of licensed nonnurse-midwives, whose training meets standards set by international professional organizations, may be as safe as that of physicians in hospital and certified nurse- midwives in and out of hospital.
The Medical Journal of AustraliaAntenatal care of low risk obstetric patients by midwives
44 Citations1992Warwick Giles, Jennifer Collins +2 more
To assess the practicality, acceptability to patients and salary costs of the antenatal care of low risk obstetric patients by midwives, a study of midwives in Northern Ireland found that low risk patients are more likely to be referred to midwives than the general population.
Journal of Advanced NursingTowards a partnership in care: nurses' and doctors' interpretation of extremity trauma radiology
39 Citations1998Pat Overton-Brown, Denis Anthony
Nursing ResearchInteractional Styles of Nurse Practitioners and Physicians Regarding Patient Decision Making
39 Citations1989Susan G. Taylor, Judith M. Pickens +1 more
Tests of a priori hypotheses using hierarchical log-linear modeling yielded the following significant results: Males and physicians in solo practice used more command statements and fewer consequence statements than females and nurse practitioners in soloPractice, who used fewer command Statements and more consequence statements.
Journal of Advanced NursingA comparative study of the attitudes of nursing and medical students to aspects of patient care and the nurse's role in organizing that care
34 Citations1994Assumpta Ryan, Hugh McKenna
Comparison of the attitudes of nursing and medical students toward some issues relating to patient care and the role of the nurse in organizing that care suggests that both nursing andmedical students need to develop a mutual understanding and respect for each other's roles if interprofessional relations are to improve.
MidwiferySafest birth attendants: recent Dutch evidence
33 Citations1991Marjorie Tew, S.M.I. Damstra-Wijmenga
Analysis of national perinatal statistics from Holland, 1986, demonstrates that for all births after 32 weeks' gestation mortality is much lower under the non-interventionist care of midwives than under the interventionist management of obstetricians at all levels of predicted risk.
Nursing StandardRadiotherapy outpatient review: a nurse-led clinic
32 Citations1999J. Campbell, Lesley German +1 more
The results suggest that specialist nursing staff, given appropriate medical support, provide more effective care by using a holistic model for reviewing patients undergoing outpatient radiotherapy.
Social Science & MedicineFrom practice to research: The case for criticism in an age of evidence
32 Citations1998Michael Berkwits
Social critical studies of research and evidence would reveal the many influences similar to these that are relevant to clinical medicine and correct an imbalance in contemporary medicine in which clinicians are being trained to maintain high standards of critical consciousness in methodological domains but not in the broader historical and sociocultural domains which subsume them.
PubMedUsing unannounced standardized patients to assess the HIV preventive practices of family nurse practitioners and family physicians.
31 Citations1998Patricia A. Carney, D H Ward
Determining risk, including condom use, sexual orientation, and number of past sexual partners, was performed less often than experts advise by both physicians and NPs (done between 9% and 63% of encounters).
Holistic Nursing PracticePatient satisfaction with outpatient human immunodeficiency virus care as delivered by nurse practitioners and physicians
29 Citations1995Suzanne R. Langner, Carol M. Hutelmyer
When nurse practitioners were compared with physician providers, however, nurse practitioners fared more favorably in the areas relating to clinic waiting time, provider knowledge about the disease, continuity of care, and patient education.
BMJNursing and the future of primary care
29 Citations2000Steve Iliffe
The four trials of nursing in primary care in this week's BMJ give a better idea of what the future of primary care might look like.
The Nurse PractitionerUsing Unannounced Standardized Patients to Assess the HIV Preventive Practices of Family Nurse Practitioners and Family Physicians
28 Citations1998Patricia A. Carney, Deborah Ward
BMJCommunity obstetric care in West Berkshire.
28 Citations1991P Street, Marie Gannon +1 more
The effects of a revised obstetric booking policy whereby all low risk pregnant women received their antenatal care entirely in the community may safely be provided by their general practitioner and midwife are assessed.
Journal of Advanced NursingThe concept of the specialist community nurse
24 Citations1996Anne Kelly
The main arguments presented are that, although the role of the specialist community nurse will be exposed to constraints from both the medical and managerial culture and tensions within the profession regarding perceptions of professionalization may militate against progress towards specialist status, the concept is a worthy goal and can be underpinned by phenomenological concepts of professionalism.
Nursing StandardCan a mental health nurse be a nurse practitioner?
24 Citations1996Alison Torn, Elaine McNichol
The concept of a mental health nurse practitioner is discussed, alongside the need to clarify other advanced nursing roles, in a larger study examining the role of the nurse practitioner and its potential utility in mental health nursing.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipAppropriateness of Geriatric Prescribing Decisions Made by Nurse Practitioners and Physicians
23 Citations1994D. F. Mahoney
NPs scored higher on an index of appropriateness than physicians a difference that remained whether or not the nurse had regulatory support to prescribe, and recommendations are made for more equitable state prescription policies.
PubMedA rural-urban comparative study of nonphysician providers in community and migrant health centers.
21 Citations2020Lei Shi
Findings demonstrate that the use of nonphysician providers is an important way both to achieve cost containment and improve access to primary care for those residing in medically underserved areas.
Journal of Nurse-MidwiferyPractice stylesA comparison of obstetricians and nurse-midwives
17 Citations1996Judith T. Fullerton, Katherine Hollenbach +1 more
It is suggested that health system administrators should inform women and families about differences in practice styles before families select from among the various insurance options that may, in the end, restrict the choice of provider or birth setting.
BirthA Comparison of Outcomes Between Joint and Physician‐Only Obstetric Practices
17 Citations1994Lynn M. Schimmel, Lynn McCreery Schimmel +4 more
The type of practice from which women receive care is significantly associated with both method of birth and possibility of severe perineal trauma and no significant differences were found in parity, birthweight, or newborn outcomes in the two types of practice.
PubMedA comparison of the evaluation and treatment of cervical dysplasia by gynecologists and nurse practitioners.
14 Citations1998David L. Morris, Cathy H. McLean +2 more
It can be concluded that NPCs are viable alternative providers in the evaluation and treatment of cervical dysplasia and when they were statistically different, NPCs practices were more consistent with generally accepted medical practice.
European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive BiologySurvey of the management of third stage of labour in the Netherlands
12 Citations1996A.N.J.A. de Groot, Jos van Roosmalen +1 more
Routine use of prophylactic oxytocic use in the third stage of labour in the Netherlands is not the standard practice, and Obstetricians are much more likely to use proplylaxis than midwives.
BirthToward Lower Cesarean Birth Rates and Effective Care: Five Years' Outcomes of Joint Private Obstetric Practice
12 Citations1997Lynn M. Schimmel, Leon D. Schimmel +1 more
An obstetric practice in a private community hospital setting that effectively used obstetricians, nurse-midwives, and nurse practitioners reported low rates of cesarean birth, preterm birth, severe lacerations, instrument deliveries, and legal incidents, and excellent cost-effective maternal and neonatal outcomes.
Archives of Internal MedicineThe neglected medical history and therapeutic choices for abdominal pain. A nationwide study of 799 physicians and nurses
12 Citations1991J. Avorn
The Nurse PractitionerA Comparison of the Evaluation and Treatment of Cervical Dysplasia by Gynecologists and Nurse Practitioners
11 Citations1998DONNA L. MORRIS, CATHY H. MCLEAN +2 more
Diabetic MedicinePerceived Needs of General Practitioners and Practice Nurses for the Care of Diabetic Patients
10 Citations1991Elizabeth K. Carr, Bella Kirk +1 more
GPs envisaged that patient education would be a major problem in establishing a diabetes service, but only 58 % identified education as a task that could be accomplished by the practice nurse.
PubMedThe nurse practitioner as a physician substitute in a remote rural community: a case study.
8 Citations1980Roger A. Rosenblatt, B Huard
From the data, three major components of the practice were analyzed: economics, with an emphasis on practice growth and visit pattern; patients' characteristics, demographic and clinical; and medical process variables reflecting the nature of the medical interactions.
Health Informatics JournalEvidence-based policy making in health informatics: indications from systematic reviews of nursing record systems and telemedicine
6 Citations2000Christine Urquhart, Rosemary Currell +1 more
Whether or not there is a problem for information systems evaluation in healthcare, given the contrast between the quantitative and qualitative research approaches is examined, to suggest that a pluralistic approach is highly desirable.
PubMedNurse or doctor: biometry for intraocular lens power calculation, who should measure?
5 Citations1995Craig Ea, Hanna It +3 more
This prospective study shows that appropriately trained nursing staff in the ophthalmology department are able to perform the measurements for biometry at least as accurately as junior medical staff.
Accident and Emergency NursingPlaster checks by nurses: safe and efficient?
1 Citations1996Anne‐Maree Kelly, Spaso Miljesic +2 more
Allowing plaster checks to be performed by nurses, with referral to a doctor if they are concerned, would have reduced the number of plaster checks performed by doctors by twothirds.