Ecological Experimentation: Strengths and Conceptual Problems
Published 1 January 1989
David Tilman
Citations256
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Although this chapter will critically evaluate the potential contributions of experimentation to ecological understanding, it is stressed at the outset that ecological research requires a synthetic approach in which observational, experimental, and theoretical approaches are pursued in a simultaneous, coordinated, interactive manner.
Abstract
The ecological world is a multi-causal system in which patterns result from the direct effects of physical factors, from intraspecific and interspecific biotic interactions, and from indirect and feedback effects of one species or system element on another. As such, there is no single, simple approach that can ever unambiguously demonstrate how or why a particular process, physical factor, or species has an effect on another element of the ecosystem. Although this chapter will critically evaluate the potential contributions of experimentation to ecological understanding, I must stress at the outset that ecological research requires a synthetic approach in which observational, experimental, and theoretical approaches are pursued in a simultaneous, coordinated, interactive manner.
Keywords
Environmental Science
Ecological MonographsPseudoreplication and the Design of Ecological Field Experiments
8,292 Citations1984Stuart H. Hurlbert
Suggestions are offered to statisticians and editors of ecological journals as to how ecologists' under- standing of experimental design and statistics might be improved.
The American Midland NaturalistOn the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection
5,476 Citations1953R. L. Livezey, Charles Darwin
Theoretical Population BiologyPredation, apparent competition, and the structure of prey communities
2,559 Citations1977Robert D. Holt
In order to study the consequences of predator-mediated apparent competition in isolation from other complicating factors, a model community is analyzed in which there is no direct interspecific competition among the prey.
The American NaturalistField Experiments on Interspecific Competition
2,347 Citations1983Thomas W. Schoener
Competition was found in 90% of the studies and 76% of their species, indicating its pervasive importance in ecological systems, and the Hairston-Slobodkin-Smith hypothesis concerning variation in the importance of competition between trophic levels was strongly supported.
Choice Reviews OnlinePlant strategies and the dynamics and structure of plant communities
2,317 Citations1988
The American NaturalistOn the Prevalence and Relative Importance of Interspecific Competition: Evidence from Field Experiments
1,950 Citations1983Joseph H. Connell
The present survey illustrates how difficult it is to produce a clear and unambiguous demonstration of interspecific competition.
NatureThresholds and breakpoints in ecosystems with a multiplicity of stable states
1,711 Citations1977Robert M. May
This review discusses how alternate stable states can arise in simple 1- and 2-species systems, and applies these ideas to grazing systems, to insect pests, and to some human host–parasite systems.
EcologyPerturbation Experiments in Community Ecology: Theory and Practice
1,275 Citations1984Edward A. Bender, Ted J. Case +1 more
The American NaturalistOn the Evidence Needed to Judge Ecological Stability or Persistence
1,191 Citations1983Joseph H. Connell, Wayne P. Sousa
An analysis of census data from many long-term studies revealed a continuum of temporal variability in the dynamics of natural populations and communities, with no evidence of multiple stable states in unexploited natural populations or communities.
Ecological MonographsSecondary Succession and the Pattern of Plant Dominance Along Experimental Nitrogen Gradients
1,081 Citations1987David Tilman
The distributions along the experimental gradients of most of the common species were consistent with the pattern observed in the old—field survey, demonstrating that nitrogen influences the pattern of secondary succession at Cedar Creek.
Cambridge University Press eBooksFrom the Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society
1,079 Citations2011William Parsons
Springer advanced texts in life sciencesQuaternary History and the Stability of Forest Communities
638 Citations1981Margaret B. Davis
The American NaturalistCompetitive Interactions in Ecosystems
318 Citations1976Stephen H. Levine
An analysis was made of the indirect interactions between competing consumers, showing that the overall interaction between the consumers could be beneficial to both and that contact between the species does not depend on direct niche overlap.
Soil Use and ManagementSoil organic matter, effects on soils and crops
231 Citations1986A. E. Johnston
Journal of Applied EcologyThe Dynamics of a Grassland Ecosystem: Botanical Equilibrium in the Park Grass Experiment
207 Citations1980Jonathan Silvertown
No regular or irregular cycles of component biomass operating between years were detected and it is inferred that populations were regulated by processes operating within individual years.
EcologyThe Experimental Test of an Analysis of Field Distributions: Competition In Terrestrial Salamanders
183 Citations1980Nelson G. Hairston
Experimental removal of the terrestrial salamander Plethodon jordani from marked plots in the Great Smoky Mountains and the Balsam Mountains of North Carolina, USA resulted in statistically significant increases in the abundance of P. glutinosus in both areas.
HeredityRapid population differentiation in a mosaic environment
173 Citations1976M.S. Davies, R. W. Snaydon
It is concluded that selection pressures acting upon A. odoratum in the mosaic of environments that occur on the Park Grass Experiment are large and sufficient to account for the morphological and physiological differences that have been observed between closely adjacent populations of A. odatum.
Soil Use and ManagementSoil acidification during more than 100 years under permanent grassland and woodland at Rothamsted
166 Citations1986A. E. Johnston, K. W. T. Goulding +1 more
EvolutionRAPID POPULATION DIFFERENTIATION IN A MOSAIC ENVIRONMENT. II. MORPHOLOGICAL VARIATION IN<i>ANTHOXANTHUM ODORATUM</i>
123 Citations1972R. W. Snaydon, M.S. Davies
Large spatial variation in environmental factors, together with relatively stable conditions in time for 50-100 years, are similar to the conditions specified by Levins (1962, 1963) and Maynard Smith (1966) as most likely to induce population differentiation.
OecologiaDirect and indirect effects of n-species competition
114 Citations1979Lawrence R. Lawlor
A measure of net interspecific competition is proposed which incorporates both direct and indirect effects between each species pair in a community such that changes in the first species induce changes in other species which in turn directly affect the second species.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of LondonX. Agricultural, botanical, and chemical results of experiments on the mixed herbage of permanent meadow, conducted for more than twenty years in succession on the same land.—Part I
63 Citations1880John Bennet Lawes, Joseph Henry Gilbert
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of LondonXXVIII. Agricultural, botanical, and chemical results of experiments on the mixed herbage of permanent meadow, conducted for more than twenty years in succession on the same land. — Part. II. The botanical results
43 Citations1882J. B. Lawes, J. H. Gilbert +1 more
OikosInterpreting the Results of Field Experiments: Effects of Indirect Interactions
35 Citations1983Joseph H. Connell
Problemes poses par l'interpretation des resultats d'etudes sur la competition intra- et interspecifique lors ofertaines sur le terrain lors d’etude sur the terrain.