Sustainably unpersuaded
Published 5 May 2012
Hrönn Brynjarsdóttir, Maria Håkansson, James Pierce, Eric P. S. Baumer, Carl DiSalvo, Phoebe Sengers
Citations453
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
A critical analysis of persuasive sustainability research from 2009-2011 is provided, arguing that persuasion is based on a limited framing of sustainability, human behavior, and their interrelationship, which makes supporting sustainability easier, but leads to characteristic patterns of breakdown.
Abstract
In this paper we provide a critical analysis of persuasive sustainability research from 2009-2011. Drawing on critical sociological theory of modernism, we argue that persuasion is based on a limited framing of sustainability, human behavior, and their interrelationship. This makes supporting sustainability easier, but leads to characteristic patterns of breakdown. We then detail problems that emerge from this narrowing of vision, such as how the framing of sustainability as the optimization of a simple metrics places technologies incorrectly as objective arbiters over complex issues of sustainability. We conclude by suggesting alternative approaches to move beyond these problems.
Keywords
Computer ScienceSocial SciencesEnvironmental Science
Choice Reviews OnlineSeeing like a state: how certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed
4,118 Citations1998
Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed
2,175 Citations1999James Scott
Ambiguity as a resource for design
1,207 Citations2003William Gaver, Jacob Beaver +1 more
It is argued that ambiguity is a resource for design that can be used to encourage close personal engagement with systems and tactics for emphasising ambiguity are described that may help designers and other practitioners understand and craft its use.
Digital Commons - Lingnan (Lingnan University)The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism: and Other Writings
1,135 Citations1905Max Weber, Peter Baehr +1 more
Reflective design
785 Citations2005Phoebe Sengers, Kirsten Boehner +2 more
Reflective design combines analysis of the ways in which technologies reflect and perpetuate unconscious cultural assumptions, with design, building, and evaluation of new computing devices that reflect alternative possibilities.
The design of eco-feedback technology
779 Citations2010Jon E. Froehlich, Leah Findlater +1 more
A comparative survey of eco-feedback technology is conducted, including 89 papers from environmental psychology and 44 papers from the HCI and UbiComp literature, to provide an overview of predominant models of proenvironmental behaviors and a summary of key motivation techniques to promote this behavior.
Persuasive technology : using computers to change what we think and do
751 Citations2003B. J. Fogg
Mapping the landscape of sustainable HCI
745 Citations2010Carl DiSalvo, Phoebe Sengers +1 more
An empirical analysis of how sustainable HCI is defining itself as a research field is provided, based on a corpus of published works, which identifies established genres in the area, key unrecognized intellectual differences, and emerging issues.
Choice Reviews OnlineThe closed world: computers and the politics of discourse in Cold War America
696 Citations1996
AIS Electronic Library (AISeL) (Association for Information Systems)Located accountabilities in technology production
607 Citations2002Lucy Suchman
The relevance of recent feminist reconstructions of objectivity for the development of alternative practices of technology production and use is explored and three contrasting positions for design are discussed as alternative bases for a politics of professional design practice.
UbiGreen
554 Citations2009Jon E. Froehlich, Tawanna R. Dillahunt +5 more
This paper explores the use of personal ambient displays on mobile phones to give users feedback about sensed and self-reported transportation behaviors, and presents a working system for semi-automatically tracking transit activity and a visual design capable of engaging users in the goal of increasing green transportation.
Persuasive computers
428 Citations1998B. J. Fogg
The study of computers as persuasive technologies (called “captology”) was introduced at CHI 97 as a new area of inquiry and seven directions for further research and design are proposed.
HCI and environmental sustainability
412 Citations2010Paul Dourish
This paper examines the way that traditional HCI discourse obscures political and cultural contexts of environmental practice that must be part of an effective solution, and proposes that questions of scale might provide a useful new entry point for design practice.
Journal of American HistoryThe Closed World: Computers and the Politics of Discourse in Cold War America.
409 Citations1997Ken Alder, Paul Edwards
One size does not fit all
309 Citations2010Helen Ai He, Saul Greenberg +1 more
This paper synthesizes a wide range of motivational psychology literature to develop a motivational framework based on the Transtheoretical (aka Stages of Behavior Change) Model, and states the mo-tivational goal(s), and recommendation(s) for how technol-ogies can reach these goals.
Design IssuesDeclaration by Design: Rhetoric, Argument, and Demonstration in Design Practice
306 Citations1985Richard Buchanan
Designing eco-feedback systems for everyday life
305 Citations2011Yolande Strengers
The paper proposes an alternative design paradigm for eco-feedback systems premised on the realities of everyday life and identifies several design directions that emerge from this new starting point.
Fit4life
266 Citations2011Stephen Purpura, Victoria Schwanda +3 more
The design of a system - Fit4Life - that encourages individuals to address the larger goal of reducing obesity in society by promoting individual healthy behaviors is described.
Home, habits, and energy
217 Citations2010James Pierce, Diane J. Schiano +1 more
A novel vocabulary for analyzing and designing energy-conserving interactions is proposed based on findings from a qualitative study of people's everyday interactions with energy-consuming products and systems in the home.
OneBusAway
204 Citations2010Brian Ferris, Kari Watkins +1 more
Results from a survey of OneBusAway users show a set of important positive outcomes: strongly increased overall satisfaction with public transit, decreased waiting time, increased transit trips per week, increased feelings of safety, and even a health benefit in terms of increased distance walked when using transit.
A bright green perspective on sustainable choices
172 Citations2008Allison Woodruff, Jay Hasbrouck +1 more
A qualitative study of 35 United States households whose occupants have made significant accommodations to their homes and behaviors in order to be more environmentally responsible is presented to inform the design of future sustainable technologies through an exploration of existing "green" lifestyles.
A vehicle for research
144 Citations2009Paul M. Aoki, R.J. Honicky +5 more
This paper presents a qualitative analysis of the landscape of environmental action, focusing on insights that will help researchers frame meaningful technological interventions.
arXiv (Cornell University)A Vehicle for Research: Using Street Sweepers to Explore the Landscape of Environmental Community Action
139 Citations2009Paul M. Aoki, R.J. Honicky +5 more
UpStream
135 Citations2010Stacey Kuznetsov, Eric Paulos
This work hopes to motivate immediate reduction in water use as well as higher-order behaviors through unobtrusive low-cost water flow sensing and several persuasive displays through pervasive technology as an approach for promoting water conservation in public and private spaces.
"show-me"
112 Citations2009Karin Kappel, Thomas Grechenig
To promote water conservation by providing feedback in form of an ambient display that can easily be integrated in current shower types, a prototype shower water meter (show-me) and a prototype feedback device are built.
Materializing energy
107 Citations2010James Pierce, Eric Paulos
This paper draws on a diverse body of scholarly works related to energy and materiality to articulate a perspective on energy-as-materiality and propose a design approach of materializing energy.
InAir
105 Citations2010Sunyoung Kim, Eric Paulos
InAir demonstrated the persuasive power of sharing for furthering improvements to indoor air quality in terms of fostering new social awareness and behavior changes as well as strengthening social bonds and prompting collaborative efforts across social networks to improve human health and well being.
Prescriptive persuasion and open-ended social awareness
105 Citations2012Eric P. S. Baumer, Sherri Jean Katz +8 more
It is suggested that open-ended social awareness, making users aware of both others' and their own decisions, may also serve as an effective central design principle for mobile health.
It's not all about "Green"
94 Citations2009Tawanna R. Dillahunt, Jennifer Mankoff +2 more
A study of 26 low-income households in two very different locations explores the relationship between energy saving behaviors, external factors, and users' intrinsic values and beliefs and discusses how Ubicomp technologies for saving energy can address some of these challenges.
Power explorer
91 Citations2009Anton Gustafsson, Magnus Bång +1 more
The hypothesis is that a more casual game play and a richer learning interaction enabled by building the game on a real time sensor system could stimulate more lasting effects in the player's attitude toward environmental questions in general.
Coffee maker patterns and the design of energy feedback artefacts
83 Citations2010Loove Broms, Cecilia Katzeff +4 more
Results indicate that the Energy AWARE Clock played a significant role in drawing households' attention to their electricity use and became a natural part of the household and conceptions of electricity became naturalized into informants' everyday language.
WattBot
83 Citations2009Dane Petersen, Jay Steele +1 more
WattBot is a residential electricity monitoring and feedback system called WattBot, that allows users to track their home energy usage and encourages them to reduce consumption.
"Mate, we don't need a chip to tell us the soil's dry"
83 Citations2010William Odom
Findings from ethnographic fieldwork and a participatory design workshop conducted with members of urban agriculture communities found members heavily resisted technological augmentation of their agricultural practices, but suggested several novel ways in which interactive systems could be leveraged to help achieve their goals and potentially engender more sustainable ways of living.
Some consideration on the (in)effectiveness of residential energy feedback systems
82 Citations2010James Pierce, Chloe Fan +3 more
It is argued that HCI researchers, designers and others concerned with the design and evaluation of interactive systems should more strongly consider the ineffectiveness of such systems, including not only potential limitations of specific types of REFS or REFS in general but also potentially counterproductive or harmful effects of RE FS.
Participatory sensing in public spaces
80 Citations2010Stacey Kuznetsov, Eric Paulos
This work explores non-experts' use of place-based, modular sensors to activate, author and provoke urban landscapes, and suggests design opportunities for merging grassroots data collection with public expressions and activism.
Design requirements for ambient display that supports sustainable lifestyle
77 Citations2010Tanyoung Kim, Hwajung Hong +1 more
This work presents the results of user studies with two ambient displays in different visualization styles and suggests design requirements for ambient displays that support different stages of persuasion from raising awareness to motivating to change behaviors and to maintaining desired habits.
Design methods for ethical persuasive computing
75 Citations2009Janet Davis
Value Sensitive Design and Participatory Design are two methodological frameworks that account for ethical issues throughout the process of technology design that should be applied to persuasive technology---computer systems intended to change behaviors and attitudes.
Smart metering demand management programs
72 Citations2008Yolande Strengers
Insight is offered for designers of interactive demand management strategies about how to go beyond achieving efficiency benefits in the home in order to fundamentally change expectations and norms ingrained in the habitus.
It's not easy being green
69 Citations2009Marshini Chetty, A. J. Bernheim Brush +2 more
Research directions for home computer power management are suggested that could help users be more green without having to dramatically change their home computing habits.
Green tracker
61 Citations2010Nadine Amsel, Bill Tomlinson
The development of Green Tracker is described, a tool that estimates the energy consumption of software in order to help concerned users make informed decisions about the software they use.
Using individual, social and economic persuasion techniques to reduce CO <sub>2</sub> emissions in a family setting
61 Citations2009Miyuki Shiraishi, Yasuyuki Washio +4 more
This paper presents EcoIsland, which is a system persuading individuals and families to change their lifestyle patterns to reduce CO2 emissions by visualizing the user's current eco-friendly behavior as an island shared by his/her family members.
Local issues, local uses
60 Citations2009Carl DiSalvo, Marti Louw +2 more
This paper describes six creativity support tools developed to foster community engagement and expression with robotics and sensing, assessing the benefits and shortcomings of each tool.
SSRN Electronic JournalUsing Individual, Social and Economic Persuasion Techniques to Reduce CO2 Emissions in a Family Setting
51 Citations2009Miyuki Shiraishi, Vili Lehdonvirta +4 more
Making food, producing sustainability
50 Citations2010Tad Hirsch, Phoebe Sengers +3 more
It is argued that attention to the relationship small producers have to the environment and their experiences of interrelations between environmental, economic, and social sustainability suggest new foundational issues for sustainable HCI research.
Understanding conflict between landlords and tenants
49 Citations2010Tawanna R. Dillahunt, Jennifer Mankoff +1 more
It is argued that a consideration of multiple stakeholders, and the power imbalances among them, will drive important new research questions and lead to more widely applicable solutions for technologies that may affect and be affected by the conflict between stakeholders around energy use.
Can ambient persuasive technology persuade unconsciously?
48 Citations2009Jaap Ham, Cees Midden +1 more
Results indicated that supraliminal feedback and subliminal feedback both led to more correct energy consumption ratings as compared to receiving no feedback.
With a little help from a friend
46 Citations2011Matthias Laschke, Marc Hassenzahl +2 more
This design case presents and discusses the Shower Calendar, a "persuasive" concept for reducing the con-sumption of water for showering that starts from a dis-cussion of different types of feedback employed by earlier design cases.
Watt-Lite
46 Citations2010Li Jönsson, Loove Broms +1 more
The design of Watt-Lite, a set of three oversized torches projecting real time energy statistics of a factory in the physical environments of its employees is discussed, meant to explore ways of representing, understanding and interacting with electricity in industrial workspaces.
Scandinavian Journal of Information SystemsLocated accountabilities in technology production
45 Citations2002SuchmanLucy
Climate persuasive services
39 Citations2009Jorge Luis Zapico, Marko Turpeinen +1 more
It is suggested that the persuasive power of ICT can be oriented towards climate change, and the concept of "climate persuasive services" is defined as ICT applications that change personal attitudes regarding climate change and/or change behavior towards reducing greenhouse gases emissions.
Evaluating a social media application for sustainability in the workplace
36 Citations2011David Lehrer, Janani Vasudev
This work proposes that a social network integrated into the workplace environment - allowing people to track their own energy-related activities, to share this information, and to view and react to peers' activities - can take advantage of social influence to positively affect behavior.
Competitive carbon counting
31 Citations2010Derek Foster, Mark Blythe +2 more
It is argued that socially-mediated discussion and competition made for a more enjoyable user experience and reduced energy in the socially enabled condition.
Power ballads
31 Citations2011Derek Foster, Conor Linehan +2 more
It was found the use of aversive feedback did not act as a deterrent to regularly interacting with the application through evaluating user engagement and punishment of non-desirable behaviour discourages users from engaging with a persuasive application.
The effect of eco-driving system towards sustainable driving behavior
27 Citations2010Heewon Lee, Woohun Lee +1 more
It is found that the current Eco-Driving System shows minor benefits in gas mileage due to different driving behaviors and also increased task loads for participants, so a new research direction is suggested for the Eco- Driving System for further study.
Coralog
27 Citations2009Tanyoung Kim, Hwajung Hong +1 more
The goal of this application is to make the public become aware of the connection between their everyday activities and global climate change, which will educate them about the formerly unseen effects that their actions may have and potentially lead to a sustainable living.
Cross currents
21 Citations2010Tad Hirsch, Ken Anderson
A qualitative study of practices and attitudes in a water-stressed region of the United States is presented and it is suggested that sustainability has the potential to move from the periphery of CHI research and become a galvanizing force for the community at large.
Weigh your waste
15 Citations2009Alex A. Gartland, Paulina Piasek
The 'Weigh Your Waste' (WYW) device will allow the user to monitor their waste charges and provide a platform to learn and explore areas such as: recycling, reusing old items, how to make compost and many other green activities.
Designing with unconscious human behaviors for eco-friendly interaction
14 Citations2009Minjung Sohn, Tek-Jin Nam +1 more
A framework of design space matrix and initial case studies for the design method to apply unconscious human behaviors in interaction design, which is expected to be used unconsciously by users with reduced environmental impacts.
ADAPT
14 Citations2009Timothy M. Miller, Patrick Rich +1 more
This work describes the design process and rationale, the resulting design, lessons learned, and future research directions of a persuasive ambient display designed to engage community members in reducing environmental waste on the authors' college campus.
Flo
11 Citations2011Paul Shrubsole, Tine Lavrysen +2 more
A family game was designed to explore whether this could be an effective and fun approach for raising the awareness of family members towards their energy use and, in the long run, to provide an effective tool for affecting their habits regarding sustainable behavior.
Exploring Practices of Thermal Comfort for Sustainable Design
9 Citations2011Lenneke Kuijer, Annelise de Jong
PrintMarmoset
8 Citations2009Jun Xiao, Jian Fan
A field study of current behaviors and attitudes around printing confirmed the affordances of paper, but also revealed many problems associated with printing web content, so a browser extension is designed and implemented that targets these problems while simultaneously addressing user needs and environmental responsibility.
Data Archiving and Networked Services (DANS)Flo: Raising Family Awareness about Electricity Use
2 Citations2012Paul Shrubsole, Tine Lavrysen +2 more