Relationship of empathy to appraisal, depression, life satisfaction, and physical health in informal caregivers of older adults
Research in Nursing & HealthPublished 1 January 2001
Haejung Lee, Patrícia Flatley Brennan, Barbara J. Daly
Citations118
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.90
SNIP1.00
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Caregivers with high cognitive empathy appraised the caregiving situation as less stressful and less threatening, were less depressed, and reported higher life satisfaction than did caregivers with low cognitive empathy.
Abstract
The relationship between empathy and caregiving appraisal and outcomes was examined among 140 informal caregivers of older adults. Caregivers with high cognitive empathy appraised the caregiving situation as less stressful and less threatening, were less depressed, and reported higher life satisfaction than did caregivers with low cognitive empathy. The caregivers' appraisal, along with educational levels and total household income, significantly predicted individual differences in caregiver depression, life satisfaction, and perceived physical health. Emotional empathy was negatively related to life satisfaction. There appeared to be distinct roles for emotional and cognitive empathy in informal caregiving outcomes. The study supported the important role of caregiving appraisal and resources in caregiving outcomes.
Keywords
PsychologySocial SciencesHealth Professions
The GerontologistCaregiving and the Stress Process: An Overview of Concepts and Their Measures
4,724 Citations1990Leonard I. Pearlin, Joseph T. Mullan +2 more
This paper views caregiver stress as a consequence of a process comprising a number of interrelated conditions, including the socioeconomic characteristics and resources of caregivers and the primary and secondary stressors to which they are exposed.
The GerontologistProgress in Development of the Index of ADL
4,038 Citations1970S Katz, T. Downs +2 more
Journal of GerontologyThe Measurement of Life Satisfaction
2,567 Citations1961Bernice L. Neugarten, R. J. Havighurst +1 more
The GerontologistSubjective Burden of Husbands and Wives as Caregivers: A Longitudinal Study
1,835 Citations1986Steven H. Zarit, Peter A. Todd +1 more
The GerontologistPsychiatric and Physical Morbidity Effects of Dementia Caregiving: Prevalence, Correlates, and Causes
1,785 Citations1995R. Schulz, Alison T. O'Brien +2 more
Across studies, psychiatric morbidity in caregivers was linked to patient problem behaviors, income, self-rated health, perceived stress, and life satisfaction, and physical morbidity was associated with patient Problem behaviors and cognitive impairment, and with caregiver depression, anxiety, and perceived social support.
The psychotherapeutic process: A research handbook.
1,397 Citations1986Leslie S. Greenberg, William M. Pinsof
International Journal of Health ServicesA Measure of Primary Sociobiological Functions
1,239 Citations1976Sidney Katz, C. Amechi Akpom
The Index of Independence in Activities of Daily Living appears to be based on functions of sociobiological primacy, and has been used to produce predictive information about chronic conditions and to evaluate the benefits of long-term services.
Psychosomatic MedicineSpousal caregivers of dementia victims: longitudinal changes in immunity and health.
1,001 Citations1991Janice K. Kiecolt‐Glaser, Jason R. Dura +3 more
Caregivers who reported lower levels of social support at intake and who were most distressed by dementia‐related behaviors showed the greatest and most uniformly negative changes in immune function at follow‐up.
The Psychological MonographsDimensions of therapist response as causal factors in therapeutic change.
820 Citations1962Godfrey T. Barrett‐Lennard
Journal of GerontologyA Two-factor Model of Caregiving Appraisal and Psychological Well-Being
663 Citations1991M. P. Lawton, Miriam S. Moss +3 more
Limited support was found for the hypothesis that the positive and negative aspects of caregiving contributed to analogous aspects of generalized psychological well-being but not to the opposite-valence outcomes.
Journal of GerontologyAn Analysis of a Short Self-Report Measure of Life Satisfaction: Correlation With Rater Judgments
588 Citations1969Vivian Wood, M. L. Wylie +1 more
Psychology and AgingStress, appraisal, coping, and social support as predictors of adaptational outcome among dementia caregivers.
534 Citations1987William E. Haley, Ellen G. Levine +2 more
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyThe psychological and physical health of family members caring for an elderly person with dementia
404 Citations1992Mona Baumgarten, Renaldo N. Battista +4 more
The results suggest that family caregivers of elderly persons with dementia might benefit from careful monitoring of their health status, and from greater access to specialized support services.
The Journals of Gerontology Series BContributors to and Mediators of Psychological Well-Being for Informal Caregivers
363 Citations1999Mary Ellen Yates, Sharon L. Tennstedt +1 more
Findings indicate that the caregiving stressors led to caregiver depression indirectly through their effect on hours of care provided and the resulting caregiver perception of role overload, and that caregivers with high levels of mastery or emotional support were at lower risk of depression.
Psychology and AgingA 2-year longitudinal study of depression among Alzheimer's caregivers.
357 Citations1991Richard Schulz, Gail M. Williamson
Results from a 2-year (4 waves) longitudinal study show strong evidence for patient decline and high levels of depressive symptomatology among caregivers, and male caregivers exhibited significant increases in depression over time.
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyPsychological, Social, and Health Consequences of Caring for a Relative with Senile Dementia
332 Citations1987William E. Haley, Ellen G. Levine +3 more
Results clearly indicate the serious and wide‐ranging effects of the stress of caregiving, and reinforce the importance of providing comprehensive services for caregiving families.
Journal of Counseling PsychologyUnderstanding empathy: Integrating counseling, developmental, and social psychology perspectives.
310 Citations1983Gerald A. Gladstein
Cancer NursingCaregiving demands and appraisal of stress among family caregivers
310 Citations1989Marilyn T. Oberst, Suzie Thomas +2 more
There was a strong positive correlation between caregiver load and the harm/loss and threat appraisals and a need for frequent reassessment of demands on family caregivers throughout the course of treatment.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipExploring Empathy: A Conceptual Fit for Nursing Practice?
298 Citations1992Janice M. Morse, Gwen Anderson +5 more
Empathy was uncritically adopted from psychology and is actually a poor fit for the clinical reality of nursing practice, so other communication strategies presently devalued need to be reexamined and may be more appropriate than empathy during certain phases of the illness experience.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical PsychologyTherapeutic empathy and recovery from depression in cognitive-behavioral therapy: A structural equation model.
283 Citations1992David D. Burns, Susan Nolen–Hoeksema
Journal of the American Geriatrics SocietyMeasuring Physical Function in Community‐Dwelling Older Persons: A Comparison of Self‐Administered, Interviewer‐Administered, and Performance‐Based Measures
268 Citations1995David B. Reuben, Laura A. Valle +2 more
A comparison of two self‐administered, one interviewer‐administering, and one performance‐based measure of physical function in community‐based older persons is compared to find the latter to be more accurate than the former.
Psychology Press eBooksBehavior, Health, and Aging
223 Citations2014Stephen B. Manuck
This work focuses on the part of Aging and the Life Cycle that is concerned with the impact of psychological factors, health, and disease on the physical and mental health of the elderly.
PubMedAppraisal and caregiving burden in family members caring for patients receiving chemotherapy.
216 Citations1992P J Carey, Marilyn T. Oberst +2 more
It is suggested that caregivers' appraisals of their situations may mediate the effects of illness and contextual factors on caregiver outcomes and that family hardiness is an important caregiver resource.
Current PsychologyEmotional empathy and associated individual differences
206 Citations1988Albert Mehrabian, Andrew L. Young +1 more
Psychology and AgingAnxiety and depressive disorders in adult children caring for demented parents.
170 Citations1991Jason R. Dura, Karl Stukenberg +1 more
Research in Nursing & HealthEmpathy and burnout in male and female helping professionals
161 Citations1989Carol A. Williams
It is hypothesized that high emotional empathy may predispose helping professionals to emotional exhaustion and that emotional exhaustion, if not mediated by personal accomplishment, may lead to the development of depersonalization.
Aging and Caregiving: Theory, Research, and Policy
161 Citations1990David E. Biegel, Arthur Blum
Murdoch Research Repository (Murdoch University)The Relationship Inventory now: Issues and advances in theory, method, and use.
140 Citations1986Godfrey T. Barrett‐Lennard
Journal of Clinical and Experimental NeuropsychologyPsychosocial consequences of caring for a spouse with multiple sclerosis
136 Citations1997Robert G. Knight, Robert C. Devereux +1 more
Spousal caregivers of persons with multiple sclerosis completed a questionnaire assessing the stress associated with caregiving and Regression analyses supported the importance of satisfaction with coping and social support as predictors of perceived burden.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipRelationships Between Nurse‐Expressed Empathy, Patient‐Perceived Empathy and Patient Distress
121 Citations1995Joanne Olson
This study is one of the first to link behavioral measures of nurse empathy to patient outcomes.
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipBalancing Engagement and Detachment in Caregiving
93 Citations1997Betty J. Carmack
The longer and more intense a caregiver's involvement, the more important it is to learn to balance engagement and detachment, and caregivers may need to learn effective balancing skills.
Journal of Advanced NursingEmpathy, experience of burnout and attitudes towards demented patients among nursing staff in geriatric care
87 Citations1990Shire Àstrom, Mats Nilsson +2 more
The nursing staff showed an overall figure of moderately well-developed empathy and the RNs showed the highest empathy, and a weak negative correlation between burnout and empathy is in accordance with other authors suggesting that burnout experience leads to lower empathy in the nursing staff.
Nursing ResearchEmpathy Training as the Major Thrust of a Staff Development Program
84 Citations1976Elaine L. LaMonica, Donald K. Carew +3 more
The study indicated that all nurses tested possessed an extremely low level of empathy, and that the staff development program significantly raised their levels of empathy but that more training was needed to enable all or the majority of subjects to reach at least the minimal facilitative level necessary to help another person successfully.
Research and Theory for Nursing PracticeEmpathy and Nursing Care Outcomes
83 Citations1987Elaine L. La Monica, Richard M. Wolf +2 more
Clients cared for by nurses in the experimental group showed significantly less anxiety and hostility than clients cared for prior to the experimental treatment; mean differences on depression and satisfaction with care were in the hypothesized direction.
Nursing ResearchAN EXPERIMENT IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF EMPATHY IN NURSING STUDENTS
81 Citations1971Beatrice J. Kalisch
The GerontologistFactors Associated with Symptoms of Depression Among Informal Caregivers of Demented Elders in the Community
77 Citations1998Garbis Meshefedjian, Jane McCusker +2 more
Results indicated that a higher CES-D score was significantly associated with three caregiver characteristics (being a spouse or child of the patient, self-identified ethnicity other than English and French Canadian, and lower education), and two patient characteristics (greater behavioral disturbance and moderate to severe functional impairment).
The GerontologistBetween Stressors and Outcomes: Can We Simplify Caregiving Process Variables?
63 Citations1996Valerie Braithwaite
A sixth dimension identified in this analysis, "inner strength and efficacy," represented psychological resources and supported Lawton et al.'s (1989) assumption that resources and appraisals can be measured separately.
Cancer NursingThe meaning and impact of empathic relationships in hospice nursing
62 Citations1993Barbara M. Raudonis
According to the hospice patient, an empathic relationship developed through a process of reciprocal sharing and revealing of personhood within a context of caring and acceptance, which resulted in the improvement and maintenance of patients' physical and emotional well-being.
Age and AgeingCoping by the Carers of Dementia Sufferers
59 Citations1995Karim Saad, Jennifer S. Hartman +4 more
The active management strategy 'being firm in directing behaviour' was significantly inversely associated with depression amongst carers living with the dementia sufferers, whilst carers who prioritized their daily routines were significantly more likely to be depressed.
Cancer NursingDistress in cancer patients and primary nursesʼ empathy skills
58 Citations1992Pat Reid-Ponte
A significant correlation was found between the perceiving/feeling/listening empathy skill and patient distress, and nurses' age, years of experience, and education were significantly correlated with some empathy skills.
British Journal of Medical PsychologyCoping resources and depression in the caregiving spouses of Alzheimer patients
46 Citations1990Elizabeth R. Morrissey, Joseph Becker +1 more
The role in which stress occurs is an important factor in understanding stress and the coping process and none of the indicators of mobilized coping resources was correlated with depression among workers.
Issues in Mental Health NursingBiopsychosocial Elements of Empathy: a Multidimensional Model
44 Citations1990Carol A. Williams
The International Journal of Aging and Human DevelopmentNursing Home Nurses' Attitudes, Empathy, and Ideologic Orientation
39 Citations1986Margaret Bagshaw, Mary Adams
Assessment of the empirical relationship of the psychosocial variables of empathy, attitudes, and ideological orientation toward treatment suggested directions for enhancing the ability of nursing personnel to interact therapeutically with elderly persons in nursing homes.
The Journal of Rural HealthDeterminants of Primary Caregiver Stress and Burden: Area of Residence and the Caregiving Networks of Frail Elders*
37 Citations1990Jeffrey W. Dwyer, Michael K. Miller
The analysis shows that several characteristics of the care-receiver and the primary caregiver have a differential effect on stress and burden across residential categories, and that, within rural, small city, and urban samples, the determinants ofstress and burden are not homogeneous.
Nursing OutlookReview and synthesis of selected nursing studies on teaching empathy and implications for nursing research and education
23 Citations1994Kathleen Wheeler, Elizabeth Ann Barrett
The mandate by caring theorists to integrate caring into nursing curricula could be accomplished without major curricula change and the integration of empathy training, with special emphasis on expanding one's awareness of self as well as others, espouses a pedagogical approach to caring.
Nursing ResearchMood and Blood Pressure Responses in Black Female Caregivers and Noncaregivers
22 Citations1999Sandra J. Fulton Picot, Jaclene A. Zauszniewski +2 more
Evaluated relationship between mood symptoms and daytime ambulatory blood pressures during a 12-hour period in Black female caregivers and noncaregivers found elevated anger was associated with significant decreases in DBP, while lowered anger wasassociated with significant increases in DBp.
PubMedNurses' empathy and patients' satisfaction with nursing care.
12 Citations1992Warner Rs
It was concluded that empathy training programs for nurses may not be necessary and that although patients are generally satisfied with nursing care received in acute care settings, the data do not support a relationship between nurses' empathy levels and patients' satisfaction.