Do Safety Checklists Improve Teamwork and Communication in the Operating Room? A Systematic Review
Annals of SurgeryPublished 30 October 2013
Stephanie Russ, Shantanu Rout, Nick Sevdalis, Krishna Moorthy, Ara Darzi, Charles Vincent
Citations321
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.59
SNIP2.41
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Evidence suggests that safety checklists improve the perceived quality of OR teamwork and communication and reduce observable errors relating to poor team skills and this may be one mechanism through which patient outcomes are improved.
Abstract
Safety checklists are beneficial for OR teamwork and communication and this may be one mechanism through which patient outcomes are improved. Future research should aim to further elucidate the relationship between how safety checklists are used and team skills in the OR using more consistent methodological approaches and utilizing validated measures of teamwork such that best practice guidelines can be established.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
New England Journal of MedicineA Surgical Safety Checklist to Reduce Morbidity and Mortality in a Global Population
5,607 Citations2009Alex B. Haynes, Thomas G. Weiser +13 more
Implementation of the checklist was associated with concomitant reductions in the rates of death and complications among patients at least 16 years of age who were undergoing noncardiac surgery in a diverse group of hospitals.
The LancetAn estimation of the global volume of surgery: a modelling strategy based on available data
2,483 Citations2008Thomas G. Weiser, Scott E. Regenbogen +5 more
In view of the high death and complication rates of major surgical procedures, surgical safety should now be a substantial global public-health concern.
BMC Health Services ResearchThe Safety Attitudes Questionnaire: psychometric properties, benchmarking data, and emerging research
1,785 Citations2006J. Bryan Sexton, Robert L. Helmreich +6 more
The Safety Attitudes Questionnaire demonstrated good psychometric properties and healthcare organizations can use the survey to measure caregiver attitudes about six patient safety-related domains, to compare themselves with other organizations, to prompt interventions to improve safety attitudes and to measure the effectiveness of these interventions.
Journal of Nursing RegulationThe Checklist Manifesto: How to Get Things Right
1,148 Citations2011Atul A. Gawande
New England Journal of MedicineEffect of a Comprehensive Surgical Safety System on Patient Outcomes
992 Citations2010Eefje N. de Vries, Hubert A. Prins +10 more
Implementation of this comprehensive checklist was associated with a reduction in surgical complications and mortality in hospitals with a high standard of care and did not change in the control hospitals.
Journal of the American College of SurgeonsPatterns of Communication Breakdowns Resulting in Injury to Surgical Patients
834 Citations2007Caprice C. Greenberg, Scott E. Regenbogen +5 more
SurgeryThe impact of stress on surgical performance: A systematic review of the literature
636 Citations2009Sonal Arora, Nick Sevdalis +4 more
Surgeons are subject to many intra-operative stressors that can impair their performance, and current evidence is characterized by marked heterogeneity of research designs and variable study quality.
Archives of surgeryEvaluation of a Preoperative Checklist and Team Briefing Among Surgeons, Nurses, and Anesthesiologists to Reduce Failures in Communication
586 Citations2008Lorelei Lingard
Interprofessional checklist briefings reduced the number of communication failures and promoted proactive and collaborative team communication in general surgery at a Canadian academic tertiary care hospital.
BMJ Quality & SafetyChanges in safety attitude and relationship to decreased postoperative morbidity and mortality following implementation of a checklist-based surgical safety intervention
518 Citations2011Alex B. Haynes, Thomas G. Weiser +14 more
Improvements in postoperative outcomes were associated with improved perception of teamwork and safety climate among respondents, suggesting that changes in these may be partially responsible for the effect of the checklist.
Annals of SurgeryEffect of A 19-Item Surgical Safety Checklist During Urgent Operations in A Global Patient Population
464 Citations2010Thomas G. Weiser, Alex B. Haynes +4 more
Implementation of the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist was associated with a greater than one-third reduction in complications among adult patients undergoing urgent noncardiac surgery in a diverse group of hospitals.
The LancetReality check for checklists
456 Citations2009Charles L. Bosk, Mary Dixon‐Woods +2 more
This paper was published as The Lancet, 2009, 374 (9688), pp. 444-445, and is available from www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/01406736.
SurgeryAnalysis of surgical errors in closed malpractice claims at 4 liability insurers
406 Citations2006Selwyn O. Rogers, Atul A. Gawande +5 more
System factors play a critical role in most surgical errors, including technical errors, and closed claims analysis can help to identify priority areas for intervening to reduce errors.
The American Journal of SurgeryBridging the communication gap in the operating room with medical team training
382 Citations2005Samir S. Awad, Shawn P. Fagan +5 more
Medical team training using crew resource management principles can improve communication in the OR, ensuring a safer environment that leads to decreased adverse events.
Journal of the American College of SurgeonsThe Impact of Nontechnical Skills on Technical Performance in Surgery: A Systematic Review
369 Citations2011Louise Hull, Sonal Arora +4 more
Evidence suggests that certain nontechnical aspects of performance can enhance or, if lacking, contribute to deterioration of surgeons' technical performance.
BMJPractical challenges of introducing WHO surgical checklist: UK pilot experience
322 Citations2010Amit Vats, Charles Vincent +4 more
The WHO checklist has the potential to reduce preventable adverse events in surgery, but A Vats and colleagues' experience suggests that a careful and rigorous implementation plan is required to ensure that the checklist is used routinely and correctly.
Annals of SurgeryA Systematic Review of the Effectiveness, Compliance, and Critical Factors for Implementation of Safety Checklists in Surgery
307 Citations2012Annegret Borchard, David Schwappach +2 more
Checklists are effective and economic tools that decrease mortality and morbidity in surgery and further research in particular relating to implementation is needed.
AnesthesiologyTeamwork in the Operating Room
292 Citations2006J. Bryan Sexton, Martin A. Makary +8 more
Rigorous assessment of teamwork climate is possible using this psychometrically sound teamwork climate scale and initial benchmarks allow others to compare their teamwork climate to national means, in an effort to focus more on what excellent surgical teams do well.
BMJ Quality & SafetyGetting teams to talk: development and pilot implementation of a checklist to promote interprofessional communication in the OR
264 Citations2005Lorelei Lingard
The preoperative team checklist shows promise as a feasible and efficient tool that promotes information exchange and team cohesion and is described to describe how the checklist tool was used by operating room (OR) teams.
Journal of the American College of SurgeonsOperating Room Briefings and Wrong-Site Surgery
256 Citations2006Martin A. Makary, Arnab Mukherjee +8 more
Or briefings significantly reduce perceived risk for wrong-site surgery and improve perceived collaboration among OR personnel and caregiver assessments before and after implementation of briefings.
The American Journal of SurgeryReliability of a revised NOTECHS scale for use in surgical teams
226 Citations2008Nick Sevdalis, Rachel Davis +4 more
The present evidence suggests that the revised NOTECHS scale exhibits good reliability, and further empirical research should assess the validity of the scale.
BMJ Quality & SafetyDevelopment and validation of the SURgical PAtient Safety System (SURPASS) checklist
213 Citations2009Eefje N. de Vries, Markus W. Hollmann +3 more
The SURPASS checklist is the first validated patient safety checklist for the entire surgical pathway and can be applied in clinical practice relatively simply.
Journal of the American College of SurgeonsObservational Teamwork Assessment for Surgery: Content Validation and Tool Refinement
207 Citations2011Louise Hull, Sonal Arora +3 more
Findings demonstrate that OTAS is psychometrically robust for capturing teamwork in the operating room.
Annals of SurgerySurgeon Information Transfer and Communication
170 Citations2007Reed G. Williams, Ross D. Silverman +9 more
To determine the nature of surgeon information transfer and communication errors that lead to adverse events and near misses, and recommend strategies for minimizing or preventing these errors, the ITCP Project is a multi-institutional effort to better understand surgeon ITCP and their patient care consequences.
International OrthopaedicsUse of the WHO surgical safety checklist in trauma and orthopaedic patients
163 Citations2010Mathew David Sewell, Miriam Adebibe +5 more
Archives of SurgeryImpact of Preoperative Briefings on Operating Room Delays
145 Citations2008Shantanu Nundy
Preoperative briefings have the potential to increase OR efficiency and thereby improve quality of care and reduce cost and decreased the frequency of communication breakdowns that lead to delays.
British Journal of AnaesthesiaImproving patient safety in the operating theatre and perioperative care: obstacles, interventions, and priorities for accelerating progress
142 Citations2012Nick Sevdalis, Louise Hull +1 more
Some of the reasons for the lack of evident progress in improving patient safety across healthcare specialities are reviewed and some recommendations based on the existing evidence-base that have potential to improve patient safety and outcomes in the coming decade are offered.
Archives of SurgeryIncorrect Surgical Procedures Within and Outside of the Operating Room
120 Citations2009Julia Neily
Incorrect ophthalmic and orthopedic surgical procedures appear to be overrepresented among adverse events occurring in ORs, and earlier communication based on crew resource management to prevent surgical adverse events is supported.
The Permanente JournalPreoperative Safety Briefing Project
116 Citations2003James Defontes, Stephanie Surbida
The Preoperative Safety Briefing is now standard in many operating suites in the KP Orange County Service Area and the concepts and design are transferable, and similar projects are underway in the Departments of Radiology and of Labor and Delivery at KP Anaheim Medical Center.
Journal of the American College of SurgeonsDevelopment and Pilot Evaluation of a Preoperative Briefing Protocol for Cardiovascular Surgery
104 Citations2009Sarah E. Henrickson, Rishi K. Wadhera +3 more
The findings demonstrate the feasibility of creating a specialty-specific preoperative briefing to decrease surgical flow disruptions and improve patient safety in the operating room.
Acta Anaesthesiologica ScandinavicaA pilot study of the implementation of <scp>WHO</scp><scp>S</scp>urgical <scp>C</scp>hecklist in <scp>F</scp>inland: improvements in activities and communication
100 Citations2011Riikka Takala, Satu‐Liisa Pauniaho +10 more
A surgical safety checklist that has reduced post‐operative morbidity and mortality in a high‐income country is introduced and its possible impact on the operating room process, safety‐related issues and communication among surgical staff is assessed.
Patient Safety in SurgeryThe SURgical PAtient Safety System (SURPASS) checklist optimizes timing of antibiotic prophylaxis
98 Citations2010Eefje N. de Vries, Lucia Dijkstra +3 more
The use of the SURPASS checklist leads to better compliance with regard to the timing of antibiotic prophylaxis administration, and the proportion of patients that did not receive antibiotics until after the incision decreased significantly.
CHEST JournalPreoperative Briefing in the Operating Room
97 Citations2010Yael Einav, Daniel Gopher +6 more
Team briefings designed to supply a broader-perspective surgery model may be an easy-to-apply tool to reduce the number of nonroutine events during surgery and increase patient safety.
Acta Anaesthesiologica ScandinavicaImplementing a pre‐operative checklist to increase patient safety: a 1‐year follow‐up of personnel attitudes
96 Citations2009Lena Nilsson, O. Lindberget +2 more
A survey of personnel attitudes to a pre‐operative checklist (‘time out’) immediately before start of the operative procedure to assess perioperative verification processes.
BMJ Quality & SafetyEvaluation of a preoperative team briefing: a new communication routine results in improved clinical practice
96 Citations2011Lorelei Lingard, Glenn Regehr +8 more
Use of a preoperative team checklist briefing was associated with improved physician compliance with antibiotic administration guidelines, and recommendations to enhance timely antibiotic therapy are provided.
Quality Management in Health CareEffect of Surgical Safety Checklists on Postoperative Morbidity and Mortality Rates, Shiraz, Faghihy Hospital, a 1-Year Study
95 Citations2011Mehrdad Askarian, Farideh Kouchak +1 more
Complications decreased by 57% after intervention and both high patient information detection and elevated levels of cooperation by surgical personnel were observed, suggesting compliance likely helped prevent some adverse effects associated with surgery.
Interactive Cardiovascular and Thoracic SurgeryBriefing and debriefing in the cardiac operating room. Analysis of impact on theatre team attitude and patient safety
91 Citations2009Sotiris Papaspyros, Kalyana Javangula +2 more
The health industry may benefit from embracing the briefing-debriefing technique as an adjunct to continuous improvement through reflective learning, deliberate practice and immediate feedback as the initial step toward a substantive and sustainable organizational transformation.
Acta Anaesthesiologica ScandinavicaThe implementation of a perioperative checklist increases patients' perioperative safety and staff satisfaction
84 Citations2011Andreas Böhmer, Frank Wappler +7 more
BMJ Quality & SafetyThe introduction of a surgical safety checklist in a tertiary referral obstetric centre
80 Citations2011Rachel Kearns, Vishal Uppal +4 more
Following consultation with staff and patients, the authors managed to institute and sustain the performance of a surgical safety checklist for elective cases in obstetric theatres and recognise that further work is required in order to further evaluate and optimise this process.
Annals of SurgeryObservational Teamwork Assessment for Surgery
79 Citations2012Stephanie Russ, Louise Hull +4 more
It is feasible to train both clinicians and nonclinicians to use OTAS to assess teamwork behaviors in ORs over a short structured training period and OTAS is an accessible tool that can be used robustly by assessors from both clinical and nonclinical backgrounds.
The American Journal of SurgeryBriefing guide study: preoperative briefing and postoperative debriefing checklists in the Veterans Health Administration medical team training program
75 Citations2010Douglas E. Paull, Lisa Mazzia +7 more
Checklist-driven preoperative briefings and postoperative debriefings are associated with improvements in patient safety for surgical patients and prophylaxis compliance rates were higher after initiation of a surgical checklist.
Clinical OtolaryngologyTowards better patient safety: WHO Surgical Safety Checklist in otorhinolaryngology
74 Citations2011Päivi Helmiö, Karin Blomgren +4 more
BMJ Quality & SafetyA theory-based instrument to evaluate team communication in the operating room: balancing measurement authenticity and reliability
65 Citations2006Lorelei Lingard, Glenn Regehr +2 more
Reasonable inter-rater reliability was shown by the instrument in assessing the relative rate of communication failures displayed per procedure, suggesting that the instrument could be used to measure the effect of team communication intervention on overall failure rates at the level of procedure.
The Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient SafetyImplementing Standardized Operating Room Briefings and Debriefings at a Large Regional Medical Center
59 Citations2009Sean M. Berenholtz, Kathy Schumacher +6 more
Implementation of a standardized briefing and debriefing tool in a large regional medical center was a practical and feasible strategy to improve perceptions of interdisciplinary communication and teamwork in the OR.
The American Surgeon<i>The Surgical Safety Checklist: Lessons Learned During Implementation</i>
57 Citations2011James Forrest Calland, Florence E. Turrentine +6 more
Surgical procedural safety checklists have the capacity to increase the frequency of positive team behaviors in the operating room during laparoscopic surgery, and participants in the intervention (checklist) group consistently rated their cases as involving less satisfactory subjective levels of comfort, team efficiency, and communication.
Surgical EndoscopyRisk-sensitive events during laparoscopic cholecystectomy: the influence of the integrated operating room and a preoperative checklist tool
49 Citations2010Sonja N. Buzink, Lotte van Lier +2 more
This study investigates the influence of the integrated OR system and Pro/cheQ, a digital checklist tool, on the number and type of equipment- and instrument-related risk-sensitive events (RSE) during laparoscopic cholecystectomies.
Cognition Technology & WorkParadoxical effects of interprofessional briefings on OR team performance
44 Citations2007Sarah Whyte, Lorelei Lingard +7 more
Qualitative analysis of fieldnotes from 302 preoperative team briefings identified five paradoxical findings: team briefings could mask knowledge gaps, disrupt positive communication, reinforce professional divisions, create tension, and perpetuate a problematic culture.
The American SurgeonImplementation of a Preoperative Briefing Protocol Improves Accuracy of Teamwork Assessment in the Operating Room
42 Citations2008John T. Paige, Deborah L. Aaron +5 more
Using a preoperative protocol seems to improve OR staff teamwork behaviors and self-assessment accuracy and the use of a 360-degree assessment method targeting specific, observable behaviors may be useful in evaluating team-based interventions and enhancing teamwork effectiveness.
Cognition Technology & WorkIs team training in briefings for surgical teams feasible in simulation?
26 Citations2007Maria Koutantji, Peter McCulloch +8 more
Training surgical teams in simulation is feasible but much more work is needed on measurement development and training strategy to confirm its efficacy and utility.
Critical Care Nursing QuarterlyHospital Checklists
18 Citations2011Jeffrey M. Robbins
If a checklist is to succeed as a mechanism for transforming evidence-based care and safety protocols into best and actual practice, it needs to be used consistently and durably; to achieve this, hospitals need to foster a supportive environment as well as acquire a system to monitor, measure, and manage a culture that effectively embraces checklists.
Observing and Assessing Surgical Teams: The Observational Teamwork Assessment for Surgery© (OTAS)©
17 Citations2017Shabnam Undre, Nick Sevdalis +1 more
Cognition Technology & WorkEngineering the system of communication for safer surgery
13 Citations2010Andrew N. Healey, Kamal Nagpal +2 more
It is argued that a new view of communication is needed to improve safety in surgery; the view that communication is more fundamentally as a property of the whole system of work rather than confined to interpersonal exchanges.