Overcoming theory-practice inconsistencies: Critical realism and information systems research
Information and OrganizationPublished 9 May 2006
Matthew L. Smith
Citations215
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.80
SNIP1.83
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is proposed that a critical realist ontology allows for one re-interpretation of the activity of science as implicitly predicated upon natural and social realism as well as the concepts of structures and generative mechanisms.
Abstract
This paper argues that information systems (IS) research conducted within the standard account of the paradigms of positivism and interpretivism suffers from persistent theory-practice inconsistencies. These inconsistencies are located between researchers' stated (or implicit) ontological assumptions and research practice and results. Such a situation calls for a (re)consideration of the underlying ontological premises of information systems research and practice. This paper proposes that a critical realist ontology allows for one re-interpretation of the activity of science as implicitly predicated upon natural and social realism as well as the concepts of structures and generative mechanisms. This interpretation provides greater explanatory power vis-à-vis current research practices and resolves the theory-practice contradictions highlighted above. Consequently, it is a powerful logical argument for accepting this new conceptualization as an improvement upon the former. To illustrate, this paper recasts one such debate in light of critical realist assumptions; technological determinism vs. social construction of technology.
Keywords
Social SciencesDecision Sciences
Case Study Research: Design and Methods
74,912 Citations1984Robert K. Yin
Academy of Management ReviewBuilding Theories from Case Study Research
23,160 Citations1989Kathleen M. Eisenhardt
Qualitative Data Analysis
17,446 Citations2008
Qualitative data is extremely varied in nature and can include everything from field research where one lives in another context or culture for a period of time to photographs that illustrate some aspect of the phenomenon.
American Sociological ReviewThe Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge.
16,589 Citations1967George L. Simpson, Peter L. Berger +1 more
Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference
13,404 Citations2010William R. Shadish, Thomas D. Cook +1 more
Journal of MarketingTrust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity
10,681 Citations1996Peter A. Schneider, Francis Fukuyama
Case Studies and Theory Development in the Social Sciences
9,543 Citations2005Alexander L. George, Andrew Bennett
The Foundations of Social Research: Meaning and Perspective in the Research Process
9,403 Citations1998Michael Crotty
Medical Entomology and ZoologyReal World Research: A Resource for Social Scientists and Practitioner-Researchers
6,247 Citations1993Colin Robson
Canadian Journal of Program EvaluationFourth-Generation Evaluation
5,992 Citations1988Anne Neufeld, Alan Ryan
Organization ScienceThe Duality of Technology: Rethinking the Concept of Technology in Organizations
4,786 Citations1992Wanda J. Orlikowski
The paper suggests that the reformulation of the technology concept and the structurational model of technology allow a deeper and more dialectical understanding of the interaction between technology and organizations.
A Realist Theory of Science
4,008 Citations2013Roy Bhaskar
European Journal of Information SystemsInterpretive case studies in IS research: nature and method
3,738 Citations1995Geoff Walsham
The paper aims to provide a useful reference point for researchers who wish to work in the interpretive tradition, and more generally to encourage careful work on the conceptualisation and execution of case studies in the information systems field.
Social Studies of ScienceThe Social Construction of Facts and Artefacts: or How the Sociology of Science and the Sociology of Technology might Benefit Each Other
3,384 Citations1984Trevor Pinch, Wiebe E. Bijker
Information Systems ResearchStudying Information Technology in Organizations: Research Approaches and Assumptions
3,344 Citations1991Wanda J. Orlikowski, Jack J. Baroudi
It is suggested that much can be gained if a plurality of research perspectives is effectively employed to investigate information systems phenomena and that there exist other philosophical assumptions that can inform studies of the relationships between information technology, people, and organizations.
Realist social theory the morphogenetic approach
2,798 Citations1995Margaret S. Archer
Information Systems ResearchResearch Commentary: Desperately Seeking the “IT” in IT Research—A Call to Theorizing the IT Artifact
2,722 Citations2001Wanda J. Orlikowski, Calogero Iacono
It is proposed that IS researchers begin to theorize specifically about IT artifacts, and then incorporate these theories explicitly into their studies, and believe that such a research direction is critical if IS research is to make a significant contribution to the understanding of a world increasingly suffused with ubiquitous, interdependent, and emergent information technologies.
Philosophy of Natural Science
2,506 Citations1966Carl G. Hempel
How the Laws of Physics Lie
2,095 Citations1983Nancy Cartwright
European Journal of Operational ResearchInterpreting information systems in organizations
2,030 Citations1995
Cambridge University Press eBooksNuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences
1,984 Citations1989Jon Elster
Realism and social science
1,761 Citations2000Andrew Sayer
Cambridge University Press eBooksSocial Mechanisms
1,754 Citations1998Peter Hedström, Peter Hedström +12 more
SU+ Digital Repository (Strathmore University)Scientific Realism: How Science Tracks Truth
1,657 Citations1999Stathis Psillos
The Philosophical QuarterlyThe Possibility of Naturalism: A Philosophical Critique of the Contemporary Human Sciences.
1,653 Citations1982Gilly Cantor, Roy Bhaskar
Qualitative data analysis
1,573 Citations2023Elena Chatzopoulou
Information Systems ResearchGeneralizing Generalizability in Information Systems Research
1,550 Citations2003Allen S. Lee, Richard Baskerville
The framework indicates ways in which researchers in information systems and other fields may properly lay claim to generalizability, and thereby broader relevance, even when their inquiry falls outside the bounds of sampling-based research.
Information Systems ResearchCombining IS Research Methods: Towards a Pluralist Methodology
1,376 Citations2001John Mingers
It is suggested that research results will be richer and more reliable if different research methods, preferably from different (existing) paradigms, are routinely combined together.
MIS QuarterlyA Scientific Methodology for MIS Case Studies
1,314 Citations1989Allen S. Lee
An overview of the methodological problems involved in the study of a single case is provided, scientific method is described, an elucidation of how a previously published MIS case study captures the major features of scientific method, and what a scientific methodology for MIS case studies does, and does not, involve are summarized.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsBeing Human: The Problem of Agency
1,293 Citations2002Ulf Himmelstrand, Margaret S. Archer
MIS QuarterlyCombining Qualitative and Quantitative Methods in Information Systems Research: A Case Study1
1,082 Citations1988Bonnie Kaplan, Dennis Duchon
No one approach to information systems research can provide the richness that information systems, as a discipline, needs for further advancement, so the desirability for a variety of approaches to studying information systems is found.
Nature's Capacities and Their Measurement
1,076 Citations1994Nancy Cartwright
Information Systems ResearchThe Emergence of Interpretivism in IS Research
1,050 Citations1995Geoff Walsham
The paper contributes to analysis of the development of the IS field as a whole, and provides some conceptual ideas and a reference point for further work in this relatively neglected area of research.
Choice Reviews OnlineCulture and agency: the place of culture in social theory
1,046 Citations1989Margaret S. Archer
Organization ScienceIntegrating Positivist and Interpretive Approaches to Organizational Research
1,022 Citations1991Allen S. Lee
The Whale and the Reactor
1,002 Citations1988Langdon Winner
Explaining Society: Critical Realism in the Social Sciences
972 Citations2001Berth Danermark, Mats Ekström +1 more
Educational ResearcherCausal Explanation, Qualitative Research, and Scientific Inquiry in Education
772 Citations2004Joseph A. Maxwell
Cambridge University Press eBooksSocial mechanisms: An introductory essay
736 Citations1998Peter Hedström, Richard Swedberg
The Information SocietyShaping the Web: Why the Politics of Search Engines Matters
682 Citations2000Lucas D. Introna
It is argued that search engines raise not merely technical issues but also political ones, raising doubts whether, in particular, the market mechanism could serve as an acceptable corrective.
OmegaMultimethodology: Towards a framework for mixing methodologies
672 Citations1997John Mingers, John Brocklesby
A framework that can attend to the relative strengths of different methodologies and provide a basis for constructing multimethodology designs is described, and a systematic way of decomposing methodologies to identify detachable elements is presented.
Academy of Management ReviewThe Validity of Idiographic Research Explanations
668 Citations1989Haridimos Tsoukas
Philosophy of the Social SciencesMechanisms in the Analysis of Social Macro-Phenomena
607 Citations2004Renate Mayntz
Critical Scientific Realism
605 Citations2002Ilkka Niiniluoto
Readings in the philosophy of social science
519 Citations1994Mike W. Martin, Lee McIntyre
Philosophy of Science: The Central Issues
441 Citations1998Martin Curd, J. A. Cover
Information and OrganizationReal-izing information systems: critical realism as an underpinning philosophy for information systems
422 Citations2004John Mingers
Critical realism is proposed as an underpinning philosophy that has the potential to overcome both sets of difficulties within the underlying philosophies of science—particularly positivism and interpretivism.
European Journal of Information SystemsThe Labyrinths of Information: Challenging the Wisdom of Systems
412 Citations2005Ray J. Paul
From Control to Drift
357 Citations2000Claudio U. Ciborra, Kristin Braa +8 more
Medical Entomology and ZoologyInformation systems research : issues, methods, and practical guidelines
354 Citations1992Robert D. Galliers
Social theory and philosophy for information systems
336 Citations2004John Mingers, Leslie P. Willcocks
Collecting major social theorists and philosophers into one volume, Social Theory and Philosophy for Information Systems provides a historical and critical analysis of each that is both authoritative and firmly focused on practical relevance to IS.
INFORMATION SYSTEMS EPISTEMOLOGY: AN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
331 Citations2000Rudy Hirschheim
This paper takes an historical perspective on information systems epistemology and hopes to expose some of the hidden assumptions which lie behind the authors' conception of valid research and valid research methods.
The Ontological Status of Theoretical Entities
327 Citations2014
The British Journal of Social WorkBeyond Social Constructionism: Critical Realism and Social Work
309 Citations2001Stan Houston
Organization StudiesOrganization, Trust and Control: A Realist Analysis
307 Citations2001Michael I. Reed
MIS QuarterlyThe Problem of Statistical Power in MIS Research
302 Citations1989Jack J. Baroudi, Wanda J. Orlikowski
This article should serve as a useful guide for MIS researcher sin the planning, execution, and interpretation of inferential statistical analyses.
Information Systems and Global Diversity
273 Citations2003Chrisanthi Avgerou
The author shows how the processes of ICT innovation and organizational change reflect local aspirations, concerns, and action, as well as the multiple institutional influences of globalization.
Critical Realist Applications in Organisation and Management Studies
270 Citations2005Steve Fleetwood, Stephen Ackroyd
The Economic JournalNuts and Bolts: For the Social Sciences.
247 Citations1990Alexander Rosenberg, Jon Elster
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyThe contribution of critical realism as an underpinning philosophy for OR/MS and systems
223 Citations2000John Mingers
This paper proposes that a particular account of the philosophy of science, known as ‘critical realism’, is especially suitable as an underpinning of OR/MS.
Philosophy of the Social SciencesThe Mechanisms of Emergence
192 Citations2004R. Keith Sawyer
The author draws on philosophy of mind and various complexity concepts to propose a set of criteria whereby one can determine whether a given social mechanism generates emergent properties, in the sense that their explanation cannot be reduced to a mechanistic account of individuals and their interactions.
Critical Realism, Post-positivism and the Possibility of Knowledge
164 Citations2004Ruth Groff
Making realism work : realist social theory and empirical research
159 Citations2004Bob S. Carter, Caroline New
Journal of Information TechnologyEvaluating information systems projects: a multidimensional approach
144 Citations1998Guy Fitzgerald
Journal of Information TechnologyTowards dissolution of the is research debate: from polarization to polarity
136 Citations1998Brian Fitzgerald, Debra Howcroft
Internet ResearchAssessing community informatics: a review of methodological approaches for evaluating community networks and community technology centers
136 Citations2002Dara O’Neil
Analysis of the emerging community informatics evaluation literature finds that community networks and community technology center assessments fall into five key areas: strong democracy; social capital; individual empowerment; sense of community; and economic development opportunities.
DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals)Critical realism and information systems research: Why bother with philosophy?
135 Citations2002Philip Dobson
Journal of MarketingTruth in Marketing Theory and Research: An Alternative Perspective
133 Citations1992George M. Zinkhan, Rudy Hirschheim
Oxford University Press eBooksThe Social Study of Information and Communication Technology: Innovation, Actors, and Contexts
132 Citations2004Chrisanthi Avgerou, Claudio Ciborra +1 more
The carbon fixation patterns of Isoetes lacustris and Lobelia dortmanna suggest that the CO2 concentration in the loch may be growth limiting, and that root uptake and/or dark acidification are means of optimising CO2 supply.
Philosophy of the Social SciencesNonreductive Individualism Part II—Social Causation
131 Citations2003R. Keith Sawyer
Medical Entomology and ZoologyFrom Science to Emancipation: Alienation and the Actuality of Enlightenment
125 Citations2003Roy Bhaskar
Journal of International DevelopmentWired for change: the links between ICTs and development discourses
119 Citations2002Susanne Schech
It is argued that those who enthusiastically embrace ICTs tend to operate within a modernization discourse, while sceptics are influenced by dependency and post-colonial discourses of development.
OmegaInformation systems: what sort of science is it?
116 Citations2000Chrisanthi Avgerou
It is argued that the major strength of the field is its responsiveness to a large variety of issues emerging in organisations as they learn to exploit the new technological potential.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsMicrofoundations, Method, and Causation: On the Philosophy of the Social Sciences
115 Citations1999Aage B. Sørensen, Daniel Little
Information and OrganizationThe order of technology: Complexity and control in a connected world
113 Citations2005Jannis Kallinikos
Current developments, as manifested in the diffusion of large-scale information systems and mostly the internet spin a web of technological relations that challenge the strategies of functional simplification and closure and the organizational practices that have traditionally accommodated them.
MIS QuarterlyDiscovery and Representation of Causal Relationships in MIS Research: A Methodological Framework1
101 Citations1997Byungtae Lee, Anitesh Barua +1 more
The paper describes the representational shortcomings and statistical pitfalls of factor-analytic methods commonly deployed in empirical research and proposes using TETRAD, a non-parametric tool, at the exploratory phase for its ability to accommodate a wide variety of causal models.
European Journal of Social TheoryRefusing the Realism—Structuration Divide
98 Citations2001Rob Stones
Review of Political EconomyCausal Laws, Functional Relations and Tendencies
96 Citations2001Steve Fleetwood
The future for philosophy
91 Citations2004Brian Leiter
Sociologija Mintis ir veiksmasOn Using ANT for Studying Information Systems: A (Somewhat) Socratic Dialogue
84 Citations2020Bruno Latour
Tai Bruno Latouro straipsnio, kuris parašytas kaip dialogas, „On Using ANT for Studying Information Systems: A (Somewhat) Socratic Dialogue“ vertimas.
Evaluation Journal of AustralasiaRealist Evaluation in Practice: Health and Social Work
81 Citations2007Eric Weir, Mansoor A.F. Kazi
This chapter discusses the development of Realism for Practice, and the use of Interpretivist Research Methods in Realist Evaluation.
Elsevier eBooksThe evaluation of information systems: a critique
78 Citations1991Veronica Symons, Geoff Walsham
This chapter presents a critique of the literature on information systems research and evaluation research, and suggests a particular perspective on information system evaluation that is used to discuss the deficiencies of several approaches to the evaluation of information systems.
London School of Economics and Political Science Research Online (London School of Economics and Political Science)Reopening the Black Box of Technology Artifacts and Human Agency
76 Citations2002Jannis Kallinikos
The argument presented in this article is that the premises governing human-technology interaction partly derive from the distinctive ways by which each technology defines a domain of reference, and organizes and codifies knowledge and experience within it.
Science Technology & Human ValuesComputers and the Transformation of Social Analysis
59 Citations1991Steve Woolgar, Keith Grint
It is important to examine what happens to traditional arguments about the impact of technology when the more virulent arguments from relativismconstructivism are brought to bear.
Journal of Information TechnologyAn exploratory study of information systems in support of employee empowerment
55 Citations2000Anna Psoinos, Thomas Kern +1 more
Journal of Information TechnologyParadigm Wars: Ceasefire Announced who Will set up the New Administration? <sup>†</sup>
55 Citations2004John Mingers
This paper presents a personal overview of the history of the IS discipline over the last 20 years, and highlights two particular strands of development over which there has been much controversy – the so-called paradigm wars and the related debate over a critical approach to information systems.
…