Member Checking: Can Benefits Be Gained Similar to Group Therapy?
The Qualitative ReportPublished 9 June 2015Open access
Melissa Harper, Patricia M. Cole
Citations340
SNIP1.27
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
Member checking continues to be an important quality control process in qualitative research as during the course of conducting a study, participants receive the opportunity to review their statements for accuracy and, in so doing; they may acquire a therapeutic benefit. The authors of this article suggest that this benefit is similar to some of the components of group therapy, especially in normalizing the phenomenon being experienced. Even if the participants never meet, they can feel a sense of relief that their feelings are validated and that they are not alone.
Keywords
Social SciencesHealth Professions
Qualitative inquiry and research design: choosing among five traditions.
18,670 Citations1998John W. Creswell
Phenomenological research methods
13,453 Citations1994Clark E. Moustakas
International Journal of Qualitative MethodsVerification Strategies for Establishing Reliability and Validity in Qualitative Research
4,938 Citations2002Janice M. Morse, Michael Barrett +3 more
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Theory and Practice of Group Psychotherapy:
4,154 Citations1990Irvin D. Yalom, Eric Crouch
The present book is the central work of the set and seems to me the most substantial and one of the most readable of his works because of its straightforward style and the liberal use of clinical examples.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyMaking sense of qualitative data
3,774 Citations1996Amanda Coffey, Paul Atkinson
BMJChecklists for improving rigour in qualitative research: a case of the tail wagging the dog?
2,557 Citations2001Rosaline S. Barbour
It is argued that there is no substitute for systematic and thorough application of the principles of qualitative research and technical fixes will achieve little unless they are embedded in a broader understanding of the rationale and assumptions behind qualitative research.
Making sense of qualitative data complementary research strategies
560 Citations1996Coffey, Amanda 1967-, Atkinson, Paul 1947-
Health Care For Women InternationalMember Checking With Older Women: A Framework for Negotiating Meaning
433 Citations2007Susanna Doyle
In this study a methodology for conducting member checks is developed that is consistent with participatory approaches and the active negotiation of meaning inherent in this paradigm.
International Journal of Social Research MethodologyInviting intimacy: The interview as therapeutic opportunity
301 Citations2000Maxine Birch, Tina Miller
Image the Journal of Nursing ScholarshipBenefits of Participating in Research Interviews
281 Citations1994Sally A. Hutchinson, Margaret E. Wilson +1 more
C catharsis, self-acknowledgement, sense of purpose,Self-awareness, empowerment, healing, and providing a voice for the disenfranchised as the sometimes unanticipated benefits reported by interview participants are described.
Educational ResearcherSelf-Care and the Qualitative Researcher: When Collecting Data Can Break Your Heart
198 Citations2005Kathleen B. Rager
This article addresses the essential nature of the emotional connection that must be part of the qualitative research process and calls for increased awareness of these issues and their significance in the preparation of novice researchers.
AORN JournalEvaluating the findings of qualitative research
156 Citations2001Michelle M. Byrne
An overview of strategies used to support and evaluate qualitative research is provided, to see how the concepts of credibility, transferability, and confirmability are met in a study.
International Journal of Social Research MethodologyQualitative bereavement research: incongruity between the perspectives of participants and research ethics boards
105 Citations2009Jennifer L. Buckle, Sonya Corbin Dwyer +1 more
Nurse ResearcherQualitative interviewing: encountering ethical issues and challenges
102 Citations2006Amanda Clarke
The author argues that researchers must be mindful of the impact their questioning can have on subjects, especially those who are vulnerable, and suggests that a reflexive approach can help minimise the risk of harmful effects.
Journal of Advanced NursingParticipants’ experiences of being interviewed about an emotive topic
97 Citations2006Lesley Lowes, Gill Paul
The Qualitative ReportWhen Research Interviews are More Therapeutic Than Therapy Interviews
70 Citations1992Jerry Gale
Medical Entomology and ZoologyEssentials of Group Therapy
67 Citations2004Virginia A. Brabender, April Fallon +1 more
This series discusses theoretical Approaches to Group Psychotherapy, training Group Therapists for Current and Future Practice, and Ethical, Legal, and Group Management Issues.
Qualitative InquiryHow Interviewing Became Therapy for Wives of Professional Athletes: Learning From a Serendipitous Experience
56 Citations2001Steven M. Ortiz
Social Service ReviewTherapeutic Effects of Qualitative Research: Reconstructing the Experience of Treatment as a By‐Product of Qualitative Evaluation
49 Citations2003Michal Shamai
Qualitative Health ResearchThe Narrative Correspondence Method: What a Follow-Up Study Can Tell Us about the Longer Term Effect on Participants in Emotionally Demanding Research
44 Citations2004Anne Grinyer
Qualitative data gathered from the parents of young adults with cancer who, over the previous 4 years, had contributed narrative accounts to a research project on the experience of caring for a young adult son or daughter with the illness show that the parents valued their involvement, and many had found the process of writing therapeutic.
Journal of research in nursingThe culture of cancer and the therapeutic impact of qualitative research interviews
40 Citations2005Linda Colbourne, Magi Sque
There may be positive and negative aspects of a therapeutic component to the researcher role and that the researcher should think carefully concerning the stance that he/she will take in the field.
International Journal of Nursing PracticeTaming the rescuer: The therapeutic nature of qualitative research interviews
24 Citations2007Vicki Drury, Karen Francis +1 more
The dilemmas faced by a researcher when interviewing in a non-sensitive area is explored and the ethical decision-making that occurred during the interviews to prevent blurring of boundaries is explained.
Family ProcessDebriefing the Family: Is Research an Intervention?
19 Citations1995Danielle A. Bussell, KATHRYN COOKE MATSEY +2 more
Feedback from families participating in the Nonshared Environment and Adolescent Development project, a longitudinal study of family process and adolescent development, indicates that families differed in their perceptions about whether the research experience was positive, detrimental, or inconsequential.
International Journal of Pharmacy PracticeCan in-depth research interviews have a ‘therapeutic’ effect for participants?
19 Citations2004C Morecroft, Judy Cantrill +1 more
Whether there was any discernible ‘therapeutic’ effect upon participants after an in‐depth research interview, which focused upon their experiences of hypertension and its management, was explored.
Nursing InquirySocial poetics as research and practice: living in and learning from the process of research
14 Citations2001Dee Aldridge, Chris Stevenson
This paper is both a report of research work carried out by one author of the paper with the other involved in a supervisory role, and a reflection on methodology that was an emergent property of the research process.
Learning Disabilities Research and PracticeAnd Now the Rest of the Story: The Research Process as Intervention in Experimental and Qualitative Studies
11 Citations2000Daniel J. Boudah, B. Keith Lenz
The Qualitative ReportThe Unanticipated in Qualitative Inquiry
6 Citations2000Sally St. George, Dan Wulff
American Journal of Family TherapyTherapist debriefing interviews: Therapist versus ethnographer
1 Citations1999Lane Brigham, Harvey Joanning
