Emergence of Structural Patterns in Neutral Trophic Networks
PLoS ONEPublished 10 August 2012Open access
Elsa Canard, Nicolas Mouquet, Lucile Marescot, Kevin J. Gaston, Dominique Gravel, David Mouillot
Citations86
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.80
SNIP1.07
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This work presents a neutral model of predator-prey interactions and analyzes the structural characteristics of the simulated networks to suggest that neutral processes create “neutral forbidden links” due to uneven species abundance distributions and the low probability of interaction between rare species.
Abstract
Interaction networks are central elements of ecological systems and have very complex structures. Historically, much effort has focused on niche-mediated processes to explain these structures, while an emerging consensus posits that both niche and neutral mechanisms simultaneously shape many features of ecological communities. However, the study of interaction networks still lacks a comprehensive neutral theory. Here we present a neutral model of predator-prey interactions and analyze the structural characteristics of the simulated networks. We find that connectance values (complexity) and complexity-diversity relationships of neutral networks are close to those observed in empirical bipartite networks. High nestedness and low modularity values observed in neutral networks fall in the range of those from empirical antagonist bipartite networks. Our results suggest that, as an alternative to niche-mediated processes that induce incompatibility between species ("niche forbidden links"), neutral processes create "neutral forbidden links" due to uneven species abundance distributions and the low probability of interaction between rare species. Neutral trophic networks must be seen as the missing endpoint of a continuum from niche to purely stochastic approaches of community organization.
Keywords
Social SciencesAgricultural and Biological SciencesEnvironmental Science
EcologyTOWARD A METABOLIC THEORY OF ECOLOGY
7,791 Citations2004James H. Brown, James F. Gillooly +3 more
This work has developed a quantitative theory for how metabolic rate varies with body size and temperature, and predicts how metabolic theory predicts how this rate controls ecological processes at all levels of organization from individuals to the biosphere.
Journal of Theoretical BiologyThe measurement of diversity in different types of biological collections
5,791 Citations1966E. C. Pielou
Information content may be used as a measure of the diversity of a many-species biological collection whereby the sample size is progressively increased by addition of new quadrats and the mean increment in total diversity that results from enlarging the sample still more provides an estimate of the Diversity per individual in the whole population.
EcologyThe Unified Neutral Theory of Biodiversity and Biogeography
5,705 Citations2002Gottfried Jetschke, Stephen P. Hubbell
A study of the issue indicates that it is not a serious problem for neutral theory, and there is sometimes a difference between some of the simulation-based results of Hubbell and the analytical results of Volkov et al. (2003).
The American NaturalistOn Optimal Use of a Patchy Environment
4,435 Citations1966Robert H. MacArthur, Eric R. Pianka
A graphical method is discussed which allows a specification of the optimal diet of a predator in terms of the net amount of energy gained from a capture of prey as compared to the energy expended in searching for the prey.
NatureFunctional cartography of complex metabolic networks
4,013 Citations2005Roger Guimerà, Luı́s A. Nunes Amaral
A methodology is proposed that can find functional modules in complex networks, and classify nodes into universal roles according to their pattern of intra- and inter-module connections, which yields a ‘cartographic representation’ of complex networks.
The Quarterly Review of BiologyConceptual Synthesis in Community Ecology
2,645 Citations2010Mark Vellend
Organizing the material of community ecology according to this framework can clarify the essential similarities and differences among the many conceptual and theoretical approaches to the discipline, and allow for the articulation of a very general theory of community dynamics.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesThe nested assembly of plant–animal mutualistic networks
2,496 Citations2003Jordi Bascompte, Pedro Jordano +2 more
It is shown that mutualistic networks are highly nested; that is, the more specialist species interact only with proper subsets of those species interacting with the more generalists, which generates highly asymmetrical interactions and organizes the community cohesively around a central core of interactions.
Biological reviews/Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical SocietyBivariate line‐fitting methods for allometry
2,311 Citations2006David I. Warton, Ian J. Wright +2 more
This review describes for the practitioner the essential features of line‐fitting methods for estimating the relationship between two variables: what methods are commonly used, which method should be used when, and how to make inferences from these lines to answer common research questions.
ScienceStability of Ecological Communities and the Architecture of Mutualistic and Trophic Networks
1,818 Citations2010Élisa Thébault, Colin Fontaine
It is concluded that strong variations in the stability of architectural patterns constrain ecological networks toward different architectures, depending on the type of interaction.
NatureEcological networks and their fragility
1,490 Citations2006José M. Montoya, Stuart L. Pimm +1 more
E ecological networks, in which species are linked together, either directly or indirectly through intermediate species, have well defined patterns that both illuminate the ecological mechanisms underlying them and promise a better understanding of the relationship between complexity and ecological stability.
Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesTolerance of pollination networks to species extinctions
1,204 Citations2004Jane Memmott, Nickolas M. Waser +1 more
Tolerance in pollination networks contrasts with catastrophic declines reported from standard food webs, and the most–linked pollinators were bumble–bees and some solitary bees, which should receive special attention in efforts to conserve temperate pollination systems.
NatureThe architecture of mutualistic networks minimizes competition and increases biodiversity
1,165 Citations2009Ugo Bastolla, Miguel A. Fortuna +4 more
It is shown that nestedness reduces effective interspecific competition and enhances the number of coexisting species, and that a nested network will naturally emerge if new species are more likely to enter the community where they have minimal competitive load.
International Journal for ParasitologyInternational Journal for Parasitology
1,159 Citations2014Alex Loukas, Brian M. Cooke +2 more
Ecology LettersNeutral theory and community ecology
1,138 Citations2004Jérôme Chave
The mathematical and biological aspects of Hubbell’s (2001) neutral theory of species abundance for ecological communities are reviewed, and its historical connections with closely related approaches in population genetics are clarified.
Journal of Animal EcologyReview: Ecological networks – beyond food webs
940 Citations2008Thomas C. Ings, José M. Montoya +15 more
A number of 'dead ends' and 'fruitful avenues' are suggested for future research into ecological networks by suggesting a new catalogue of evermore complete, taxonomically resolved, and quantitative data.
Ecology LettersInvariant properties in coevolutionary networks of plant–animal interactions
872 Citations2002Pedro Jordano, Jordi Bascompte +1 more
This work hypothesizes that plant–animal mutualistic networks follow a build-up process similar to complex abiotic nets, based on the preferential attachment of species, and reveals generalized topological patterns characteristic of self-organized complex systems.
Ecology LettersReconciling niche and neutrality: the continuum hypothesis
833 Citations2006Dominique Gravel, Charles D. Canham +2 more
Results demonstrate that niche and neutrality form ends of a continuum from competitive to stochastic exclusion, and whether the relative importance of niche vs. neutral processes in controlling community dynamics will vary depending on community species richness, niche overlap and dispersal capabilities of species.
EcologyCOEXISTENCE OF THE NICHE AND NEUTRAL PERSPECTIVES IN COMMUNITY ECOLOGY
770 Citations2006Mathew A. Leibold, Mark A. McPeek
It is argued that both evolutionary and ecological processes operate to promote the introduction and to sustain the persistence of ecologically similar and in many cases nearly equivalent species embedded in highly structured food webs.
Physical Review EModularity and community detection in bipartite networks
751 Citations2007Michael Barber
The bipartite modularity is presented in terms of a modularity matrix B; some key properties of the eigenspectrum of B are identified and used to describe an algorithm for identifying modules in bipartites networks.
Ecological MonographsArtifacts or Attributes? Effects of Resolution on the Little Rock Lake Food Web
709 Citations1991Neo D. Martinez
It is suggested that food-web patterns such as the scale-invariant links- per-species ratio, short chain lengths, and limited number of trophic levels are constrained by the resolution of food- web data rather than by ecological factors.
Journal of Theoretical BiologyThe measurement of diversity in different types of biological collections
602 Citations1967E.C. Pielou
Community Food Webs: Data and Theory
535 Citations2011Joel E. Cohen, Frédéric Briand +2 more
This book proposes a novel theory unifying many of the recently discovered empirical regularities in real food webs, as well as extensive empirical data, and shows that community food webs obey several striking phenomenological regularities.
Journal of Animal EcologyNestedness versus modularity in ecological networks: two sides of the same coin?
517 Citations2010Miguel A. Fortuna, Daniel B. Stouffer +6 more
It is found that the correlation between nestedness and modularity for a population of random matrices generated from the real communities decreases significantly in magnitude and sign with increasing connectance independent of the network type.
EcologyTEMPORAL DYNAMICS IN A POLLINATION NETWORK
509 Citations2008Jens M. Olesen, Jordi Bascompte +2 more
The day-to-day dynamics of an arctic pollination interaction network over two consecutive seasons are studied and temporal dynamics provides a mechanistic explanation for previously reported network patterns such as the heterogeneous distribution of number of interactions across species.
The American NaturalistConstant Connectance in Community Food Webs
469 Citations1992Neo D. Martinez
Results from the constant connectance hypothesis combined with related findings regarding food chain lengths indicate that large food webs have many more links and much longer food chains than previously suggested.
The American NaturalistThe Distribution of Abundance in Neutral Communities
455 Citations2000Graham Bell
The patterns of abundance generated by a simple stochastic birth‐death‐immigration model are described in order to characterize the diversity of neutral communities of ecologically equivalent species and demonstrates the necessity for an appropriate null model when functional hypotheses are being tested.
EcologyEvaluating multiple determinants of the structure of plant–animal mutualistic networks
441 Citations2009Diego P. Vázquez, Natacha P. Chacoff +1 more
The results suggest that both relative species abundance and complementarity in spatiotemporal distribution contribute substantially to generate observed network patters, but that this information is by no means sufficient to predict the occurrence and frequency of pairwise interactions.
NaturePhylogenetic constraints and adaptation explain food-web structure
420 Citations2004Marie-France Cattin, Louis‐Félix Bersier +3 more
A new model built on the hypothesis that any species' diet is the consequence of phylogenetic constraints and adaptation is proposed, which better reflects the complexity and multidimensionality of most natural systems.
Journal of BiogeographyA new algorithm to calculate the nestedness temperature of presence–absence matrices
415 Citations2006Miguel A. Rodríguez‐Gironés, Luis Santamarı́a
A new algorithm, BINMATNEST (binary matrix nestedness temperature calculator), that overcomes difficulties in the algorithm implemented by the NTC.
Trends in Ecology & EvolutionThe merits of neutral theory
385 Citations2006David Alonso, Rampal S. Etienne +1 more
It is argued that neutral theory is also a stochastic theory, a sampling theory and a dispersal-limited theory, and these important additional features should be retained in future theoretical developments of community ecology.
Journal of Animal EcologyA truce with neutral theory: local deterministic factors, species traits and dispersal limitation together determine patterns of diversity in stream invertebrates
371 Citations2006Ross M. Thompson, Colin R. Townsend
Assemblages of species with low and moderate dispersal ability were best predicted by combined models, including distance between sites and local ecological factors, and the perceived dichotomy between neutral and local environmental processes in determining local patterns of diversity may not be useful.
Journal of Theoretical BiologyWhy nestedness in mutualistic networks?
345 Citations2007Enrique Burgos, Horacio Ceva +5 more
It is established that a nested pattern of contacts is the best possible one as far as robustness is concerned, but only when the least linked species have the greater probability of becoming extinct.
The Network Structure of Food Webs
344 Citations2005Jennifer A. Dunne
The history of the search for generalities in the structure of complex food webs is reviewed, current and future research trends are discussed, and it is suggested that once variable diversity and connectance are taken into account, there are universal coarse-grained characteristics of how trophic links and species are distributed.
ScienceScale and Structure in Natural Food Webs
288 Citations1992Karl E. Havens
The degree to which widely accepted generalizations about food web structure apply to natural communities was determined through examination of 50 pelagic webs sampled consistently with even taxonomic resolution of all trophic levels, suggesting that the link-species scaling law does not reflect a real ecological trend.
EcographyNull Versus Neutral Models: What's The Difference?
280 Citations2006N. J. Gotelli, Brian J. McGill
The neutral model posits that random variation in extinction and speciation events, coupled with limited dispersal, can account for many community properties, including the relative abundance distribution, and has recently been proposed as a specific form of more general null models in biogeography and community ecology.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesForaging biology predicts food web complexity
273 Citations2006Andrew P. Beckerman, Owen L. Petchey +1 more
It is shown that a simple diet breadth model predicts highly constrained values of connectance as an emergent consequence of individual foraging behavior, and provides a mechanistic explanation of connectances currently lacking in food web models.
Ecology LettersCompartments in a marine food web associated with phylogeny, body mass, and habitat structure
256 Citations2009Enrico L. Rezende, Eva M. Albert +2 more
Computational tools from the physics of complex networks with phylogenetic statistical methods are combined to show that a large marine food web is organized in compartments, and that body size, phylogeny, and spatial structure are jointly associated with such a compartmentalized structure.
Journal of EcologyEcological networks, nestedness and sampling effort
254 Citations2007Anders Nielsen, Jordi Bascompte
This work manipulates sampling effort in time and space and shows that nestedness is less sensitive to sampling effort than number of species and links within the network, indicating that the sensitivity of ecological networks properties to effects of sampling effort might be smaller than previously expected.
Journal of Animal EcologySpecies abundance and the distribution of specialization in host–parasite interaction networks
253 Citations2005Diego P. Vázquez, Robert Poulin +2 more
In parallel with recent studies of plant‐animal mutualistic networks, these analyses suggest that host‐parasite interactions in these systems are highly asymmetric: specialist parasites tend to interact with hosts with high parasite richness, whereas hosts with low parasite richness tend to interaction mainly with generalist parasites.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesThe assembly and disassembly of ecological networks
238 Citations2009Jordi Bascompte, Daniel B. Stouffer
This work focuses on network assembly by emphasizing temporal processes at the species level, as well as the structural building blocks of complex ecological networks, and on network disassembly as a consequence of species extinctions or habitat loss.
OikosA neutral‐niche theory of nestedness in mutualistic networks
225 Citations2008Abhay Krishna, Paulo R. Guimarães +2 more
The neutral theory of biodiversity is extended for the first time to a multi trophic system and the importance of relative species abundance (RSA) for the nested assembly of plant–animal mutualistic networks is investigated.
Theoretical Population BiologyThe structure of food webs
220 Citations1979Stuart L. Pimm
For nonrandom models of species interaction there is a precipitous decrease in stability as connectance increases, however, the range of stability for different models of the same connectance is large; stability also depends on how the species interactions are organized.
EcologyOrigin of compartmentalization in food webs
204 Citations2010Roger Guimerà, Daniel B. Stouffer +4 more
It is found that the compartmentalization observed in empirical food webs can be accounted for solely by the niche organization of species and their diets, and the composition of compartments can be used to address the long-standing question of what determines the ecological niche of a species.
OikosTopological properties of food webs: from real data to community assembly models
196 Citations2003José M. Montoya, Ricard V. Solé
A device to lower bulk material from a supply level down to a discharge conveyor which device will avoid free falls of material when in operation such as would damage the material.
Advances in ecological research/Advances in Ecological ResearchFood Webs, Body Size, and Species Abundance in Ecological Community Description
195 Citations2005Tomas Jönsson, Joel E. Cohen +1 more
I. Summary of Trivariate Relationships and EVect of Food Web Perturbation.
OecologiaAsymmetric specialization and extinction risk in plant–flower visitor webs: a matter of morphology or abundance?
161 Citations2006Martina Stang, Peter G. L. Klinkhamer +1 more
The simulations showed that both nectar-holder depth and abundance were able to produce asymmetry; but that the expected degree of asymmetry was stronger if based on both, and that asymmetric specialization could not be the reason that the extinction risk of specialists and generalists is equalized, as suggested in the literature.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B Biological SciencesSelf–organized instability in complex ecosystems
139 Citations2002Ricard V. Solé, David Alonso +1 more
This work explores a recent stochastic model of population dynamics that is shown to reproduce and suggests that the patterns displayed by species-rich communities, including rarity, would result from such a spontaneous tendency towards instability.
Ecological MonographsTemporal Variation in Food Web Structure: 16 Empirical Cases
120 Citations1991Kenneth G. Schoenly, Joel E. Cohen
The relation between cumulative and time—specific versions of webs in 16 published cases is analyzed, finding that a single opportunistic species, even though it makes only rare and brief visits to a habitat, can dramatically reshape web structure.
EcologyFood webs are built up with nested subwebs
109 Citations2010Michio Kondoh, Satoshi Kato +1 more
It is shown that 31 published food webs consist of bipartite subwebs that are as highly nested as mutualistic networks, contradicting the hypothesis that antagonistic interactions disfavor nested structure and suggesting that nested networks may be a common pattern of communities that include resource-consumer interactions.
EcologyRareness and specialization in plant–pollinator networks
104 Citations2010Jimena Dorado, Diego P. Vázquez +2 more
This study shows that trap nest sampling was good for estimating rare species degree, and proposes the analysis of food composition in bee trap nests to assess the reliability of network specialization estimates.
International Journal for ParasitologyNestedness, anti-nestedness, and the relationship between prevalence and intensity in ectoparasite assemblages of marine fish: a spatial model of species coexistence
96 Citations2000Robert Poulin, Jean‐François Guégan
The results presented here suggest that, although nestedness may not be common in parasite communities, other departures from random species assembly are possible, and that some form of structure may be present in many communities.
Ecological ComplexityThe signature of phylogenetic constraints on food-web structure
91 Citations2008Louis‐Félix Bersier, Patrik Kehrli
The exploration of the relationship between trophic and taxonomic similarity in food-webs shows that phylogeny and Trophic structure are closely linked, and it is important to understand how evolutionary processes shaping body sizes can affect food-web structure.
Journal of Animal EcologyConnectance in stream food webs
89 Citations2002J. M. Schmid‐Araya, Peter Schmid +4 more
The link scaling law and the constant connectance hypothesis must be rejected for food webs in stream systems because of the high physical heterogeneity and complexity of the sedimentary habitat.
Functional EcologyScaling from individuals to networks in food webs
71 Citations2010Daniel B. Stouffer
Paying greater attention to both the similarities and differences between the two types of models will be better able to demonstrate the ecological insights offered by phenomenological models, and will help to understanding the true origins of food-web structure.
Journal of Theoretical BiologyEmergence of complexity in evolving niche-model food webs
51 Citations2007Christian Guill, Barbara Drossel
It is found that despite the stabilising effect of foraging adaptation the system displays elements of self-organised critical behaviour and the conclusion that in the framework of the niche model adaptive foraging is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the emergence of complex networks.
Theoretical EcologyHow trophic interaction strength depends on traits
51 Citations2009Axel G. Rossberg, Åke Brännström +1 more
It is shown how a community’s, potentially low-dimens ional, effective trophic niche space is related to its higher-dimensional phenotypic trait space, and implies a method for directly measuring this dimensionality.
Ecology LettersSpeed of expansion and extinction in experimental populations
21 Citations2009John M. Drake, Blaine D. Griffen
The first empirical tests of the prediction of equal passage times entailed by diffusion models of population dynamics are reported, supporting continued application in both population theory and conservation decision making under the restricted conditions where the approximation can be expected to hold.
EcologyOrigin of compartmentalization in food webs
20 Citations2010Roger Guimerà, Daniel B. Stouffer +4 more
RePEc: Research Papers in EconomicsSelf-organized Instability in Complex Ecosystems
4 Citations2001Ricard V. Solé, David Alonso +1 more