Why Review Articles on the Health Effects of Passive Smoking Reach Different Conclusions
JAMAPublished 20 May 1998
Deborah E. Barnes
Citations430
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score5.35
SNIP10.71
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The conclusions of review articles on the health effects of passive smoking are strongly associated with the affiliations of their authors, and readers should consider authors' affiliations when deciding how to judge an article's conclusions.
Abstract
The conclusions of review articles are strongly associated with the affiliations of their authors. Authors of review articles should disclose potential financial conflicts of interest, and readers of review articles should consider authors' affiliations when deciding how to judge an article's conclusions.
Keywords
Social SciencesMedicine
Annals of Internal MedicineSystematic Reviews: Synthesis of Best Evidence for Clinical Decisions
2,186 Citations1997Deborah J. Cook, Cynthia D. Mulrow +1 more
Patients' inquiries about breast cancer screening and exercise treatment for claudication highlight the need for a concise, current, rigorous synthesis of the best available evidence on each of these topics: in brief, a systematic review.
BMJSystematic Reviews: Rationale for systematic reviews
1,642 Citations1994Cynthia D. Mulrow
Systematic literature reviews establish whether scientific findings are consistent and can be generalised across populations, settings, and treatment variations, or whether findings vary significantly by particular subsets.
Journal of Educational StatisticsSumming up: The Science of Reviewing Research
1,490 Citations1987Ian P. Wilkinson, Richard J. Light +1 more
JAMAA Comparison of Results of Meta-analyses of Randomized Control Trials and Recommendations of Clinical Experts
1,464 Citations1992Elliott M. Antman
Finding and analyzing all therapeutic trials in a given field has become such a difficult and specialized task that the clinical experts called on to summarize the evidence in a timely fashion need access to better databases and new statistical techniques to assist them.
New England Journal of MedicineMeta-Analyses of Randomized Controlled Trials
1,268 Citations1987Henry S. Sacks, Jayne Berrier +3 more
Annals of Internal MedicineThe Medical Review Article: State of the Science
854 Citations1987Cynthia D. Mulrow
It is indicated that current medical reviews do not routinely use scientific methods to identify, assess, and synthesize information.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyValidation of an index of the quality of review articles
789 Citations1991Andrew D Oxman, Gordon Guyatt
The OQAQ is a valid measure of the quality of research overviews and the primary shortcoming noted was the need for judgement in applying the index.
BMJThe accumulated evidence on lung cancer and environmental tobacco smoke
736 Citations1997Allan Hackshaw, M R Law +1 more
The epidemiological and biochemical evidence on exposure to environmental Tobacco smoke, with the supporting evidence of tobacco specific carcinogens in the blood and urine of non-smokers exposed to environmental tobacco smoke, provides compelling confirmation that breathing other people's tobacco smoke is a cause of lung cancer.
BMJEnvironmental tobacco smoke exposure and ischaemic heart disease: an evaluation of the evidence
606 Citations1997M R Law, Joan K. Morris +1 more
Breathing other people's smoke is an important and avoidable cause of ischaemic heart disease, increasing a person's risk by a quarter, and platelet aggregation provides a plausible and quantitatively consistent mechanism for the low dose effect.
Health PolicyEnvironmental tobacco smoke. Measuring exposures and assessing health effects
519 Citations1987Hugo Kesteloot
PubMedGuidelines for reading literature reviews.
495 Citations1988Andrew D Oxman, Gordon Guyatt
New guidelines that will help readers assess the scientific quality of the review are proposed and will allow clinicians to spend their valuable reading time on high-quality material and to judge the validity of an author's conclusions.
Journal of General Internal MedicineSource of funding and outcome of clinical trials
403 Citations1986Richard A. Davidson
Few trials supported by pharmaceutical manufacturers favored traditional therapy; some reasons for this finding may include selection of drugs likely to be proven efficacious, Type II errors (false-negative studies), and fear of discontinuation of funding should such studies be submitted.
European Journal of General PracticeEffect of Maternal Cigarette Smoking on Pregnancy Complications and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome
354 Citations1995Joseph R. DiFranza, Robert Lew
The low success rate of smoking cessation among pregnant women suggests that efforts to reduce the complications of pregnancy attributable to tobacco use by pregnant women should focus on preventing nicotine addiction among teenaged girls.
Controlled Clinical TrialsMethodology and overt and hidden bias in reports of 196 double-blind trials of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs in rheumatoid arthritis
336 Citations1989Peter C Gøtzsche
Important design aspects were decreasingly reported in NSAID trials over the years, whereas the quality of statistical analysis improved, and it is not obvious how a reliable meta-analysis could be done in these trials.
Annals of Internal MedicineThe Quality of Drug Studies Published in Symposium Proceedings
333 Citations1996Mildred K. Cho, Lisa A. Bero
If symposia sponsored by drug companies are a growing source of information about drugs for pharmacists and physicians, assessing the quality of the articles in these symposium is important, and the methodologic quality and relevance of drug studies published in symposiums with those of studies that were published in Symphony that had other sponsors or in the peer-reviewed parent journals are compared.
International Journal of EpidemiologyComparing Two Methods of Clinical Measurement: A Personal History
294 Citations1995J M Bland, Douglas G. Altman
The problems with the main methods used, notably correlation and regression, are explained, and the limits of agreement approach which is proposed is proposed.
Journal of Clinical EpidemiologyAgreement among reviewers of review articles
283 Citations1991Andrew D Oxman, Gordon Guyatt +5 more
Assessment of the consistency of an index of the scientific quality of research overviews found it was possible to achieve reasonable to excellent agreement for all of the items in the index, including the overall assessment of scientific quality.
Archives of Internal MedicineA study of manufacturer-supported trials of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs in the treatment of arthritis
275 Citations1994Paula A. Rochon
JAMAMinimizing the Three Stages of Publication Bias
225 Citations1990Thomas C. Chalmers
Bias can be minimized by insisting on high-quality research and thorough literature reviews, eliminating the double standard concerning peer review and informed consent applied to clinical research and practice, and publishing legitimate trials regardless of their results.
Journal of the American College of CardiologyPassive smoking as a cause of heart disease
223 Citations1994A. Judson Wells
It is concluded that passive smoking increases the coronary death rate among U.S. never smokers by 20% to 70% and clinicians are advised to counsel their patients to avoid tobacco smoke at home, at work and in transportation settings.
Journal of Health Politics Policy and LawIndustry-Funded Research and Conflict of Interest: An Analysis of Research Sponsored by the Tobacco Industry Through the Center for Indoor Air Research
175 Citations1996Deborah E. Barnes, Lisa Bero
CIAR's stated mission of funding high-quality, objective research has been compromised by conflict of interest, and at least some of CIAR's projects are being used to promote the tobacco industry's agenda.
JAMAEvaluating the Quality of Articles Published in Journal Supplements Compared With the Quality of Those Published in the Parent Journal
135 Citations1994Paula A. Rochon
It is suggested that randomized control trials published in journal supplements are generally of inferior quality compared with articles published in the parent journal.
JAMAThe Relationship Between Methodological Quality and Conclusions in Reviews of Spinal Manipulation
122 Citations1995Willem JJ Assendelft
The majority of the reviews concluded that spinal manipulation is an effective treatment for low back pain, and although the reviews with a relatively high methodological quality had a positive conclusion, strong conclusions were precluded by the overall low quality of the Reviews.
JAMALawyer Control of the Tobacco Industry's External Research Program
92 Citations1995Lisa Bero
The involvement of tobacco industry lawyers in the selection of scientific projects to be funded is in sharp contrast to the industry's public statements about its review process for its external research program.
Tobacco ControlScientific quality of original research articles on environmental tobacco smoke
75 Citations1997Deborah E. Barnes, Lisa Bero
Non-peer-reviewed symposium articles tend to be of poor quality in published reports on environmental tobacco smoke, and should not be used in scientific, legal, or policy settings unless their quality has been independently assessed.
JAMASponsored Symposia on Environmental Tobacco Smoke
66 Citations1994Lisa Bero
Symposia on environmental tobacco smoke are more likely to present unbalanced data and be authored by tobacco industry-affiliated individuals than journal articles on ETS and the publication records and affiliations of authors of symposia with the authors of scientific consensus documents are compared.
European Respiratory JournalExposure to environmental tobacco smoke and adult non-neoplastic respiratory diseases
63 Citations1994Jean Trédaniel, Paolo Boffetta +2 more
There is a need for further epidemiological studies on ETS exposure and adult non-neoplastic respiratory disorders, as most of the studies that have used the most sensitive indicators of pulmonary function have suggested a negative impact of Ets exposure.
Paediatric and Perinatal EpidemiologyExposure to passive smoking during pregnancy and childhood, and cancer risk: the epidemiological evidence
46 Citations1994Jean Trédaniel, Paolo Boffetta +3 more
There is some consistency of association between ETS exposure in childhood and the risk of lung cancers in adulthood, but evidence from studies of exposure to known carcinogens from ETS, and of genotoxic effects indicates that any effect, if present, is expected to be weak and therefore could not have been detected by most of the studies which have been performed.
OtolaryngologySmoking and middle ear disease: Are they related? A review article
43 Citations1995H NEELIII, Stephen G. Harner +1 more
The literature does not offer sufficient support for the hypothesis that second-hand smoke causes middle ear disease to accept the hypothesis, and it is found that the difficulty of publishing negative studies, the need for academics to publish significant findings, and the poor foundation for some authors’ conclusions in the literature are found.
Tobacco ControlTobacco industry response to a risk assessment of environmental tobacco smoke
40 Citations1993Lisa Bero, Stanton A. Glantz
This study compares the content of the comments submitted by persons affiliated with the tobacco industry to the response of the EPA's Science Advisory Board and examines the peer review status of the literature cited to support criticisms of the risk assessment.
Occupational and Environmental MedicineInfluence of design characteristics on the outcome of retrospective cohort studies.
27 Citations1988G. M. H. Swaen, Judith Meijers
Retrospective cohort studies focusing on exposures in the chemical industry appeared to yield most negative findings, which is partly explained by the relation between the affiliation of the investigator and the outcome of the study.
Family PracticeAn Analysis of Review Articles Published in Primary Care Journals
20 Citations1993Christopher Silagy
The extent to which review articles published in the seven main primary care journals during 1991 had been assembled using a systematic and scientific approach was assessed.
Archives of Environmental Health An International JournalOn the Health Effects of Environmental Tobacco Smoke
15 Citations1988W. Allan Crawford
Some of the constituents of tobacco smoke are found in the home, the outdoor environment, and the workplace in permissible concentrations and are considered unlikely to cause ill health.
PubMedThe relationship between passive smoking and child health: methodologic criteria applied to prior studies.
7 Citations1989D H Rubin, Karla Damus
While a few well-designed studies demonstrate a significant effect of passive smoking on child health, most studies had significant design problems that prevent reliance on their conclusions Thus, many questions remain, and future studies should consider important methodological standards to determine more accurately the effect of Passive smoking onChild health.
International archives of occupational and environmental health. SupplementEpidemiological Issues on Involuntary Smoking and Lung Cancer
1 Citations1990Y. Shimizu, Tsukasa Namekata +1 more
Both case-control and cohort studies of passive smoking and lung cancer published since 1981 were reviewed to give concrete solutions for solving the problems of low-level risk assessment of this indoor environmental air pollutants and its potential carcinogenic effect.