Ratings of Physician Communication by Real and Standardized Patients
The Annals of Family MedicinePublished 1 March 2007Open access
Kevin Fiscella, Peter Franks, Malathi Srinivasan, Richard L. Kravitz, Ronald M. Epstein
Citations95
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.10
SNIP1.69
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Real patient and standardized patient ratings of physician communication style differ substantially and appear to provide different information about physicians’ communication style.
Abstract
Real patient and standardized patient ratings of physician communication style differ substantially and appear to provide different information about physicians' communication style.
Keywords
Health ProfessionsBusiness, Management and Accounting
Medical CareA 12-Item Short-Form Health Survey
17,142 Citations1996John E. Ware, Mark Kosinski +1 more
Twenty cross-sectional and longitudinal tests of empirical validity previously published for the 36-item short-form scales and summary measures were replicated for the 12-item Physical Component Summary and the12-item Mental Component Summary, including comparisons between patient groups known to differ or to change in terms of the presence and seriousness of physical and mental conditions.
JAMADefining and Assessing Professional Competence
3,027 Citations2002Ronald M. Epstein
An inclusive definition of competence is generated: the habitual and judicious use of communication, knowledge, technical skills, clinical reasoning, emotions, values, and reflection in daily practice for the benefit of the individual and the community being served.
PubMedThe impact of patient-centered care on outcomes.
2,497 Citations2000Moira Stewart, Judith Belle Brown +5 more
Positive perceptions of patient-centered communication were associated with better recovery from their discomfort and concern, better emotional health 2 months later, and fewer diagnostic tests and referrals.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyMotivational predictors of weight loss and weight-loss maintenance.
1,351 Citations1996Geoffrey C. Williams, Virginia M. Grow +3 more
JAMAComparison of Vignettes, Standardized Patients, and Chart Abstraction
1,245 Citations2000John Peabody, Jeff Luck +3 more
Vignettes appear to be a valid and comprehensive method that directly focuses on the process of care provided in actual clinical practice and show promise as an inexpensive case-mix adjusted method for measuring the quality of care given by a group of physicians.
Social Science & MedicineMeasuring patient-centered communication in Patient–Physician consultations: Theoretical and practical issues
1,209 Citations2005Ronald M. Epstein, Peter Franks +5 more
Nine areas for improvement in measuring patient-centered communication are proposed: developing theory-based operational definitions of PCC, clarifying what is being measured, validating of instruments, and examining pathways and mediators of links between PCC and outcomes.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyMotivational predictors of weight loss and weight-loss maintenance.
1,157 Citations1996Geoffrey C. Williams, Virginia M. Grow +3 more
Testing the theory with 128 patients in a 6-month, very-low-calorie weight-loss program confirmed the predictions that participants whose motivation for weight loss was more autonomous would attend the program more regularly, lose more weight during the program, and evidence greater maintained weight loss at follow-up.
Diabetes CareSupporting Autonomy to Motivate Patients With Diabetes for Glucose Control
1,153 Citations1998Geoffrey C. Williams, Zachary R. Freedman +1 more
The findings support the prediction of the self-determination theory that patients with diabetes whose health care providers are autonomy supportive will become more motivated to regulate their glucose levels, feel more able to regulating their glucose, and show improvements in their HbA1c values.
Journal of General Internal MedicinePatients’ participation in medical care
1,112 Citations1988Sheldon Greenfield, Sherrie H. Kaplan +3 more
The authors conclude that the intervention is feasible and that it changes patient behavior, improves blood sugar control, and decreases functional limitations.
JAMAInfluence of Patients’ Requests for Direct-to-Consumer Advertised Antidepressants
590 Citations2005Richard L. Kravitz, Ronald M. Epstein +6 more
Patients' requests have a profound effect on physician prescribing in major depression and adjustment disorder, and direct-to-consumer advertising may have competing effects on quality, potentially both averting underuse and promoting overuse.
Health PsychologyTesting a Self-Determination Theory Process Model for Promoting Glycemic Control Through Diabetes Self-Management.
576 Citations2004Geoffrey C. Williams, Holly A. McGregor +3 more
A longitudinal study tested the self-determination theory (SDT) process model of health behavior change for glycemic control within a randomized trial of patient activation versus passive education and found that self-management behaviors mediated the relation between change in perceived competence and change in gly glucose control.
International Journal for Quality in Health CareHow valid and reliable are patient satisfaction data? An analysis of 195 studies
500 Citations1999John Sitzia
With few exceptions, the study instruments in this sample demonstrated little evidence of reliability or validity, and study authors exhibited a poor understanding of the importance of these properties in the assessment of satisfaction.
Medical CarePatient Trust
445 Citations2004Kevin Fiscella, Sean Meldrum +5 more
Physician verbal behavior during an SP encounter is associated with trust reported by SPs and patients and research is needed to determine whether interventions designed to enhance physicians’ exploration patients’ experiences of disease and illness improves trust.
The Annals of Family MedicinePatient-Centered Communication and Diagnostic Testing
372 Citations2005Ronald M. Epstein
Patient-centered communication is associated with fewer diagnostic testing expenditures but also with increased visit length, an effect primarily associated with the effect on testing expenditures.
Archives of General PsychiatryMultisomatoform Disorder
356 Citations1997Kurt Kroenke
Multisomatoform disorder may be a valid diagnosis and potentially more useful than the DSM-IV diagnosis of undifferentiated somatization disorder and its diagnosis should not be precluded simply because of a coexisting mood or anxiety disorder.
Health Services ResearchRace/Ethnicity, Language, and Patients' Assessments of Care in Medicaid Managed Care
353 Citations2003Robert Weech‐Maldonado, Leo S. Morales +4 more
This study suggests that racial and ethnic minorities and persons with limited English proficiency face barriers to care, despite Medicaid-enabled financial access, as part of their quality improvement efforts.
National Academies Press eBooksEnvisioning the National Health Care Quality Report
349 Citations2001Margarita P. Hurtado
Annals of Internal MedicinePatients' Global Ratings of Their Health Care Are Not Associated with the Technical Quality of Their Care
291 Citations2006John T. Chang, Ron D. Hays +9 more
A conceptual model based on Donabedian's work is developed that examines the relationship of quality of care, both technical and interpersonal, with patients' global evaluations of health care and concludes that patient preferences and placing priority on the personal relationship between physician and patient have been shown to be key strategies of a patient-centered approach.
PubMedSwitching doctors: predictors of voluntary disenrollment from a primary physician's practice.
276 Citations2001Dana Gelb Safran, Jana E. Montgomery +3 more
These findings highlight the importance of relationship quality in determining patients' loyalty to a physician's practice and suggest that in the race to the bottom line medical practices and health plans cannot afford to ignore that the essence of medical care involves the interaction of one human being with another.
Medical CareUsing Telephone Interviews to Reduce Nonresponse Bias to Mail Surveys of Health Plan Members
152 Citations2002Floyd J. Fowler, Patricia M. Gallagher +4 more
Returns to mail surveys are likely to be related to survey content and hence are potentially biased, but telephone interviews of mail nonrespondents can produce less biased samples than mail-only protocols.
The Joint Commission Journal on Quality ImprovementUsing Standardized Patients to Measure Quality: Evidence from the Literature and a Prospective Study
131 Citations2000Peter Glassman, Jeff Luck +2 more
In the study, trained standardized patients were able to assess physician practice accurately for common medical conditions, using proven criteria linked to health outcomes.
Medical CareFactors Affecting Response Rates to the Consumer Assessment of Health Plans Study Survey
111 Citations2002Alan M. Zaslavsky, Lawrence Zaborski +1 more
CAHPS-MMC survey procedures have resulted in high response rates, and current case-mix strategies compensate for some of the remaining effects of differing response rates on comparisons among plans.
BMC Medical EducationCan standardized patients replace physicians as OSCE examiners?
97 Citations2006Kevin McLaughlin, Laura Gregor +2 more
These results suggest that SP examiners are acceptable to medical students, SP rate students higher than physicians and, unlike physician scores, SP scores are not related to other measures of competence.
The American Journal of MedicineHistory-taking and Preventive Medicine Skills among Primary Care Physicians: An Assessment Using Standardized Patients
95 Citations1998Paul G. Ramsey, J. Randall Curtis +3 more
Primary care physicians may miss important patient information in their initial interactions with patients and medical intake questionnaires or other approaches should be considered to ensure that more complete and accurate information is available to guide diagnostic and treatment plans.
Advances in Health Sciences EducationCommunication Skills in Standardized-Patient Assessment of Final-Year Medical Students: A Psychometric Study
79 Citations2004Gretchen Guiton, Carol S. Hodgson +2 more
Findings indicate that communication skills across the seven-case examination demonstrate areliable generic component that supports relative decision making, but that asignificant case-by-student interaction exists, which supports the case-specific nature of students' ability tocommunicate with patients.
Academic MedicineA standardized-patient assessment of a continuing medical education program to improve physiciansʼ cancer-control clinical skills
78 Citations1995Patricia A. Carney, Allen J. Dietrich +2 more
The educational techniques that rehearsed or portrayed clinical applications seem to have increased the physicians' performances of cancer-control clinical activities and the standardized-patient instrument seems to be particularly useful in evaluating interventions that address specific skills training.
Social Science & MedicineStudying physician effects on patient outcomes: Physician interactional style and performance on quality of care indicators
71 Citations2005Peter Franks, Anthony Jerant +4 more
Evidence is found of an apparent relationship between patient perceptions of their physician and patient outcomes, however, the apparent relationships found in this study do not reflect physician style, but presumably reflect unmeasured patient confounding.
Journal of General Internal MedicineIntention to discontinue care among primary care patients
65 Citations2001Alex D. Federman, E. Francis Cook +5 more
Failure of physicians to acknowledge patient concerns, provide explanations of care, and spend sufficient time with patients may contribute to patients’ decisions to discontinue care at their usual site of care.
PubMedControl, compliance, and satisfaction in the family practice encounter.
65 Citations1997Cecil Dw, I Killeen
Patients showed assertive control patterns, and physicians manifested patterns of willingness to let patients take control of the conversation, which showed that when physicians exhibited less control dominance, there was an increase in patient compliance and satisfaction.
Journal of General Internal MedicineWhat drives referral from primary care physicians to mental health specialists? A randomized trial using actors portraying depressive symptoms
62 Citations2006Richard L. Kravitz, Peter Franks +6 more
Controlling for patient and health system factors, physicians’ therapeutic confidence and personal experience were important influences on mental health referral.
Journal of General Internal MedicineHow do physicians respond to patients’ requests for costly, unindicated services?
59 Citations1997Thomas H. Gallagher, Bernard Lo +2 more
Few physicians agreed to a standardized patient’s request for a medically unindicated MRI, but more than half agreed to refer this patients to a specialist.
The Annals of Family MedicineAre Patients' Ratings of Their Physicians Related to Health Outcomes?
58 Citations2005Paul W. Franks
A relationship between patient perceptions of their physicians and reported health status declines is found; multilevel analysis suggested that this relationship is not a physician effect; it may reflect unmeasured patient confounding.
Teaching and Learning in MedicineCan standardized patients predict real‐patient satisfaction with the doctor‐patient relationship?
55 Citations1994Robyn Tamblyn, Brian Schnarch +4 more
It is concluded that SP rating was a valid predictor of a resident's ranking based on RP evaluation but would not be a sensitive enough measure to predict residents who were in the lowest quartile of RP rating.
PubMedUse of standardized patients in the assessment of medical practice.
46 Citations1998Robyn Tamblyn
The study of physician performance by Hutchison and colleagues is a good example of the use of standardized patients to evaluate a specific research question — the determinants of adherence to evidence-based preventive guidelines.
Psychological AssessmentConfirmatory factor analysis of the Consumer Assessment of Health Plans Study (CAHPS) 1.0 core survey.
43 Citations2001Grant N. Marshall, Leo S. Morales +3 more
Results demonstrated that the 23 CAHPS 1.0 report items measure consumer reports of experiences with 5 aspects of health plan performance: Access to Care, Timeliness of Care, Provider Communication, Health Plan Consumer Service, and Office Staff Helpfulness.
Journal of Healthcare ManagementCase Management of the Elderly in a Health Maintenance Organization: The Implications for Program Administration Under Managed Care
39 Citations1999Brenda Stevenson Marshall, Michael Long +3 more
Managed care administrators should be favorably disposed to implementing a case management model with the potential for affecting functional status, the most significant predictor of expensive continuing care for this cohort of Medicare beneficiaries, while working to develop more effective protocols and resource control strategies.
Health Services ResearchCaught in the Act? Prevalence, Predictors, and Consequences of Physician Detection of Unannounced Standardized Patients
37 Citations2006Carol E. Franz, Ron Epstein +7 more
There was some evidence for differential treatment of detected standardized patients by physicians with regard to referrals but not antidepressant prescribing or follow-up recommendations, and systematic assessment of detection is recommended.
Psychological AssessmentConfirmatory factor analysis of the Consumer Assessment of Health Plans Study (CAHPS) 1.0 core survey.
37 Citations2001Grant N. Marshall, Leo S. Morales +3 more
PubMedUsing unannounced standardized patients to assess the HIV preventive practices of family nurse practitioners and family physicians.
31 Citations1998Patricia A. Carney, D H Ward
Determining risk, including condom use, sexual orientation, and number of past sexual partners, was performed less often than experts advise by both physicians and NPs (done between 9% and 63% of encounters).
The Nurse PractitionerUsing Unannounced Standardized Patients to Assess the HIV Preventive Practices of Family Nurse Practitioners and Family Physicians
28 Citations1998Patricia A. Carney, Deborah Ward
Medical CareConnoisseurs of Care? Unannounced Standardized Patients’ Ratings of Physicians
27 Citations2006Malathi Srinivasan, Peter Franks +4 more
These analyses provide some evidence that medical connoisseurship can be learned when adequately sampled by trained SPs, some physician skills can be reliably measured in community practice settings.
PubMedAssessing students' communication and interpersonal skills across evaluation settings.
22 Citations2003Alexander W Chessman, Amy V. Blue +3 more
This study calls into question the ability of a routine end-of-clerkship OSCE to identify students' interpersonal skills abilities on fourth-year clinical performance exams and potentially that component of the anticipated USMLE SP exam.
Journal of General Internal MedicineIntention to Discontinue Care Among Primary Care Patients. Influence of Physician Behavior and Process of Care
6 Citations2001Alex D. Federman, E. Francis Cook +5 more