How effective is drug abuse resistance education? A meta-analysis of Project DARE outcome evaluations.
American Journal of Public HealthPublished 1 September 1994Open access
Susan T. Ennett, Nancy S. Tobler, Christopher L. Ringwalt, Robert L. Flewelling
Citations655
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
DARE's short-term effectiveness for reducing or preventing drug use behavior is small and is less than for interactive prevention programs.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Project DARE (Drug Abuse Resistance Education) is the most widely used school-based drug use prevention program in the United States, but the findings of rigorous evaluations of its effectiveness have not been considered collectively. METHODS: We used meta-analytic techniques to review eight methodologically rigorous DARE evaluations. Weighted effect size means for several short-term outcomes also were compared with means reported for other drug use prevention programs. RESULTS: The DARE effect size for drug use behavior ranged from .00 to .11 across the eight studies; the weighted mean for drug use across studies was .06. For all outcomes considered, the DARE effect size means were substantially smaller than those of programs emphasizing social and general competencies and using interactive teaching strategies. CONCLUSIONS: DARE's short-term effectiveness for reducing or preventing drug use behavior is small and is less than for interactive prevention programs.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of Educational StatisticsStatistical Methods for Meta-Analysis
10,479 Citations1988Stanley Wasserman, Larry V. Hedges +1 more
Journal of Drug IssuesMeta-Analysis of 143 Adolescent Drug Prevention Programs: Quantitative Outcome Results of Program Participants Compared to a Control or Comparison Group
654 Citations1986Nancy S. Tobler
Future programming implications are discussed as Peer Programs were identified as effective for the average school-based adolescent population, but the Alternatives programs were shown to be highly successful for the “at risk” adolescents such as drug abusers, juvenile delinquents or students having school problems.
Health Education ResearchSchool-based substance abuse prevention: a review of the state of the art in curriculum, 1980–1990
536 Citations1992William B. Hansen
Comprehensive and Social Influence programs are found to be most successful in preventing the onset of substance use.
American Journal of Public HealthA meta-analysis of adolescent smoking prevention programs.
419 Citations1993William H. Bruvold
Because behavioral effect represents the fundamental objective of programs for prevention of adolescent tobacco use, the present results indicate that school-based programs should consider adopting interventions with a social reinforcement, social norms, or developmental orientation.
American Journal of Public HealthPreventing adolescent drug use: long-term results of a junior high program.
328 Citations1993Phyllis L. Ellickson, Robert M. Bell +1 more
It is unlikely that early prevention gains can be maintained without additional prevention efforts during high school, and future research is needed to develop and test such efforts.
Journal of Drug EducationThe Effects of School-Based Substance Abuse Education — A Meta-Analysis
279 Citations1988Robert L. Bangert‐Drowns
The meta-analysis showed that typical substance abuse education had its most positive effects on knowledge and attitudes, but was unsuccessful in changing the drug-using behaviors of students.
Journal of School HealthEssential Elements of School‐Based Smoking Prevention Programs
266 Citations1989Thomas J. Glynn
The current status of adolescent tobacco use in the United States is discussed in the context of the identification of those elements considered necessary for successful school-based smoking prevention programs.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical PsychologyPlanning for the appropriate analysis in school-based drug-use prevention studies.
239 Citations1990David M. Murray, Peter J. Hannan
Researchers should adopt alternative methods that acknowledge the intragroup dependence often seen when intact social groups are assigned to study conditions, and the number of schools required for an unbiased analysis may be substantially greater than for the traditional methods.
American Journal of Public HealthSix-year follow-up of the first Waterloo school smoking prevention trial.
235 Citations1989Brian R. Flay, David Koepke +4 more
Six-year follow-up data are reported from the first large-scale randomized trial of the social influences approach to smoking prevention, finding that Grade 6 smoking experience and social risk were each strong predictors of T8 smoking behavior.
Journal of Behavioral MedicineFour- and five-year follow-up results from four seventh-grade smoking prevention strategies
204 Citations1988David M. Murray, Marsha Davis-Hearn +3 more
The results suggest that a seventh-grade program, built around the social influences model and taught jointly by same-age peer leaders and local classroom teachers, may reduce 4-year weekly- and daily-smoking cumulative incidence rates, providing the first evidence for any long-term effects for thesocial influences model.
Behaviour Research and TherapyPediatric and adolescent behavioral medicine
194 Citations1983S. Rachman
Journal of Behavioral MedicineFive- and six-year follow-up results from four seventh-grade smoking prevention strategies
130 Citations1989David M. Murray, Phyllis L. Pirie +2 more
Data indicated that participants who received seventh-grade interventions based on the social influences model had similar smoking patterns compared to participants in other conditions, which supports the call for booster sessions after the initial seventh- grade intervention program.
Persuasive Communication and Drug Abuse Prevention
128 Citations2012Lewis Donohew, Howard E. Sypher +1 more
Addictive BehaviorsLong-term evaluation of drug abuse resistance education
115 Citations1994Susan T. Ennett, Dennis P. Rosenbaum +4 more
Results from a longitudinal evaluation of the DARE program in 36 schools in Illinois provide only limited support for DARE's impact on student's drug use immediately following the intervention, and no support for either continued or emerging impact on drug use 1 or 2 years after receiving DARE instruction.
Journal of Behavioral MedicineAre social-psychological smoking prevention programs effective? The waterloo study
112 Citations1985Brian R. Flay, Katherine B. Ryan +5 more
This study provides the methodologically most rigorous test to date of social influence programs for smoking prevention and documents for the first time significant effects for those at high risk for smoking.
Crime and JusticeSubstance Abuse Prevention: Theory, Practice, and Effectiveness
103 Citations1990Gilbert J. Botvin
The extant empirical and theoretical literature suggests the need for a comprehensive prevention strategy that combines school-based interventions with those affecting the family, social institutions, and the larger community.
Journal of School HealthDifferential Effectiveness of an Elementary School‐based Alcohol Misuse Prevention Program
96 Citations1989T. E. Dielman, Jean T. Shope +2 more
Results indicated the intervention was effective in reducing the rate of increase of alcohol use and misuse among grade six students who entered the study with prior unsupervised as well as supervised alcohol use.
Health Education ResearchAn outcome evaluation of Project DARE (Drug Abuse Resistance Education)
91 Citations1991Christopher L. Ringwalt, Susan T. Ennett +1 more
Journal of Drug EducationA Short-Term Evaluation of Project Dare (Drug Abuse Resistance Education): Preliminary Indications of Effectiveness
83 Citations1987William DeJong
Compared to a control group, students who had DARE training reported significantly lower use of alcohol, cigarettes, and other drugs since graduating from sixth grade.
International Journal of the AddictionsSkills Enhancement to Prevent Substance Abuse Among American Indian Adolescents
80 Citations1987Lewayne D. Gilchrist, Steven P. Schinke +2 more
The findings suggest that behavioral skills training approaches hold promise for reducing substance use and abuse among American Indians.
Evaluation ReviewReducing the Risk of Drug Involvement Among Early Adolescents
80 Citations1993Michele A. Harmon
Psychology and HealthA meta-analysis and theoretical review of school based tobacco and alcohol intervention programs
80 Citations1988William H. Bruvold, Thomas G. Rundall
American Journal of Public HealthSkills intervention to prevent cigarette smoking among adolescents.
78 Citations1985Steven P. Schinke, L D Gilchrist +1 more
Youths who received health information and skills intervention had lower intentions to smoke and less cigarette use at 24-month follow-up than youths whoreceived health information alone and youths who received no intervention.
Health CommunicationSensation Seeking as a Potential Mediating Variable for School-Based Prevention Intervention: A Two-Year Follow-Up of DARE
77 Citations1991Richard Clayton, Anne M. Cattarello +1 more
For more information on DARE, see VioPro record number 889.
Journal of Pediatric PsychologyPrevention of Adolescent Alcohol Misuse: An Elementary School Program
61 Citations1986T. E. Dielman, Jean T. Shope +2 more
Journal of Drug EducationImpact Evaluation of Drug Abuse Resistance Education (DARE)
59 Citations1992Harold K. Becker, Michael W. Agopian +1 more
The research suggests that DARE does not significantly change the amount of drug use, which is minimal at the fifth grade level, and children receiving DARE during the study period maintained existing levels of drug abuse.
American Journal of Public HealthPreventing substance use: rethinking strategies.
44 Citations1993J G Dryfoos
Evaluation and Program PlanningWhy reports of outcome evaluations are often biased or uninterpretable
44 Citations1993Joel M. Moskowitz
Examining why the conclusions of many outcome evaluations do not stand up to scrutiny drawing upon examples from evaluations of drug abuse prevention programs suggests some potential solutions that may reduce the institutional pressures and constraints that undermine evaluation studies.
Health Education QuarterlySkills Methods to Prevent Smoking
33 Citations1986Steven P. Schinke, Lewayne D. Gilchrist +3 more
At postintervention, skills condition subjects, more than health education subjects, had better scores on measures of smoking-related knowledge, attitudes, and intentions, and reported cigarette use was lower in the skills condition than in the health education condition at all postinterventions measurements, including a 24-month follow-up.
Journal of Drug EducationEffects on Students of Teacher Training in Use of a Drug Education Curriculum
32 Citations1990Kenneth R. Allison, Gloria Silverman +1 more
Students whose teachers had intensive staff development were less likely to intend to take a drink if offered than studentswhose teachers had in-service or no training.
Urban EducationPrevention Strategies for Vulnerable Pupils
23 Citations1988Steven P. Schinke, Mary Y. Bebel +2 more
Journal of Drug EducationAn Impact Evaluation of a Rural Youth Drug Education Program
22 Citations1987Paul D. Sarvela, E. J. McClendon
The drug use prevalence rates and health beliefs of 265 youth in rural northern Michigan and northeastern Wisconsin, as well as the outcomes of a comprehensive drug education program are described.
Journal of Adolescent Health CareSkills-building methods to prevent smoking by adolescents
21 Citations1985Steven P. Schinke, Lewayne D. Gilchrist +2 more
Outcome results on measures of non-smoking intentions, attitudes, predictions, problem-solving abilities, and peer interactions favored subjects in the skills-building group when compared with subjects inThe discussion and pretest-posttest control groups.
PubMedElementary school-based prevention of adolescent alcohol misuse.
14 Citations1987T. E. Dielman, Jean T. Shope +2 more
Conceptual and methodological issues considered in the design, implementation and evaluation of AMPS are discussed as examples of the planning which must go into a well-designed alcohol misuse prevention program.
The Journal of Primary PreventionEvaluation of an affective development teacher training program
9 Citations1984Joel M. Moskowitz, Janet H. Malvin +2 more
Effective Classroom Management (ECM), an affective development course, was provided to fifth grade teachers and teachers were taught techniques in communication, classroom management, and self-esteem enhancement to make classroom environments more responsive to students' affective and cognitive needs.
Deep Blue (University of Michigan)Early Adolescent Substance Use in Rural Northern Michigan and Northeastern Wisconsin.
5 Citations1984Paul D. Sarvela