Evaluating the effects of behavioral realism in embodied agents
International Journal of Human-Computer StudiesPublished 18 July 2009
Victoria Groom, Clifford Nass, Tina Chen, Alexia Nielsen, James K. Scarborough, Erica Robles
Citations120
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.39
SNIP2.34
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
An empirical study compared three theories of agent realism: Realism Maximization Theory, Uncanny Valley Theory, and Consistency Theory showed that people responded best to an embodied agent when it demonstrated moderately realistic, inconsistent behavior.
Abstract
Designers of embodied agents constantly strive to create agents that appear more human-like, with the belief that increasing the human-likeness of agents will improve users' interactions with agents. While designers have focused on visual realism, less attention has been paid to the effects of agents' behavioral realism on users' responses. This paper presents an empirical study that compared three theories of agent realism: Realism Maximization Theory, Uncanny Valley Theory, and Consistency Theory. Results of this study showed that people responded best to an embodied agent when it demonstrated moderately realistic, inconsistent behavior. These results support Uncanny Valley Theory and demonstrate the powerful influence of agent behavior on users' responses.
Keywords
PsychologyComputer Science
Choice Reviews OnlineThe media equation: how people treat computers, television, and new media like real people and places
4,921 Citations1997
This chapter discusses the media equation, which describes the role media and personality play in the development of a person's identity and aims at clarifying these roles.
The MIT Press eBooksEmbodied Conversational Agents
1,788 Citations2000
This book describes research in all aspects of the design, implementation, and evaluation of embodied conversational agents as well as details of specific working systems.
The persona effect
785 Citations1997James C. Lester, Sharolyn A. Converse +4 more
The study revealed the persona eflecr, which is that the presence of a lifelike character in an interactive learning environment~ven one that is not expressive— can have a strong positive effect on student’s perception of their learning experience.
Matching robot appearance and behavior to tasks to improve human-robot cooperation
761 Citations2004Jennifer L. Goetz, Sara Kiesler +1 more
It is hypothesize that an appropriate match between a robot's social cues and its task improve the people's acceptance of and cooperation with the robot.
International Journal of Human-Computer StudiesCan computer personalities be human personalities?
607 Citations1995Clifford Nass, Youngme Moon +3 more
Disney Animation: The Illusion of Life
551 Citations1981Frank R. Thomas, Ollie Johnston
Wired for Speech: How Voice Activates and Advances the Human-Computer Relationship
508 Citations2005Clifford Nass, Scott Brave
Wired for Speech demonstrates that people are "voice-activated": the authors respond to voice technologies as they respond to actual people and behave as they would in any social situation, and voice interfaces can truly emerge as the next frontier for efficient, user-friendly technology.
Applied Artificial IntelligenceThe power of a nod and a glance: Envelope vs. emotional feedback in animated conversational agents
384 Citations1999Justine Cassell, Kristinn R. Þórisson
It is hypothesized that for embodied conversational agents, nonverbal behaviors related to the process of conversation, what the authors call envelope feedback, is much more important than other feedback, such as emotional expression.
Screenplay: The Foundations of Screenwriting
379 Citations1979Syd Field
The social life of avatars: presence and interaction in shared virtual environments
301 Citations2002Ralph Schroeder
International Joint Conference on Artificial IntelligenceWhy robots will have emotions
277 Citations1981Aaron Slowan, Monica Croucher
To understand emotions, the authors need to understand motives and the types of processes they can produce, which leads to a study of the global architecture of a mind.
A meta-analysis of the impact of the inclusion and realism of human-like faces on user experiences in interfaces
243 Citations2007Nick Yee, Jeremy N. Bailenson +1 more
Results revealed significantly larger effect sizes when analyzing subjective responses than when analyzing behavioral responses such as task performance and memory, which has implications for both designers building interfaces as well as social scientists designing experiments to evaluate those interfaces.
Computer supported cooperative workSocial Interaction in Virtual Environments: Key Issues, Common Themes, and a Framework for Research
216 Citations2002Ralph Schroeder
The MIT Press eBooksNudge Nudge Wink Wink: Elements of Face-to-Face Conversation for Embodied Conversational Agents
200 Citations2000Justine Cassell
It will not be possible to apply exactly the same teaching process to the machine as to a normal child, so that it could not send the creature to school without the other children making excessive fun of it.
The MIT Press eBooksTruth Is Beauty: Researching Embodied Conversational Agents
193 Citations2000Clifford Nass, Katherine Isbister +1 more
Lecture notes in computer scienceDevelopment of an Android Robot for Studying Human-Robot Interaction
158 Citations2004Takashi Minato, Michihiro Shimada +2 more
An android robot that has similar appearance as humans and several actuators generating micro behaviors is developed and a new research direction based on the android robot is proposed.
Human Communication ResearchWhen a Talking-Face Computer Agent is Half-Human and Half-Humanoid: Human Identity and Consistency Preference
156 Citations2007Li Gong, Clifford Nass
The overall inconsistency effects suggest that people treat humanoid entities in a different category from natural human ones.
Communicative facial displays as a new conversational modality
139 Citations1993Akikazu Takeuchi, Katashi Nagao
This work is attempting to introduce facial displays into computer-human interaction as a new modality to make the interaction tighter and more efficient while lessening the cognitive load.
Computers in Human BehaviorCooperating with life-like interface agents
137 Citations1999Salvatore Parise, Sara Kiesler +2 more
This work studied how the appearance of a life-like interface agent influenced people’s interaction with it, using a social interaction framework of making and keeping promises to cooperate.
IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and Cybernetics - Part A Systems and HumansEvaluating humanoid synthetic agents in e-retail applications
85 Citations2001Helen McBreen, M.A. Jack
Results showed participants have a preference for 3D rather than 2D cartoon-like agents and have a desire to interact with fully embodied agents.
CogPrints (University of Southampton)Why robots will have emotions
78 Citations1981Sloman, Aaron, Croucher, Monica
The Effects of Emotion of Voice in Synthesized and Recorded Speech
35 Citations2001Clifford Nass, Ulla G. Foehr +2 more
Interacting with ComputersPsychological responses to simulated displays of mismatched emotional expressions
31 Citations2007Chris Creed, Russell Beale
The results appear to follow cognitive dissonance theory as subjects attempted to make mismatched expressions consistent on both the visual and audio dimensions of animations, resulting in confused perceptions of the emotional expressions.
The effects of distance in local versus remote human-computer interaction
29 Citations1998Youngme Moon
Results indicate that persuasion is significantly more likely to occur when the computer is perceived as being proximate, as opposed to distant, and implications for long-distance human-computer interaction are discussed.
IEEE MultimediaEscaping the World: High and Low Resolution in Gaming
10 Citations2005B. Serviss
Insight into the game industry is provided as well as discussing the debate between high and low resolution graphics in the context of other visual media such as art and film.