Somatic symptoms of anxiety: Comparison of self-report and physiological measures
Biological PsychiatryPublished 1 March 1986
Daniel R. McLeod, Rudolf Hoehn‐Saric, Robin L. Stefan
Citations70
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score4.68
SNIP2.24
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is suggested that patient reports of physical symptoms such as sweating and rapid heart rate can be useful in clinical evaluation and research settings that do not require quantitative assessment of physiological activity.
Abstract
The frequently reported absence of significant correlations between patient rating scales and physiological measures has led to the belief that patients cannot reliably perceive physiological changes that are experienced under conditions of stress. To determine whether or not this conclusion is justified for patients with clinical anxiety, self-reports and psychophysiological recordings were examined and compared in 20 patients suffering from generalized anxiety disorder. No systematic correlations were found between patient ratings and physiological measures of somatic symptomatology during periods of rest or psychological stress (Stroop Test). However, parallel directional changes in the two sets of measures were observed upon exposure to stress, indicating that patients could accurately report the direction, but not the degree, of changes in physical symptoms of anxiety. These results suggest that patient reports of physical symptoms such as sweating and rapid heart rate can be useful in clinical evaluation and research settings that do not require quantitative assessment of physiological activity.
Keywords
PsychologyMedicine
Manual for the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory
25,350 Citations1970Charles D. Spielberger, Richard L. Gorsuch +1 more
The Psychology of Physical Symptoms
1,766 Citations1982James W. Pennebaker
JAMAAnxiety: New Research and Changing Concepts
392 Citations1982Arnold Goldberg
This syndrome in one form or another represents the major focus of this book, which, as the proceedings of a conference, is a fascinating and terribly uneven review of current biologic and pharmacologic research into the problem.
Psychological MedicineAwareness of cardiac function in anxious, phobic and hypochondriacal patients
113 Citations1980Peter Tyrer, Ian Lee +1 more
The results suggest that somatic symptoms in hypochondriacal and anxiety neurosis reflect increased awareness of bodily function.
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Relationship Between Clinical Diagnosis and Anxiety, Assessed by Forearm Blood Flow and Other Measurements
101 Citations1968D. H. W. Kelly, C. J. S. Walter
If several independent methods of assessing anxiety are used, more data is available, and a better overall judgment on an individual patient can be made.
PsychophysiologyIndividual Differences in Heartbeat Discrimination
89 Citations1982Edward S. Katkin, Marie A. Morell +3 more
The results confirmed prior findings that subjects are unable to discriminate their own heartbeats without training, but that they can team such discrimination.
Progress in Neuro-PsychopharmacologySymptomatic volunteers in multicenter drug trials
83 Citations1979Lino Covi, Ronald S. Lipman +2 more
Symptomatic volunteers appear to present a feasible alternative to the increasingly diminishing pool of outpatients in anti-anxiety and antidepressant drug trials.
PsychophysiologyPhysical Symptoms Associated with Blood Pressure
78 Citations1982James W. Pennebaker, Linda Gonder‐Frederick +3 more
The within-subjects correlation patterns varied from subject to subject, were internally consistent, and were related to sex and SBP variability.
Psychosomatic MedicineThe Effects of Normal and Rapid Speech on Blood Pressure
78 Citations1982Erika Friedmann, Sue A. Thomas +3 more
These findings are discussed in light of earlier research on the blood pressure communication response and are evaluated in the context of the speech pattern characteristics of the Type A (coronary‐prone) individual.
Psychosomatic MedicineEffect of Mental Stress on Baroreceptor-Mediated Changes in Blood Pressure and Heart Rate and on Plasma Catecholamines and Subjective Responses in Healthy Men and Women
77 Citations1983Lennart Forsman, Lars Erik Llndblad
The results suggest that nonspecific mental stress does not substantially influence the ability of carotid sinus baroreceptors to decrease heart rate or blood pressure in response to sustained changes in baroreceptor input.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseHuman Speech and Blood Pressure
70 Citations1980James J. Lynch, Sue Thomas +4 more
Findings from this study indicate that interpersonal communications surrounding the measurement of blood pressure can rapidly alter systolic and diastolic pressures.
PsychophysiologyA COMPARISON OF PHYSIOLOGICAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL MEASUREMENTS ON ANXIOUS PATIENTS AND NORMAL CONTROLS
65 Citations1970Desmond Kelly, Clinton C. Brown +1 more
Resting forearm blood flow and heart rate were found to be better measures of arousal in this study than skin resistance, EMG, or cutaneous vasomotor status, since the latter did not show significant differences between anxious patients and normal controls.
PsychophysiologyAutonomic and Affective Reactions of High and Low Socially‐Anxious Individuals Awaiting Public Performance
55 Citations1979Martha L. Knight, Richard J. Borden
The present findings suggest a psychological time-division process, such that the anticipation interval consists of an initial waiting period, followed by a briefer period of active preparatron, which is the primary determinant of reactions while awaiting threat.
PsychophysiologyStimulus Characteristics Influencing Estimation of Heart Rate
54 Citations1981James W. Pennebaker
The results indicated that HR judgment is more dependent on external stimuli than on actual HR, and that HR estimation is dependent to a large degree on an inference process.
PsychophysiologyMeasuring Baseline‐Treatment Differences in Heart Rate Variability: Variance versus Successive Difference Mean Square and Beats per Minute versus Interbeat Intervals
51 Citations1979Ronald J. Heslegrave, John C. Ogilvie +1 more
The combination of SDMS as the variability statistic, and IBI as the scale of measurement for HR, is both the best and most appropriate technique for assessing changes in HR variability.
Psychological MedicineThe relationship between psychological and physiological measures of anxiety
47 Citations1978Gary R. Morrow, Anthony H. Labrum
The absence of mood-specific physiological measures for anxiety, as measured by the psychological tests, supports previous theory and investigation and points to the inadvisability of assuming that studies on anxiety that use diverse physiological and psychological measures yield results that may be compared as though they were assessing a common mood.
Psychiatric Clinics of North AmericaGeneralized Anxiety Disorder
35 Citations1985Rudolf Hoehn‐Saric, Daniel R. McLeod
It is concluded that although not as sharply defined as implied by DSM-III, generalized anxiety disorder appears to be a useful diagnostic category.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchCardiovascular responses of individuals with type a behavior pattern and parental coronary heart disease
23 Citations1982David B. Newlin, Robert W. Levenson
Results indicated that subjects at greater risk for CHD had more substantial peripheral vascular responses to the stressors compared to low risk subjects; there were no differences in sympathetic cardiac responses related to contractility.
PsychosomaticsExtent of agreement between patient and physician ratings of emotional distress
20 Citations1982Andrew Winokur, Michael Guthrie +2 more
The findings support the value of the HSCL as a screening instrument for the detection of anxiety and depression in nonpsychiatric medical patients.
Pavlovian Journal of Biological ScienceRelations between visceral and behavioral function in men at bedrest
4 Citations1983Benjamin H. Natelson, C. W. Deroshia +3 more
Principal components analysis suggested an“alertness” factor comprised of physiological measures as well as selfratings which helped in predicting better performance which may be due to the injection of common, slow temporal trends into many of the different data sets.