The Emotional Impact of Medical Errors on Practicing Physicians in the United States and Canada
The Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient SafetyPublished 1 August 2007
Amy D. Waterman, Jane Garbutt, Erik Hazel, William Claiborne Dunagan, Wendy Levinson, Victoria J. Fraser
Citations478
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.98
SNIP1.04
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Physicians' job-related stress increased when they had been involved with a serious error, however, one third of physicians only involved with near misses also reported increased stress.
Abstract
Many physicians experience significant emotional distress and job-related stress following serious errors and near misses. Organizational resources to support physicians after errors should be improved.
Keywords
Health Professions
BMJCrossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century
10,744 Citations2001Alexi Baker
Analyzing health care organizations as complex systems, Crossing the Quality Chasm also documents the causes of the quality gap, identifies current practices that impede quality care, and explores how systems approaches can be used to implement change.
Annals of Internal MedicineBurnout and Self-Reported Patient Care in an Internal Medicine Residency Program
2,163 Citations2002Tait D. Shanafelt, Katharine A. Bradley +2 more
The prevalence of burn out among internal medicine residents in a single university-based program is evaluated and the relationship of burnout to self-reported patient care practices is evaluated.
New England Journal of MedicineEffect of Reducing Interns' Work Hours on Serious Medical Errors in Intensive Care Units
1,759 Citations2004Christopher P. Landrigan, Jeffrey M. Rothschild +9 more
BMJMedical error: the second victim
1,435 Citations2000Albert W. Wu
Patients, who have an understandable need to consider their doctors infallible, have colluded with doctors to deny the existence of error.
JAMAAssociation of Perceived Medical Errors With Resident Distress and Empathy
1,414 Citations2006Colin P. West, Mashele Huschka +5 more
Self-perceived medical errors are common among internal medicine residents and are associated with substantial subsequent personal distress, suggesting that perceived errors and distress may be related in a reciprocal cycle.
American Journal of Preventive MedicinePhysician response to surveys A review of the literature
952 Citations2001Scott Kellerman
Surprisingly, the response rates of mail surveys of physicians compared favorably with those from telephone and personal interview surveys.
JAMAPatients' and Physicians' Attitudes Regarding the Disclosure of Medical Errors
944 Citations2003Thomas H. Gallagher, Amy D. Waterman +3 more
American Journal of PsychiatrySuicide Rates Among Physicians: A Quantitative and Gender Assessment (Meta-Analysis)
866 Citations2004Eva Schernhammer, Graham A. Colditz
Studies on physicians' suicide collectively show modestly (men) to highly (women) elevated suicide rate ratios, and larger studies should help clarify whether female Physicians' suicide rate is truly elevated or can be explained by publication bias.
New England Journal of MedicineViews of Practicing Physicians and the Public on Medical Errors
774 Citations2002Robert J. Blendon, Catherine M. DesRoches +8 more
Though substantial proportions of the public and practicing physicians report that they have had personal experience with medical errors, neither group has the sense of urgency expressed by many national organizations to advance their agenda.
New England Journal of MedicineFatigue among Clinicians and the Safety of Patients
685 Citations2002David M. Gaba, Steven K. Howard
The authors argue that reform is needed because the long work hours of clinicians adversely affect the quality of health care and current policies regulating residents' hours of work and options for new regulations governing residency shifts.
JAMAConfronting Depression and Suicide in Physicians
662 Citations2003Claudia Center, Miriam Davis +12 more
As barriers are removed and physicians confront depression and suicidality in their peers, they are more likely to recognize and treat these conditions in patients, including colleagues and medical students.
JAMADo House Officers Learn From Their Mistakes?
566 Citations1991Albert W. Wu
House officers who accepted responsibility for the mistake and discussed it were more likely to report constructive changes in practice and residents were less likely to make constructive changes if they attributed the mistake to job overload.
JAMASleep Deprivation and Clinical Performance
406 Citations2002Matthew B. Weinger
This review focuses on the consequences of sleep loss both in controlled laboratory environments and in clinical studies involving medical personnel, and the potential adverse impact of reduced work schedules on the economics of health care, on continuity of care, and on quality of care.
Journal of General Internal MedicineThe work lives of women physicians
394 Citations2000the SGIM Career Satisfaction Study Group, Julia E. McMurray +5 more
Addressing gender differences in job satisfaction, work life issues, and burnout of U.S. physicians will optimize the participation of female physicians within the medical workforce.
Journal of General Internal MedicineThe heart of darkness
382 Citations1992John F. Christensen, Wendy Levinson +1 more
How physicians think and feel about their perceived mistakes is described, and how physicians’ prior beliefs and manners of coping with mistakes may influence their emotional responses are examined to promote further discussion in the medical community about this sensitive issue.
PubMedThe work lives of women physicians results from the physician work life study. The SGIM Career Satisfaction Study Group.
358 Citations2000Janice McMurray, Mark Linzer +4 more
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthSuicide in doctors: a study of risk according to gender, seniority and specialty in medical practitioners in England and Wales, 1979–1995
323 Citations2001Keith Hawton, A Clements +3 more
There is an increased risk of suicide in female doctors, but male doctors seem to be at less risk than men in the general population, which highlights the need to tackle stress and mental health problems in doctors more effectively.
The British Journal of PsychiatryA Systematic Review on Gender-Specific Suicide Mortality in Medical Doctors
320 Citations1996Sari Lindeman, Esa Läärä +2 more
The aim here is to describe the variation of published estimates of relative risk of doctors to die from suicide, which showed the suicide rates among doctors were higher than those in the general population and among other academic occupational groups.
Wiley eBooksStress in health professionals
320 Citations1987Roy Payne, Jenny Firth‐Cozens
At a time when the health professions are undergoing a period of considerable change, this book recommends ways in which this can be tackled and used positively for the benefit of both patients and health professionals.
Health Care Management ReviewUnderstanding physicians' intentions to withdraw from practice
316 Citations2010Eric S. Williams, Thomas R. Konrad +6 more
This study proposes and tests a model relating job stress to four intentions to withdraw from practice mediated by job satisfaction and perceptions of physical and mental health.
Annals of Internal MedicineHealth Plan Members' Views about Disclosure of Medical Errors
295 Citations2004Kathleen M. Mazor, Steven R. Simon +5 more
Assessment of patients' views of disclosure of medical errors and the relationship of the error, severity of clinical outcome, and the level of disclosure to 5 dependent variables found that full disclosure improved trust, satisfaction, and emotional response.
New England Journal of MedicineFacing Our Mistakes
275 Citations1984David Hilfiker
Looking at the appointment book for July 12, 1978, I notice that Barb Daily will be in today for her first prenatal examination, and "Wonderful," I think, remembering my joy as I helped her deliver her daughter.
Archives of Internal MedicineChoosing Your Words Carefully
258 Citations2006Thomas H. Gallagher, Jane Garbutt +7 more
Physicians vary widely in how they would disclose errors to patients, and disclosure standards and training are necessary to meet public expectations and promote professional responsibility following errors.
New England Journal of MedicineTaking Their Own Lives — The High Rate of Physician Suicide
247 Citations2005Eva Schernhammer
It has been known for some time that suicide rates among doctors are higher than those in the general population, but the gap evidently begins as early as medical school, writes Dr Eva Schernhammer.
Health Care Management ReviewUnderstanding Physicians' Intentions to Withdraw from Practice: The Role of Job Satisfaction, Job Stress, Mental and Physical Health
229 Citations2001Eric S. Williams, Thomas R. Konrad +6 more
This study proposes and tests a model relating job stress to four intentions to withdraw from practice mediated by job satisfaction and perceptions of physical and mental health.
Archives of Internal MedicineUS and Canadian Physicians' Attitudes and Experiences Regarding Disclosing Errors to Patients
222 Citations2006Thomas H. Gallagher, Amy D. Waterman +6 more
US and Canadian physicians' error disclosure attitudes and experiences are similar despite different malpractice environments, and reveal mixed feelings about disclosing errors to patients.
Social Science & MedicineManaging medical mistakes: Ideology, insularity and accountability among internists-in-training
220 Citations1984Terry Mizrahi
The whole system of accountability during graduate medical specialty training was found to be a variable, and at times, contradictory process.
Health Care Management ReviewEustress at Work: The Relationship between Hope and Health in Hospital Nurses
212 Citations2001Bret L. Simmons, Debra L. Nelson
Hope, the belief that one has both the will and the way to accomplish one's goals, had a significant, positive relationship with the perception of health in this sample of hospital nurses.
Archives of Family MedicineThe emotional impact of mistakes on family physicians
192 Citations1996Michael C. Newman
Making mistakes unfavorably affects family physicians and creates a strong need for support, and family physicians may benefit from sharing experiences that diminish perfectionism and recognize mistakes as a natural part of practicing medicine.
JAMAPhysicians' attitudes toward using deception to resolve difficult ethical problems
167 Citations1989D. H. Novack
JAMAPhysicians' Attitudes Toward Using Deception to Resolve Difficult Ethical Problems
164 Citations1989Dennis H. Novack
Most physicians indicated some willingness to engage in forms of deception, and appear to justify their decisions in terms of the consequences and to place a higher value on their patients' welfare and keeping patients' confidences than truth telling for its own sake.
European Psychologist“Forgivingness”: Factor Structure in a Sample of Young, Middle-Aged, and Elderly Adults
141 Citations1998Étienne Mullet, Anne Houdbine +2 more
Annals of Emergency MedicineCoping with medical mistakes and errors in judgment
138 Citations2002Richard M. Goldberg, Gloria J. Kuhn +2 more
The affective aspects of physician errors are focused on and a strategy for coping with them is presented and the need for practitioners to be trained in their management is presented.
Depression and AnxietyStresses on women physicians: Consequences and coping techniques
138 Citations2003Gail Erlick Robinson
Although women physicians suffer from a variety of stressors that can lead to career impediments, stress reactions, and psychiatric problems, generally they are satisfied with their careers and personal coping techniques can help women deal with these stressors.
Stress and HealthPhysician stress: results from the physician worklife study
131 Citations2002Mark Linzer, Martha Gerrity +5 more
Adjusting for and modifying these aspects of daily practice and providing more control over work, a more person-centred work environment and more support for balancing work and home life will likely bring less stress to doctors and better care to their patients.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare EthicsMorally Managing Medical Mistakes
84 Citations2000Martin L. Smith, Heidi P. Forster
A mistake can result in serious and permanent damage for the patient, such as the failure to consider epiglottitis in an initial differential diagnosis, resulting in a chronic vegetative state for a seven-year-old boy.
Project Muse (Johns Hopkins University)After Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness
82 Citations2005Nancy Berlinger
Journal of Advanced NursingUnderstanding the nature of errors in nursing: using a model to analyse critical incident reports of errors which had resulted in an adverse or potentially adverse event
78 Citations2000Meurier
The case study approach using critical incidents of clinical errors was shown to provide relevant information regarding the interaction of organizational factors, local circumstances and active failures (errors) in producing an adverse or potentially adverse event.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchPhysician health, stress and gender at a university hospital
72 Citations2003Bodil Bergman, Fayyaz Ahmad +1 more
Different strategies are needed for women and men physicians to reduce their stress levels, and the somatic symptoms scale was significantly correlated with satisfaction with amount of time spent working.
Medical Errors and Medical Narcissism
70 Citations2004John D. Banja
Medical errors and medical narcissism, Medical errors andMedical narcissism and medical errors andmedical narcissism.
Kennedy Institute of Ethics journalMedical Malpractice, Mistake Prevention, and Compensation
68 Citations2001Thomas May, Mark P. Aulisio
It is argued that both the prevention of medical mistakes and the goals of malpractice litigation itself will be better served if substantial malpractice reform is undertaken.
BMJAfter Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness
63 Citations2005Farr A. Curlin
In After Harm, Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness Nancy Berlinger applies a “religious studies perspective” to describe the words and actions that make forgiveness possible after medical harm by appropriating Dietrich Bonhoeffer's theological justification for lying to his Nazi interrogators in the period before his eventual execution.
Critical Reviews in Oncology/HematologyDoctors’ responses to medical errors
36 Citations2004Michael Rowe
Doctor's responses to error within the context of contemporary medical care is reviewed and themes that emerge from this review are considered.
Journal of Surgical OncologyThe psychology of error in relation to medical practice
30 Citations2004John R. Pani, Julia H. Chariker
Cognitive psychology as it relates to the origins of human error and an application of that material to issues that arise in medical practice are reviewed.
Annals of Emergency MedicineHuman error in medicine: Promise and pitfalls, part 1
30 Citations2000Robert L. Wears, Bruce D Janiak +7 more
PsychosomaticsSued and nonsued physicians
29 Citations1987Sara C. Charles, Richard B. Warnecke +3 more
This interview study was designed to clarify the degree of stress generated by recent changes in medical practice, to view them in the context of previously identified stressors, and to demonstrate how two groups of physicians-those who have been sued and those who have not-perceive and experience these stressors in this transitional period of health care.
PubMedGender differences in physician stress.
26 Citations1992Gross Eb
Although both men and women physicians felt pressured by the amount of time demanded by their profession, women had the additional pressure of family obligations and were more likely to be concerned about the responsibility inherent in the doctor's role.
Academic MedicineStress and coping mechanisms in a group of family practice residents
20 Citations1985Howard L. Rudner
Perspectives In Psychiatric CareCareer Perspectives
16 Citations2001Susan Bendersky Sacks, Paul T. Clements +1 more
PubMedCare after chaos: use of critical incident stress debriefing after traumatic workplace events.
16 Citations2004Susan Bendersky Sacks, Paul T. Clements +1 more
CISD is a specific model of group debriefing, which can be used to accelerate recovery from traumatic work-place events and promote return to normalcy, benefiting the individual, organization, and the community at large.
New England Journal of MedicineMistakes in the Operating Room — Error and Responsibility
14 Citations2004Sherwin B. Nuland
In this chapter, Dr. Sherwin B. Nuland relates his experience with a patient who was the victim of both types of errors.
Cardiac Electrophysiology ReviewWith a Little More Soul
4 Citations2003Blair P. Grubb
The following paper tries to address the factors behind a loss of the "soul" in modern medical practice and suggests ways to correct it.