Graduated driver licensing for reducing motor vehicle crashes among young drivers
Cochrane Database of Systematic ReviewsPublished 19 April 2004
Lisa Hartling, Natasha Wiebe, Kelly Russell, Jackie Petruk, Carla Spinola, Terry P. Klassen
Citations156
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.62
SNIP2.04
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
The existing evidence shows that GDL is effective in reducing the crash rates of young drivers, although the magnitude of the effect is unclear. The conclusions are supported by consistent direction of the findings, and the temporal relationship and plausibility of the association. The reviewers have made recommendations for primary research on GDL (e.g. study methods, standardized reporting of outcomes and results, long-term follow-up). The project has also shown what is needed to carry out systematic reviews of observational studies (e.g. quality assessment instruments).
Keywords
Agricultural and Biological SciencesMedicineEngineering
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthThe feasibility of creating a checklist for the assessment of the methodological quality both of randomised and non-randomised studies of health care interventions.
8,257 Citations1998Sara H. Downs, Nicholas Black
It is shown that it is feasible to develop a checklist that can be used to assess the methodological quality not only of randomised controlled trials but also non-randomised studies and it is possible to produce a Checklist that provides a profile of the paper, alerting reviewers to its particular methodological strengths and weaknesses.
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineThe environment and disease: association or causation?
7,311 Citations2015Austin Bradford Hill
The objects of this newly founded Section of Occupational Medicine are to provide a means, not readily afforded elsewhere, whereby physicians and surgeons with a special knowledge of the relationship between sickness and injury and conditions of work may discuss their problems, not only with each other, but also with colleagues in other fields, by holding joint meetings with other Sections of the Society.
JAMATrends in Sudden Cardiovascular Death in Young Competitive Athletes After Implementation of a Preparticipation Screening Program
1,512 Citations2006Domenico Corrado, Cristina Basso +4 more
The incidence of sudden cardiovascular death in young competitive athletes has substantially declined in the Veneto region of Italy since the introduction of a nationwide systematic screening in 1982.
Journal of Safety ResearchTeenage drivers: patterns of risk
699 Citations2003Allan F. Williams
Patterns of risk among teenage drivers form the basis for graduated licensing systems, which are designed to promote low-risk and discourage high-risk driving.
OBSERVATIONAL BEFORE-AFTER STUDIES IN ROAD SAFETY -- ESTIMATING THE EFFECT OF HIGHWAY AND TRAFFIC ENGINEERING MEASURES ON ROAD SAFETY
664 Citations1997Ezra Hauer
This three part monograph aims to enable road safety researchers and professionals to interpret correctly the results of one of the main sources of knowledge about the effect of road safety engineering measures, the "observational Before-After study".
Observational Before-After Studies in Road Safety
655 Citations1997Ezra Hauer
JAMACarrying Passengers as a Risk Factor for Crashes Fatal to 16- and 17-Year-Old Drivers
531 Citations2000Li-Hui Chen
The data indicate that the risk of fatal injury for a 16- or 17-year-old driver increases with the number of passengers, which supports inclusion of restrictions on carrying passengers in graduated licensing systems for young drivers.
Accident Analysis & PreventionThe situational risks of young drivers: The influence of passengers, time of day and day of week on accident rates
305 Citations1998Sean Doherty, Jean Andrey +1 more
The results indicate that the accident involvement rates of 16-19 year old drivers are higher than those of 20-24 and 25-59 year olds in all situations that were examined, but that they were disproportionately high on weekends, at nighttime and with passengers.
Accident Analysis & PreventionArea-wide urban traffic calming schemes: a meta-analysis of safety effects
243 Citations2001Rune Elvik
The meta-analysis shows that area-wide urban traffic calming schemes on the average reduce the number of injury accidents by about 15%, which is the largest reduction for residential streets, while a somewhat smaller reduction is found for main roads.
Accident Analysis & PreventionThe effect of teenage passengers on the fatal crash risk of teenage drivers
240 Citations1998David F. Preusser, Susan A. Ferguson +1 more
The results indicated that passenger presence was associated with proportionately more at-fault fatal crashes for drivers aged 24 and younger, were a neutral factor fordrivers aged 25-29, and were associated with fewer at-Fault involvements for Drivers aged 30 and older.
Journal of Health EconomicsGraduated driver licensing and teen traffic fatalities
193 Citations2005Thomas S. Dee, David C. Grabowski +1 more
Evidence that GDL regulations reduced traffic fatalities among 15-17-year-olds by at least 5.6% is presented and the life-saving benefits of these regulations were plausibly related to their restrictiveness.
Journal of Public Health PolicyEffectiveness and Role of Driver Education and Training in a Graduated Licensing System
175 Citations1998Daniel R. Mayhew, Herbert M. Simpson +2 more
A contemporary review of the value of driver education/training, particularly in relation to new licensing systems such as graduated ones, is provided and the merits of integrating drivereducation/training programs with new approaches to the licensing of young drivers are considered.
JAMAInitial Effects of Graduated Driver Licensing on 16-Year-Old Driver Crashes in North Carolina
172 Citations2001Robert D. Foss
In its initial years, the North Carolina GDL system produced substantial declines in 16-year-old driver crashes, and crash rates declined sharply for all levels of severity after the GDL program was implemented.
PEDIATRICSGraduated Driver Licensing Programs and Fatal Crashes of 16-Year-Old Drivers: A National Evaluation
150 Citations2006Lihui Chen, Susan P. Baker +1 more
Accident Analysis & PreventionAn evaluation of the New Zealand Graduated Driver Licensing System
142 Citations1996John Langley, Alexander C. Wagenaar +1 more
It is shown that the introduction of the GDLS was closely followed by substantial reductions in car crash injuries for all age groups, especially 15-19 year olds (23% reduction), and an analysis of licensure data suggests that the reduction in crashes may, in large part, be attributable to an overall reduction in exposure.
JAMAGraduated Driver Licensing in Michigan
141 Citations2001Jean T. Shope, Lisa J. Molnar +2 more
Analysis of the first 2 full calendar years following Michigan's GDL program implementation indicates substantial crash reductions among 16-year-olds, and future research is necessary to determine if these reductions are maintained and if other jurisdictions achieve similar results.
Accident Analysis & PreventionEffect of Florida’s graduated licensing program on the crash rate of teenage drivers
128 Citations2000R G Ulmer, David F. Preusser +3 more
There was a 9% reduction in the fatal and injury crash involvement rate in Florida during 1997, the first full year of graduated licensing, compared with 1995 and reductions were not seen among Alabama teenagers nor among 18 year-olds in Florida.
American Journal of Preventive MedicineEffectiveness of primary and secondary enforced seat belt laws
120 Citations1999F P Rivara, DianeC. Thompson +1 more
The review of existing studies suggests that primary enforcement laws are likely to be more effective than secondary laws, but few studies are of good quality, and quantitative estimates of the relative effect of primary compared with secondary laws are limited.
Journal of Safety ResearchThe evolution and effectiveness of graduated licensing
119 Citations2003H M Simpson
The extent to which graduated licensing has produced reductions in collisions is examined, and questions that still remain unanswered about graduated licensing are outlined, which suggest that future efforts to promote graduated licensing must emphasize adherence to the fundamental risk reduction and multistage principles on which the concept is based.
Accident Analysis & PreventionDifferences in young driver crash involvement in states with varying licensure practices
101 Citations1996Susan A. Ferguson, William A. Leaf +2 more
State crash data indicated that Delaware and Connecticut showed the highest rates of 16-year-old driver involvements in nonfatal and fatal injury crashes and Pennsylvania and upstate New York, which have night driving curfews for 16 year-olds, showed lower crash rates overall and much higher crash rates during their respective curfew hours.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyInjury Control: A Guide to Research and Program Evaluation
95 Citations2009Frederick P. Rivara, Peter Cummings +3 more
1. An Overview of Injury Research Frederick P. Rivara and Elizabeth McLoughlin.
Journal of Safety ResearchEvaluation of California's graduated driver licensing program
76 Citations2004Scott Masten, R A Hagge
Though the observed crash savings associated with the restrictions were of modest size, this is the first study to evidence a direct positive impact of the passenger restriction component of GDL programs.
Journal of Safety ResearchThe genesis of GDL
76 Citations2003P F Waller
The early research that lead to graduated driver licensing, some of the educational principals on which it is based, obstacles to its acceptance, andSome of the early efforts in the U.S. and elsewhere are discussed.
American Journal of Preventive MedicineEffectiveness of graduated driver licensing in reducing motor vehicle crashes
72 Citations1999Robert D. Foss, Kelly R. Evenson
There is evidence that one central element of graduated licensing, a restriction on nighttime driving by novices, reduces young driver crashes, and a definitive conclusion about the effectiveness of GDL systems for reducing motor vehicle crashes or crash-related injuries must await examination of other G DL systems.
Traffic Injury PreventionSpecific and Long-Term Effects of Nova Scotia's Graduated Licensing Program
67 Citations2003Daniel R. Mayhew, Herbert M. Simpson +2 more
Overall the data indicate substantial benefits of graduated licensing for 16 to 17-year-old beginners, but no benefits beyond the learner stage for older beginners.
Journal of Safety ResearchMichigan's graduated driver licensing program: Evaluation of the first four years
65 Citations2004Jean T. Shope, Lisa J. Molnar
Even after adjusting for more general population-wide changes among drivers 25 years and older that might have contributed to changes in 16-year-old crash risk, reductions remained impressive (19% for all crashes in 2001).
Journal of Safety ResearchWhat we know, what we don't know, and what we need to know about graduated driver licensing
62 Citations2003James Hedlund, Ruth A. Shults +1 more
The views and judgments expressed are the authors' best attempt to capture the symposium's consensus, but they do not necessarily represent the views of the authors, their organizations, or any other individual symposium participant.
Injury PreventionThe New Zealand graduated driver licensing system: teenagers' attitudes towards and experiences with this car driver licensing system.
55 Citations1995Dorothy Begg, J Langley +2 more
Generally these young drivers were positively disposed towards the driving restrictions, but noncompliance was common; a full evaluation of all aspects of this licensing system is recommended.
Accident Analysis & PreventionMeasuring the impact of passenger restrictions on new teenage drivers
49 Citations2004Douglas Cooper, Frank Atkins +1 more
Using fatal and injury crash data from California's Statewide Integrated Traffic Records System, this study found that teenage passengers are a causal factor in crashes of 16-year-old drivers and that in the three years following implementation of the new law, the average number of teenage passengers carried by 16- year-olds decreased by approximately 25%.
Journal of Safety ResearchCalifornia's graduated driver license law: Effect on teenage drivers' deaths through 2005
46 Citations2007Mike Males
California's GDL may negatively affect older teenagers and other driver subpopulations and merits reevaluation, according to time series analysis of Fatality Analysis Reporting System mortality data.
Traffic Injury PreventionLicensing Age and Teenage Driver Crashes: A Review of the Evidence
45 Citations2009Allan F. Williams
The available evidence indicates that increasing the licensing age would further reduce young driver crashes and that New Jersey, with its combination of higher licensing age and strong graduated licensing provisions, is the model.
Journal of Safety ResearchEffects of the California graduated driver licensing program
45 Citations2004Thomas Rice, Corinne Peek‐Asa +1 more
This evaluation supports previous evidence that GDLS is an effective countermeasure to adolescent motor-vehicle crashes and their associated injuries and supports States with a traditional licensing system may prevent adolescent driver crashes by adopting a GDLS.
Journal of Safety ResearchTeenage crash reduction associated with delayed licensure in Connecticut
43 Citations2001R G Ulmer, Susan A. Ferguson +2 more
Delaying teenage licensure in Connecticut, during which time a teen could engage in more practice driving, was associated with a 22% reduction in fatal/injury crash involvements for 16-year-old drivers.
PubMedGraduated driver licensing in Wisconsin: does it create safer drivers?
33 Citations2005Susan Anderson Fohr, Peter M. Layde +1 more
Graduated driver licensing in Wisconsin has resulted in a drop in the general population crash rates for 16 and 17 year olds, which is the result of reduced exposure to the risk of collision rather than safer driving by teens.
Annals of Emergency MedicineGraduated driver licensing in Utah: Is it effective?
30 Citations2004Lisa K. Hyde, Lawrence J. Cook +2 more
The results suggest that graduating driver licensing may have contributed to a reduction in young driver crashes, but the effects were minimal compared with those shown in many other graduated driver licensing evaluations.
Transportation Research Record Journal of the Transportation Research BoardImpact of Partial Graduated Driver’s License Program on Teen Motor Vehicle Crashes in Kentucky
30 Citations2001Kenneth R. Agent, Lorena Steenbergen +4 more
Results from this study indicate a need for more effective measures to decrease MVCs for ages 16.5 to 18, such as upgrading to a full graduated driver licensing program.
YOUTH LICENSE CONTROL DEMONSTRATION PROJECT
27 Citations1983Abigail McKnight, Patrick Hyle +1 more
The Provisional Licensing Program as implemented in Maryland is administratively and financially feasible; the parent-supervised instruction and driver improvement programs were not fully implemented and their effect cannot be assessed.
Annals of Emergency MedicineImpact of Georgia’s Teenage and Adult Driver Responsibility Act
27 Citations2006Angelyn Rios, Marlena M. Wald +4 more
Journal of Safety ResearchThe effectiveness of provisional licensing in Oregon: An analysis of traffic safety benefits
26 Citations1994Barnie Jones
Journal of Safety ResearchThe Iowa graduated driver licensing program: Effectiveness in reducing crashes of teenage drivers
25 Citations2008David M. Neyens, Birsen Donmez +1 more
The analyses suggest that the Iowa GDL program is effective in reducing the crash rates of 16- and 17-year-old drivers but the effects do not sustain for 18-year old drivers.
Rosa P: A digital library for transportation research (United States Department of Transportation)National Evaluation of Graduated Driver Licensing Programs
22 Citations2010Susan P. Baker, Lihui Chen +2 more
The greatest benefit of Graduated Driver Licensing programs appears to be in programs that include age requirements plus 3 or more months of waiting before the intermediate stage, nighttime driving restriction, and either supervised driving of at least 30 hours or a passenger restriction.
Journal of Safety ResearchDoes the Maryland graduated driver licensing law affect both 16-year-old drivers and those who share the road with them?
19 Citations2008Bevan B. Kirley, Andrea E Feller +2 more
Maryland's GDL delayed licensure and reduced crashes and non-fatal injuries among 16-year-old drivers per population and per licensed driver suggests other components of GDL are beneficial for drivers and possibly for other road users.
Accident Analysis & PreventionEvaluation of Iowa's graduated driver's licensing program
19 Citations2008Shauna Hallmark, David Veneziano +3 more
After implementation of GDL, the 14-, 16- and 17- year-old age groups experienced a greater decrease in crash rate than the middle-age control group while 15-year-old experienced a smaller decrease, which suggests that the crash rate for 15-Year-old drivers may actually have increased when downward trends were adjusted for.
Journal of Transport GeographyThe impact of the graduated driver licence scheme on road traffic accident youth mortality in New Zealand
18 Citations2007Simon Kingham, Jamie Pearce +2 more
Proceedings International Council on Alcohol, Drugs and Traffic Safety ConferenceTHE QUEBEC GRADUATED LICENSING SYSTEM FOR NOVICE DRIVERS: A TWO-YEAR EVALUATION OF THE 1997 REFORM
18 Citations2000Jessica Bouchard, Christian Dussault +3 more
Preliminary results have shown that the net one-year effect of the revised GLS was to reduce fatalities by 32.8% and injuries by 15.1% and for the first time, the study evaluated the impact of Zero Alcohol on collision involvement.
Traffic Injury PreventionThe Effects of Graduated Driver Licensing on Hospitalization Rates and Charges for 16-and 17-Year-Olds in North Carolina
17 Citations2007Lewis H. Margolis, Scott Masten +1 more
The North Carolina GDL program was associated with a marked decline in the rate of hospitalizations and hospital charges for 16-year-old drivers, and over $650,000 in hospital charges have been averted each year.
PubMedEarning a driver's license.
16 Citations2000Allan F. Williams
The author describes the first five multistage graduated systems enacted in the United States in 1996 and 1997 and factors that will influence the acceptability and effectiveness of these new licensing systems are discussed.
The Journal of Rural HealthGraduated Drivers License Programs and Rural Teenage Motor Vehicle Fatalities
15 Citations2006Michael A. Morrisey, David C. Grabowski
Prehospital Emergency CareEffect of a Graduated Licensing System on Motor Vehicle Crashes andAssociated Injuries Involving Drivers Less Than 18 Years-of-Age
9 Citations2007Robert E. O’Connor, Laurie Lin +2 more
Journal of Safety ResearchThe compelling case for graduated licensing
4 Citations2003Allan F. Williams
PsycEXTRA DatasetGraduated driver licensing in Georgia: The impact of the Teenage and Adult Driver Responsibility Act (TADRA)
3 Citations2007
