Reducing youth screen time: Qualitative metasynthesis of findings on barriers and facilitators.
Health PsychologyPublished 31 March 2015Open access
Karl E. Minges, Neville Owen, Jo Salmon, Ariana M. Chao, David W. Dunstan, Robin Whittemore
Citations104
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.28
SNIP1.20
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
For youth and parents, mutually agreed rules, limits, and parental monitoring of screen time were perceived as likely to be effective and can guide the development of interventions to decrease sedentary behavior.
Abstract
Screen time is an established norm in many youth cultures, presenting barriers to behavior change. Parents recognize the importance of reducing youth screen time, but model and promote engagement themselves. For youth and parents, mutually agreed rules, limits, and parental monitoring of screen time were perceived as likely to be effective.
Keywords
Social SciencesMedicine
Journal of Environmental PsychologyQualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook
45,597 Citations1994
This book presents a step-by-step guide to making the research results presented in reports, slideshows, posters, and data visualizations more interesting, and describes how coding initiates qualitative data analysis.
Diabetes CareGlobal Prevalence of Diabetes
15,331 Citations2004Sarah H. Wild, Gojka Roglić +3 more
Findings indicate that the "diabetes epidemic" will continue even if levels of obesity remain constant, and given the increasing prevalence of obesity, it is likely that these figures provide an underestimate of future diabetes prevalence.
American Journal of EvaluationA General Inductive Approach for Analyzing Qualitative Evaluation Data
10,745 Citations2006David R. Thomas
Although the general inductive approach is not as strong as some other analytic strategies for theory or model development, it does provide a simple, straightforward approach for deriving findings in the context of focused evaluation questions.
Obesity Facts‘Small Changes' to Diet and Physical Activity Behaviors for Weight Management
9,509 Citations2013Andrew P. Hills, Nuala M. Byrne +2 more
A case for the use of small and incremental changes in diet and physical activity for improved weight management in the context of a toxic obesogenic environment is presented.
JAMAPrevalence of Obesity and Trends in Body Mass Index Among US Children and Adolescents, 1999-2010
3,948 Citations2012Cynthia L. Ogden, Margaret D. Carroll +2 more
The most recent estimates of obesity prevalence in US children and adolescents for 2009-2010 are presented and trend analyses over a 12-year period indicated a significant increase in obesity prevalence between 1999-2000 and 2009- 2010 in males aged 2 through 19 years but not in females.
American Journal of EpidemiologyAmount of Time Spent in Sedentary Behaviors in the United States, 2003-2004
2,668 Citations2008Charles E. Matthews, Kong Y. Chen +5 more
The authors evaluate participants from the 2003-2004 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey aged >/=6 years who wore an activity monitor for up to 7 days to provide the first objective measure of the amount of time spent in sedentary behavior in the US population.
Exercise and Sport Sciences ReviewsToo Much Sitting
2,109 Citations2010Neville Owen, Geneviève N. Healy +2 more
Sitting time, TV time, and time sitting in automobiles increase premature mortality risk, and breaking up sedentary time is beneficial.
International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical ActivitySystematic review of sedentary behaviour and health indicators in school-aged children and youth
2,023 Citations2011Mark S. Tremblay, Allana G. LeBlanc +6 more
Evidence suggests that daily TV viewing in excess of 2 hours is associated with reduced physical and psychosocial health, and that lowering sedentary time leads to reductions in BMI.
PEDIATRICSChildren, Adolescents, and Television
1,744 Citations2001
The possible negative health effects of television viewing on children and adolescents, such as violent or aggressive behavior, substance use, sexual activity, obesity, poor body image, and decreased school performance, are described.
Medicine & Science in Sports & ExerciseSitting Time and Mortality from All Causes, Cardiovascular Disease, and Cancer
1,606 Citations2009Peter T. Katzmarzyk, Timothy S. Church +2 more
These data demonstrate a dose-response association between sitting time and mortality from all causes and CVD, independent of leisure time physical activity and physicians should discourage sitting for extended periods.
Diabetes CareBreaks in Sedentary Time
1,470 Citations2008Geneviève N. Healy, David W. Dunstan +5 more
Evidence is provided of the importance of avoiding prolonged uninterrupted periods of sedentary (primarily sitting) time and new public health recommendations regarding breaking up sedentary time that are complementary to those for physical activity are suggested.
European Heart JournalSedentary time and cardio-metabolic biomarkers in US adults: NHANES 2003–06
1,381 Citations2011Geneviève N. Healy, Charles E. Matthews +3 more
These are the first population-representative findings on the deleterious associations of prolonged sedentary time with cardio-metabolic and inflammatory biomarkers and suggest that clinical communications and preventive health messages on reducing and breaking up sedentaryTime may be beneficial for cardiovascular disease risk.
PubMedReducing obesity via a school-based interdisciplinary intervention among youth: Planet Health.
1,309 Citations1999Steven L. Gortmaker, Karen E. Peterson +5 more
Planet Health decreased obesity among female students, indicating a promising school-based approach to reducing obesity among youth.
Exercise and Sport Sciences ReviewsThe Evolving Definition of "Sedentary"
1,253 Citations2008Russell R. Pate, Jennifer R. O’Neill +1 more
Future claims about the effects of sedentary, light, and moderate-to-vigorous activities on health outcomes should be supported by data from studies in which all levels of physical activity are differentiated clearly and measured independently.
Journal of Advanced NursingMeta‐synthesis method for qualitative research: a literature review
1,241 Citations2005Denis Walsh, Soo Downe
Despite the contingent nature of evidence gleaned from meta-synthesis and current lack of consensus about some of its aspects, meta-Synthesis is an important technique for qualitative researchers and can deepen understanding of the contextual dimensions of health care.
Health Education ResearchUnderstanding participation in sport and physical activity among children and adults: a review of qualitative studies
1,220 Citations2006Steven Allender, Gill Cowburn +1 more
Medical Entomology and ZoologyHandbook for Synthesizing Qualitative Research
1,103 Citations2006Margarete Sandelowski, Julie Barroso
International Journal of ObesityRelationships between media use, body fatness and physical activity in children and youth: a meta-analysis
1,099 Citations2004S. J. Marshall, Stuart Biddle +3 more
While the total amount of time per day engaged in sedentary behavior is inevitably prohibitive of physical activity, media-based inactivity may be unfairly implicated in recent epidemiologic trends of overweight and obesity among children and youth.
Research in Nursing & HealthQualitative metasynthesis: Issues and techniques
990 Citations1997Margarete Sandelowski, Sharron L. Docherty +1 more
The major problem yet to be resolved is developing usable and communicable systematic approaches to conducting metasynthesis projects that maintain the integrity of individual studies.
PEDIATRICSChildren, Adolescents, and the Media
916 Citations2013Victor C. Strasburger, Marjorie J. Hogan +10 more
Media influences on children and teenagers should be recognized by schools, policymakers, product advertisers, and entertainment producers.
PubMedPhysical activity of Canadian children and youth: accelerometer results from the 2007 to 2009 Canadian Health Measures Survey.
869 Citations2011Rachel C. Colley, Didier Garriguet +4 more
Despite of age group, boys are more active than girls and physical activity levels of Canadian children and youth are low.
American Journal of Preventive MedicineAdults' Sedentary Behavior
837 Citations2011Neville Owen, Takemi Sugiyama +4 more
An ecologic model of sedentary behaviors is described, highlighting the behavior settings construct and the multiple levels of determinants of prolonged sitting time, which are likely to operate in distinct ways in these different contexts.
CirculationTelevision Viewing Time and Mortality
833 Citations2010David W. Dunstan, Elizabeth Barr +8 more
Television viewing time was associated with increased risk of all-cause and CVD mortality, and chronic disease prevention strategies could focus on reducing sitting time, particularly prolonged television viewing.
BMJ Quality & SafetyThe problem of appraising qualitative research
626 Citations2004Mary Dixon‐Woods
This work distinguishes universal features of quality from those specific to methodology and offers a set of minimally prescriptive prompts to assist with the assessment of generic features of qualitative research.
Nutrition Metabolism and Cardiovascular DiseasesSedentary behaviour and obesity development in children and adolescents
570 Citations2007Juan Pablo Rey-López, Germán Vicente‐Rodríguez +2 more
Sedentary lifestyle patterns in children and adolescents, i.e. playing digital games, using computers and especially watching television, have been associated with obesity, but not all sedentary behaviour has shown the same relevance to, and relationship with, obesity.
Applied Physiology Nutrition and MetabolismCanadian Sedentary Behaviour Guidelines for Children and Youth
556 Citations2011Mark S. Tremblay, Allana G. LeBlanc +6 more
These are the first evidence-based Canadian Sedentary Behaviour Guidelines for Children and Youth and provide important and timely recommendations for the advancement of public health based on a systematic synthesis, interpretation, and application of the current scientific evidence.
Qualitative Health ResearchMeta-Synthesis of Qualitative Findings
487 Citations1996Louise Jensen, Marion Allen
A framework for synthesizing qualitative findings is described, and issues surrounding employment of this technique and the practical importance of interpretive meta-synthesis are highlighted in relation to theory development.
Medicine & Science in Sports & ExerciseTelevision Time and Continuous Metabolic Risk in Physically Active Adults
435 Citations2008Geneviève N. Healy, David W. Dunstan +4 more
Significant, detrimental dose-response associations of television-viewing time were observed with waist circumference, systolic blood pressure, and 2-h plasma glucose in men and women, and with fasting plasma glucose, triglycerides, and HDL-C in women.
British Journal of Sports MedicineToo much sitting: a novel and important predictor of chronic disease risk?: Figure 1
400 Citations2008Neville Owen, Adrian Bauman +1 more
A brief overview of recent evidence for the distinct relationships between ‘too much sitting’ and biomarkers of metabolic health and, thus, with increased risk of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease and other prevalent chronic health problems is provided.
DiabetesPhysical Activity, Sedentary Behavior, and Health: Paradigm Paralysis or Paradigm Shift?
373 Citations2010Peter T. Katzmarzyk
Emerging evidence for the role of sedentary behavior on health, which may be independent of physical activity per se, finds us at a crossroad with respect to prescribing optimal daily human movement patterns for health.
PubMedDance and reducing television viewing to prevent weight gain in African-American girls: the Stanford GEMS pilot study.
365 Citations2003Thomas N. Robinson, Joel D. Killen +15 more
This study confirmed the feasibility, acceptability, and potential efficacy of using dance classes and a family-based intervention to reduce television viewing, thereby reducing weight gain, in African-American girls.
PLoS ONEActive Video Games and Health Indicators in Children and Youth: A Systematic Review
348 Citations2013Allana G. LeBlanc, Jean‐Philippe Chaput +7 more
Overall, AVGs are associated with acute increases in EE, but effects on habitual physical activity are not clear, and there is not sufficient evidence to recommend AVGs as a means of increasing daily physical activity.
American Journal of Preventive MedicineHealth Risks, Correlates, and Interventions to Reduce Sedentary Behavior in Young People
330 Citations2011Jo Salmon, Mark S. Tremblay +2 more
A growing body of evidence supports the development of public health recommendations to limit the time spent in screen-based behaviors and more research is needed to examine the prospective and experimental evidence of associations between overall sedentary time and health.
Journal of Advanced NursingSupporting breastfeeding mothers: qualitative synthesis
310 Citations2008Rhona J. McInnes, Julie A. Chambers
A report of a synthesis of mothers' and healthcare professionals' experiences and perceptions of breastfeeding support, finding mothers tended to rate social support as more important than health service support.
Physiotherapy Research InternationalMaking words count: the value of qualitative research
289 Citations2004Ros Johnson, Jackie Waterfield
Some of the most frequently used techniques aimed at ensuring quality and value in qualitative research, such as sampling, triangulation, multiple coding, respondent validation and the use of audit trails are examined, as well as addressing reflexivity.
Preventive MedicineSystematic review of correlates of screen-viewing among young children
279 Citations2010Itziar Hoyos Cillero, Russell Jago
Findings suggest that research on correlates of screen-viewing among young children is limited, but there are some clear correlates on which future interventions could be tailored.
International Journal of Behavioral MedicineCouch kids: Correlates of television viewing among youth
278 Citations2004Trish Gorely, Simon J. Marshall +1 more
Further research should aim to identify modifiable correlates of TV/video viewing if interventions are to be successfully tailored to reduce this aspect of inactivity among youth.
Medicine & Science in Sports & ExercisePhysical activity, genetic, and nutritional considerations in childhood weight management
223 Citations1998Oded Bar‐Or, John P. Foreyt +8 more
To achieve long-standing control of overweight, one should combine changes in eating and activity patterns, using behavior modification techniques, and the onus is also on society to reduce incentives for a sedentary lifestyle and over-consumption of food.
PEDIATRICSReducing Children's Television-Viewing Time: A Qualitative Study of Parents and Their Children
214 Citations2006Amy B. Jordan, James Hersey +2 more
Data from this exploratory study suggest several potential barriers to implementing a 2-hour limit, including parents' need to use television as a safe and affordable distraction, parents' own heavy television viewing patterns, the role that television plays in the family's day-to-day routine, and a belief that children should spend their weekend leisure time as they wish.
American Journal of Preventive MedicineA Review of Preschool Children’s Physical Activity and Sedentary Time Using Objective Measures
211 Citations2014Jill A. Hnatiuk, Jo Salmon +3 more
The considerable variation of prevalence estimates makes it difficult to determine the "true" prevalence of physical activity and sedentary time in preschool children, and future research should aim to reduce inconsistencies in the employed methodologies.
PubMedDeveloping optimal search strategies for detecting clinically relevant qualitative studies in MEDLINE.
203 Citations2004Sharon Wong, Nancy L Wilczynski +1 more
Health Education ResearchMedia Health Literacy (MHL): development and measurement of the concept among adolescents
184 Citations2011Diane Levin‐Zamir, Dafna Lemish +1 more
The findings suggest that as a determinant of adolescent health behavior, MHL identifies groups at risk and may provide a basis for health promotion among youth.
Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent MedicineEffectiveness of Interventions Aimed at Reducing Screen Time in Children
172 Citations2011Gita Wahi
A systematic review and meta-analysis did not demonstrate evidence of effectiveness of interventions aimed at reducing screen time in children for reducing BMI and screen time, however, interventions in the preschool age group hold promise.
PEDIATRICSA Meta-analysis of Interventions That Target Children's Screen Time for Reduction
147 Citations2011Dayna M. Maniccia, Kirsten K. Davison +3 more
Results show that interventions to reduce children's screen time have a small but statistically significant effect, and future research can expand on these findings by examining the clinical relevance and sustainability of effects, conducting a more thorough analysis of effect modifiers, and identifying critical components of effective interventions.
British Journal of Sports MedicineSedentary behaviour interventions in young people: a meta-analysis
135 Citations2011Stuart Biddle, Sophie O'Connell +1 more
Behaviour change interventions targeting reductions in sedentary behaviour have been shown to be successful, although effects are small.
Qualitative Health ResearchSearch Strategies for Identifying Qualitative Studies in CINAHL
135 Citations2007Nancy L Wilczynski, Susan Marks +1 more
Empirically derived search strategies combining indexing terms and textwords can achieve high sensitivity and high specificity for retrieving qualitative studies from CINAHL.
PEDIATRICSEffects of Open-Loop Feedback on Physical Activity and Television Viewing in Overweight and Obese Children: A Randomized, Controlled Trial
120 Citations2006Gary S. Goldfield, Risa Mallory +8 more
Providing feedback of physical activity in combination with reinforcing physical activity with sedentary behavior is a simple method of modifying the home environment that may play an important role in treating and preventing child obesity.
PEDIATRICSCharacteristics of Screen Media Use Associated With Higher BMI in Young Adolescents
112 Citations2013David S. Bickham, Emily A. Blood +3 more
Findings support the notion that attention to TV is a key element of the increased obesity risk associated with TV viewing, and interventions that interrupt these processes may be effective in decreasing obesity among screen media users.
International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical ActivityFamily and home correlates of television viewing in 12-13 year old adolescents: the Nepean Study.
103 Citations2006Louise L. Hardy, Louise A. Baur +6 more
Evaluation & the Health ProfessionsDeveloping Optimal Search Strategies for Retrieving Qualitative Studies in PsycINFO
103 Citations2006K. Ann McKibbon, Nancy L Wilczynski +1 more
The authors tested multiple search strategies using 4,985 potential search terms in PsycINFO and compared the results with the hand search data to calculate retrieval effectiveness.
American Journal of Preventive MedicinePrimary care interventions to reduce television viewing in African-American children
101 Citations2002Benjamin Ford
The effects on physical activity suggest that the behavioral intervention may be more effective in reducing children's television viewing, and changes in overall household television use and meals eaten while watching television also appeared to favor the Behavioral intervention.
Health Education ResearchUnderstanding children's sedentary behaviour: a qualitative study of the family home environment
99 Citations2008Joanna Granich, Michael Rosenberg +2 more
Efforts to reduce SB in children should focus on the influencing factors that reciprocally interact within the family home, and an emphasis on increasing awareness about the risks associated with spending excessive time in screen-based activities should be a priority.
Journal of Behavioral MedicinePatterns of Sedentary Behaviour and Physical Activity Among Adolescents in the United Kingdom: Project STIL
99 Citations2007Trish Gorely, Simon J. Marshall +2 more
A potential need for different behavioural targets in interventions to reduce sedentary behaviour in sub groups of the adolescent population is suggested and modifiable determinants of different sedentary lifestyles among young people are examined.
Qualitative Health ResearchDeveloping Optimal Search Strategies for Retrieving Clinically Relevant Qualitative Studies in EMBASE
99 Citations2005Leslie A. Walters, Nancy L Wilczynski +1 more
The authors identified search strategies with high performance for retrieving qualitative studies in EMBASE for the 2000 publishing year by combining search terms to optimize the combination of sensitivity and specificity.
AppetiteEnergy intake associated with television viewing in adolescents, a cross sectional study
98 Citations2004Jan Van den Bulck, Jan Van Mierlo
Estimated daily energy intake accompanying TV viewing amounts to 19% of the Belgian average energy allowance (AEA) in boys and between 12 and 14% of AEA in girls.
International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical ActivityMaintenance and decline of physical activity during adolescence: insights from a qualitative study
98 Citations2011Mathieu Bélanger, Michelle Casey +7 more
Although maintainers and decliners associate physical activity with similar themes, the experiences of both groups differ substantially with regards to those themes.
Health PsychologyPatterns of sedentary behavior among adolescents.
89 Citations2007Marion F. Zabinski, Gregory J. Norman +3 more
Reducing certain sedentary behaviors (e.g., watching television, using a computer) can be an effective weight loss strategy for youth and a limited number of distinct sedentary behavior patterns are suggested.
Canadian Journal of Public HealthTackling the Obesity Pandemic
87 Citations2006Paul A. Spanier, Simon J. Marshall +1 more
The importance of understanding sedentariness as an important health behaviour, distinct from physical activity, and identifying the modifiable determinants of sedentary behaviours is outlined.
European Journal of Cardiovascular NursingParental Influence on Models of Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease in Children
65 Citations2003Deborah E. Norton, Erika Sivarajan Froelicher +2 more
A broader base of knowledge is developed about what parents and children believe is healthy, how parents model beliefs and behaviors for their children, and how to build self-efficacy for positive health behaviors.
Preventive MedicineEffect of electronic time monitors on children's television watching: Pilot trial of a home-based intervention
53 Citations2009Cliona Ní Mhurchú, Vaughan S. Roberts +5 more
Electronic TV time monitors are feasible to use for home-based TV watching interventions although acceptability varies between families, and preliminary findings from this pilot suggest that such devices have potential to decrease children's TV watching.
International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical ActivityWhy did soft drink consumption decrease but screen time not? Mediating mechanisms in a school-based obesity prevention program
48 Citations2008Marijke JM Chin A Paw, Amika Singh +2 more
The findings imply that interventions aimed at EBRB-change should be gender-specific, and future studies aimed at reducing SCB consumption among boys should target attitude and habit strength as mediating mechanisms.
Child Care Health and DevelopmentChildren and television watching: a qualitative study of New Zealand parents' perceptions and views
43 Citations2009Enid Dorey, Vaughan S. Roberts +4 more
It is imperative for interventions aimed at reducing TV viewing to consider the role TV plays within a family context, ensuring parental perceptions around the benefits and barriers of reducing TV are accounted for.
Child Care Health and DevelopmentWhat helps children to be more active and less sedentary? Perceptions of mothers living in disadvantaged neighbourhoods
32 Citations2011Jenny Veitch, Clare Hume +3 more
This qualitative study aims to gain in-depth insights from mothers regarding their child's resilience to low physical activity and high screen-time among children living in disadvantaged neighbourhoods in Victoria, Australia.
International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical ActivityAdolescent-parent interactions and attitudes around screen time and sugary drink consumption: a qualitative study
30 Citations2009Libby Hattersley, Vanessa A. Shrewsbury +4 more
Preventive Medicine“If there wasn't the technology then I would probably be out everyday”: A qualitative study of children's strategies to reduce their screen viewing
23 Citations2011Simon J. Sebire, Russell Jago +3 more
Children appeared open to screen-Viewing reduction and identified the strategies that they may respond to best which can inform the development of interventions designed to reduce screen-viewing.
Obesity Research & Clinical PracticeBarriers to increasing physical activity and limiting small screen recreation among obese children
19 Citations2009Lauren Puglisi, Anthony D. Okely +2 more
There are an array of barriers to increasing physical activity and limiting small screen recreation among obese children and their parents and parents believe they know what they have to do to overcome many of these barriers but are unaware of the actions they need to take.
Health Education ResearchChildren's perceptions of the factors helping them to be 'resilient' to sedentary lifestyles
16 Citations2013Jenny Veitch, Lauren Arundell +2 more
The perceptions of 'resilient' children regarding factors that assist them to engage in high levels of physical activity and low screen time are explored to inform future studies targeting this important population group of children.
Health Education JournalScreen-related sedentary behaviours of school-aged children
15 Citations2010Meizi He, Leonard Piché +3 more
School principals and teachers were very concerned about excessive screen-related behaviour among school-aged children when away from school and suggested that interventions should emphasize increasing daily physical education, promoting recreational sports at or Away from school, and engaging parents in regulating screen time at home.
Journal of Asthma“ <i>Asthma Isn’t an Excuse, It’s Just a Condition</i> ”: Youths’ Perceptions of Physical Activity and Screen Time
12 Citations2012Jennifer L. P. Protudjer, Jonathan McGavock +4 more
Sport Education and SocietyThe feel of mobility: how children use sedentary lifestyles as a site of resistance
11 Citations2011Martha Bell
Family & Community HealthUnderstanding the Day-to-Day Lives of Obese Children and Their Families
2 Citations2012Lauren Puglisi, Anthony D. Okely +2 more
Lack of parenting skills and role modeling, environments encouraging poor weight-related behaviors, low self-awareness and enjoyment of sedentary activities were common themes.
…
