Conceptual Structure and the Structure of Concepts: A Distributed Account of Category-Specific Deficits

A new account of the fine-grained structure of semantic categories derived from neuropsychological, behavioral, and developmental data is presented, claiming that the distinctiveness of functional features correlated with perceptual features varies across semantic domains and that category structure emerges from the complex interaction of these variables.

Abstract

We present a new account of the fine-grained structure of semantic categories derived from neuropsychological, behavioral, and developmental data. The account places theoretical emphasis on the functions of the referents of concepts. We claim (i) that the distinctiveness of functional features correlated with perceptual features varies across semantic domains; and (ii) that category structure emerges from the complex interaction of these variables. The representational assumptions that follow from these claims make strong predictions about what types of semantic information are preserved in patients showing category-specific deficits following brain damage. These claims are illustrated with a connectionist simulation which, when damaged, shows patterns of preservation of distinctive and shared functional and perceptual information which varies across semantic domains. The data model both dissociations between knowledge for artifacts and for living things and recent neuropsychological evidence concerning the robustness of functional information in the representation of concepts.