Informing the market: The strengths and weaknesses of information in the british national health service
Health Care AnalysisPublished 1 June 1997
Martin McKee, Laurent Chenet
Citations7
SJR quartileQ2
SJR score0.60
SNIP1.34
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is concluded that the existing British system fails to provide robust measures of how many patients are treated, for what conditions, and with what treatments.
Abstract
Many countries are experimenting with planned (or quasi-) markets to discover if they can efficiently deliver health care in keeping with societal objectives. This paper examines the information requirements of this approach. Information is necessary in order to compare the performance of providers, to support billing, and to monitor access to care. It should be accurate, unambiguous, and resistant to manipulation. We draw on a project to find out how information on hospitalisation could be used in contracting in the British National Health Service. We conclude that the existing British system fails to provide robust measures of how many patients are treated, for what conditions, and with what treatments. We identify some promising remedies, others that are more difficult, and some which may be impossible to implement in any planned market, given the uncertainty of clinical practice.
Keywords
MedicineHealth ProfessionsEconomics, Econometrics and Finance
Oxford University Press eBooksAn Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations
11,633 Citations1776Adam C. Smith
Annals of Internal MedicineClinical Epidemiology: A Basic Science for Clinical Medicine.
3,508 Citations1991
Clinical Epidemiology is a book dedicated to H.L. Mencken, Kurt Vonnegut, Jr., Douglas Adams, and the Emperor's New Clothes and Physicians and others who wish to recognize key clinical epidemiologic features of the diagnosis and management of patients will benefit from reading.
British Journal of ManagementOutcome‐related Performance Indicators and Organizational Control in the Public Sector<sup>1</sup>
276 Citations1993Peter Smith
International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health CareUsing Administrative Diagnostic Data to Assess the Quality of Hospital Care: Pitfalls and Potential of ICD-9-CM
168 Citations1990Lisa I. Iezzoni
The purpose of this article is to introduce ICD-9-CM, to review its strengths and limitations, and to suggest ways that it can be used through administrative files for assessing the quality of hospital care.
BMJCoronary artery surgery: are women discriminated against?
140 Citations1993Mark Petticrew, Martin McKee +1 more
There appears to be a systematic difference in the treatment received by men and women in the United Kingdom, and men were significantly more likely than women to undergo revascularisation in both regions.
New England Journal of MedicinePossible Influence of the Prospective Payment System on the Assignment of Discharge Diagnoses for Coronary Heart Disease
125 Citations1993Annlouise R. Assaf, Kate L. Lapane +2 more
The data are consistent with the hypothesis that the prospective reimbursement system has influenced the assignment of hospital discharge codes in a way that would increase payment to hospitals, but do not permit us to distinguish whether hospitals began to assign more precise diagnoses with the advent of the DRG system, or whether they began to favor diagnoses of acute conditions solely for financial reasons.
BMJGuidelines, enthusiasms, uncertainty, and the limits to purchasing
76 Citations1995Martin McKee, Aileen Clarke
The challenges of balancing the desire for protocol based uniformity with the needs of individual patients are examined, the extent to which existing purchasing structures can support this process is explored, and whether such moves will actually lead to reduced costs are questioned.
BMJ Quality & SafetyMortality league tables: do they inform or mislead?
66 Citations1995Martin McKee, Duncan Hunter
Examination of methodological issues related to the publication of mortality league tables, with particular reference to severity adjustment and sample size, finds that Rankings of hospitals by death rate are sensitive to adjustment for severity of disease.
BMJThe consultant episode: an unhelpful measure.
58 Citations1992Aileen Clarke, Martin McKee
The role of the matrix metalloproteinase stromelysin in the progression of squamous cell carcinoma and its identity to erythroid-potentiating activity is investigated.
BMJ Quality & SafetyComparative hospital databases: value for management and quality.
49 Citations1994Robert K. Cleary, R.W. Beard +5 more
Current methods of extracting and coding diagnostic and procedural data from case notes in this sample of hospitals is unsatisfactory: notes were difficult to access and recording is unacceptably incomplete.
BMJDistribution of NHS funds between fundholding and non-fundholding practices
46 Citations1994J. H. Dixon, Mark Dinwoodie +7 more
Estimating the amount spent on specific hospital care by health agencies in 1993–4 and comparing it with the resources allocated to patients registered with fundholding practices for the same type of care in North West Thames appears to have been funded more generously than non-fundholding practices.
Public HealthThe completeness and accuracy of health authority and cancer registry records according to a study of ovarian neoplasms
22 Citations1991A.K. Mukherjee, Ian Leck +2 more
The completeness and accuracy of Hospital Activity Analysis (HAA) and Regional Cancer Registry (RCR) records were investigated in a series of 868 histologically reviewed cases in which primary ovarian neoplasms had been diagnosed according to one or more of seven data sources including HAA and RCR.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthA possible artefactual component in specific cause mortality gradients. Social class variations in the clinical accuracy of death certificates.
21 Citations1988M. Samphier, Christopher Robertson +1 more
It appears that in the majority of the most common causes of death grouped by ICD chapter (neoplasms, cerebrovascular and digestive) social class gradients would be steeper if mortality data were based on pathologists' rather than clinicians' diagnoses.
PubMedPurpose of admission and resource use during cancer hospitalizations.
20 Citations1991Lisa I. Iezzoni, Mary Henderson +2 more
POA and indicators of case complexity added only modestly to the ability of diagnosis-related groups to predict hospitalization charges, which varied significantly by POA.
BMJMaking routine data adequate to support clinical audit
17 Citations1995Martin McKee, Jennifer Dixon +1 more
Journal of Public HealthPIS and DRGs: coding inaccuracies and their consequences for resource management
15 Citations1991S.H. Smith, Christopher J. Kershaw +2 more
The resource implications of assiduous quality control of recording, coding and computing is pointed out, and it is suggested that improved classification systems should be assessed for use in the NHS.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthChallenges of monitoring use of secondary care at local level: a study based in London, UK.
15 Citations1996Laurent Chenet, Martin McKee
This paper provides a framework for those working at district level to begin to analyse the association between hospitalisation and deprivation locally and identifies some of the issues that must be taken into account when seeking to interpret these data.
BMJInterview with Alain Enthoven: is there convergence between Britain and the United States in the organisation of health services?
15 Citations1995P Newman
Alain Enthoven, Marriner S Eccles professor of public and private management at Stanford University, has been the principal proponent of managed competition in both countries and explores the similarities and differences that have arisen between Britain and the United States.
Journal of the Royal Society of MedicineIs Money Wasted on Audit?
3 Citations1994Martin McKee
It was concluded that the relationship between retroviruses and autoimmunity remained an open question which required further investigation by both retrovirologists and immunologists.