Accuracy of self-reported body weight, height and waist circumference in a Dutch overweight working population
BMC Medical Research MethodologyPublished 28 October 2008Open access
J. Caroline Dekkers, Marieke F. van Wier, Ingrid Hendriksen, Jos W. R. Twisk, Willem van Mechelen
Citations246
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.67
SNIP1.73
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Results suggest that self-reported BMI and WC are satisfactorily accurate for the assessment of the prevalence of overweight/obesity and increased WC in a middle-aged overweight working population.
Abstract
ISRCTN04265725.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
BiometricsThe Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data
78,934 Citations1977J. Richard Landis, Gary G. Koch
A general statistical methodology for the analysis of multivariate categorical data arising from observer reliability studies is presented and tests for interobserver bias are presented in terms of first-order marginal homogeneity and measures of interob server agreement are developed as generalized kappa-type statistics.
The LancetSTATISTICAL METHODS FOR ASSESSING AGREEMENT BETWEEN TWO METHODS OF CLINICAL MEASUREMENT
47,620 Citations1986J Martin Bland, DouglasG. Altman
An alternative approach, based on graphical techniques and simple calculations, is described, together with the relation between this analysis and the assessment of repeatability.
Child Abuse & NeglectChild abuse: Adolescent records vs. adult recall
8,846 Citations1990Donna Della Femina, Catherine A. Yeager +1 more
In a follow-up study of incarcerated Connecticut youth, 69 subjects interviewed during young adulthood, 26 gave histories of abuse discrepant with histories obtained from records and interviews conducted in adolescence, finding reasons for these discrepant data are discussed.
JAMAExcess Deaths Associated With Underweight, Overweight, and Obesity
2,829 Citations2005Katherine M. Flegal
PubMedClinical Guidelines on the Identification, Evaluation, and Treatment of Overweight and Obesity in Adults--The Evidence Report. National Institutes of Health.
2,736 Citations1998Anna Meiliana, Andi Wijaya
Obesity ReviewsA comparison of direct vs. self‐report measures for assessing height, weight and body mass index: a systematic review
1,960 Citations2007Sarah Connor Gorber, Mark S. Tremblay +2 more
Overall, the data show trends of under‐reporting for weight and BMI and over-reporting for height, although the degree of the trend varies for men and women and the characteristics of the population being examined.
Annals of Internal MedicineObesity in Adulthood and Its Consequences for Life Expectancy: A Life-Table Analysis
1,479 Citations2003Anna Peeters, Jan J. Barendregt +4 more
An estimate of the effect of obesity and overweight in adulthood on life expectancy is provided, implicitly taking into account the various possible weight trajectories throughout the life course, based on data from the Framingham Heart Study.
Public Health NutritionValidity of self-reported height and weight in 4808 EPIC–Oxford participants
1,090 Citations2002Elizabeth Spencer, Paul N. Appleby +2 more
Self-reported height and weight data are valid for identifying relationships in epidemiological studies and can be used to improve the accuracy of estimates of height, weight and BMI in analyses where anthropometric factors are the primary variables of interest.
EpidemiologyValidity of Self-Reported Waist and Hip Circumferences in Men and Women
1,010 Citations1990Eric B. Rimm, Meir J. Stampfer +4 more
The moderate degree of measurement error for the ratio of self-reported waist and hip circumferences implies that previously reported associations based on self-report of these measures may have been appreciably underestimated.
Archives of Internal MedicineOverweight, Obesity, and Health Risk
964 Citations2000National Task Force on the Prevention and Treatment of Obesity
A review of the large body of evidence indicating that higher levels of body weight and body fat are associated with an increased risk for the development of numerous adverse health consequences suggests efforts to prevent further weight gain in adults at risk for overweight and obesity are essential.
American Journal of EpidemiologyCOMPARISON OF SELF-REPORTED AND MEASURED HEIGHT AND WEIGHT
640 Citations1982Mari Palta, Ronald J. Prineas +2 more
Screening data from the Hypertension Detection and Follow-up Program in Minneapolis, MN, 1973-1974 provided an opportunity to evaluate the accuracy of self-report of height and weight, and it was found that both were reported, on the average, with small but systematic errors.
Social Science & MedicineSocioeconomic status and weight change in adults: a review
509 Citations2004Kylie Ball, David Crawford
It is suggested that in developed countries, weight gain prevention efforts might best be focused on those who are most socioeconomically disadvantaged, particularly those in lower status occupations.
International Journal of ObesityValidity of self-reported weight and height in the French GAZEL cohort
459 Citations2000Isabelle Niedhammer, I. Bugel +3 more
The findings suggest that self-reported weight and height should be treated with caution, because of biases leading to misclassification for overweight and obesity, especially in certain segments of the population.
Journal of Midwifery & Women s HealthAccuracy of Self‐Reported Height and Weight in Women: An Integrative Review of the Literature
393 Citations2003Janet L. Engstrom, Susan Paterson +3 more
Findings indicate that direct measurement of height and weight should be performed whenever possible for optimal measurements in clinical practice and clinically oriented research.
EpidemiologyBody Mass Definitions of Obesity
302 Citations1990F. Javier Nieto-García, Trudy L. Bush +1 more
The results suggest that substantial misclassification can occur when self-reported information is used to define body mass categories, and that self-report of these variables is appropriate in epidemiologic studies.
American Journal of Preventive MedicineSelf-reported weight and height
274 Citations2001Haq Nawaz, Wing‐Lok Chan +3 more
Obese women who seek weight-loss assistance tend to under- Report their weight and over-report their height, suggesting that self-reported data are likely to be inaccurate.
Journal of Epidemiology & Community HealthAccuracy of the estimated prevalence of obesity from self reported height and weight in an adult Scottish population
265 Citations2000C Bolton-Smith, Mark Woodward +2 more
This Scottish population was unique in the under-reporting of height as well as weight, which resulted in BMI estimates with low error, which suggest that self reported weights and heights would be satisfactory for the monitoring of obesity prevalence in Scotland.
PubMedThe predictive validity of body mass index based on self-reported weight and height.
263 Citations1989A Kuskowska-Wolk, Per Karlsson +2 more
The regression lines of subjective parameters on controlled ones were significantly different from the line of identity for both sexes for weight, height and BMI, demonstrating a 'flat slope syndrome', which may invalidate data and conclusions of population surveys based on self-reported measures.
International Journal of EpidemiologySocioeconomic differentials in misclassification of height, weight and body mass index based on questionnaire data
256 Citations1997Gunnel Boström, Finn Diderichsen
This study shows that socioeconomic differences in height, when using self-reported information, involve an underestimation, which means that the height differences between socioeconomic groups in Sweden may actually be higher than that reported by individuals in surveys.
PubMedEstimates of obesity based on self-report versus direct measures.
218 Citations2008Margot Shields, Sarah Connor Gorber +1 more
Under-reporting of weight was high among people who were overweight, and particularly high among those who were obese, compared with people of normal weight.
Public HealthCan self-reported data accurately describe the prevalence of overweight?
207 Citations1995RJ Roberts
The results have important implications for the use of self-reported data for the scientific measurement of the prevalence of overweight, especially in longitudinal studies, and suggest that further research should be conducted into the stability of reporting bias over time.
International Journal of ObesityValidity of self-reported height and weight in a Japanese workplace population
170 Citations2005Keiko Wada, Koji Tamakoshi +9 more
The self-reported height and weight were generally reliable in the middle-aged employed Japanese men and women, but it should be remembered that self- reported weight was biased by actual BMI and affected by age and the presence of diabetes.
Journal of the American Dietetic AssociationAnthropometric Measurements and Body Silhouette of Women
169 Citations2002B. Téhard, Marti van Liere +2 more
Self-reported measurements (made with or without help) are valid measures in epidemiological studies, however they should be interpreted with caution in certain instances, especially for overweight subjects.
American Journal of EpidemiologyACCURACY AND RELIABILITY OF SELF-MEASUREMENT OF BODY GIRTHS
159 Citations1988Lawrence H. Kushi, Susan A. Kaye +3 more
Girth self-measurement was both repeatable when re-ascertained by mail and accurate when compared with subsequent technician measurement, and for most girths, within-person variation in girth measurement also increased as girth size increased.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public HealthA comparison of self‐reported and measured height, weight and BMI in Australian adolescents
116 Citations2002Zaimin Wang, Carla Patterson +1 more
The relationship between self‐reported weight and height to actual weight andheight in older Australian adolescents is compared to that in younger adolescents to explore the role of self-reported height and weight in adolescent obesity.
Age and AgeingAgreement between measured and self-reported weight in older women. Results from the British Women's Heart and Health Study
116 Citations2002Debbie A. Lawlor
Self-report of weight should not be relied upon in prospective epidemiological studies or clinical practice when accuracy at the level of the individual is required, and at an individual level differences between self-report and measured weight are frequently large.
Public Health NutritionAccuracy of self-reported waist and hip measurements in 4492 EPIC–Oxford participants
110 Citations2004Elizabeth Spencer, Andrew Roddam +1 more
Self-reported waist and hip measurements in EPIC–Oxford are sufficiently accurate for identifying relationships in epidemiological studies and WHR was underestimated by less than 2% by men and women; the extent of underestimation was greater among those with larger WHR, older people and those with greater BMI.
Journal of NutritionSelf-Reported and Technician-Measured Waist Circumferences Differ in Middle-Aged Men and Women
107 Citations2005Janne Bigaard, Iben Spanggaard +3 more
The self-reported waist circumference at the level of the umbilicus was correlated with the technician-measured circumference atThe natural waist, and the diameter at the natural waist was overestimated for women, depending on baseline waist circumference, and slightly underestimated for men, Depending on baseline BMI.
PubMedValidation study of self-reported measures of fat distribution.
98 Citations1996Weaver Tw, Lawrence H. Kushi +7 more
Self measurements of these anthropometric variables are highly accurate even when used to formulate derived variables, and are therefore appropriate for epidemiologic studies.
Scandinavian Journal of Social MedicineAccuracy of Self-Reported Body Weight Compared to Measured Body Weight
87 Citations1987Laura Jalkanen, Jaakko Tuomilehto +2 more
The results showed that older people underestimated their weight to a greater extent than did younger people of both sexes, and the error between measured and self-reported weight was greater in heavier subjects than in thinner individuals.
Obesity ReviewsAssociations between obesity and health conditions may be overestimated if self‐reported body mass index is used
77 Citations2007Arnaud Chioléro, Isabelle Peytremann‐Bridevaux +1 more
It is shown that selfreported BMI is most often lower than measured BMI, i.e. that some obese individuals are misclassified as being non-obese, and therefore prevalence of obesity is underestimated and any association between obesity and health conditions will be underestimated.
PubMedEffects of measurement on obesity and morbidity.
63 Citations2008Margot Shields, Sarah Connor Gorber +1 more
British Journal Of NutritionSelf-reported waist circumference compared with the ‘Waist Watcher’ tape-measure to identify individuals at increased health risk through intra-abdominal fat accumulation
59 Citations1998Thang S. Han, Michael E. J. Lean
People tend to underestimate their waist circumference, but the ‘Waist Watcher’ tape-measure offers advantages over self-reported home-assessed measurement, and may be used as a screening tool for self-classifying the risk of ill health through intra-abdominal fat accumulation.
American Journal of EpidemiologyTHE ASSOCIATION OF DIETARY FAT WITH SERUM CHOLESTEROL IN VEGETARIANS: THE EFFECT OF DIETARY ASSESSMENT ON THE CORRELATION COEFFICIENT
52 Citations1988Lawrence H. Kushi, Kenneth W. Samonds +4 more
Biologic responsiveness to dietary fat in the vegetarians was similar to that predicted by the Keys equation derived from nonvegetarians, and multiple-day averaging of dietary records and relatively smaller ratio of within-person to between-person variation in intake favor the detection of cross-sectional associations of diet with serum cholesterol.
BMC Public HealthALIFE@Work: a randomised controlled trial of a distance counselling lifestyle programme for weight control among an overweight working population [ISRCTN04265725]
43 Citations2006Marieke F. van Wier, Geertje AM Ariëns +5 more
ALIFE@Work will make a substantial contribution to the development of cost-effective weight control- and lifestyle interventions that are applicable to and attractive for the large population at risk.
Nutrition and CancerAccuracy of self‐measurement of body fat distribution by waist, hip, and thigh circumferences
39 Citations1991Jo L. Freudenheim, Sherri L. Darrow
The accuracy of self-measurement of waist, hip, and thigh circumferences, indicators of fat distribution, were examined for 227 women who were sent either a calibrated or uncalibrated tape measure and subsequently remeasured by a trained technician.
Journal of the American Dietetic AssociationAccuracy of Self-Measurement of Waist and Hip Circumference in Men and Women
36 Citations1997Cynthia A. Roberts, Lora B. Wilder +3 more
Public Health NutritionThe accuracy of self-reported weight by overweight and obese women in an outpatient setting
33 Citations2001K. Rossouw, Marjanne Senekal +1 more
Self- reported weight of a group of overweight/obese individuals may be a valid and reliable indicator of actual weight, but self-reported weight of an overweight/OBese individual can not be interpreted similarly.
PubMedA validation study of body fat distribution as determined by self-measurement of waist and hip circumference.
31 Citations1989Teri R. Hall, Terry Young
Female subjects tend to underestimate waist circumference, and misclassification of fat distribution pattern may result from this error, which may in turn lead to underestimation of associations between fat pattern and disease risk.
International Journal of ObesityDietary restraint and the mis-reporting of anthropometric measures by middle-aged adults
24 Citations2003Adrienne Cullum, Anne McCarthy +4 more
Dietary restraint score may be a useful tool for identifying individuals more likely to mis-report anthropometric measurements, although associations may vary by gender.