Structuring Discourse for Collective Interpretation
Published 1 January 2000
Simon Buckingham Shum, Albert M. Selvin, White Plains
Citations24
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This paper reflects on three examples of a discourse-oriented approach to supporting collective interpretation, and draws attention to specific challenges that discourse-structuring technologies raise, and strategies for tackling them.
Abstract
This paper reflects on three examples of a discourse-oriented approach to supporting collective interpretation. By this, we mean activities involving two or more people who are trying to make sense of an issue. The common theme linking the examples is that each mediates interpretive activity via a software environment which structures discourse: participants construct their interpretation within a representational framework which in return provides computational services. As a by-product, this persistent trace of the sensemaking process can serve as a collective memory resource for subsequent reinterpretation. Based on the three examples, we draw attention to specific challenges that discourse-structuring technologies raise, and strategies for tackling them. A generic issue emerging from this work is the design of ontologies (representational schemes) by and for communities of practice.
Keywords
Computer ScienceSocial Sciences
The Journal of Academic LibrarianshipSorting Things Out: Classification and Its Consequences
5,261 Citations2000Maiko Spiess, Geoffrey Bowker +9 more
ComputerHypertext: An Introduction and Survey
2,708 Citations1987Conklin
A survey of existing hypertext systems, their applications, and their design is both an introduction to the world of hypertext and a survey of some of the most important design issues that go into fashioning a hypertext environment.
Organization ScienceShaping Electronic Communication: The Metastructuring of Technology in the Context of Use
705 Citations1995Wanda J. Orlikowski, JoAnne Yates +2 more
A theoretical framing of the mediation process suggests that it can be a powerful organizational mechanism for helping organizations provide the ongoing attention and resources needed to adapt electronic communication technologies to changing conditions, contexts, and organizational forms.
Human-Computer InteractionA Language/Action Perspective on the Design of Cooperative Work
472 Citations1987Terry Winograd
Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW)Do categories have politics?
393 Citations1993Lucy Suchman
It is proposed that the adoption of speech act theory as a foundation for system design carries with it an agenda of discipline and control over organization members' actions.
ACM Transactions on Information SystemsSemistructured messages are surprisingly useful for computer-supported coordination
329 Citations1987Thomas W. Malone, Kenneth R. Grant +3 more
It is argued that using a set of semistructured message templates is surprisingly helpful in designing a variety of computer-based communication and coordination systems.
Human-Computer InteractionA Process-Oriented Approach to Design Rationale
297 Citations1991E. Jeffrey Conklin, K. C. Burgess Yakemovic
Computer Supported Cooperative Work (CSCW)Formality Considered Harmful: Experiences, Emerging Themes, and Directions on the Use of Formal Representations in Interactive Systems
271 Citations1999Frank Shipman, Catherine C. Marshall
It is posed that, while it is impossible to remove all formalisms from computing systems, system designers need to match the level of formal expression entailed with the goals and situation of the users -- a design criteria not commonly mentioned in current interface design.
Shifting perspectives on organizational memory: from storage to active remembering
190 Citations1996Liam J. Bannon, Kari Kuutti
This paper provides an important reformulation of one aspect of "memory" that is implicit if not explicit in most current views (i.e. the notion of memory as a passive store), arguing instead for an active, constructive view of "remembering" that has a long, if forgotten history within psychology and other fields.
A confederation of tools for capturing and accessing collaborative activity
172 Citations1995Scott Minneman, Steve Harrison +5 more
A confederation of tools that combine to support the real-time capture of and subsequent access to informal collaborative activities, called Coral, which involves frequent discussion and decision-making meetings and later access of the captured records of those meetings to produce accurate documentation.
Supporting knowledge-base evolution with incremental formalization
170 Citations1994Frank Shipman, Raymond J. McCall
Experiences with the domain independent Hyper-Object Substrate show that its flexibility for incrementally adding and formalizing information is useful for the rapid prototyping and modification of semi-formal information spaces.
International Journal on Digital LibrariesScholOnto: an ontology-based digital library server for research documents and discourse
166 Citations2000Simon Buckingham Shum, Enrico Motta +1 more
The design rationale and implementation of ScholOnto is described, an ontology-based digital library server to support scholarly interpretation and discourse that enables researchers to describe and debate via a semantic network the contributions a document makes, and its relationship to the literature.
Questioning Representations
148 Citations1991Mike Robinson, Liam J. Bannon
It is suggested that a more fruitful approach might be to accept that the final determination of a system rests with the users, and in the long run this might give rise to different types of design principles than those used at the moment.
Human-Computer InteractionGraphical Argumentation and Design Cognition
138 Citations1997Simon Buckingham Shum, Allan MacLean +2 more
This article presents a use-oriented analysis of a graphical argumentation notation known as QOC (Questions, Options, and Criteria), and shows that it provides most support when elaborating poorly understood design spaces, but is a distraction when evaluating well-constrained design spaces.
Design environments for constructive and argumentative design
117 Citations1989Gerhard Fischer, Raymond J. McCall +1 more
Two computer-supported environments are created, CRACK and VIEWPOINTS, to support two complementary problem solving activities in design: constructive design and argumentative design.
From documents to discourse
72 Citations1998Tamara Sumner, Simon Buckingham Shum
This research reports here on two cases – an e-journal and a ‘new form’ of conference – where D3E is used to promote new forms of discourse between participants, and uses these cases to illustrate four principles that guide the socio-technical design actions.
Analyzing the Usability of a Design Rationale Notation
70 Citations2020Simon Buckingham Shum
This chapter examines how designers use a DR notation during design problem solving, and compares the account of the QOC–design relationship which emerges from these studies, with reports of other DR approaches in use.
Texas Digital Library (University of Texas)Supporting Collaborative Analysis and Design with Hypertext Functionality
67 Citations2006Albert M. Selvin
Conversational Modeling is reported on, a technique that has been used successfully in a number of collaborative systems analysis, requirements gathering and work process redesign projects in a telecommunications company, and appears to be due to the combination of hypertext functionality, a structured modeling framework, and group facilitation strategies.
Pushing Toulmin Too Far: Learning From an Argument Representation Scheme
65 Citations1998Susan E. Newman, Catherine Marshall
This paper uses the experiences with argument representation to examine some of the issues affecting the design of representational schemes, and focuses on how well a particular scheme, Toulmin structures, maps into the domain of argumentative discourse and captures and highlights various phenomena the authors consider central to argumentation.
Analysing the Usability of a Design Rationale Notation
48 Citations1996Simon Buckingham Shum
Arguments in hypertext
27 Citations2000Locke M. Carter
The author presents concepts of informal logic, stasis theory, primacy/recency/repetition effects, spatial metaphors, and textual coherence as a starting point for building a rhetorical understanding of argumentation strategies in hypertext.
New scenarios in scholarly publishing and debate
18 Citations2012Simon Buckingham Shum
Redesigning the Peer Review Process: A Developmental Theory-in-Action
18 Citations2000Tamara Sumner, Simon Buckingham Shum +4 more
It is argued that ‘meta-structuring’ is an instance of a broader class of theories, which it is called “developmental theories-in-action”, which offer a promising direction for future research agendas.
A framework for assessing group memory approaches for software design projects
14 Citations1997Beatrix Zimmermann, Albert M. Selvin
A framework for assessing group memory systems is described and a group profile is defined which is used to define features of a group, which can be compared with the assumptions and requirements of the group memory system.
Lecture notes in computer scienceScholarly Discourse as Computable Structure
13 Citations2000Simon Buckingham Shum, John Domingue +1 more
This paper summarises the goals and implementation of a knowledge based hypertext environment called ScholOnto (for Scholarly Ontologies), which aims to provide researchers with computational support in representing and analysing the structure of scholarly claims, argumentation and perspectives.
Journal of Organizational Computing and Electronic CommerceWhat: An argumentative groupware approach for organizing and documenting research activities
11 Citations1991Safaa Hashim
A toolkit for publishing Web discussion documents: design principles and case studies
4 Citations2002Tamara Sumner, Simon Buckingham Shum
D3E is an experimental system supporting the publication of Web based documents with integrated discourse facilities and embedded interactive components, and three applications are reported-an e-journal, a hybrid Web/face-to-face conference, and a national policy document-where it is used to promote critical discourse between participants.