Therapeutic relationships in critical care nursing: a reflection on practice
Nursing in Critical CarePublished 17 April 2008
Elizabeth O’Connell
Citations49
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score0.95
SNIP1.24
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Engaging in therapeutic nurse-patient relationships can expose nurses to emotional pain in the context of critical care nursing, but the process of reflection can facilitate critical care nurses in the development of the emotional intelligence required to develop and maintain these relationships.
Abstract
AIMS: The aim of this paper is to gain a greater understanding of the emotional intelligence required to form therapeutic nurse-patient relationships in the context of critical care nursing. CONTEXT: There is currently a demand for patient-centred nursing in all aspects of health care to improve both quality of care and consumer satisfaction. Central to patient-centred care is the presence of a therapeutic nurse-patient relationships, but the development of these relationships present a challenge in the acute and technological world of critical care nursing. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK: Using Titchen's Skilled Companionship Model as a guide as well as empirical and theoretical knowledge on nurse-patient relationships, this paper presents a reflection on a relationship that the author developed with a patient and his family encountered in her practice as a critical care nurse. REFLECTIVE CONCLUSIONS: Engaging in therapeutic nurse-patient relationships can expose nurses to emotional pain in the context of critical care nursing. The process of reflection can facilitate critical care nurses in the development of the emotional intelligence required to develop and maintain these relationships and this enhances the care of critically ill patients and their families.
Keywords
PsychologyMedicineHealth Professions
PubMedNursing: human science and human care. A theory of nursing.
900 Citations1988Jean Watson
Watson's Theory of Human Care draws from the works of Western and Eastern philosophers, approaching the human care relationship as a moral idea that includes concepts such as phenomenal field, actual caring occasion, and transpersonal caring.
Nursing Theories and Nursing Practice
522 Citations2005Marilyn Parker
Patient Education and CounselingPatient-centredness in chronic illness: what is it and does it matter?
468 Citations2003Susan Michie, Jane Miles +1 more
This review of published research on health care communication in chronic illness investigates whether studies of patient-centred consultations use distinctive concepts, and whether different concepts are differentially associated with health outcomes.
International Journal of Nursing PracticeA conceptual framework for person‐centred practice with older people
361 Citations2003Brendan McCormack
In the framework, person-centredness is premised on the concept of authentic consciousness and is operationalized through five imperfect duties, identified as the patient's values, the nurse's values and the context of the care environment.
Nursing InquiryThe heart of the art: emotional intelligence in nurse education
346 Citations2004Dawn Freshwater, Theodore Stickley
It is argued that much of what is described within curriculum documentation is little more than rhetoric when the surface is scratched and proposed that some educationalists and practitioners have embraced the concept of emotional intelligence uncritically, and without fully grasping the entirety of its meaning and application.
Journal of Clinical NursingPower imbalance between nurses and patients: a potential inhibitor of partnership in care
264 Citations2003Saras Henderson
The findings showed that nurses viewed involving patients in care as requiring them to give patients information and to share their decision-making powers with them, with the exception of a few, which created a situation of power imbalance with subsequent little patient input.
Medical Entomology and ZoologyTheory and Nursing: Integrated Knowledge Development
254 Citations1999Peggy L. Chinn, Maeona K. Kramer
Nursing's Fundamental patterns of Knowing and Nursing's Knowledge Development Pathways: Explaining and Structuring Theory.
Journal of Advanced NursingBeyond empathy: expanding expressions of caring
202 Citations2006Janice M. Morse, Joan L. Bottorff +3 more
A model describing nurses' responses to patients who are suffering is presented and four types of communication patterns are identified: engaged responses (first-level) are used in a connected relationship; when the nurse responses reflexively and is focused on him-/herself, the response is reflected.
Pediatric Physical TherapyPractice Knowledge and Expertise in the Health Professions
197 Citations2002Carmen I. Rios
Journal of Clinical NursingThe meaning of caring to nurses: an investigation into the nature of caring work in an intensive care unit
188 Citations2003Kathleen Wilkin, Éamonn Slevin
This study demonstrated that the lived experience of caring reflects the humanistic nature of nursing, and confirms that to care is human and the capacity to Care is affirmed and actualised in caring for the critically ill patient and their relatives.
Journal of Clinical NursingNurse–patient relationships and partnership in hospital care
167 Citations2000Anne McQueen
The argument here is that forming such a therapeutic relationship involves the nurse in work of an interpersonal and emotional nature that is required to be recognized in clinical practice, education and research.
PubMedImportance of nurse caring behaviors as perceived by patients after myocardial infarction.
149 Citations1988Sherill Nones Cronin, Bobbi Harrison
An analysis of the relative importance of each identified behavior revealed that nursing actions that focused on the physical care and monitoring of patients were seen as most indicative of caring.
Journal of Advanced NursingBeyond empathy: expanding expressions of caring
129 Citations1992Janice M. Morse, Joan L. Bottorff +3 more
Scandinavian Journal of Caring SciencesNurses’ experiences of interactions with family members in intensive care units
128 Citations2003Ing-Mari K. Söderström, Eva Benzein +1 more
Nurses' experiences of interactions with family members in intensive care units were described, and two categories emerged: inviting and noninviting interactions between nurses and family members.
Dimensions of Critical Care NursingTechnological Caring
104 Citations1987Marilyn A. Ray
This investigator uses a qualitative method to study human caring experience in critical care nursing using common quantitative research methods.
Heart & LungThe importance of nurse caring behaviors as perceived by patients receiving care at an emergency department
95 Citations2002Gy∂a Baldursdottir, Helga Jónsdóttir
Clinical competence is considered to be the most important nurse caring behavior, which further emphasizes the notion of caring as a moral stance integral to all interactions with patients.
Nursing InquiryThe art of loving and the therapeutic relationship
93 Citations2002Theodore Stickley, Dawn Freshwater
A framework for developing the art of loving within nursing care is presented, which emphasises the balance between discipline, concentration, patience, concern and activity and outlines the boundaries in which genuine love may be expressed within the parameters of a professional role.
Nursing PhilosophyThe tidal model: the lived‐experience in person‐centred mental health nursing care
78 Citations2001Phil Barker
The Tidal Model extends and develops some of the traditional assumptions concerning the centrality of interpersonal relations within nursing practice, emphasizing in particular the importance of perceived meanings within the lived-experience of the person-in-care and the role of the narrative in the development of person-centred care plans.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingInvolving families in care within the intensive care environment: a descriptive survey
72 Citations1995Fiona Hammond
The study suggests benefits, to both nurses and relatives, of lay participation in physical care of critically ill patients on the ICU environment, and highlights issues of personal choice for individual lay involvement and adequate information for families to become involved.
Therapeutic Nursing: Improving Patient Care Through Self Awareness and Reflection
72 Citations2002Dawn Freshwater
The Therapeutic Use of Self in Nursing - Dawn Freshwater and the Importance of Philosophical Conference forTherapeutic use of self in Practice - Roderick McKenzie
Heart & LungExpert nursing behaviors in care of the dying adult in the intensive care unit
71 Citations1995Susan McClement, Lesley F. Degner
Journal of Advanced NursingA Heideggerian hermeneutic study of the practice of critical care nurses
70 Citations1995Allan John Walters
This study provides a Heideggerian analysis of the practice of eight critical care nurses who work in an Australian intensive care unit and describes two themes that emerged from a larger study on expert critical care nursing practice, referred to as 'balancing' and 'being busy'.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingThe communication process with ventilator patients in the ICU as perceived by the nursing staff
70 Citations1993Ingegerd Bergbom-Engberg, H. Haljamäe
There are many factors, in addition to ICU experience, that may influence the ability of an ICU nurse to establish and maintain a well functioning communication with ventilated patients and the likelihood of doing so is shown.
Issues in Comprehensive Pediatric NursingPARENTS' PERCEPTIONS OF NURSES' CAREGIVING BEHAVIORS IN THE PEDIATRIC INTENSIVE CARE UNIT
62 Citations2004Bonnie Lee Harbaugh, Patricia Short Tomlinson +1 more
Parents' reports suggest that the best nursing behaviors are those that facilitate and complement critical aspects of the parental role, thus reinforcing family integrity during a time of turmoil and uncertainty, and contributes to nurses' understanding of PICU hospitalization as a family event.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingPreventing the ITU syndrome or how not to torture an ITU patient! Part 2
61 Citations1995Ian Dyer
Methods of preventing the ITU syndrome should begin, whenever possible, before admission and should continue throughout the patients' stay, with the main emphasis placed on prevention, but early detection and treatment of problems should also be given high priority.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingIntensive care nurses’ experiences of caring Part 2: Research findings
54 Citations2000Jayne P. Beeby
The research findings obtained from a phenomenological study conducted to answer the question 'what is caring for nurses working in intensive care?' identify that these nurses participated in delivering three types of caring involving physical, technical and emotional labour.
Advances in Nursing ScienceTherapeutic reciprocity
52 Citations1990Patrícia Marck
The thesis of this article is that therapeutic reciprocity, as one phenomenon of caring, allows both the nurse and the client to benefit from their relationship in a mutually empowering manner.
Journal of Clinical NursingIntensive Care Unit psychosis, the therapeutic nurse–patient relationship and the influence of the intensive care setting: analyses of interrelating factors
48 Citations1999MARTYN DYSON
This paper will explore the interaction between Intensive Care Unit Psychosis, the therapeutic nurse-patient relationship, and the environment in which nurses' interactions with their clients occur while considering the implications for contemporary nursing practice.
Nursing StandardKeeping the person in the centre of nursing
45 Citations2000Pauline Ford, Brendan McCormack
An overview of what it means to be a person and how this is articulated in person-centred approaches to practice is presented.
Butterworth-Heinemann eBooksLearning human skills : an experiential guide for nurses
41 Citations1990Philip Burnard
A guide, covering both theory and practice, to how nurses can enhance their interpersonal skills and also develop counselling and group skills.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingClinical signs of ICU syndrome/delirium: an observational study
40 Citations2001Anetth Granberg‐Axéll, Ingegerd Bergbom +1 more
It was found that the patients showed a great variety of clinical signs that could be related to the ICU syndrome, and these signs did not seem to be separate phenomena but were inter-connected and part of a progression, and, therefore must be seen in the overall context and situation.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingPreventing the ITU syndrome or how not to torture an ITU patient! Part I
40 Citations1995Ian Dyer
The analogies between psychological torture and ITU care are explored, and this is followed by consideration of ways of reducing the incidence of the syndrome and a suggested method of auditing an ITU in order to identify potential problem areas.
Nursing StandardThe sociology of intimacy in the nurse-patient relationship
39 Citations2006Maura Dowling
It is revealed that 'over-involved' or 'intimate' nurse-patient relationships do not tend to be welcomed by nurses.
Holistic Nursing PracticeTechnologic Competence as Caring in Critical Care Nursing
37 Citations1998Rozzano C. Locsin
Technology, caring, and competence are core concepts that constitute the framework of technologic competence as caring in critical care nursing, a framework grounded in the perspective of nursing as caring.
Journal of Clinical NursingTechnological competence as a fundamental structure of learning in critical care nursing: a phenomenological study
33 Citations2000Christine V. Little
It is argued that curriculum development for clinically based, post-registration courses can be constructively informed by local consultation and that phenomenological study can complement more traditional approaches often relied upon in educational research.
British Journal of NursingExploring mutuality within the nurse–patient relationship
27 Citations1998Steve Briant, Dawn Freshwater
Heart & LungCritical care nurses' lived experiences of caring
25 Citations1997Helen A. Bush, Wendy J. Barr
The fundamental structure of caring as lived by Critical Care Nurses was formed and the decision process used by nurses would benefit from further examination for the presence of the affective and nurse outcome subprocesses.
Journal of Neuroscience NursingExperiences of Critical Care Nurses Caring for Unresponsive Patients
23 Citations1999Nancy E. Villanueva
The study identified areas that need to be addressed in both general nursing education and nursing practice, such as instruction on talking to comatose patients, working with families and orientation information for nurses new to caring for these populations.
Nurse Education TodayTherapeutic nursing-improving patient care through self-awareness and reflection
23 Citations2003Steven Ersser
This book examines that highly complex and sometimes elusive area of nursing, ‘the most effective therapeutic tool the nurse possesses’ and does so largely with clarity, insight and illustration, in its attempt to integrate both analysis and theory with practical ways to improve self-awareness within nursing practice, education and research.
Nursing in Critical CareReflection on the relationship between technology and caring
19 Citations2005Christopher Johns
Critical care nurses need to empathize and respond to the patient's experience on being attached to all forms of medical equipment to provide effective and effective critical care.
Intensive and Critical Care NursingFamily nursing in intensive care part two: the needs of a family with a member in intensive care
16 Citations1998Yvonne Robb
If it was shown that the meeting of family needs was an area of care which could be improved upon, then a family-centred approach to care would be a reasonable option, then changing the system of care to a more formal family nursing approach would seem to be unnecessary.