Randomised trials in surgery: problems and possible solutions
BMJPublished 15 June 2002Open access
Peter McCulloch, Irving Taylor, Mitsuru Sasako, Bryony Lovett, Damian Griffin
Citations747
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The quality and quantity of randomised trials of surgical techniques is acknowledged to be limited, but according to Peter McCulloch and colleagues, however, some aspects of surgery present special difficulties forrandomised trials.
Keywords
Decision SciencesMedicine
New England Journal of MedicineRandomized, Controlled Trials, Observational Studies, and the Hierarchy of Research Designs
3,474 Citations2000John Concato, Nirav R. Shah +1 more
The results of well-designed observational studies (with either a cohort or a case-control design) do not systematically overestimate the magnitude of the effects of treatment as compared with those in randomized, controlled trials on the same topic.
New England Journal of MedicineA Comparison of Observational Studies and Randomized, Controlled Trials
2,352 Citations2000Kjell Benson, Arthur J. Hartz
Little evidence is found that estimates of treatment effects in observational studies reported after 1984 are either consistently larger than or qualitatively different from those obtained in randomized, controlled trials.
BMJWhy we need observational studies to evaluate the effectiveness of health care
1,602 Citations1996Nicholas Black
The view is widely held that experimental methods (randomised controlled trials) are the "gold standard" for evaluation and that observational methods have little or no value, but this ignores the limitations of randomised trials.
New England Journal of MedicineExtended Lymph-Node Dissection for Gastric Cancer
1,592 Citations1999Johannes J. Bonenkamp, J. Hermans +14 more
The results in Dutch patients do not support the routine use of D2 lymph-node dissection in patients with gastric cancer, as recommended by the Japanese medical community.
British Journal of CancerPatient survival after D1 and D2 resections for gastric cancer: long-term results of the MRC randomized surgical trial
1,379 Citations1999for the Surgical Co-operative Group, A. Cuschieri +7 more
The findings indicate that the classical Japanese D2 resection offers no survival advantage over D1 surgery, however, the possibility that D 2 resection without pancreatico-splenectomy may be better than standard D1 resection cannot be dismissed by the results of this trial.
JAMAEndarterectomy for asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis. Executive Committee for the Asymptomatic Carotid Atherosclerosis Study
1,340 Citations1995Michael Walker, John R. Marler +18 more
Patients with asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis of 60% or greater reduction in diameter and whose general health makes them good candidates for elective surgery will have a reduced 5-year risk of ipsilateral stroke if carOTid endarterectomy performed with less than 3% perioperative morbidity and mortality is added to aggressive management of modifiable risk factors.
The LancetRandomised comparison of morbidity after D1 and D2 dissection for gastric cancer in 996 Dutch patients
1,033 Citations1995Johannes J. Bonenkamp, Ilfet Songun +14 more
Morbidity and mortality differences persisted in almost all subgroup analyses, and D2 dissection should not be used as standard treatment for western patients.
JAMAEffect of Out-of-Hospital Pediatric Endotracheal Intubation on Survival and Neurological Outcome
845 Citations2000Marianne Gausche, Roger Lewis +9 more
The addition of out-of-hospital ETI to a paramedic scope of practice that already includes BVM did not improve survival or neurological outcome of pediatric patients treated in an urban EMS system.
Obesity FactsThe Ethics of Childhood Obesity Treatment - from the Childhood Obesity Task Force (COTF) of European Association for the Study of Obesity (EASO)
593 Citations2014Jens‐Christian Holm, Paulina Nowicka +5 more
This paper aims to demonstrate the efforts towards in-situ applicability of EMMARM, as to provide real-time information about the physical and emotional impacts of EMTs on the immune system.
American Journal of OphthalmologyA comparison of observational studies and randomized, controlled trials
459 Citations2000Kjell Benson, Arthur J. Hartz
Little evidence is found that estimates of treatment effects in observational studies reported after 1984 are either consistently larger than or qualitatively different from those obtained in randomized, controlled trials.
The LancetRandomised controlled trial of laparoscopic versus mini cholecystectomy
438 Citations1992Alan Barkun, J.S. Sampalls +9 more
Although there was significant postoperative improvement in all of three quality of life scores in both groups, LC patients improved more quickly than did MC patients, showing the superior effectiveness of LC over MC in treating cholelithiasis.
The LancetInpatient general medicine is evidence based
437 Citations1995D L Sackett, John E. Ellis +2 more
This study suggests that earlier pessimism over the extent to which evidence-based medicine is already practised is misplaced.
The LancetLaparoscopic versus minilaparotomy cholecystectomy: a randomised trial
401 Citations1994A J McMahon, J N Baxter +8 more
Compared to minilaparotomy cholecystectomy, laparoscopic choleCystectomy results in shorter hospital stay, less postoperative dysfunction, and quicker return to normal activities, but is more costly.
Health Technology AssessmentStatistical assessment of the learning curves of health technologies
348 Citations2001Craig Ramsay, Adrian Grant +4 more
Systematically to identify 'novel' statistical techniques applied to learning curve data in other fields, such as psychology and manufacturing and to test these statistical techniques in data sets from studies to assess health technologies in which learning curve effects are known to exist.
The LancetMonitoring the results of cardiac surgery by variable life-adjusted display
286 Citations1997Jocelyn Lovegrove, Oswaldo Valencia +3 more
SurgeryShould we be performing more randomized controlled trials evaluating surgical operations?
284 Citations1995Michael J. Solomon, Robin S. McLeod
Questions evaluating therapy for malignant disease, comparing surgical with nonsurgical therapies, and where survival was the primary outcome were more likely to have problems precluding RCT.
The European Journal of SurgeryTotal Mesorectal Excision (TME) with or without Preoperative Radiotherapy in the Treatment of Primary Rectal Cancer: Prospective Randomised Trial with Standard Operative and Histopathological Techniques
278 Citations1999Ellen Kapiteijn
The accrual of the trial is going well and it is feasible; short term preoperative radiotherapy is safe even in combination with TME, and the feasibility analysis shows that cooperation between and within the participating disciplines goes well.
The LancetBristol, Shipman, and clinical governance: Shewhart's forgotten lessons
236 Citations2001Mohammed A. Mohammed, Kar Keung Cheng +2 more
Using six case studies, including the excess deaths after paediatric cardiac surgery seen in Bristol, UK, and the activities of general practitioner turned murderer Harold Shipman, a central role is shown for Shewhart's approach in turning the rhetoric of clinical governance into a reality.
The LancetComparison of fluorouracil with additional levamisole, higher-dose folinic acid, or both, as adjuvant chemotherapy for colorectal cancer: a randomised trial
230 Citations2000Gray, R. G., Kerr, D. J +3 more
The inclusion of levamisole in chemotherapy regimens for colorectal cancer does not delay recurrence or improve survival, and higher-dose folinic acid produced no extra benefit in these regimens over that from low-dosefolinic acid.
Diseases of the Colon & RectumRandomized, controlled trials in surgery
203 Citations2001Melina Gattellari, Jeanette Ward +1 more
Positive attitudes among Australian surgeons toward randomized, controlled trials are revealed, although concerns about the feasibility of randomized,controlled trials have been reinforced.
World Journal of SurgeryPostoperative wound infections and surgical face masks: A controlled study
197 Citations1991Th. Göran Tunevall
The results indicate that the use of face masks might be reconsidered, as they have not been proven to protect the patient operated by a healthy operating team.
British journal of surgerySurgical practice is evidence based
188 Citations1997N. Howes, Leena Chagla +2 more
The proportion of surgical treatments supported by satisfactory scientific evidence has not been evaluated previously and the reluctance of surgeons to perform randomized controlled trials has been criticized.
UrologyGoserelin versus orchiectomy in the treatment of advanced prostate cancer: Final results of a randomized trial
173 Citations1995Nicholas J. Vogelzang, Gerald W. Chodak +6 more
Goserelin is well tolerated and as effective as orchiectomy in patients with Stage D2 prostate cancer in a randomized, open, multicenter study conducted in 283 patients.
BMJCumulative risk adjusted mortality chart for detecting changes in death rate: observational study of heart surgery
172 Citations1998Jan Poloniecki, Oswaldo Valencia +1 more
Hospital league tables for mortality from heart surgery will be of limited value because year to year differences in death rate can be large even when the underlying risk or case mix does not change.
PubMedPitfalls in randomized surgical trials.
158 Citations1980W. van der Linden
Reporting on trials should contain information about pretrial routine and level of training of participants, and the design may imply systematic bias in favor of operations that are in wide use and bias in favour of technically simple procedures.
Medical Clinics of North AmericaRandomization of the First Patient
147 Citations1975Thomas C. Chalmers
Journal of Clinical OncologyMorbidity and mortality after D2 gastrectomy for gastric cancer: results of the Italian Gastric Cancer Study Group prospective multicenter surgical study.
141 Citations1998Maurizio Degiuli, Mitsuru Sasako +4 more
Given that postoperative morbidity and mortality rates are favorably comparable with those reported after the Western standard gastrectomy, the more extensive Japanese procedure with pancreas preservation can be regarded as a safe radical treatment of gastric cancer for selected Western patients treated in experienced centers.
Surgical EndoscopyThe E.A.E.S. Consensus development conferences on laparoscopic cholecystectomy, appendectomy, and hernia repair
135 Citations1995Edmund Neugebauer, H. Troidl +4 more
Assessment of the current status of the endoscopic surgical approaches for the treatment of cholelithiasis, appendicitis, and inguinal hernia concluded that Laparoscopic cholecystectomy is the procedure of choice for symptomatic choleLithiasis.
British journal of surgeryCusum as an aid to early assessment of the surgical trainee
128 Citations1995André M. van Rij, James R. McDonald +4 more
Evaluation of surgical performance using the cusum may prove to be a more objective tool for assessing surgical trainees than early impressions or less clinically oriented tests.
British journal of surgeryD2 gastrectomy: Lessons from a prospective audit of the learning curve
119 Citations1996Dhruv Parikh, Matthew G. Johnson +3 more
The results suggest a learning curve lasting about 18–24 months or 15 to 25 procedures before a plateau is reached and D2 gastrectomy should be restricted to specialist centres where adequate training and supervision can be provided during the learning curve.
World Journal of SurgerySentinel Node Biopsy in Breast Cancer: ALMANAC Trial
96 Citations2001Dayalan Clarke, Nader Khonji +1 more
The Medical Research Council of the United Kingdom has funded the audit phase of a multicenter, two phase, randomized trial called the Axillary Lymphatic Mapping Against Nodal Axillary Clearance (ALMANAC) trial, which will compare standard axillary management with sentinel node-guided axillary Management.
PubMedSanctuary therapy: a randomized trial of 724 children with previously untreated acute lymphoblastic leukemia: A Report from Children's Cancer Study Group.
83 Citations1982M E Nesbit, H N Sather +5 more
There appears to be a benefit with regard to length of bone marrow remission and survival for patients with initial white blood counts greater than or equal to 20,000/cu mm treated with cranial RT plus i.t. MTX.
Journal of Clinical OncologyAlternative medicine: an attractive nuisance.
59 Citations1998John Durant
British journal of surgerySurgical evaluation at the crossroads
49 Citations1993A V Pollock
It is suggested that a complete, accurate and objective comparison of the outcome of a novel intervention with that of a traditional intervention in previous years, or in another surgical group, can yield valuable information and can lead surgeons to improve their practice.
Melanoma ResearchSentinel node localization in primary melanoma
19 Citations1999Alessandro Testori, Mirco Bartolomei +9 more
SN biopsy should be performed by surgeons and nuclear medicine doctors in co-operation, both methods being adopted simultaneously to reduce the percentage of procedure failures.