'Bin bag' study: a survey of the research requests received by general practitioners and the primary health care team.

PubMedPublished 1 November 1999

Miranda A. Moore, K Post, Helen Smith

Citations12

TL;DR

Although general practice teams feel swamped by research requests, this sensation may be exaggerated by invitations to participate in non-scientific surveys as well as true research projects.

Abstract

General practitioners receive a large and increasing number of unsolicited requests to participate in research. This study describes the volume and nature of research requests received by 18 primary care teams in a three-month period. On average, each practice receives 16 to 24 research requests each year. The most frequent request is to complete a questionnaire (32%). Only one-fifth of studies originate from academic or service general practice. Remuneration for participating in a study was only offered for 15% of studies. Although general practice teams feel swamped by research requests, this sensation may be exaggerated by invitations to participate in non-scientific surveys as well as true research projects. Practice teams would welcome help in distinguishing quality research proposals from the remainder.

Keywords

MedicineHealth Professions

BMJGeneral practice postal surveys: a questionnaire too far?

273 Citations1996Brian McAvoy, Eileen Kaner

Approaches that might reverse this trend include monitoring all research activities going on in an area to ensure that practices are not overused, giving general practitioners incentives to participate, and improving the relevance of research and the quality of questionnaires.

View PDF

PubMed'So much post, so busy with practice--so, no time!': a telephone survey of general practitioners' reasons for not participating in postal questionnaire surveys.

186 Citations1998Eileen Kaner, Catherine Haighton +1 more

GPs were most likely to respond to postal surveys that had a high interest factor, that involved localized research relevant to general practice, and that incorporated a personalized approach by researchers, including good-quality explanatory information.

BMJFuture provision of out of hours primary medical care: a survey with two general practitioner research networks

47 Citations1996Val Lattimer, Helen Smith +3 more

General practitioners were keen to try alternative arrangements for out of hours care delivery, despite the lack of formal trials, and over 80% of general practitioners in two research networks were willing to try a new out ofhours service for their practice.

View PDF

PubMedThe content and methodology of research papers published in three United Kingdom primary care journals.

42 Citations1998T. TURNER THOMAS, Tom Fahey +1 more

The content and design of published general practice research in the UK is varied and broad, and in contrast to surgical journals, nearly one-fifth of studies in general practice followed a longitudinal design.

View PDF

BMJSurveys demand too much time

7 Citations1996Mark Cottrill

One of the general practitioners who do not respond to postal surveys as defined by Brian R McAvoy and Eileen F S Kaner is identified.

BMJPostal surveys in general practice

4 Citations1996Nick Summerton

'Senn's concerns arise from what he calls the principle of "label invariance," which means that many analyses of data from clinical trials are unaffected by which group is called the treated group and which the control group.