A critical survey on the status of multiple criteria decision making theory and practice
OmegaPublished 1 September 1992
TJ Stewart
Citations622
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.31
SNIP2.20
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
Abstract
This paper seeks to review and to contrast the main streams of thought in Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) theory and practice, without attempting to review all MCDM methods in detail. The main purpose is to identify pitfalls in the usage of various approaches, and to suggest approaches which are most robustly and effectively useable, especially by the non-expert in MCDM methodology. Problem areas in MCDM still requiring further research are also discussed.
Keywords
Computer ScienceDecision SciencesEngineering
European Journal of Operational ResearchHow to make a decision: The analytic hierarchy process
9,361 Citations1990Thomas L. Saaty
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyDecisions with Multiple Objectives: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs.
8,440 Citations1994Ralph L. Keeney, Howard Raiffa +1 more
Management ScienceDecision-Making in a Fuzzy Environment
6,763 Citations1970Richard Bellman, L. A. Zadeh
Fuzzy Sets and SystemsFuzzy programming and linear programming with several objective functions
3,591 Citations1978H.‐J. Zimmermann
It is shown that solutions obtained by fuzzy linear programming are always efficient solutions and the consequences of using different ways of combining individual objective functions in order to determine an “optimal” compromise solution are shown.
Multiple Criteria Optimization: Theory, Computation, and Application
3,446 Citations1989Richard Laundy
Medical Entomology and ZoologyDecision analysis and behavioral research
3,065 Citations1986Detlof von Winterfeldt, Ward Edwards
Management ScienceManagement Models and Industrial Applications of Linear Programming
1,899 Citations1957A. Charnes, W. W. Cooper
Theory and DecisionThe outranking approach and the foundations of electre methods
1,776 Citations1991Bernard Roy
IGI Global eBooksThe Analytic Hierarchy Process
1,334 Citations2011John Wang, Chandana Chakraborty +1 more
European Journal of Operational ResearchAn overview of the analytic hierarchy process and its applications
1,027 Citations1990Luís G. Vargas
The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a theory of measurement for dealing with quantifiable intangible criteria that has found rich applications in decision theory, conflict resolution and in models of the brain.
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyThe Future of Operational Research is Past
1,001 Citations1979Russell L. Ackoff
Fuzzy Sets and SystemsLatent connectives in human decision making
942 Citations1980H.‐J. Zimmermann, P. Zysno
The results of the experiments support the hypothesis that people often use compensatory procedures and suggest a new class of operators which varies with respect to a parameter of compensation.
Mathematical ProgrammingLinear programming with multiple objective functions: Step method (stem)
921 Citations1971R. Benayoun, Jean de Montgolfier +2 more
In this man-model symbiosis, phases of computation alternate with phases of decision, which allows the decision-maker to “learn” to recognize good solutions and the relative importance of the objectives.
OmegaOn a short-coming of Saaty's method of analytic hierarchies
908 Citations1983Valerie Belton, Tony Gear
Management ScienceAn Interactive Approach for Multi-Criterion Optimization, with an Application to the Operation of an Academic Department
879 Citations1972Arthur M. Geoffrion, James S. Dyer +1 more
An interactive mathematical programming approach to multi-criterion optimization is developed, and then illustrated by an application to the aggregated operating problem of an academic department.
Lecture notes in economics and mathematical systemsThe Use of Reference Objectives in Multiobjective Optimization
866 Citations1980Andrzej P. Wierzbicki
Any point in the objective space can be used instead of weighting coefficients to derive scalarizing functions which have minima at Pareto points only, and entire basic theory of multiobjective optimization can be developed with the help of reference objectives.
Management ScienceAn Exposition of the AHP in Reply to the Paper “Remarks on the Analytic Hierarchy Process”
841 Citations1990Thomas L. Saaty
Management ScienceAn Interactive Programming Method for Solving the Multiple Criteria Problem
761 Citations1976Stanley Zionts, Jyrki Wallenius
A man-machine interactive mathematical programming method for solving the multiple criteria problem involving a single decision maker is presented, it is assumed that all decision-relevant criteria or objective functions are concave functions to be maximized, and that the constraint set is convex.
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyMulti-Objective Decision Analysis with Engineering and Business Applications
697 Citations1983Simon French
This paper presents a meta-modelling architecture suitable for multiobjective analysis of the decision-Making process and some of the strategies used in this process have been developed.
Readings in Multiple Criteria Decision Aid
587 Citations1990Carlos A. Bana e Costa
This chapter discusses decision-Aid and Decision-Making in Ill-Structured Environments and Measurement Theory And Decision Aid, and the Outranking Approach and the Foundations of Electre Methods.
Management ScienceAn Interactive Multiple Objective Linear Programming Method for a Class of Underlying Nonlinear Utility Functions
394 Citations1983Stanley Zionts, Jyrki Wallenius
This paper develops a method for interactive multiple objective linear programming assuming an unknown pseudo concave utility function satisfying certain general properties and presents the supporting theory and algorithm.
European Journal of Operational ResearchA comparison of the analytic hierarchy process and a simple multi-attribute value function
349 Citations1986Valerie Belton
European Journal of Operational ResearchGeometrical representations for MCDA
299 Citations1988Bertrand Mareschal, Jean‐Pierre Brans
This new approach provides assistance to understand the conflictual aspects of the criteria and to tackle the problem of the weights associated to them to create geometrical representations for multicriteria decision problems.
Building Criteria: A Prerequisite for MCDA
248 Citations1990Denis Bouyssou
The aim of this paper is to emphasize the importance of this phase of decision-aid by a number of frequently encountered difficulties and some techniques to overcome them.
Management ScienceSolving the Discrete Multiple Criteria Problem using Convex Cones
234 Citations1984Pekka Korhonen, Jyrki Wallenius +1 more
Computers & Operations ResearchMathematical programming with multiple objectives: A tutorial
234 Citations1980C. L. Hwang, S.R. Paidy +2 more
Consideration in selecting criteria for comparative evaluation of the methods and availability of computer codes for some methods are discussed.
Decision SciencesAmbiguous Criteria Weights in AHP: Consequences and Solutions*
188 Citations1989Bertram Schoner, William C. Wedley
Management ScienceThe Effects of Splitting Attributes on Weights in Multiattribute Utility Measurement
170 Citations1988Martin Weber, Franz Eisenführ +1 more
OR SpectrumRecent developments in modelling preferences under risk
168 Citations1987Martin Weber, Colin F. Camerer
European Journal of Operational ResearchUsing fuzzy sets in operational research
164 Citations1983H.-J. Zimmerman
Fuzzy Set Theory as proposed by L. Zadeh in 1965 promises to bridge part of the gap in modelling of problems which are not well-structured and which can not easily be cast into classical mathematical models.
Computers & Operations ResearchAn aspiration-level interactive model for multiple criteria decision making
160 Citations1992Vahid Lotfi, Theodor J. Stewart +1 more
A simple, eclectic approach for solving discrete alternative multiple criteria decision problems is presented, based on the concept of the level of aspiration, and draws on ideas of various researchers.
Computers & Operations ResearchGeneralized goal programming An overview
155 Citations1983James P. Ignizio
This paper introduces the approach to generalized goal programming, describes its underlying philosophy, and indicates the specific subclass of models and methods which serve to comprise the overall approach.
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyInteractive Sequential Goal Programming
147 Citations1981Abu S. M. Masud, C. L. Hwang
The method, called Interactive Sequential Goal Programming (ISGP), combines and extends the attractive features of both Goal Programming and interactive solution approaches for MODM problems and is applicable to both linear and non-linear problems.
Lecture notes in economics and mathematical systemsMultiple Criteria Decision Making Theory and Application
135 Citations1980Günter Fandel, Tomáš Gál
The Promethee Methods for MCDM; The Promcalc, Gaia And Bankadviser Software
102 Citations1990Jean Pierre Brans, Bertrand Mareschal
The PROMETHEE Methods are particularly appropriate to treat multicriteria problems of the following type: for which A is a finite set of possible alternatives and fj(x), j = 1, 2,…,k a set of k evaluation criteria.
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyA Multi-criteria Decision Support System for R&D Project Selection
101 Citations1991Theodor J. Stewart
This paper describes the development of a decision support system for the selection of a portfolio of R&D projects, which was carried out for a large electricity utility corporation, and the application of a reference point approach for the underlying multi-criteria decision problem.
European Journal of Operational ResearchA survey of generalized goal programming (1970–1982)
100 Citations1986Carlos Romero
A survey of the literature on Goal Programming from 1970 through 1982 is provided, categorized according to 18 areas of application and according to 12 different variants of GP.
Interactive multiple goal programming : applications to financial planning
92 Citations1981Jaap Spronk
The IMGP Model is used as a guide for Capital Budgeting and Financial Planning with Multiple Goals and the Firm's Market Value as One of the Elements in a Dynamic Goal Complex.
Computers & Operations ResearchAn assessment of some criticisms of goal programming
81 Citations1985Edward L. Hannan
Some of the characteristics of goal programming that have engendered this controversy are examined and an effort is made to identify the conditions under which the use of GP is most theoretically defensible.
OmegaA categorized bibliographic survey of goal programming
78 Citations1985Stelios H. Zanakis, Sushil Gupta
A total of 240 goal programming articles that have so far appeared in over 60 English journal publications are compiled and classified according to technique and application areas, providing interesting insights regarding goal programming article characteristics, literature trends and future needs.
European Journal of Operational ResearchJudgemental modelling based on geometric least square
77 Citations1988G. Islei, A. G. Lockett
RAIRO - Operations ResearchThe french and the american school in multi-criteria decision analysis
57 Citations1990Freerk A. Lootsma
Use of a Simple Multi-Attribute Value Function Incorporating Visual Interactive Sensitivity Analysis for Multiple Criteria Decision Making
54 Citations1990Valerie Belton, Stephen Vickers
V·I·S·A is a computer program for multiple criteria decision aid, based on a simple weighted multi-attribute value function, incorporating a hierarchical structure of criteria and visual interactive sensitivity analysis, best suited to the problem of choosing a preferred alternative from a set of well defined alternatives.
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyPlanning with Multiple Criteria
52 Citations1993Penelope M. Mullen
Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical SciencesPolicy selection by structural mapping
33 Citations1977B. H. P. Rivett
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyA Descriptive Approach to Multiple-Criteria Decision Making
31 Citations1981Theodor J. Stewart
The aim of this approach is to identify basic relationships and conflicts between the available decision alternatives and between criteria so that the responsible decision maker can make an intelligent selection of a course of action, without the need for formal utility analysis, computation of Pareto optimal sets, etc.
Computers & Operations ResearchInteractive fuzzy programming with preference criteria in multiobjective decision-making
31 Citations1991Cesar G. Tapia, B. A. Murtagh
A fuzzy cardinal priority ranking of the generated nondominated solutions can be determined to provide a useful decision-making aid.
European Journal of Operational ResearchPriam, an interactive program for chosing among multiple attribute alternatives
30 Citations1986P. Lévine, Jean‐Charles Pomerol
The program Priam presented hereafter is an interactive program for chosing a best issue from a multiple attribute alternative set using the artificial intelligence methods and relies on a heuristic exploration of the alternative set.
Naval Research Logistics (NRL)Experience with prototype multicriteria decision support systems for pelagic fish quota determination
27 Citations1988Theodor J. Stewart
An attempt to use certain multiple-criteria decision-making aids to support the formulation of catch quota policies in pelagic fisheries management and the evidence is that IMGP is particularly useful in this context, and that it does facilitate the reaching of consensus between different interest groups.
Journal of the Operational Research SocietyA Structural Mapping Approach to Complex Decision-Making
25 Citations1978David D. Clarke, B. H. P. Rivett
The method suggested here uses multidimensional scaling techniques, as applied to the problem of constructing geographical maps from fragmentary information, to draw maps of policies involving many attributes in such a way as to throw most preferred and least preferred policies to opposite poles.
European Journal of Operational ResearchPruning of decision alternatives in multiple criteria decision making, based on the Uta method for estimating utilities
25 Citations1987Theodor J. Stewart
European Journal of Operational ResearchInteractive multiple goal programming: Applications to financial planning
22 Citations1982Brigitte Nagels
IEEE Transactions on Systems Man and CyberneticsAn interactive multiple objective linear programming method based on piecewise-linear additive value functions
18 Citations1987Theodor J. Stewart
It is shown how the idea of approximating a utility function by a piecewise-linear additive form and a separable programming approach can be brought together in an interactive method for multiple-objective linear programming that is able to approximate the true preferred solution when the utility function is concave.
Computers & Operations ResearchAn interactive outranking system for multiattribute decision making
14 Citations1988Rudolf Vetschera
An interactive extension to the ELECTRE multi-attribute decision technique is presented, which is motivated by difficulties in specifying the threshold levels required by this method, and an interactive algorithm in which alternatives are successively eliminated by threshold modifications is introduced.
