Referring to Landmark or Street Information in Route Directions: What Difference Does It Make?

The first experiment showed that in a wayfinding task, route directions referring to streets were less effective than those referring to landmarks for guidance purposes, and the second showed that when people generate route directions, they tend to produce less street than landmark information.

Abstract

When describing routes in urban environments, speakers usually refer to both street names and visual landmarks. However, a navigational system can be designed which only refers to streets or, alternatively, only to landmarks. Does it make any difference which type of information users are provided with? The answer to this question is crucial for the design of navigational aids. We report two experiments. The first one showed that in a wayfinding task, route directions referring to streets were less effective than those referring to landmarks for guidance purposes. The second experiment showed that when people generate route directions, they tend to produce less street than landmark information. These studies provide a further illustration of the critical role of landmarks in route directions.