Conceptual, Methodological, and Theoretical Problems in Studying Social Support as a Buffer Against Life Stress
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorPublished 1 June 1982
Peggy A. Thoits
Citations1,498
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score2.52
SNIP2.29
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
Empirical work on the buffering hypothesis is reviewed, alternate conceptualizations and operationalizations of support are outlined, a refined hypothesis and model for analysis are presented, and three theoretical approaches that may be used to explain the interrelationships between support, events, and disturbance are suggested.
Abstract
The buffering hypothesis suggests that social support can moderate the impacts of life events upon mental health. However, several problems have yet to be resolved in this literature. Social support has been inadequately conceptualized and operationalized; therefore, the specific dimensions of support that reduce event impacts cannot be identified. The direct effect of events upon support and the interactive (buffering) effect of events with support have been confounded in many studies, such that results may have been biased in favor of the hypothesis. The relationships between events, support, and psychological disturbance have not been clarified theoretically; thus, the possibility that support itself is an etiologicalfactor has been overlooked. This article reviews empirical work on the buffering hypothesis, outlines alternate conceptualizations and operationalizations of support, presents a refined hypothesis and model for analysis, and suggests three theoretical approaches that may be used to explain the interrelationships between support, events, and disturbance.
Keywords
PsychologySocial SciencesHealth Professions
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchThe social readjustment rating scale
11,022 Citations1967Thomas H. Holmes, Richard H. Rahe
This report defines a method which achieves etiologic significance as a necessary but not sufficient cause of illness and accounts in part for the time of onset of disease and provides a quantitative basis for new epidemiological studies of diseases.
Psychosomatic MedicineSocial Support as a Moderator of Life Stress
6,764 Citations1976Sidney Cobb
It appears that social support can protect people in crisis from a wide variety of pathological states: from low birth weight to death, from arthritis through tuberculosis to depression, alcoholism, and the social breakdown syndrome.
American Journal of EpidemiologySOCIAL NETWORKS, HOST RESISTANCE, AND MORTALITY: A NINE-YEAR FOLLOW-UP STUDY OF ALAMEDA COUNTY RESIDENTS
5,347 Citations1979Lisa Berkman, S. Leonard Syme
The findings show that people who lacked social and community ties were more likely to die in the follow-up period than those with more extensive contacts.
Human Nature and the Social Order
4,846 Citations2017Charles Horton Cooley
American Journal of EpidemiologyTHE CONTRIBUTION OF THE SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT TO HOST RESISTANCE: THE FOURTH WADE HAMPTON FROST LECTURE1
1,954 Citations1995John C. Cassel
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorExemplification of a Method for Scaling Life Events: The PERI Life Events Scale
1,216 Citations1978Barbara Snell Dohrenwend, Alexander R. Askenasy +2 more
This paper challenges several arguments for rejecting the rationale of Holmes' and Rahe's Social Readjustment Rating Scale and proposes procedural improvements for three aspects of life-event scale construction: construction of a life- event list, selection of judges, and tests of whether judges agree on their ratings.
ICPSR Data HoldingsAmericans View Their Mental Health, 1957
1,113 Citations1984Gerald Gurin, Joseph Veroff +1 more
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorSocial Support, Occupational Stress, and Health
1,044 Citations1980James M. LaRocco, James S. House +1 more
The buffering hypothesis for mental and physical health variables (anxiety, depression, irritation, and somatic symptoms), but, as in the previous three studies, fail to support thebuffering hypothesis in regard to job-related strains.
Medical CareSocial Support and Health
841 Citations1977Berton H. Kaplan, John C. Cassel +1 more
There is little strong empirical evidence to confirm the role social support may play in health and illness, and attempts at conceptualization and measurement have been inadequate, discipline-bound (or study-bound), and usually formulated for post-hoc interpretation of unexpected, but striking findings.
American Journal of Public HealthSupport Systems and Community Mental Health
838 Citations1975Marvin E. Perkins
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseTHE STRESS-BUFFERING ROLE OF SOCIAL SUPPORT
818 Citations1977Alfred Dean, Nan Lin
This paper offers a selective review of the essential status of empirical knowledge, an examination of the nature and significance of social support systems, and detailed proposals for approaching problems of measurement and research design.
American Journal of EpidemiologyPSYCHOSOCIAL ASSETS, LIFE CRISIS AND THE PROGNOSIS OF PREGNANCY12
810 Citations1972Katherine B. Nuckolls, John C. Cassel +1 more
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorThe Effect of Social Support in Moderating the Health Consequences of Unemployment
769 Citations1978Susan Gore
It is argued that these study findings demonstrate the exacerbation of life stress by a low sense of social support, and health differences between supported and unsupported populations under stress are commonly interpreted as evidence that support buffers the effects ofLife stress.
SociologySocial Class and Psychiatric Disturbance among Women in an Urban Population
767 Citations1975George W. Brown, Máire Ní Bhrolcháin +1 more
American Sociological ReviewInteraction and Adaptation: Intimacy as a Critical Variable
696 Citations1968Marjorie Fiske Lowenthal, Clayton Haven
The introduction of a variable bearing on the quality of social relationships, in this case the presence or absence of a confidant, helps considerably to explicate both sets of findings.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorSocial Support as a Contingency in Psychological Well-Being
622 Citations1981R. Jay Turner
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseLIFE EVENT STRESS, SOCIAL SUPPORT, COPING STYLE, AND RISK OF PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPAIRMENT
463 Citations1978Gavin Andrews, Christopher Tennant +2 more
There was no evidence that coping style or social support became associated by moderating the relationship between life event stress and impairment, but rather because of their independent relationship with psychological impairment.
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyDesirable versus undesirable life events: Their relationship to stress and mental distress.
442 Citations1975Amiram D. Vinokur, Melvin L. Selzer
Social Science & Medicine (1967)Social support networks and the crisis of bereavement
326 Citations1977Kenneth N. Walker, Arlene MacBride +1 more
The role of support networks during the bereavement crisis is examined specifically and a brief description of the Community Resources Service's project “A Preventive Intervention for the Newly Bereaved” illustrates how understanding of network supports can aid the mental health professional in crisis intervention.
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric EpidemiologyFriends, confidants and symptoms
310 Citations1976P. Miller, J. G. Ingham
The results supported those of Brown et al. in showing that women reporting the lack of an intimate confidant had psychological symptoms of significantly greater severity than those reported by their more adequately supported counterparts.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorLife Events, Social Supports, and Psychiatric Symptoms: A Re-Analysis of the New Haven Data
297 Citations1978William W. Eaton
The data provide some serendipitous evidence that life events are more likely to cause mental disorder if the individual has not experienced similar stresses before and there is also evidence that members of the household provide support in times of crisis that help prevent mental disorder.
Social ForcesMarital Status and Depression: The Importance of Coping Resources
291 Citations1982Ronald C. Kessler, Marilyn J. Essex
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Social Network, Support and Neurosis
291 Citations1977Scott Henderson
The objective must now be to determine whether depleted primary group interaction is causally related to morbidity, or whether it is only an associated or a secondary factor in aetiology, or indeed wholly unrelated.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorSocial Class and Mental Illness Reconsidered: The Role of Economic Stress and Social Support
270 Citations1978Ramsay Liem, Joan H. Liem
It is argued that stress and support factors are systematically organized within classes at several levels of analysis and constitute critical conditions of class membership related to psychological functioning.
Journal of Community PsychologyLife stress, social support, and psychological vulnerability: Epidemiological considerations
262 Citations1982Peggy A. Thoits
Using data from the New Haven Community Survey, the existence of differential psychological vulnerability is reconfirmed and the applied buffering hypothesis is tested, finding that the psychological vulnerability of low status groups cannot be explained by the interaction of many events and few available sources of social support.
The British Journal of PsychiatryCrises and Life Changes preceding the Onset or Relapse of Acute Schizophrenia: Clinical Aspects
259 Citations1970J. L. T. Birley, George W. Brown
In a previous publication (Brown and Birley, 1968), some findings which suggest that life changes and crises frequently precipitate the acute onset, relapse or exacerbation of schizophrenic states are presented.
The British Journal of PsychiatrySocial Bonds in the Epidemiology of Neurosis: A Preliminary Communication
224 Citations1978Scott Henderson, D. G. Byrne +4 more
In a random sample of the general population a strong inverse relationship was found between social bonds and the presence of neurotic symptoms, and this association was strongest in the case of close affectional ties.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorLife Events, Social Integration and Psychiatric Symptomatology
220 Citations1975Jerome K. Myers, Jacob Jay Lindenthal +1 more
Data are presented on relationship between life events, social integration, and psychiatric symptoms in a community and those who display significant symptoms but reportfew life events are less well integrated than those who reportfew symptoms but many events.
Social Science & Medicine Part A Medical SociologySocial networks: A promising direction for research on the relationship of the social environment to psychiatric disorder
220 Citations1980Daniel P. Mueller
There is a need for systematic investigations of the relationship of social network characteristics to specific psychiatric disorders, particularly depression, and findings indicate that social networks may be particularly important in onset and course of depression.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorLife Events and Mental Status: A Longitudinal Study
207 Citations1972Jerome K. Myers, Jacob Jay Lindenthal +2 more
Over a two-year period it was found that the greater the net change in life events the more likely was the individual's mental status to have changed.
The Journal of Nervous and Mental DiseaseLIFE EVENTS AND PSYCHIATRIC IMPAIRMENT
197 Citations1971Jerome K. Myers, Jacob Jay Lindenthal +1 more
Certain cultural and social factors, particularly role expectations and values, are discussed as possible factors helping to account for the relationships found between life crises and psychiatric impairment.
The British Journal of PsychiatryThe Patient's Primary Group
196 Citations1978Scott Henderson, Paul Duncan‐Jones +2 more
Patients were found to spend the same amount of time as normals with their primary group, but proportionately more of that time was affectively unpleasant and the majority of patients considered that their principal attachment figures gave them insufficient support.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorStressful Life Events and Psychiatric Symptomatology: Change or Undesirability?
195 Citations1977Daniel P. Mueller, Daniel W. Edwards +1 more
Schizophrenia BulletinSocial Support, Social Networks, and Schizophrenia
177 Citations1981M. Hammer
If social connections are studied structurally as they change and develop over time, the impact of the specifically social processes can be better separated from that of the personal characteristics of the focal individual than seems possible with other approaches.
The British Journal of PsychiatryVulnerability Factors and Depression in Men
159 Citations1981Alec Roy
In a matched controlled study of 71 depressed men, parental loss before 17 years, poor marriage, and unemployment were found to be vulnerability factors associated with depression in men.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchMagnitude estimations of social readjustments
152 Citations1967Minoru Masuda, Thomas H. Holmes
In sixteen comparisons of mean item scorings of groups different in age, sex, marital status, education, social class, generation American, religion, and race, the range of correlation coefficients was O-820 to 0.975, the average r being O-945, and Spearman's rank order correlation coefficients were almost identical.
Schizophrenia BulletinMethodological Issues in Developing a Scale to Measure Social Support
139 Citations1981Allan H. McFarlane, K. A. Neale +3 more
Evaluation of the properties of a Social Relationship Scale (SRS) that was developed as part of a prospective study of the psychosocial influences on the health status of a population is described.
Journal of Psychosomatic ResearchLife change, coping ability and chronic intrinsic asthma
134 Citations1973Gilberto de Araujo, Paul P. Van Arsdel +2 more
It was found that patients with high Berle scores invariably required small doses of steroids regardless of their LCU, and patients with low BI and LCU required significantly higher doses of steroid than those with high BI and low LCU.
Social Science & Medicine (1967)Psychiatric disorder in London and North Uist
84 Citations1977G.W. Browns, S. Davidson +4 more
There are differences in the form of the disorder according to the extent to which women are integrated into the culture of the island, and those most integrated have a higher rate of anxiety and lower rate of depression and the least integrated the reverse pattern.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorProblems in the Ratio Measurement of Life Stress
65 Citations1976Richard L. Hough, Dianne Timbers Fairbank +1 more
There are problems with the work of Rahe and his associates, in particular, the relative lack of concern with careful instrument construction and administration, the glossing over of the problem of cultural variance, and the use of analytic procedures that do not fully exploit the potential of their measurement technique.
American Journal of Public Health and the Nations HealthSocial aspects of coronary heart disease in two adjacent, ethnically different communities.
58 Citations1966John G. Bruhn, Brianna Chandler +3 more
It is found that myocardial infarction and ischemia rare among the South African Bantu and the mortality rate from coronary heart disease in seven small rural towns in Norway was about half that in Oslo.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorSelf-Disclosure, Significant Others and Psychological Well-Being in Old Age
51 Citations1973Sharon Moriwaki
Social patterns of illness and medical care in cross-cultural communities of coastal Peru and Chile and Latin American Studies Program Dissertation Series.
Occupational Stress and Health
28 Citations1979James S. House, Mark F. Jackman
There has been a growing concern with health problems in the United States, not the least of which is the burgeoning national expenditure on medical care, which results in vast amounts of money and energy being directed toward increasingly complex institutions to care for the sick.