The mundane realities of the everyday lay use of the internet for health, and their consequences for media convergence
Sociology of Health & IllnessPublished 1 November 2005Open access
Sarah Nettleton, Roger Burrows, Lisa O’Malley
Citations263
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.19
SNIP1.48
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is suggested that there is an emerging concordance between the lay use of the internet for health and illness and dominant (generally) biomedical conceptions of what constitutes "good quality" health information.
Abstract
The internet is now a major source of health information for lay people. Within the medical, sociological and popular literatures there have been three main responses to this development. We classify these as "celebratory", "concerned" and "contingent". This paper falls into the third category and, drawing on techniques of discourse analysis, examines people's accounts of their use of online health resources. It identifies six implicit rules--which we call "rhetorics of reliability"--that people readily draw upon when articulating why they trust some online sources and not others. In addition participants locate their accounts within broader discursive frameworks in order to present themselves as "sensible" users. The article concludes by suggesting that there is an emerging concordance between the lay use of the internet for health and illness and dominant (generally) biomedical conceptions of what constitutes "good quality" health information.
Keywords
Social SciencesHealth Professions
Modern Language JournalInterpreting Qualitative Data Methods for Analysing Talk, Text and Interaction
6,920 Citations1997Robert C. Kleinsasser, David J. Silverman
BMJHow do consumers search for and appraise health information on the world wide web? Qualitative study using focus groups, usability tests, and in-depth interviews
1,938 Citations2002Günther Eysenbach
Although their search technique was often suboptimal, internet users successfully found health information to answer questions in an average of 5 minutes 42 seconds (median 4 minutes 18 seconds) per question.
JAMAEmpirical Studies Assessing the Quality of Health Information for Consumers on the World Wide Web
1,874 Citations2002Günther Eysenbach, John Powell +2 more
A methodological framework on how quality on the Web is evaluated in practice is established, to determine the heterogeneity of the results and conclusions, and to compare the methodological rigor of these studies to determine to what extent the conclusions depend on the methodology used.
Emergence: The Connected Lives of Ants, Brains, Cities, and Software
1,452 Citations2001Steven B. Johnson
Drawing upon evolutionary theory, urban studies, neuroscience, and computer games, Emergence is a guidebook to one of the key components of twenty-first-century culture.
The Information SocietyShaping the Web: Why the Politics of Search Engines Matters
682 Citations2000Lucas D. Introna
It is argued that search engines raise not merely technical issues but also political ones, raising doubts whether, in particular, the market mechanism could serve as an acceptable corrective.
Social Science & MedicineConsumerism, reflexivity and the medical encounter
602 Citations1997Deborah Lupton
The article concludes that late modernist notions of reflexivity as applied to issues of consumerism fail to recognize the complexity and changeable nature of the desires, emotions and needs that characterize the patient-doctor relationship.
Sociology of Health & IllnessDoctor in the house: the Internet as a source of lay health knowledge and the challenge to expertise
520 Citations1999Michael Hardey
It is concluded that the Internet forms the site of a new struggle over expertise in health that will transform the relationship between the health professions and their clients.
BMJHow the internet affects patients' experience of cancer: a qualitative study
494 Citations2004Sue Ziébland, Alison Chapple +4 more
Cancer patients may use the internet to acquire expertise to display competence in the face of serious illness, and this expertise enabled patients to present a new type of “social fitness.”
Sociology of Health & Illness‘Ignorance is bliss sometimes’: constraints on the emergence of the ‘informed patient’ in the changing landscapes of health information
465 Citations2003Flis Henwood, Sally Wyatt +2 more
A tension caused by the emphasis on 'information for choice' in the informed patient discourse which itself obscures the potential conflict between lay and expert/medical knowledges in the clinical encounter is identified.
Critique of Information
445 Citations2002Scott Lash
Conversation analysis and discourse analysis : a comparative and critical introduction
445 Citations2005Robin Wooffitt
BMJExamination of instruments used to rate quality of health information on the internet: chronicle of a voyage with an unclear destination
380 Citations2002Anna R. Gagliardi
Many incompletely developed rating instruments continue to appear on websites providing health information, even when the organisations that gave rise to those instruments no longer exist, a systematic review of the reliability and validity of such rating instruments showed.
Sociology of Health & IllnessProstate cancer: embodied experience and perceptions of masculinity
279 Citations2002Alison Chapple, Sue Ziébland
It is concluded that the physical body as well as culture should be considered when trying to explain what it means to be masculine, and how illness may affect men's sense of masculinity.
Sociology of Health & IllnessRisk theory in epidemic times: sex, drugs and the social organisation of ‘risk behaviour’
250 Citations1997Tim Rhodes
Social Science & MedicineThe importance of being expert: the quest for cancer information on the Internet
223 Citations2004Sue Ziébland
In-depth interviews collected for DIPEx projects with men and women with cancer are used to demonstrate how the internet has been used not only to gather information and gain support from others but also to make sense of the experience of cancer.
Health Risk & SocietyShort cuts to safety: Risk and 'rules of thumb' in accounts of food choice
199 Citations2003John Green, Alizon Draper +1 more
Health PolicyPublic doubts about vaccination safety and resistance against vaccination
194 Citations2001P. Streefland
The forms and implications of public doubts about vaccines and vaccinations in industrialised and in developing countries are explained and how policy makers and programme managers could address these issues are discussed.
Social Science & MedicineWomen's health and the internet: understanding emerging trends and implications
187 Citations2003Sanjay K. Pandey, John Hart +1 more
It is concluded that women increasingly rely on the internet to supplement health information received from traditional sources and discuss the implications of the findings for policymakers and health professions.
Health Risk & SocietyHealth risk communication and amplification: learning from the MMR vaccination controversy
184 Citations2004Judith Petts, Simon Niemeyer
A study of information strategies that parents use to make sense of health risk issues, particularly MMR identifies a preference for personal and face-to-face engagement with health professionals, stressing the importance of user-centred health risk communication.
British Journal of SociologyCulture, the ‘sick role’ and the consumption of health
153 Citations2002Chris Shilling
This paper revisits Parsons's conception of the 'sick role' and examines the relevance of his writings on the cultural understanding of sickness to the consumption of health in the contemporary era, and focuses on the development of pro-active approaches towards the healthy body, and the growth of 'information rich' consumers of health care.
PubMedReadability levels of patient education material on the World Wide Web.
147 Citations1999Mark A Graber, Cathy M. Roller +1 more
Much of the medical information targeted for the general public on the Web is written at a reading level higher than is easily understood by much of the patient population.
Sociology of Health & IllnessNew directions for critical internet health studies: representing cancer experience on the web
105 Citations2005Clive Seale
Using existing methods for analysing media texts and developing new methods where appropriate, sociologists and media analysts interested in health need to develop more critical perspectives on this important new medium.
International Journal of Social WelfareMedicine on the line? Computer‐mediated social support and advice for people with diabetes
97 Citations2002Brian D. Loader, Steve Muncer +3 more
The article critically analyses the use by people with diabetes of one such Usenet group and attempts to identify any disparity between the lay health-knowledge in evidence and biomedical opinions proffered by the use of a panel of consultant diabetiologists.
Journal of Medical Internet ResearchReliability of Health Information on the Internet: An Examination of Experts' Ratings
94 Citations2002Mark Craigie, Brian D. Loader +2 more
The aim was to assess the reliability of medical experts' judgments of threads in an Internet newsgroup related to a common disease, and to show the limitations of commonly-used statistics for measuring reliability.
Sociology of Health & IllnessMedia activism and Internet use by people with HIV/AIDS
88 Citations2003James Gillett
The potential of the Internet, as a form of media activism, to raise the private troubles of people with health problems as public issues through a revitalisation of the public sphere in contemporary post-industrial societies is discussed.
Social Science & MedicineManaged competition, governmentality and institutional response in the United Kingdom
87 Citations2001Donald W. Light
The use of managed competition policy to transform the NHS from an administered public service to a set of interlocking markets and contracts is traced, leaving an enduring legacy of accountability to purchasers in economic terms such as efficiency, transaction costs, and cost effectiveness.
Journal of Public HealthWeb page quality: can we measure it and what do we find? A report of exploratory findings
85 Citations2000Victoria Abbott
The sample of Web pages used to quantify the quality of a sample of World Wide Web pages relating to MMR vaccine contained some quality information but also contained a great deal of misleading, inaccurate data.
The Sociology of Health and Illness Reader
85 Citations2002Sarah Nettleton, Ulla Gustafsson
The author examines the role of stigma, identity, and shame in the development of a positive view of one's sexual identity in the age of social media and the changing landscape of information and communication.
Health An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health Illness and Medicine‘The Story of My Illness’: Personal Accounts of Illness on the Internet
79 Citations2002Michael Hardey
It is suggested that home pages constitute the emergence of a new genre that forms part of a broader reconfiguration of the relationship between lay and medical expertise.
Journal of Information ScienceConceptions of the Internet in Everyday Life Information Seeking
63 Citations2004Reijo Savolainen, Jarkko Kari
Concepts of the Internet as an information source reflect the acceptability, accessibility and usability of Internet sources and general level conceptions of sources and channels will gain importance as a criterion by which sources will be accepted or rejected.
Aslib ProceedingsHealth information on the Internet: a qualitative study of NHS Direct Online users
61 Citations2003Peter Williams, David Nicholas +1 more
The way the general public exploits the Internet for health information, the motives behind usage, attitudes towards issues such as quality concerns, and the extent to which Internet interventions affect the doctor‐patient relationship are examined.
Information Communication & SocietyHealth E-types?
56 Citations2004Sarah Nettleton, Roger Burrows +2 more
A simple typology of different forms of engagement with the Internet by families with children with various forms of chronic illness is presented, arguing that any reading of the 'digital divide' that is based upon a simple homology between socio-structural location, reflexivity and differential ability to gain material purchase from information in the 'information age' is misjudged.
Information Communication & SocietyFreedom or Folly? Canadians and the Consumption of Online Health Information
41 Citations2004Faiza Hirji
E-health does contain potential for improving the delivery of medical services in Canada if contained within clearly defined parameters, and if alternatives still exist for those who cannot or will not benefit from such technology.