What is Species Selection?
Systematic ZoologyPublished 1 September 1984
Elisabeth S. Vrba
Citations177
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The immediate focus of the critique is Cracraft's (1982) discussion of the relationship between patterns in the fossil record and long-term processes, which are the subject of a wider debate on the nature and role of selection in evolution which is current among biologists in diverse subdisciplines.
Abstract
Journal Article What is Species Selection? Get access Elisabeth S. Vrba Elisabeth S. Vrba Transvaal MuseumP.O. Box 413, Pretoria 0001, South Africa Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic PubMed Google Scholar Systematic Biology, Volume 33, Issue 3, September 1984, Pages 318–328, https://doi.org/10.2307/2413077 Published: 01 September 1984 Article history Received: 06 December 1983 Accepted: 15 February 1984 Published: 01 September 1984
Keywords
Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular BiologyEnvironmental Science
Clarendon Press eBooksThe genetical theory of natural selection
17,589 Citations1930Ronald Aylmer Fisher
PaleobiologyExaptation—a Missing Term in the Science of Form
5,102 Citations1982Stephen Jay Gould, Elisabeth S. Vrba
This work presents several examples of exaptation, indicating where a failure to conceptualize such an idea limited the range of hypotheses previously available, and proposes a terminological solution to the problem of preadaptation.
Princeton University Press eBooksAdaptation and Natural Selection
3,935 Citations2008George C. Williams
PaleobiologyPunctuated equilibria: the tempo and mode of evolution reconsidered
2,703 Citations1977Stephen Jay Gould, Niles Eldredge
It is argued that virtually none of the examples brought forward to refute the model of punctuated equilibria can stand as support for phyletic gradualism; many are so weak and ambiguous that they only reflect the persistent bias for gradualism still deeply embedded in paleontological thought.
Annual Review of Ecology and SystematicsThe Units of Selection
1,905 Citations1970Richard C Lewontin
The principle of natural selection as the motive force for evolution was framed by Darwin in terms of a "struggle for existence" on the part of organisms living in a finite and risky environment, but the logical skeleton of his argument turns out to be a powerful predictive system for changes at all levels of biological organization.
Annual Review of Ecology and SystematicsIndividuality and Selection
1,019 Citations1980David L. Hull
Two assumptions are at fault: the view that genes and organisms are "individuals" while popUlations and species are "classes," and the traditional way of organizing phenomena into a hierarchy of genes, cells, organisms, kinship groups, populations, species, and ecosystems or commu nities.
Macroevolution, pattern and process
884 Citations1979Steven M. Stanley
It is argued that only "quantum speciation" (rapid and radically divergent), can explain the story of life revealed in the fossil record; macroevolution, he contends, cannot be attributed to microevolutionary forces such as mutation, genetic drift and natural selection.
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesA theory of evolution above the species level.
705 Citations1975Steven M. Stanley
‘Downward Causation’ in Hierarchically Organised Biological Systems
702 Citations1974Donald T. Campbell
Is a New and General Theory of Evolution Emerging?
575 Citations1987Stephen Jay Gould
Group Selection
564 Citations1971George Williams
The origin of adaptations
344 Citations1963Verne Grant
PaleobiologyIndividuals, hierarchies and processes: towards a more complete evolutionary theory
311 Citations1984Elisabeth S. Vrba, Niles Eldredge
It is urged that interlevel causation should feature centrally in explanatory hypotheses of evolution, and upward causation from genome dynamics to the directed introduction of mutants may be more important in a given case.
Philosophy of ScienceArtifact, Cause and Genic Selection
283 Citations1982Elliott Sober, Richard C Lewontin
The limitations of this parsimony argument from a genic point of view are examined, and the criticisms are related to a broader view of the role of causal concepts and the dangers of reification in science.
PaleobiologyThe Theory of Evolution by Natural Selection: A Hierarchical Expansion
220 Citations1982Anthony J. Arnold, Kurt M. Fristrup
It is asserted that the development of a unified theory of evolution demands the recognition and incorporation of hierarchical structure as a conceptual foundation through extensions of Price's formula.
The Role of Development in the Evolution of Life Histories
150 Citations1982Stephen C. Stearns
The aspects of development that interest students of life history evolution are plasticity, canalization, and constraint, and organisms appear to be a mosaic of relatively recent adaptations which they would like to understand in terms of developmental mechanisms.
ScienceMacroevolutionary Trends: New Perspectives on the Roles of Adaptation and Incidental Effect
141 Citations1983Elisabeth S. Vrba
Trends, long-term directional tendencies in evolution, are traditionally interpreted as selected for and adaptive, but may be unselected effects of characters and processes within species: the effect hypothesis.
Casebooks in earth sciencesEvolutionary Pattern and Process in the Sister-Group Alcelaphini-Aepycerotini (Mammalia: Bovidae)
123 Citations1984Elisabeth S. Vrba
It is suggested that the causes of different kinds of evolution may be especially well studied in low-ranking sister-groups that include a fossil record plus extant survivors, and that are still in a phase of evolutionary radiation.
Systematic BiologyVictims of History--A Nonequilibrium Approach to Evolution
82 Citations1982E. O. Wiley, Daniel R. Brooks
The theory that speciation, the evolution of diversity in a clade, is accomplished by individual species acting as open-ended, closed, thermodynamic systems-open-ended in terms of energy and closed (or partly closed) in Terms of information and cohesion is suggested.
Systematic BiologyA Nonequilibrium Theory for the Rate-Control of Speciation and Extinction and the Origin of Macroevolutionary Patterns
60 Citations1982Joël Cracraft
Macroevolutionary analysis focuses on the explanation of general patterns of diversity among monophyletic groups and a deterministic theory of macroevolution lies in explaining inter-cladal diversity patterns by variation in the rate-controls of speciation.
Systematic BiologyNatural Selection and the Criteria by Which a Theory is Judged
36 Citations1979Ronald H. Brady
An examination of the structure of tautology and that of causal explanation provides criteria by which to examine the claims of both critics and defenders, and an examination of these criticisms, and the counter arguments are proposed, using the intent of the theorist as a criterion of judgment.