Science in medicine: Too much or too little and too limited in scope?
The American Journal of MedicinePublished 1 March 1988
Leon Eisenberg
Citations47
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.00
SNIP1.04
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
The concepts and methods of the social sciences must be integrated into medical education if physicians are to be enabled to respond effectively to illness as a human experience.
Abstract
Contrary to the common assertion that there is too much science in medicine, it is precisely the application of the natural sciences in the clinic that has enhanced the diagnostic and therapeutic powers of the physician. Much of the criticism of science in medicine mistakes the technology made possible by science, and the way that technology is employed, for science itself. What has hampered progress is too narrow a view of the sciences relevant to medicine. The concepts and methods of the social sciences must be integrated into medical education if physicians are to be enabled to respond effectively to illness as a human experience. Nonetheless, without major changes in the social context of medical practice, efforts to improve performance through curriculum reform will be futile.
Keywords
Health ProfessionsEconomics, Econometrics and Finance
American Journal of EpidemiologySOCIAL NETWORKS, HOST RESISTANCE, AND MORTALITY: A NINE-YEAR FOLLOW-UP STUDY OF ALAMEDA COUNTY RESIDENTS
5,347 Citations1979Lisa Berkman, S. Leonard Syme
The findings show that people who lacked social and community ties were more likely to die in the follow-up period than those with more extensive contacts.
ScienceAmyloid β Protein Gene: cDNA, mRNA Distribution, and Genetic Linkage Near the Alzheimer Locus
1,604 Citations1987Rudolph E. Tanzi, James F. Gusella +8 more
Overexpression of the gene in brain tissue from fetuses with Down syndrome (trisomy 21) can be explained by dosage since the locus encoding the beta protein maps to chromosome 21.
ScienceCharacterization and Chromosomal Localization of a cDNA Encoding Brain Amyloid of Alzheimer's Disease
1,324 Citations1987Dmitry Goldgaber, Michael I. Lerman +3 more
Four clones were isolated from an adult human brain complementary DNA library with an oligonucleotide probe corresponding to the first 20 amino acids of the beta peptide of brain amyloid from Alzheimer's disease, and the 3.5-kilobase messenger RNA was detected in mammalian brains and human thymus.
ScienceThe Genetic Defect Causing Familial Alzheimer's Disease Maps on Chromosome 21
1,157 Citations1987Peter St George‐Hyslop, Rudolph E. Tanzi +20 more
The chromosomal location of this defective gene has been discovered by using genetic linkage to DNA markers on chromosome 21 and provides an explanation for the occurrence of Alzheimer's disease-like pathology in Down syndrome.
BMJRelative contributions of history-taking, physical examination, and laboratory investigation to diagnosis and management of medical outpatients.
1,016 Citations1975J R Hampton, Margaret J. Harrison +3 more
To evaluate the relative importance of the medical history, the physical examination, and laboratory investigations in the diagnosis and management of medical outpatients some physicians recorded their diagnosis and a prediction of the method of management after reading the patient's referral letter, again after taking the history, and again after performing thePhysical examination.
New England Journal of MedicinePsychosocial Influences on Mortality after Myocardial Infarction
984 Citations1984William Ruberman, Eve Weinblatt +2 more
The increase in risk associated with stress and social isolation applied both to total deaths and to sudden cardiac deaths and was noted among men with both high and low levels of ventricular ectopy during hospitalization for the acute infarction.
Archives of General PsychiatryThe De Facto US Mental Health Services System
877 Citations1978Darrel A. Regier
This study analyzes available epidemiological data and recent mental health services research findings to estimate the percent of the population with a mental disorder and the proportion utilizing various types of specialty mental health and general medical treatment settings.
The LancetSMOKING AND HEALTH
875 Citations1972C. M. Fletcher
Evidence connecting smoking with disease smoking habits and total mortality diseases causing excess mortality of cigarette smokers cigarette smoking as a cause of excess mortality specific diseases related to cigarette smoking approaches to prevention and experience in the United States.
New England Journal of MedicineSmall-Area Variations in the Use of Common Surgical Procedures: An International Comparison of New England, England, and Norway
827 Citations1982Klim McPherson, John E. Wennberg +2 more
Differences among countries in the methods of organizing and financing care appear to have little relation to the intrinsic variability in the incidence of common surgical procedures among hospital service areas in these countries.
NatureBipolar affective disorders linked to DNA markers on chromosome 11
824 Citations1987Janice A. Egeland, Daniela S. Gerhard +6 more
An analysis of the segregation of restriction fragment length polymorphisms in an Old Order Amish pedigree has made it possible to localize a dominant gene conferring a strong predisposition to manic depressive disease to the tip of the short arm of chromosome 11.
American Journal of EpidemiologyPSYCHOSOCIAL ASSETS, LIFE CRISIS AND THE PROGNOSIS OF PREGNANCY12
810 Citations1972Katherine B. Nuckolls, John C. Cassel +1 more
Proceedings of the National Academy of SciencesPolymorphism of DNA sequence adjacent to human beta-globin structural gene: relationship to sickle mutation.
801 Citations1978Y Kan, A M Dozy
Restriction endonuclease mapping of the human globin genes revealed a genetic variation in a Hpa I recognition site about 5000 nucleotides from the 3' end of the beta-globin structural gene.
Culture Medicine and PsychiatryDisease and illness Distinctions between professional and popular ideas of sickness
783 Citations1977Leon Eisenberg
It is essential to reintegrate “scientific” and “social” concepts of disease and illness as a basis for a functional system of medical research and care.
New England Journal of MedicineInterpretation by Physicians of Clinical Laboratory Results
740 Citations1978Ward Casscells, Arno Schoenberger +1 more
A small survey was conducted to obtain some idea of how physicians do, in fact, interpret a laboratory result, and asked if a test to detect a disease whose prevalence is 1/1000 has a false positive rate of .
New England Journal of MedicineThe Ecology of Medical Care
732 Citations1961Kerr L. White, T. Franklin Williams +1 more
The current discussions about medical care appear largely concerned with two questions: is the burgeoning harvest of new knowledge fostered by immense public investment in medical research being delive...
New England Journal of MedicineVariations in the Use of Medical and Surgical Services by the Medicare Population
659 Citations1986Mark R. Chassin, Robert H. Brook +7 more
Large and significant differences in the use of medical and surgical services during 1981 by Medicare beneficiaries (age greater than or equal to 65) in 13 large areas of the United States are found.
New England Journal of MedicineInfluence of Adherence to Treatment and Response of Cholesterol on Mortality in the Coronary Drug Project
656 Citations1980The Coronary Drug Project Research Group
New England Journal of MedicineThe Reliability of Clinical Methods, Data and Judgments
652 Citations1975Martín Keller
The American Journal of MedicineDepression and somatization: a review
533 Citations1982Wayne Katon, Arthur Kleinman +1 more
The sociocultural and childhood experience were reviewed as two major factors influencing the ability of the patient to perceive affective changes and the effect of the environmental systems in which the patient dwells on the recognition of affective, cognitive and somatic symptoms.
The American Journal of MedicineDepression and somatization: a review
417 Citations1982Wayne Katon, Arthur Kleinman +1 more
A conceptual model is developed that elucidates the mechanism behind the selective perception and focus by the patient on the somatic manifestations of depression and is crucial in preventing misdiagnosis and potential iatrogenic harm to the patient.
NatureGenetic linkage between X-chromosome markers and bipolar affective illness
416 Citations1987Miron Baron, Neil Risch +6 more
A pedigree study shows close linkage of bipolar affective illness (manic depression) to the X-chromosome markers colour blindness and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency, providing confirmation that a major psychiatric disorder can be caused by a single genetic defect.
American Journal of PsychiatryA new look at evidence about reduced cost of medical utilization following mental health treatment
402 Citations1984Emily Mumford, Herbert J. Schlesinger +3 more
Meta-analysis of 58 controlled studies and analysis of the claims files for the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Federal Employees Plan for 1974-1978 provide mutually supporting evidence of the cost-offset effects of outpatient mental health treatment.
The British Journal of PsychiatryMindlessness and Brainlessness in Psychiatry
302 Citations1986Leon Eisenberg
The theme of this address—that brain and mind are as warp and woof in the fabric of psychiatry—may seem so much a truism as to be a banal choice, but its implications are daily contravened in both theory and practice.
NatureThe genetic defect in familial Alzheimer's disease is not tightly linked to the amyloid β-protein gene
268 Citations1987Rudolph E. Tanzi, Peter St George‐Hyslop +8 more
The detection of several recombination events with FAD suggests that the AP gene is not the site of the inherited defect underlying this disorder, and the pattern of segregation of theAP gene in FAD pedigrees is determined using restriction fragment length polymorphisms.
NatureMolecular genetic evidence for heterogeneity in manic depression
251 Citations1987Stephen Hodgkinson, Robin Sherrington +7 more
There is genetic heterogeneity of linkage in manic depression, therefore mutations at different loci are responsible for the manic depressive phentoype in the Amish and in Iceland.
NatureClose linkage of c-Harvey-ras-1 and the insulin gene to affective disorder is ruled out in three North American pedigrees
225 Citations1987Sevilla D. Detera‐Wadleigh, Wade H. Berrettini +4 more
The authors' results indicate the absence of linkage from 0 to 15% recombination frequency between AD and the insulin gene–HRASl region in these pedigrees outside the Amish population.
Journal of Health and Social BehaviorThe Effect of Psychological Distress on Physician Utilization: A Prospective Study
218 Citations1976Richard C. Tessler, David Mechanic +1 more
The results show a positive relationship between distress and physician utilization, which persists even when a variety of sociodemographic, attitudinal, and health status variables have been controlled.
American Sociological ReviewThe Fate of Idealism in Medical School
195 Citations1958Howard S. Becker, Blanche Geer
Scienceβ Amyloid Gene Duplication in Alzheimer's Disease and Karyotypically Normal Down Syndrome
186 Citations1987Jean‐Maurice Delabar, Dmitry Goldgaber +7 more
Leukocyte DNA from three patients with sporadic Alzheimer's disease and two patients with karyotypically normal Down syndrome was found to contain three copies of the chromosome 21 gene encoding brain amyloid polypeptide (beta amylid protein) of Alzheimer’s disease.
PEDIATRICSChanges in Tonsillectomy Rates Associated With Feedback and Review
167 Citations1977John E. Wennberg, Lewis Blowers +2 more
The experience suggests that feedback of population-based data on incidence of procedures may be a valuable tool for the peer review process.
ScienceAbsence of Duplication of Chromosome 21 Genes in Familial and Sporadic Alzheimer's Disease
142 Citations1987Peter St George‐Hyslop, Rudolph E. Tanzi +19 more
No significant allelic association was detected between AD and any of the loci, including the amyloid and SODI genes, providing no support for the hypothesis that defects in these specific genes are the primary cause of AD.
New England Journal of MedicineEffect of Surveillance on the Number of Hysterectomies in the Province of Saskatchewan
142 Citations1977Frank J. Dyck, Fergus A. Murphy +9 more
In 1972 the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Saskatchewan appointed a committee to study hysterectomies because the Saskatchewan Department of Health had data showing that the annual number of hysteretomies carried out in the province had increased by 72.1 per cent between 1964 and 1971, whereas the number of women over 15 years of age had increase by 7.6 per cent.
ScienceCardiovascular Research: Decades of Progress, a Decade of Promise
105 Citations1982Robert I. Levy, Jay Moskowitz
The past and present contributions of advances in cardiovascular research to this decline are reviewed and continued emphasis must be placed on research in the areas of etiology and pathogenesis, on validating potentially beneficial research hypotheses, and on the translation and dissemination of research results to the health care practitioner and the public.
Annual Review of Public HealthThe Need for Assessing the Outcome of Common Medical Practices
101 Citations1980John E. Wennberg, John P. Bunker +1 more
In this chapter, the controversies concerning surgery for the treatment of common, noncancerous conditions are summarized and the costs associated with different frequencies of prescribing surgery are estimated.
Journal of Human StressEffects of Psychological Distress on Perceptions of Physical Health and Use of Medical and Psychiatric Facilities
98 Citations1978David Mechanic
Evidence that psychological distress is an important component of illness behavior and response and must be taken into account in the appropriate organization of medical services is reviewed.
Political Science QuarterlyDoing Better and Feeling Worse: Health in the United States, <i>by John H. Knowles</i>
68 Citations1977Arthur L. Levin
This is a book that will generate debate, discussion, controversy, conflict, and perhaps some legislative reform when the impact of its arguments begins to be felt.
American Journal of EpidemiologySOCIAL DISORGANIZATION AND STROKE MORTALITY IN THE BLACK POPULATION OF NORTH CAROLINA1
63 Citations1971William B. Neser, Herman A. Tyroler +1 more
Archives of SurgeryA Decade of Surgery in Canada, England and Wales, and the United States
54 Citations1982Eugene Vayda
Overall surgical rates in Canada remained relatively unchanged and consistently 60% higher than those in England and Wales between 1966 and 1976 while overall United States rates were the highest of the three countries and increased 25% over the ten years.
PubMedThe cultural meanings and social uses of illness. A role for medical anthropology and clinically oriented social science in the development of primary care theory and research.
54 Citations1983Arthur Kleinman
The biopsychosocial model offers a paradigm for the incorporation of clinically oriented social science research as one basic science approach in which primary care researchers can receive advanced training and pursue an academic career.
PubMedAn exploration of the dimensions of illness behavior.
51 Citations1980Raymond Y. Demers, Rita Altamore +3 more
The rest of the iceberg of health problems is described, which consists of problems recorded by 107 participants over a three-week period and non-orthodox practitioner utilization patterns.
JAMAAn Informal Appraisal of the Current Status of 'Medical Sociology'
42 Citations1981Robert G. Petersdorf
The results showed that between 40% and 50% of medical students are taught medical sociology during their preclinical years, usually by several departments, and in general, departments of medicine held a negative attitude toward medical sociology, while departments of family medicine thought the subject was important and worthwhile.
Medical CareSecond Opinion Elective Surgery Programs: Outcome Status over Time
36 Citations1978Eugene G. McCarthy, Madelon Lubin Finkel
Subsequent follow up studies will present a clearer assessment of the ability of the second opinion elective surgery program to screen potential surplus surgery and to realize cost savings.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Role of the Primary Physician in the Health-Care Industry
35 Citations1981Thomas P. Almy
Mutual confidence between physician and patient is a large element in the effectiveness and the economy of health care and that confidence is now widely imperiled.
American Journal of PsychiatryHealth care: for patients or for profits?
32 Citations1986Lee D. Eisenberg
It is concluded that physicians have an ethical imperative to join in a broad public coalition to protect equity and quality in medical care.
New England Journal of MedicineWhat Future for Primary Care Private Practice?
32 Citations1987Roberta Berrien
Primary Care Update for OB/GYNSThe thalassemia syndromes
24 Citations1996Lee Hilliard, Roger L. Berkow
Clinical features of thalassemia are reviewed while focusing on evaluation and care of the pregnant patient and prenatal diagnosis and genetic counseling, prenatal diagnosis, and newborn screening.
Surgical Clinics of North AmericaVariations in Operative Rates: What Do They Mean?
22 Citations1982Eugene Vayda, William R. Mindell
This report describes and analyzes the differences in surgical rates, assesses associated factors, and suggests possible ways to resolve the problem of varying operative rates.
New England Journal of MedicineThe Abuse of Coronary Arteriography
18 Citations1979Brendan Phibbs
Coronary arteriography is a current example of the solution-turned-problem, since the procedure by its character slips through the net of controls designed by the medical profession to protect the public.
BMJUrography in Myelomatosis
15 Citations1969M. T. Cwynarski, H. M. Saxton
The reaction between the media and myeloma urine was studied in vitro and it was concluded that the risk of urography in myelomatosis is very small.
New England Journal of MedicineMy Kingdom for a Camera — Some Comments on Medical Technology
8 Citations1974Howard M. Spiro
Technology has brought advances to diagnosis and therapy that parallel the walk and casts the intellectual content of medical-school curricula in as much of a luxurious mold as Corinthian columns and Doric patios.
An Informal Appraisal of the Current Status of ‘Medical Sociology’
7 Citations1981Robert G. Petersdorf, Alvan R. Feinstein