Knowledge organization and skill differences in computer programmers
Cognitive PsychologyPublished 1 July 1981
Katherine B. McKeithen, Judith S. Reitman, Henry H. Rueter, Stephen C. Hirtle
Citations511
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.65
SNIP1.77
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
This paper infer the details of individual programmers’ chunks of key programming concepts using the Reitman-Rtreter technique for inferring tree structures from recall orders.
Abstract
Like experts in other fields, expert computer programmers can recall at a glance far more information relevant to their field than novices can. One explanation for this difference is that experts not only have more information, they have it better organized into meaningful chunks. In this paper, we infer the details of individual programmers' chunks of key programming concepts using the Reitman--Rueter (Cognitive Psychology, 1980, 12(4), 554-581.) technique for inferring tree structures from recall orders. Differences in organizations accompany skill-level differences. Beginner programmers' organizations show a rich variety of common-language associations to these programming concepts; Intermediate programmers show mixtures of programming and common-language associations; and Experts show remarkably similar, but not identical, organizations based clearly on programming knowledge.
Keywords
Computer Science
PsychometrikaHierarchical Clustering Schemes
4,891 Citations1967S. C. Johnson
A useful correspondence is developed between any hierarchical system of such clusters, and a particular type of distance measure, that gives rise to two methods of clustering that are computationally rapid and invariant under monotonic transformations of the data.
PsychometrikaThe Analysis of Proximities: Multidimensional Scaling with an Unknown Distance Function. I.
2,553 Citations1962Roger N. Shepard
The program is proposed as a tool for reductively analyzing several types of psychological data, particularly measures of interstimulus similarity or confusability, by making explicit the multidimensional structure underlying such data.
ScienceExpert and Novice Performance in Solving Physics Problems
2,121 Citations1980Jill Larkin, John McDermott +2 more
Although a sizable body of knowledge is prerequisite to expert skill, that knowledge must be indexed by large numbers of patterns that, on recognition, guide the expert in a fraction of a second to relevant parts of the knowledge store.
PsychometrikaThe Analysis of Proximities: Multidimensional Scaling with an Unknown Distance Function. II
912 Citations1962Roger N. Shepard
The results of two kinds of test applications of a computer program for multidimensional scaling on the basis of essentially nonmetric data are reported to measures of interstimulus similarity and confusability obtained from some actual psychological experiments.
Software Psychology: Human Factors in Computer and Information Systems
618 Citations1980Ben Shneiderman
Memory & CognitionChunking in recall of symbolic drawings
486 Citations1979Dennis E. Egan, Barry J. Schwartz
It is proposed that skilled subjects identify the conceptual category for an entire drawing, and retrieve elements using a generate-and-test process, and that severe constraints are placed on any explanation of the data based on guessing.
Cognitive PsychologySkilled perception in Go: Deducing memory structures from inter-response times
280 Citations1976Judith S. Reitman
The technique of partitioning recall and reproduction data into chunks on the basis of inter-response times (IRTs) was applied to the reproduction and recall of Go patterns by a Go Master and a Go beginner, but no single IRT was able to produce consistent, veridical chunks for either Go player.
Quarterly Journal of Experimental PsychologyVisual Perception of Musical Notation: Registering Pitch Symbols in Memory
162 Citations1976John Sloboda
These experiments examined the way in which experienced musicians differed from non-musicians in their recognition of briefly exposed pitch notation, and investigated the nature of the abstract code for musicians.
The American Journal of PsychologyMemory Processes among Bridge Players of Differing Expertise
157 Citations1978Randall W. Engle, Lee H. Bukstel
Cognitive PsychologyOrganization revealed by recall orders and confirmed by pauses
124 Citations1980Judith S. Reitman, Henry H. Rueter
The technique introduced here induces the organization of information in memory from systematic inspection of regularities in free recall in an “ordered tree” form, based on inferences from multitrial free recall.
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal BehaviorSome-or-none characteristics of coding behavior
115 Citations1966Burton H. Cohen
Behavior Research Methods & InstrumentationA general measure of organization in free recall for variable unit size and internal sequential consistency
80 Citations1971James W. Pellegrino
Cognitive PsychologyIn search of the M-Gram: The structure of organization in free recall
71 Citations1977Michael Friendly
This paper reviews three major classes of structural models of episodic and semantic memory which have been proposed to describe the organization of permanent memory, and presents a method for extracting representations of memory structure using output order information from a free recall learning task.
The Computer JournalA Structured Programming Experiment
49 Citations1976Hector Lucas, Rosandra Kaplan
The basic contention of this study is that programmers will perform better and have more favourable attitudes when writing structured code than when writing unrestricted programs.
Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal BehaviorLearning is organized by chunking
40 Citations1976Herman Buschke
British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical PsychologyA NEW APPROACH TO THE CHARACTERIZATION OF SEQUENTIAL STRUCTURE IN MULTI‐TRIAL FREE RECALL USING HIERARCHICAL GROUPING ANALYSIS
9 Citations1976Andrew Monk
The approach described in the present paper, hierarchical grouping analysis (HGA), appears to meet criticisms of previous approaches and the possibilities extended by using HGA are demonstrated in an analysis of some experimental data which examines the relationship between semantic inter-item associations and recall structure.
Behavior Research MethodsCLUSTER: A program for identifying recurrent clusters
4 Citations1976Murray Zangen, Philip Ziegelbaum +1 more
CLUSTER is a new program for analyzing sequential organization by delineating the specific clusters on each trial to show the development of organization and provide a basis for measuring organization in terms of such clustering.
Deep Blue (University of Michigan)Assessing Knowledge Structures In Novice And Expert Programmers.
2 Citations1979Katherine Beatrice Mckeithen