The Devil is in the Third Year: A Longitudinal Study of Erosion of Empathy in Medical School
Academic MedicinePublished 22 August 2009
Mohammadreza Hojat, Michael J. Vergare, Kaye Maxwell, George C. Brainard, Steven K. Herrine, Gerald A. Isenberg
Citations1,590
SJR quartileQ1
SJR score1.45
SNIP2.03
Generate an AI Snapshot to get a quick, structured summary of this paper.
Study Snapshot
ObjectiveStudy objective
MethodsResearch methodology
PopulationPopulation studied
Sample sizeSample sizes
OutcomesStudy outcomes here
ResultsStudy results comes here
LimitationsResearch study limitations comes here
A concise AI-generated summary of the paper will appear here once you click Generate AI Snapshot.
TL;DR
It is concluded that a significant decline in empathy occurs during the third year of medical school, and it is ironic that the erosion of empathy occurs when the curriculum is shifting toward patient-care activities; this is when empathy is most essential.
Abstract
It is concluded that a significant decline in empathy occurs during the third year of medical school. It is ironic that the erosion of empathy occurs during a time when the curriculum is shifting toward patient-care activities; this is when empathy is most essential. Implications for retaining and enhancing empathy are discussed.
Keywords
MedicineHealth Professions
Journal of Personality and Social PsychologyMeasuring individual differences in empathy: Evidence for a multidimensional approach.
9,585 Citations1983Mark H. Davis
Journal of Consulting and Clinical PsychologyDevelopment of an empathy scale.
1,460 Citations1969Robert Hogan
This paper discusses the development of a 64-item self-report measure of empathy, constructed by comparing the responses of groups with high- and low-rated empathy, using the combined MMPI-CPI item pool.
American Journal of PsychiatryPhysician Empathy: Definition, Components, Measurement, and Relationship to Gender and Specialty
1,320 Citations2002Mohammadreza Hojat, Joseph S. Gonnella +4 more
Three meaningful factors emerged (perspective taking, compassionate care, and standing in the patient's shoes) to provide support for the construct validity of the empathy scale that was found to be internally consistent with relatively stable scores over time.
The Analysis of the Self: A Systematic Approach to the Psychoanalytic Treatment of Narcissistic Personality Disorders
1,280 Citations1971Heinz Kohut
Educational and Psychological MeasurementThe Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy: Development and Preliminary Psychometric Data
1,054 Citations2001Mohammadreza Hojat, Salvatore Mangione +6 more
Psychometric findings provided support for the construct validity, criterion-related validity (convergent and discriminant), and internal consistency reliability (coefficient alpha) of the scale scores.
Medical EducationAn empirical study of decline in empathy in medical school
859 Citations2004Mohammadreza Hojat, Salvatore Mangione +5 more
Empirical research to address this issue is scarce because the definition of empathy lacks clarity, and a tool to measure empathy specifically in medical students and doctors has been unavailable.
Medical EducationEmpathy in medical students as related to academic performance, clinical competence and gender
679 Citations2002Mohammadreza Hojat, Joseph S. Gonnella +6 more
It is important to address the measurement of empathy, its development and its correlates in medical schools.
Journal of General Internal MedicineA Cross-sectional Measurement of Medical Student Empathy
546 Citations2007Daniel Chen, Robert Lew +2 more
Empathy scores of students in the preclinical years were higher than in the clinical years, and efforts are needed to determine whether differences in empathy scores among the classes are cohort effects or represent changes occurring in the course of medical education.
Academic MedicineIs There Hardening of the Heart During Medical School?
505 Citations2008Bruce W. Newton, Laurie Barber +3 more
The findings suggest that undergraduate medical education may be a major determinant differentially affecting the vicarious empathy of students on the basis of gender and/or specialty choice.
New England Journal of MedicineAttributes of Excellent Attending-Physician Role Models
499 Citations1998Scott M. Wright, David E. Kern +3 more
A case–control study to identify attributes that distinguish such physicians from their colleagues and identified 144 physicians who had been identified as excellent role models.
Academic MedicineDo clinical clerks suffer ethical erosion? Studentsʼ perceptions of their ethical environment and personal development
488 Citations1994C Feudtner, Dimitri Christakis +1 more
The ethical dilemmas that medical students perceive as affecting them while serving as clinical clerks are apparently common and often detrimental, and warrant the attention of physicians, educators, and ethicists.
Advances in Health Sciences EducationA Visitor's Guide to Effect Sizes – Statistical Significance Versus Practical (Clinical) Importance of Research Findings
427 Citations2004Mohammadreza Hojat, Gang Xu
An introduction to the computation and interpretation of effect sizes from the perspective of the consumer of the research literature is given.
Choice Reviews OnlineEmpathy in patient care: antecedents, development, measurement, and outcomes
422 Citations2007
This book discusses empathy as Related to Sex, Personal Qualities, Clinical Competence, and Career Choice, as well as the Interpersonal Dynamics in Clinician-Patient Relationships.
Academic MedicineThe Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy
405 Citations2002Mohammadreza Hojat, Joseph S. Gonnella +4 more
It is found that female students and physicians scored higher in empathy than males, and a significant overlap between empathy and clinical competence constitutes key validity evidence for the empathy scale.
Sleep MedicineSleep deprivation reduces perceived emotional intelligence and constructive thinking skills
380 Citations2007William D. S. Killgore, Ellen T. Kahn-Greene +4 more
Findings are consistent with the neurobehavioral model suggesting that sleep loss produces temporary changes in cerebral metabolism, cognition, emotion, and behavior consistent with mild prefrontal lobe dysfunction.
Academic MedicineMeasurement of Empathy Among Japanese Medical Students: Psychometrics and Score Differences by Gender and Level of Medical Education
380 Citations2009Hitomi Kataoka, Norio Koide +3 more
Women outscored men, and empathy scores increased as students progressed through medical school in this cross-sectional study, providing support for the construct validity and reliability of the Japanese translated version of the JSPE for medical students.
From Detached Concern to Empathy: Humanizing Medical Practice
340 Citations2001Jodi Halpern
Academic MedicineVanquishing Virtue
322 Citations2001Jack Coulehan, Peter Williams
The authors contend that North American medical education favors an explicit commitment to traditional values of doctoring—empathy, compassion, and altruism among them—and a tacit commitment to behaviors grounded in an ethic of detachment, self-interest, and objectivity.
Academic MedicineMood Change and Empathy Decline Persist during Three Years of Internal Medicine Training
316 Citations2005Lisa M. Bellini, Judy A. Shea
Although graduating residents appear to be better off than the population norms, some domains of their mood disturbances and empathy never fully recover from their internship year.
JAMAA Pilot Study of Medical Student 'Abuse'
291 Citations1990David V. Sheehan
A pilot survey of one third-year medical school class was carried out to explore student perceptions of mistreatment and professional misconduct in medical school training, indicating that students perceive mistreatment to be pervasive andprofessional misconduct all too common.
Journal of Dental EducationMeasurement of Changes in Empathy During Dental School
274 Citations2005Jeffrey J. Sherman, Adam P. Cramer
The JSPE was found to be both a reliable and valid empathy measure for dental students with similar psychometric properties to those found in medical students, residents, and physicians.
Journal of the American Psychoanalytic AssociationEmpathic Understanding: A Review Of The Concept And Some Theoretical Considerations
274 Citations1983Michael Franz Basch
Annals of Internal MedicineStress in Medical Residency: Status Quo after a Decade of Reform?
273 Citations2002Virginia U. Collier, Jack D. McCue +2 more
To re-examine current residents' psychological and financial situations, the Resident Services Committee of the Association of Program Directors in Internal Medicine mailed a survey in May 1998 to all 415 internal medicine program directors, who were asked to distribute copies to each of their medicine residents (residents in categorical, preliminary, and combined tracks).
Academic MedicineA Conceptual Framework for the Use of Illness Narratives in Medical Education
249 Citations2008Arno K. Kumagai
The author describes a grounding of this approach in theories of empathy and moral development and clarifies the educational value that narratives bring to medical education.
BMJExperiences of belittlement and harassment and their correlates among medical students in the United States: longitudinal survey
244 Citations2006Erica Frank, Jennifer S. Carrera +3 more
Although few students characterised the harassment or belittlement as severe, poor mental health and low career satisfaction were significantly correlated with these experiences.
Journal of Health and Human Services AdministrationTen Approaches for Enhancing Empathy in Health and Human Services Cultures
241 Citations2009Mohammadreza Hojat
10 approaches for enhancing empathy in the health care environment are described: improving interpersonal skills, audio- or video-taping of encounters with patients, exposure to role models, role playing (aging game), shadowing a patient, hospitalization experiences, studying literature and the arts, improving narrative skills, theatrical performances, and the Balint method.
New Directions for Child and Adolescent DevelopmentIndividual differences in empathy among preschoolers: Relation to attachment history
240 Citations1989Roberta Kestenbaum, Ellen A. Farber +1 more
Journal of Social and Clinical PsychologyTherapy Work and Therapists' Positive and Negative Well–Being
236 Citations2007P. Alex Linley, Stephen Joseph
JAMAMedical Student Abuse
210 Citations1990Henry K. Silver
It is concluded that medical student abuse was perceived by these students to be a significant cause of stress and should be a major concern of those involved with medical student education.
Journal of Nursing MeasurementReliability and Validity of the Jefferson Scale of Empathy in Undergraduate Nursing Students
186 Citations2009Julia Ward, Mary Schaal +4 more
It was concluded that the empathy scale used in this study is a psychometrically sound instrument for measuring empathy in undergraduate nursing students.
The Journal of Social PsychologyEmpathy Scores in Medical School and Ratings of Empathic Behavior in Residency Training 3 Years Later
184 Citations2005Mohammadreza Hojat, Salvatore Mangione +3 more
The findings support the long-term predictive validity of the self-report empathy scale, JSPE, despite different methods of evaluations (self-report and supervisors' ratings) and despite a time interval between evaluations (3 years).
Academic MedicineThe Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy: Preliminary Psychometrics and Group Comparisons in Italian Physicians
180 Citations2009Mariangela Di Lillo, Americo Cicchetti +3 more
Findings generally provide support for the construct validity and reliability of the Italian version of the Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy, and more factors appeared among Italian physicians, indicating that the underlying construct of empathy may be more complex among Italians.
Teaching and Learning in MedicineEvaluation of Empathy Among Korean Medical Students: A Cross-Sectional Study Using the Korean Version of the Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy
168 Citations2010Myoung‐Sun Roh, Bong‐Jin Hahm +2 more
The findings provide support for the reliability and validity of the Korean JSPE-S and indicate that it can serve as a useful instrument for assessing empathy among Korean medical students.
Journal of General Internal MedicineSympathy, empathy, and physician resource utilization
158 Citations1991Stephen D. Nightingale, Paul R. Yarnold +1 more
These data suggest that the constructs of sympathy and empathy reflect psychological aspects of physicians that have a measurable influence on their practice behaviors.
Medical EducationA retrospective study of attitude change during medical education
150 Citations1989Thomas Wolf, Paul M. Balson +2 more
Students perceived that they became more cynical during medical education, and believed that they were more concerned with making money, more concerned for patients, and more helpful.
Annals of Internal MedicineEvaluation of Humanistic Qualities in the Internist
148 Citations1983Julius R. Krevans, John Benson
In an important decision on 6 June 1983 the American Board of Internal Medicine accepted the following report of its Subcommittee on Evaluation of Humanistic Qualities in the Internist.
Aerospace Medicine and Human PerformanceAutomatic and controlled empathy
130 Citations1997Sara D. Hodges, Daniel M. Wegner +1 more
Redalyc (Universidad Autónoma del Estado de México)Validación de la Escala de Empatía Médica de Jefferson en estudiantes de medicina mexicanos
122 Citations2005Adelina Alcorta-Garza, Juan Francisco González-Guerrero +3 more
Medical TeacherAssessment of empathy in different years of internal medicine training
117 Citations2002Salvatore Mangione, Gregory C. Kane +4 more
Empathy is a relatively stable trait that is not easily amenable to change in residency training programs, and the issue of whether targeted educational activities for the purpose of cultivating empathy can improve empathy scores awaits empirical scrutiny.
Contemporary Sociology A Journal of ReviewsInto the Valley: Death and the Socialization of Medical Students.
105 Citations1992Jonathan B. Imber, Frederic W. Hafferty
Academic MedicineAn analysis of empathy in medical students before and following clinical experience
100 Citations1981Robert A. Diseker, Robert Michielutte
JAMATraumatic Deidealization and the Future of Medicine
97 Citations1990Jerald Kay
The articles in this issue of the Journalon medical student abuse by Silver and Glicken 1 and Sheehan et al 2 are provocative and disturbing.
New England Journal of MedicineRole Models — Guiding the Future of Medicine
91 Citations1998Kelley M. Skeff, Sunita Mutha
Evidence is presented that many physician-teachers do not exhibit the professional characteristics that residents desire to emulate, and that less than half of teaching physicians are perceived as excellent role models.
Academic MedicineProblems and concerns among medical students–1975
80 Citations1976Marc T. Edwards, C N Zimet
The survey revealed that chief among student conerns are a lack of personal freedom, excessive academic pressures, and feelings of dehumanization, and a marked trend toward increasing difficulty with thoughts of having chosen the wrong profession.
Archives of Internal MedicineLove, Boundaries, and the Patient-Physician Relationship
72 Citations1997Neil J. Farber
It is explored how a balance between clinical objectivity and bonding with the patient is optimal and achievable and the means of preventing transgressions by both patients and physicians through medical education, the process of self-awareness, and an exploration of family-of-origin issues are proposed.
Academic MedicineImpact of workshop on studentsʼ and physiciansʼ rejecting behaviors in patient interviews
31 Citations1987Daniela Krämer, Raphael Ber +1 more
It is determined that participation in a workshop on supporting behaviors in the medical interview resulted in long-term decrease or abolishment of rejecting behaviors among medical students and physicians.
Academic MedicineWhoʼs to blame for the low production of generalist graduates?
1 Citations1993Richard H. Streiffer, Betty B. Gatipon